Monograph |
Corresponding author: Benoît Dayrat ( bdayrat@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Nathalie Yonow
© 2018 Tricia C. Goulding, Munawar Khalil, Shau Hwai Tan, Benoît Dayrat.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Goulding TC, Khalil M, Tan SH, Dayrat B (2018) Integrative taxonomy of a new and highly-diverse genus of onchidiid slugs from the Coral Triangle (Gastropoda, Pulmonata, Onchidiidae). ZooKeys 763: 1-111. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.763.21252
|
A new genus of onchidiid slugs, Wallaconchis Goulding & Dayrat, gen. n., is described, including ten species. Five species were previously described but known only from the type material: Wallaconchis ater (Lesson, 1830), W. graniferum (Semper, 1880), W. nangkauriense (Plate, 1893), W. buetschlii (Stantschinsky, 1907), and W. gracile (Stantschinsky, 1907), all of which were originally classified in Onchidium Buchannan, 1800. Many new records are provided for these five species, which greatly expand their known geographic distributions. Five species are new: Wallaconchis achleitneri Goulding, sp. n., W. comendadori Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., W. melanesiensis Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., W. sinanui Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., and W. uncinus Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n. Nine of the ten Wallaconchis species are found in the Coral Triangle (eastern Indonesia and the Philippines). Sympatry is high, with up to six species found on the island of Bohol (Philippines) and eight species overlapping in northern Sulawesi (Indonesia). Wallaconchis is distinguished from other onchidiids by its bright dorsal colors (red, yellow, orange) but those are extremely variable and not useful for specific identification. Internally, the reproductive system can be used to identify all Wallaconchis species. The copulatory organs of Wallaconchis species are especially diverse compared to other onchidiid genera, and the possible role of reproductive incompatibility in species diversification is discussed. All specimens examined were freshly collected for the purpose of a worldwide revision of the Onchidiidae Rafinesque, 1815. The species are well delineated using DNA sequences and comparative anatomy. Mitochondrial DNA analysis yields thirteen molecular units separated by a large barcode gap, while nuclear DNA yields nine units. By integrating nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA with morphology, ten species are recognized. The natural history of each species (e.g., the microhabitat where they are found) is also documented. Nomenclature is addressed thoroughly (the types of all onchidiid species were examined, lectotypes were designated when needed, nomina dubia are discussed). Morphological characters, transitions to new microhabitats, and diversification processes are discussed in the context of a robust molecular phylogeny.
Euthyneura , Indo-West Pacific, marine biogeography, phylogeography, systematics
The Onchidiidae is a group of shell-less, marine, air-breathing slugs that live in intertidal habitats worldwide. Most of the diversity is found in mangroves of South-East Asia, where onchidiids have diversified into several genera, such as Onchidium Buchannan, 1800, Peronina Plate, 1893, Platevindex Baker, 1938, and Melayonchis Dayrat & Goulding, 2017. The genus Peronia Fleming, 1822, which can easily be identified externally by branched gills on the dorsal notum, has diversified in the rocky intertidal across the Indo-West Pacific. However, for decades the diversity of onchidiid slugs has remained poorly known for a variety of reasons: mangroves have rarely been explored; preserved slugs can hardly be distinguished externally; and taxonomists have avoided the overwhelming nomenclature (
The Dayrat lab is currently engaged in a global revision of the Onchidiidae, based on an integrative approach involving extensive fieldwork (sampling thousands of individuals at more than 300 stations worldwide), natural history observations, comparative anatomy, and DNA sequencing. An important component of integrative taxonomy is sound nomenclature; this revision has required the examination of the type material of all onchidiid species, the detailed analysis of all species descriptions, and the re-evaluation of the nomenclatural status of every genus- and species-group name. First, monophyletic genera had to be delineated, and now each genus is being revised separately (
Here, a new genus, Wallaconchis Goulding & Dayrat, gen. n., is described from the Indo-West Pacific, with a geographic distribution from the Andaman Islands (Bay of Bengal) to the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, Vanuatu, and Queensland. Phylogenetic analyses show that the monophyly of this new genus is strongly-supported and that it includes ten species. A new genus name is needed because no existing genus name applies to this monophyletic group. This new genus is characterized by a unique combination of morphological characters found in no other onchidiid genus: no dorsal gills, intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, and no accessory penial gland. As is often the case in other genera, all ten Wallaconchis species are cryptic externally but each is characterized by a distinctive internal anatomy.
Five of the ten species described here are new: Wallaconchis achleitneri Goulding, sp. n., W. comendadori Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., W. melanesiensis Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., W. sinanui Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n., and W. uncinus Goulding & Dayrat, sp. n. The five other species were known only from the type material and are re-described here in detail for the first time with fresh material collected from many locations: Wallaconchis ater (Lesson, 1830), W. graniferum (Semper, 1880), W. nangkauriense (Plate, 1893), W. buetschlii (Stantschinsky, 1907), and W. gracile (Stantschinsky, 1907), all of which were originally classified in Onchidium.
More than 230 non-type specimens are examined in the present study, all of which were collected by the authors in the past few years. DNA sequences are provided for 169 of these specimens. In addition to the description of five new species, dozens of new records are provided for the species with existing names.
The name Wallaconchis honors Alfred Russel Wallace, the famous naturalist who traveled extensively in the Indo-Malay Archipelago, the core of the geographic distribution of this new genus. Indeed, nine of the ten Wallaconchis species are found within the boundaries of the Coral Triangle, in the waters of eastern Indonesia and the Philippines. Four of these species are distributed outside the Coral Triangle as well, in the Andaman Islands, southern China, northern Queensland, and Vanuatu. In addition, one species is endemic to the central coast of Queensland, Australia.
The five Wallaconchis species to which existing species names are applied, were all originally described based on preserved material. Previous authors did not have access to live animals. The new collections, studied here, have revealed that many Wallaconchis species exhibit bright dorsal colors, such as red, yellow, and orange, which are unusual in the Onchidiidae. Also, the color of the dorsal notum is highly variable intra-specifically and color variation overlaps between the species. As a result, it remains extremely challenging to identify Wallaconchis species in the field, especially because they are commonly found at the exact same spots (up to six species together in a few square meters).
Contrary to other onchidiid genera, which usually are restricted to one or two microhabitats (for instance, Peronina species live on soft and deep mud saturated with water), Wallaconchis species live on a variety of different microhabitats: coral rubble, which is common in coastal mangroves of the Coral Triangle, fine sand, coarse sand, sandy mud, firm mud, as well as rocks covered with algae. Photographs of microhabitats and live specimens in the field are provided in each species description. In the general discussion, microhabitats are mapped onto the Wallaconchis phylogeny and evolutionary transitions in microhabitat are discussed in relation to species diversification.
Nearly all specimens examined here were newly collected, which provided fresh material for DNA sequencing and invaluable natural history observations in the field. Specimens were individually numbered and photographed in the field, providing the source for microhabitat data of each species. At each site, individuals were chosen to represent color, size, and microhabitat variation. A piece of tissue was cut from most specimens for DNA extraction, the rest of the specimen being relaxed and preserved for comparative anatomy. Some specimens were also preserved directly in 95% ethanol. Thanks to our numbering of individuals in the field, each DNA sequence can be matched to a particular preserved specimen and the corresponding field photographs. Specimens preserved for dissection were relaxed in magnesium chloride for approximately one day and then preserved in 70% ethanol. Samples from Sumatra, Sulawesi, and Queensland were fixed in formalin prior to being transferred into ethanol. Collections were made by Tricia Goulding and party in Australia, Benoît Dayrat and party in India and in the Philippines, and Munawar Khalil and party in Indonesia. Specimens were collected by hand at low tide. GPS coordinates are available for all stations sampled by the authors and each site is labelled with a unique station number (e.g., st 100). The only specimens that were not collected by the authors are the types of existing species and the specimens collected in Vanuatu and Papua New Guinea during expeditions organized by Dr. Philippe Bouchet (Muséum national d’histoire naturelle, Paris, France).
All available types of Onchidiidae were examined. In total, 231 non-type specimens were examined and sequenced for this study. Mitochondrial COI sequences are provided here for169 individuals and two additional mitochondrial loci (12S and 16S) and three additional nuclear loci (ITS1, ITS2 and 28S) were sequenced for a subsample of individuals. Individuals were subsampled to represent the highest COI genetic divergence within each species, as well as a broad range of geographic localities. Individual DNA extraction numbers are indicated on phylogenetic trees, in the lists of material examined, as well as in figure captions (DNA extraction numbers are included in square brackets). Animal sizes are indicated as length/width in millimeters. All specimens freshly collected by the authors (i.e., all specimens included here except for the types of existing species and the MNHN material from Vanuatu and Papua New Guinea) were deposited as vouchers in institutions in the countries where they were collected.
Museum abbreviations are:
BNHS Bombay Natural History Society, Mumbai, India
MNHN Muséum national d’histoire naturelle, Paris, France
MTQ Museum of Tropical Queensland, Townsville, Queensland, Australia
PNM National Museum of the Philippines, Manila, Philippines
SMF Naturmuseum Senckenberg, Frankfurt-am-Main, Germany
UMIZ Universitas Malikussaleh, North Aceh, Sumatra, Indonesia
ZMB Zoologisches Museum, Berlin, Germany
ZMUC Zoological Museum University of Copenhagen, Denmark
Anatomical observations were made under a dissecting microscope and drawn with a camera lucida. Radulae and male reproductive organs were prepared for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Radulae were cleaned in 10% NaOH for a week, rinsed in distilled water, briefly cleaned in an ultrasonic water bath (less than a minute), sputter-coated with gold-palladium and examined by SEM. Soft parts were dehydrated in ethanol and critical point-dried before coating. The anatomy of W. sinanui, the type species, is fully detailed. The written description of the many anatomical features that are virtually identical between species (nervous system, heart, etc.) is given only for the type species to avoid repeating the information ten times. So, any feature that is only mentioned in W. sinanui is identical in the nine other species.
DNA was extracted using the phenol-chloroform extraction protocol with cetyltrimethyl-ammonium bromide (CTAB). Three mitochondrial and three nuclear loci were amplified with PCR. Portions of three mitochondrial (COI, 16S, and 12S) loci were amplified using the following primers (all 5’-3’): COIF GGT CAA CAA ATC ATA AAG ATA TTG G, and COIR TAA ACT TCA GGG TGA CCA AAR AAY CA (
Chromatograms were consulted to resolve rare ambiguous base calls. Consensus sequences for 28S, and when necessary ITS1 and ITS2, were produced by aligning forward and reverse sequences in Geneious Pro 9.1.8 (Biomatters, Auckland, New Zealand). Alignments were obtained using Clustal W in MEGA 7 (
GenBank accession numbers for DNA sequences. All sequences are new, except for the two specimens from China (
Species | Individual (DNA) | Locality | GenBank COI | GenBank 16S | GenBank 12S | GenBank ITS1 | GenBank ITS2 | GenBank 28S |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
W. sinanui | 2737 H | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970711 | MG970879 | MG970945 | |||
2738 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970712 | MG970880 | MG970946 | ||||
2740 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970713 | MG970881 | MG970947 | MG971020 | MG971093 | MG971161 | |
2746 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970714 | ||||||
5844 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970715 | MG971021 | MG971094 | MG971162 | |||
5845 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970716 | MG971022 | MG971095 | MG971163 | |||
5846 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970717 | ||||||
W. uncinus | 2250 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970718 | MG970882 | MG970948 | |||
2256 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970719 | MG970883 | MG970949 | MG971023 | MG971096 | MG971164 | |
2261 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970720 | ||||||
2268 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970721 | MG971024 | MG971097 | MG971165 | |||
2751 H | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970722 | MG970884 | MG970950 | ||||
2752 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970723 | ||||||
2843 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970724 | ||||||
3138 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970725 | MG970885 | MG970951 | ||||
5029 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970726 | MG971025 | MG971098 | MG971166 | |||
5056 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970727 | ||||||
5070 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970728 | ||||||
5079 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970729 | MG970886 | MG970952 | ||||
5080 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970730 | ||||||
5900 | Timor, Indonesia | MG970731 | MG970887 | MG970953 | MG971026 | MG971099 | MG971167 | |
W. buetschlii | 2120 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970732 | MG971027 | MG971100 | |||
2122 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970733 | ||||||
2189 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970734 | MG970888 | MG970954 | MG971028 | MG971101 | MG971168 | |
2249 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970735 | MG971029 | MG971102 | ||||
2310 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970736 | ||||||
2554 | Queensland, Australia | MG970737 | MG970889 | MG970955 | MG971030 | MG971103 | MG971169 | |
2555 | Queensland, Australia | MG970738 | ||||||
2722 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970739 | MG970890 | MG970956 | MG971031 | MG971104 | MG971170 | |
2853 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970740 | ||||||
2872 | Seram, Indonesia | MG970741 | ||||||
2928 | Kei, Indonesia | MG970742 | ||||||
2933 | Kei, Indonesia | MG970743 | ||||||
2982 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970744 | MG971032 | MG971105 | ||||
2989 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970745 | MG970891 | MG970957 | ||||
3123 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970746 | ||||||
3128 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970747 | MG971033 | MG971106 | MG971171 | |||
3159 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970748 | ||||||
3409 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970749 | MG970892 | MG970958 | MG971034 | MG971107 | MG971172 | |
3410 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970750 | ||||||
3631 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970751 | ||||||
3637 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970752 | ||||||
W. buetschlii | 5016 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970753 | MG970893 | MG970959 | |||
5067 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970754 | ||||||
5898 | Timor, Indonesia | MG970755 | ||||||
W. gracile | 2252 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970756 | |||||
2276 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970757 | ||||||
2277 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970758 | MG970894 | MG970960 | MG971035 | MG971108 | MG971173 | |
2280 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970759 | ||||||
3106 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970760 | ||||||
3107 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970761 | MG970895 | MG970961 | ||||
3633 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970762 | ||||||
3648 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970763 | MG970896 | MG970962 | MG971036 | MG971109 | MG971174 | |
3652 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970764 | ||||||
3653 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970765 | MG970897 | MG970963 | MG971037 | MG971110 | MG971175 | |
5158 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970766 | MG970898 | MG970964 | ||||
5159 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970767 | ||||||
5932 | Timor, Indonesia | MG970768 | MG970899 | MG970965 | ||||
W. nangkauriense | 1074 | Andaman Islands, India | MG970769 | MG970900 | MG970966 | |||
1075 | Andaman Islands, India | MG970770 | ||||||
1786 | Sumatra, Indonesia | MG970771 | MG970901 | MG970967 | ||||
1787 | Sumatra, Indonesia | MG970772 | MG971038 | MG971111 | MG971176 | |||
1788 | Sumatra, Indonesia | MG970773 | MG971039 | MG971112 | ||||
2156 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970774 | ||||||
2161 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970775 | MG970902 | MG970968 | MG971040 | MG971113 | MG971177 | |
2192 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970776 | MG970903 | MG970969 | ||||
2257 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970777 | ||||||
2731 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970778 | MG970904 | MG970970 | MG971041 | MG971114 | MG971178 | |
2972 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970779 | MG971042 | MG971115 | ||||
3129 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970780 | ||||||
3136 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970781 | MG970905 | MG970971 | MG971043 | MG971116 | MG971179 | |
3162 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970782 | MG971044 | MG971117 | ||||
3208 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970783 | MG971045 | MG971118 | ||||
3217 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970784 | MG971046 | MG971119 | ||||
3268 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970785 | MG971047 | MG971120 | ||||
3269 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970786 | MG970906 | MG970972 | MG971048 | MG971121 | MG971180 | |
3276 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970787 | ||||||
3396 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970788 | ||||||
3401 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970789 | ||||||
3427 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970790 | ||||||
5763 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970791 | MG971049 | MG971122 | ||||
W. ater unit #1 | 2157 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970792 | |||||
2164 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970793 | MG970907 | MG970973 | MG971050 | MG971123 | MG971181 | |
2170 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970794 | ||||||
2221 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970795 | MG971051 | MG971124 | MG971182 | |||
2283 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970796 | ||||||
2330 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970797 | MG971052 | MG971125 | ||||
2727 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970798 | MG971053 | MG971126 | ||||
2939 | Kei, Indonesia | MG970799 | MG970908 | MG970974 | MG971054 | MG971127 | MG971183 | |
W. ater unit #1 | 2966 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970800 | |||||
2970 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970801 | MG971055 | MG971128 | ||||
2974 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970802 | ||||||
2978 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970803 | ||||||
3130 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970804 | MG970909 | MG970975 | MG971056 | MG971129 | MG971184 | |
3210 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970805 | ||||||
3215 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970806 | ||||||
3265 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970807 | MG971057 | MG971130 | ||||
3266 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970808 | MG971058 | MG971131 | ||||
3272 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970809 | MG970910 | MG970976 | MG971059 | MG971132 | MG971185 | |
3373 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970810 | ||||||
3393 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970811 | MG971060 | MG971133 | ||||
3404 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970812 | ||||||
3405 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970813 | ||||||
3406 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970814 | ||||||
3624 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970815 | ||||||
3629 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970816 | ||||||
3634 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970817 | ||||||
5057 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970818 | ||||||
5078 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970819 | ||||||
5121 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970820 | MG970911 | MG970977 | MG971061 | MG971134 | MG971186 | |
W. ater unit #2 | 2145 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970821 | |||||
2177 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970822 | MG970912 | MG970978 | ||||
2220 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970823 | ||||||
2228 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970824 | MG970913 | MG970979 | ||||
2986 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970825 | ||||||
3132 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970826 | MG971062 | MG971135 | MG971187 | |||
3137 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970827 | MG970914 | MG970980 | MG971063 | MG971136 | MG971188 | |
3591 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970828 | ||||||
3212 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970829 | MG971064 | MG971137 | MG971189 | |||
3270 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970830 | MG970915 | MG970981 | ||||
3271 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970831 | ||||||
3277 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970832 | ||||||
3370 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970833970833 | ||||||
3408 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970834 | ||||||
3420 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970835 | MG971065 | MG971138 | MG971190 | |||
5125 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970836 | MG970916 | MG970982 | ||||
W. graniferum unit #1 | 3163 | Luzon, Philippines | MG970837 | MG970917 | MG970983 | MG971066 | MG971139 | MG971191 |
3635 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970838 | MG970918 | MG970984 | MG971067 | MG971140 | MG971192 | |
3636 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970839 | MG970919 | MG970985 | MG971068 | MG971141 | MG971193 | |
5760 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970840 | MG970920 | MG970986 | MG971069 | MG971142 | MG971194 | |
5761 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970841 | MG970921 | MG970987 | MG971070 | MG971143 | MG971195 | |
S211 | China (21°06'N) | JN543166 | ||||||
S221 | China (21°06'N) | JN543167 | ||||||
W. graniferum unit #2 | 3638 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970842 | MG970922 | MG970988 | |||
5762 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970843 | MG970923 | MG970989 | MG971071 | MG971144 | MG971196 | |
5902 | Timor, Indonesia | MG970844 | MG970924 | MG970990 | ||||
W. achleitneri | 2645 | Queensland, Australia | MG970845 | MG970925 | MG970991 | MG971072 | MG971145 | MG971197 |
3534 H | Queensland, Australia | MG970846 | MG970926 | MG970992 | MG971073 | MG971146 | MG971198 | |
3535 | Queensland, Australia | MG970847 | MG970927 | MG970993 | MG971074 | MG971147 | MG971199 | |
W. comendadori | 2315 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970848 | MG970928 | MG970994 | |||
2725 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970849 | MG971075 | MG971148 | MG971200 | |||
3539 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970850 | MG970929 | MG970995 | MG971076 | MG971149 | MG971201 | |
2983 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970851 | ||||||
2985 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970852 | MG970930 | MG970996 | ||||
3131 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970853 | ||||||
3133 | Bali, Indonesia | MG970854 | MG970931 | MG970997 | ||||
3626 H | Bohol, Philippines | MG970855 | MG970932 | MG970998 | MG971077 | MG971150 | MG971202 | |
3385 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970856 | ||||||
3400 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970857 | MG970933 | MG970999 | MG971078 | MG971151 | MG971203 | |
3627 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970858 | MG971079 | MG971152 | ||||
3630 | Bohol, Philippines | MG970859 | MG971080 | MG971153 | ||||
W. melanesiensis unit #1 | 2202 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970860 | |||||
2215 | Sulawesi, Indonesia | MG970861 | MG970934 | MG971000 | ||||
2732 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970862 | MG970935 | MG971001 | ||||
2733 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970863 | ||||||
2735 | Ambon, Indonesia | MG970864 | MG970936 | MG971002 | ||||
5065 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970865 | MG970937 | MG971003 | ||||
5026 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970866 | MG970938 | MG971004 | ||||
5131 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970867 | ||||||
5132 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970868 | ||||||
5133 | Halmahera, Indonesia | MG970869 | ||||||
5417 H | Papua New Guinea | MG970870 | MG970939 | MG971005 | MG971081 | MG971154 | MG971204 | |
5421 | Papua New Guinea | MG970871 | MG971082 | MG971155 | ||||
5446 | Papua New Guinea | MG970872 | MG970940 | MG971006 | MG971083 | MG971156 | MG971205 | |
5483 | Vanuatu | MG970873 | MG970941 | MG971007 | MG971084 | MG971157 | MG971206 | |
5484 | Vanuatu | MG970874 | MG970942 | MG971008 | MG971085 | MG971158 | MG971207 | |
6089 | New Ireland, PNG | MG970875 | ||||||
6090 | New Ireland, PNG | MG970876 | MG971086 | MG971159 | ||||
W. melanesiensis unit #2 | 2963 | Lombok, Indonesia | MG970877 | MG970943 | MG971009 | MG971087 | MG971160 | MG971208 |
Platevindex luteum | Singapore | MG958714 | MG958716 | MG971010 | MG971088 | MG958718 | MG958888 | |
Peronina tenera | Peninsular Malaysia | MG958740 | MG958796 | MG971011 | ||||
Onchidina australis | New South Wales, Australia | KX179548 | KX179561 | MG971012 | MG971089 | MG958719 | MG971209 | |
Onchidium typhae | Peninsular Malaysia | KX179509 | KX179525 | MG971013 | MG971090 | MG958720 | MG971210 | |
Onchidium stuxbergi | Vietnam | KX179520 | KX179537 | MG971014 | MG971091 | MG958721 | MG971211 | |
Peronia sp. | Okinawa, Japan | HQ660043 | HQ659911 | MG971015 | ||||
Peronia sp. | Hawaii, USA | HQ660038 | HQ659906 | MG971016 | MG971092 | MG958722 | MG971212 | |
Onchidella floridana | Tobago | HQ660035 | HQ659903 | MG971017 | ||||
Onchidella celtica | France | MG958715 | MG958717 | MG971018 | ||||
Onchidella patelloide | New South Wales, Australia | MG970878 | MG970944 | MG971019 |
Four independent sets of phylogenetic analyses were performed: 1) Maximum Likelihood and Bayesian analyses with just COI sequences, performed with 169 individuals (not counting outgroups); 2) Maximum Likelihood and Bayesian analyses with concatenated COI, 16S, and 12S sequences, performed with 65 individuals (not counting outgroups); 3) Maximum Likelihood, Bayesian, and Maximum Parsimony analyses with concatenated ITS1, ITS2 and 28S sequences, performed with 48 individuals (not counting outgroups); and 4) Maximum Parsimony analyses with concatenated ITS1 and ITS2 sequences, performed with 68 individuals (not counting outgroups).
Prior to phylogenetic analyses, the best-fitting evolutionary model for each marker was selected using the Model Selection option from TOPALi v2.5 (
DNA sequences were used to test species limits, species phylogenetic relationships and the monophyly of Wallaconchis. More specifically, mitochondrial and nuclear sequences were used independently to determine whether different markers may yield different results.
The monophyly of Wallaconchis is strongly supported in all analyses (Figs
Phylogenetic tree based on mitochondrial COI sequences. Numbers by branches show bootstrap values (Maximum Likelihood analysis) and posterior probabilities (Bayesian analysis). Only significant numbers (>80% and >0.9) are indicated. Onchidella, Peronia, Peronina, Platevindex, Onchidium, Onchidina, and Melayonchis sequences serve as outgroups. Numbers for each individual correspond to unique identifiers used for DNA extraction. All sequences of Wallaconchis specimens are new, except two sequences obtained from GenBank (from specimens from China). Information on individually-identified specimens can be found in the lists of material examined and in Table
Analyses of COI sequences yielded 13 least-inclusive molecular units, all reciprocally monophyletic and highly supported, with bootstrap values above 99 and posterior probabilities of 1 (Fig.
Phylogenetic tree based on concatenated mitochondrial COI, 16S, and 12S sequences. Numbers by branches show bootstrap values (Maximum Likelihood analysis) and posterior probabilities (Bayesian analysis). Only significant numbers (>80% and >0.9) are indicated. All sequences of Wallaconchis specimens are new. Information on individually-identified specimens can be found in the lists of material examined and in Table
Analyses based on nuclear sequences, whether with all three markers (ITS1, ITS2, 28S) (Figs
Maximum parsimony bootstrap consensus tree based on concatenated nuclear ITS1, ITS2, and 28S sequences. Only bootstrap values >70% are indicated. All sequences of Wallaconchis specimens are new. Information on individually-identified specimens can be found in the lists of material examined and in Table
Maximum Likelihood phylogenetic tree based on concatenated nuclear ITS1, ITS2, and 28S sequences. Numbers by branches show bootstrap values (only numbers >80% are indicated). All sequences of Wallaconchis specimens are new. Information on individually-identified specimens can be found in the lists of material examined and in Table
Maximum parsimony bootstrap consensus tree based on concatenated nuclear ITS1 and ITS2 sequences. Only bootstrap values >70% are indicated. All sequences of Wallaconchis specimens are new. Information on individually-identified specimens can be found in the lists of material examined and in Table
In the Maximum Likelihood analyses based on the three (ITS1, ITS2, and 28S) concatenated nuclear markers (Fig.
Pairwise genetic divergences (Table
Pairwise genetic distances of COI sequences within and between mitochondrial molecular units. Ranges of minimum to maximum distances are indicated (in percentage). For instance, within W. ater unit #1, individual sequences are between 0% and 2.8% divergent, but sequences of W. ater unit # 1 and W. ater unit #2 are between 25.7% and 28.9% divergent.
Species | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. W. uncinus | 0.0–0.4 | ||||||||||||
2. W. buetschlii | 22.1–22.6 | 0.0–3.2 | |||||||||||
3. W. gracile | 14.9–16.4 | 19.8–22.0 | 0.0–1.1 | ||||||||||
4. W. nangkauriense | 13.1–15.3 | 21.2–23.6 | 14.2–16.3 | 0.0–2.1 | |||||||||
5. W. ater unit #1 | 14.6–17.1 | 23.1–26.8 | 16.0–19.1 | 10.4–13.1 | 0.0–2.8 | ||||||||
6. W. ater unit #2 | 21.4–23.1 | 25.4–28.2 | 22.5–24.6 | 23.4–24.9 | 25.7–28.9 | 0.2–1.3 | |||||||
7. W. graniferum unit #1 | 11.0–12.4 | 20.6–24.4 | 15.0–16.4 | 12.8–15.2 | 14.3–17.0 | 24.1–25.3 | 0.0–1.1 | ||||||
8. W. graniferum unit #2 | 19.8–21.4 | 23.5–26.6 | 19.8–21.4 | 20.2–22.3 | 20.9–24.5 | 17.9–19.5 | 21.8–22.6 | 0.2–2.8 | |||||
9. W. sinanui | 14.5–16.5 | 20.2–23.6 | 15.4–16.9 | 14.7–17.0 | 19.1–21.8 | 23.3–25.4 | 15.2–17.2 | 21.3–23.9 | 0.2–1.7 | ||||
10. W. achleitneri | 14.4–15.3 | 21.9–24.0 | 14.5–15.6 | 6.1–7.5 | 10.4–12.6 | 26.4–27.1 | 13.4–14.6 | 20.6–21.2 | 15.0–16.0 | 0.0–0.2 | |||
11. W. comendadori | 26.8–29.2 | 23.5–26.6 | 24.2–26.5 | 26.1–29.0 | 29.6–32.3 | 32.7–34.9 | 28.2–29.7 | 31.9–36.1 | 26.5–29.6 | 27.6–29.3 | 0.2–1.9 | ||
12. W. melanesiensis unit #1 | 26.0–28.6 | 27.8–32.9 | 27.1–31.8 | 24.3–28.3 | 25.2–28.4 | 33.6–37.9 | 27.9–31.2 | 32.8–36.9 | 27.4–30.5 | 27.5–29.6 | 23.5–27.4 | 0.2–5.6 | |
13. W. melanesiensis unit #2 | 32.9–33.9 | 34.8–36.9 | 35.2–36.8 | 36.5–38.1 | 38.7–40.3 | 39.5–40.3 | 36.7–37.2 | 40.3–41.6 | 31.3–33.6 | 37.3–37.7 | 30.3–33.0 | 26.3–27.8 | – |
The divergences between W. ater unit #1 and W. ater unit #2, between W. graniferum unit #1 and W. graniferum unit #2, and between W. melanesiensis unit #1 and W. melanesiensis unit #2 are all extremely high: minimally 21.8% (between the two W. graniferum units) to 27.8% (between the two W. melanesiensis units). However, nuclear DNA sequences and morphology show that these three pairs of units with such widely divergent haplotypes actually correspond to only three species instead of six (see below). The mitochondrial divergences likely are related to the mode of inheritance and evolution of the mitochondrial genome combined with recent population isolation due to sea level changes (see the Discussion).
Species delineation. Determining the species diversity of Wallaconchis requires integrating mitochondrial and nuclear data with morphology. Overall, ten Wallaconchis species are recognized here: two in clade A and eight in clade B (Figs
Wallaconchis sinanui, designated here.
Combination of Wallace, for Alfred Russel Wallace, one of the first naturalists to widely study the fauna of the Indo-Malay Archipelago, and Onchis, one of the names used to refer to onchidiid slugs. The core of the geographic distribution of this genus in Indonesia (Bali, Lombok, Sulawesi, and eastern Indonesia) corresponds to a region sometimes referred to as Wallacea, also after A. R. Wallace, which makes it especially fitting here.
Masculine, gender of Onchis.
Body not flattened. Dorsal gills absent. Dorsal eyes present on notum, mostly in groups of three or four eyes. Central dorsal papilla bearing eyes present and retractable, but usually not raised above the dorsal surface. Eyes at the tip of short ocular tentacles. Male opening below the right ocular tentacle. Oral lobes typically grey or dark brown. Pneumostome median. Foot wide. Visceral cavity pigmented (in black), which varies in intensity between individuals. Intestinal loops of type I. Rectal gland absent. Accessory penial gland absent. Penial morphology highly diverse, from short and straight to long and coiled. Penial hooks absent or present.
Every available genus name was carefully evaluated when searching for a name for this genus, which included examination of the type specimens of the type species of all existing genera, as well as the analysis of all the original descriptions. Nine existing species names are transferred to Wallaconchis, five of which are valid, one of which is a synonym, and three of which are nomina dubia. Historically, these five valid species names have been placed in three different genera: Onchidium Buchannan, 1800, Paraoncidium Labbé, 1934, and Scaphis Labbé, 1934. However, all five species were originally described in Onchidium (sometimes with the unjustified emendation Oncidium), traditionally used by default for many unrelated onchidiids (
Finally, a new combination was proposed by
Overall, none of the three genus names historically used in binomials for the species described here (Onchidium, Paraoncidium, Scaphis) could apply to our new genus.
(Fig.
Geographic distribution of Wallaconchis species. The colors used for each species are the same as those used in phylogenetic trees (Figs
(Table
A unique combination of characters can be used to determine whether a specimen is part of a Wallaconchis species: no dorsal gills, intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, and no accessory penial gland. This combination is not found in any other genus and these anatomical features can be easily and quickly observed through dissection. It is more challenging to identify Wallaconchis slugs using external characters, but it is not impossible. Wallaconchis slugs exhibit the highest degree of color variation in the Onchidiidae. In some species, the dorsal notum can be red, yellow, green, orange, brown, grey, black, etc., when most onchidiids are usually just brown, marbled with light to dark brown. Such bright dorsal colors are also found in Peronia, but Peronia is easily distinguished from Wallaconchis (the dorsal notum of Peronia bears gills that are absent in Wallaconchis). However, the three Wallaconchis species which are found on mud inside and around mangroves only occasionally exhibit patches of bright colors, and thus, can be easily mistaken for other genera found in mangroves. The male opening can also help identify Wallaconchis slugs at the generic level. In other genera, the male opening may be to the left of the right ocular tentacle (e.g., Melayonchis, Onchidium), or to the right of the right tentacle (e.g., Peronina, Onchidina), while in Wallaconchis it is directly below the right ocular tentacle (
Indonesia, Ambon, Lateri, 03°38.26'S, 128°14.72'E, st 128, mudflat next to small creek in mangrove preserve.
Holotype, 9/5 mm [2737], designated here (UMIZ 00058).
Indonesia, Ambon, Lateri, 03°38.26'S, 128°14.72'E, 6 specimens 11/6 mm [5844], 10/4 mm [2738], 9/6 mm [5845], 9/4 mm [2746], 9/4 mm [2740], and 7/5 mm [5846], st 128, mudflat next to small creek in mangrove preserve (UMIZ 00059).
Indonesia: Ambon (type locality).
(Fig.
Habitats and live specimens, Wallaconchis sinanui, Indonesia, Ambon, Lateri. A Type locality, mudflat adjacent to a shallow river through a mangrove (st 128) B Close up of mud with a few individuals of W. sinanui (same locality as A) C Wider view of the mud with many individuals of W. sinanui (same locality as A) D Dorsal view, 9 mm long [2746] (UMIZ 00059) E Holotype, dorsal view, 9 mm long [2737] (UMIZ 00058) F Dorsal view, 9 mm long [2740] (UMIZ 00059).
Wallaconchis sinanui is dedicated to Dominggus Ledrick Sinanu, the guard of the protected mangrove forest in Lateri who advocated for its conservation. This mangrove forest is one of the few left in Ambon, and the only locality where this species was found.
(Table
(Fig.
The dorsal notum is mostly brown, usually with two additional dark stripes or a longitudinal dark band. The ocular tentacles are light brown. The hyponotum and the foot are brownish-grey.
(Fig.
External morphology and digestive system, Wallaconchis sinanui, Indonesia, Ambon (A–C) holotype [2737] (UMIZ 00058) (D–F) [2738] (UMIZ 00059). A Dorsal notum B Anterior region, ventral view C Posterior region, ventral view D Digestive system, dorsal view E Digestive system, dorsal view (digestive gland removed) F Digestive system, ventral view (digestive gland removed). Abbreviations: a anus ddg dorsal digestive gland f foot fo female opening hn hyponotum i intestine mo male opening oddg opening of the dorsal lobe of the digestive gland oldg opening of the lateral lobe of the digestive gland opdg opening of the posterior lobe of the digestive gland ol oral lobe ot ocular tentacle pn pneumostome pdg posterior lobe of the digestive gland ppg peripodial groove st1 first stomach chamber st2 second stomach chamber st3 third stomach chamber st4 fourth stomach chamber. Scale bars: 2 mm (A, B, C); 1 mm (D, E, F).
Marginal glands (found in Onchidella Gray, 1850) are absent. The visceral cavity is not divided: the heart is not separated from the visceral organs by a thick, muscular membrane (as in Hoffmannola Strand, 1932). The heart is enclosed in the pericardium, in the posterior half of the right side of the visceral cavity. The large, anterior, ventricle becomes a large aorta that branches into smaller vessels delivering blood to the visceral organs. The auricle, significantly smaller than the ventricle, is posterior. The pericardium communicates through a small hole with the right portion of the renal-pulmonary complex. The kidney is intricately attached to the pulmonary cavity and is slightly asymmetrical (the right part being slightly larger than the left part).
(Figs
Radula, Wallaconchis sinanui, Indonesia, Ambon [5845] (UMIZ 00059). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth B Rachidian and innermost lateral teethC Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth D Outermost lateral teeth E Right lateral teeth with basal lateral spine F Outermost lateral teeth. Abbreviations: rt rachidian tooth mc median cusp lc lateral cusp 1llt first left lateral tooth 1rlt first right lateral tooth 2llt second left lateral tooth 2rlt second right lateral tooth bls basal lateral spine (of lateral tooth) nls no lateral spine hlt hook of lateral tooth ollt outermost left lateral tooth. Scale bars: 10 μm (A); 20 μm (B, D, E); 40 μm (C), 10 μm (F).
Species | Radular formula | Specimen size (length, in mm) | Catalog Numbers | DNA extraction number |
---|---|---|---|---|
W. sinanui | 36 × (50-1-50) | 11 | UMIZ 00059 | 5844 |
34 × (50-1-50) | 9 | UMIZ 00059 | 5845 | |
37 × (50-1-50) | 7 | UMIZ 00059 | 5846 | |
W. uncinus | 59 × (85-1-85) | 28 | UMIZ 00007 | 2843 |
48 × (65-1-65) | 15 | UMIZ 00008 | 3138 | |
74 × (95-1-95) | 40 | UMIZ 00011 | 5079 | |
W. buetschlii | 58 × (85-1-85) | 31 | UMIZ 00021 | 2120 |
71 × (105-1-105) | 42 | MTQ st100 | 2554 | |
42 × (70-1-70) | 16 | MTQ st100 | 2555 | |
W. gracile | 50 × (85-1-85) | 22 | UMIZ 00056 | N/A |
44 × (75-1-75) | 17 | UMIZ 00056 | 3106 | |
51 × (65-1-65) | 24 | PNM 041231 | 3652 | |
W. nangkauriense | 74 × (100-1-100) | 42 | UMIZ 00012 | N/A |
59 × (80-1-80) | 18 | UMIZ 00020 | 3129 | |
74 × (105-1-105) | 28 | PNM 041206 | 3276 | |
W. ater unit #1 | 71 × (113-1-113) | 33 | UMIZ 00038 | 2283 |
67 × (96-1-96) | 25 | UMIZ 00039 | 2330 | |
43 × (55-1-55) | 17 | UMIZ 00041 | 2939 | |
W. ater unit #2 | 65 × (90-1-90) | 29 | UMIZ 00050 | 2220 |
55 × (80-1-80) | 22 | UMIZ 00053 | 3137 | |
60 × (90-1-90) | 30 | PNM 041222 | 3270 | |
W. graniferum unit #1 | 64 × (105-1-105) | 46 | PNM 041227 | 3163 |
60 × (95-1-95) | 28 | PNM 041228 | 3636 | |
59 × (95-1-95) | 18 | PNM 041228 | 5760 | |
W. graniferum unit #2 | 60 × (85-1-85) | 26 | PNM 041228 | 3638 |
58 × (85-1-85) | 16 | PNM 041228 | 5762 | |
W. achleitneri | 37 × (70-1-70) | 14 | MTQ st117 | N/A |
38 × (65-1-65) | 8 | MTQ st117 | 3535 | |
36 × (60-1-60) | 7 | MTQ st117 | 3534 | |
W. comendadori | 47 × (95-1-95) | 7 | UMIZ 00061 | 3539 |
52 × (115-1-115) | 18 | UMIZ 00063 | 2985 | |
51 × (105-1-105) | 22 | PNM 041234 | 3385 | |
W. melanesiensis unit #1 | 58 × (130-1-130) | 13 | UMIZ 00068 | 2733 |
68 × (175-1-175) | 43 | UMIZ 00068 | 2735 | |
62 × (105-1-105) | 23 | UMIZ 00069 | 5132 | |
W. melanesiensis unit #2 | 47 × (150-1-150) | 27 | UMIZ 00070 | 2963 |
The esophagus is narrow and straight; its internal folds cannot be seen externally. The esophagus enters the stomach anteriorly. The stomach is located on the left dorsal side of the visceral mass. In dorsal view, only a portion of its posterior aspect can be seen because it is partly covered by the lobes of the digestive gland. The dorsal lobe is mainly on the right, the left, lateral lobe is mainly ventral, and the posterior lobe covers the posterior aspect of the stomach. The stomach is a U-shaped sac divided into four chambers (Fig.
(Fig.
Nervous system, Wallaconchis sinanui, holotype, Indonesia, Ambon [2737] (UMIZ 00058) scale bar 0.5 mm. Abbreviations: lcg left cerebral ganglion lpg left pedal ganglion lplg left pleural ganglion rcg right cerebral ganglion rpg right pedal ganglion rplg right pleural ganglion vg visceral ganglion.
(Fig.
The hermaphroditic gland is a single mass. A hermaphroditic duct conveys the eggs and the autosperm from the hermaphroditic gland to the fertilization chamber, which connects to a large, elongate, usually bent receptaculum seminis (caecum). The shape and size of the receptaculum seminis vary between individuals. The female gland mass contains various glands (mucus and albumen) of which the exact connections remain uncertain. The spermoviduct (for the autosperm, the exosperm, and the eggs) is embedded within the female gland mass, at least proximally. Distally, the spermoviduct branches into the deferent duct (which conveys the autosperm to the anterior region, running through the body wall) and the oviduct. The latter conveys the eggs up to the female opening and the exosperm. The oviduct is short (approximately the same length as the free deferent duct) and almost as narrow as the deferent duct. The spherical spermatheca connects to the narrow distal portion of the oviduct through a short duct.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis sinanui, holotype, Indonesia, Ambon [2737] (UMIZ 00058). A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, scale bar 0.8 mm B Anterior, male copulatory parts, scale bar 2 mm. Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca v vestibule.
(Figs
Indonesia, Ambon, Lateri, 03°38.26'S, 128°14.72'E, st 128, mudflat next to small creek in the low intertidal of mangrove preserve.
Holotype, 22/17 mm [2751], designated here (UMIZ 00004).
Indonesia, North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 4 specimens 22/11 mm [2256], 22/16 mm [2250], 18/7 mm [2268], 17/7 mm [2261], st 90, old Avicennia, Sonneratia, Rhizophora mangrove forest with, rocks and dead logs (UMIZ 00005); Ambon, Lateri, 03°38.26'S, 128°14.72'E, 1 specimen 30/21 mm [2752], st 128, mudflat next to small creek and mangrove (UMIZ 00006); Ambon, Lateri, 03°38.24'S, 128°14.78'E, 1 specimen 28/17 mm [2843], st 131, muddy Rhizophora mangrove (UMIZ 00007); Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, 08°08.61'S, 114°32.33'E, 1 specimen 15/13 mm [3138], st 157, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (UMIZ 00008); North Maluku, Ternate, Bastiong, 00°46.41'N, 127°22.76'E, 1 specimen (24/11 mm [5056]), st 203, muddy rocks near a mangrove (UMIZ 00009); Halmahera, Sofifi, 00°45.47'N, 127°35.90'E, 2 specimens 25/16 mm [5070] and 22/16 mm [5029], st 205, Sonneratia mangrove (UMIZ 00010); Halmahera, Akelamo, 01°01.33'N, 127°39.09'E, 2 specimens 40/25 mm [5079] and 35/30 mm [5080], st 207, sandy-muddy beach at margin of mangrove (UMIZ 00011); Timor, Oesapa, Kupang City, 10°08.73'S, 123°38.10'E, 1 specimen 29/18 mm [5900], st 250, open Sonneratia mangrove (UMIZ 00071).
Indonesia: Ambon (type locality), Bali, Halmahera, northern Sulawesi, and Timor.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A, B Sulawesi, Wori, tall mangrove forest of Sonneratia and some Avicennia with a rocky area and dead logs (st 90) C Ambon, Lateri, muddy mangrove with Rhizophora and Avicennia (st 131) D Type locality, Ambon, Lateri, mudflat adjacent to a shallow river through a mangrove (st 128) E Halmahera, Sofifi, mangrove with Sonneratia trees, dense roots and hard mud (st 205) F Ternate, Bastiong, muddy rocks nearby a mangrove patch (st 203).
From the Latin adjective uncinus meaning “hooked”, to refer to the distinctive hooks that the penis bears.
(Table
Summary of traits that can help identify Wallaconchis species. Observations between parentheses are less common. All traits may be subject to individual variation. Traits are described in detail in the corresponding species descriptions.
Species | Dorsal color | Hyponotum color | Penis | Oviduct |
---|---|---|---|---|
W. sinanui | Brown with dark brown mottling | Brownish-grey | Narrow, within penial sheath | Narrow |
W. uncinus | Brown, mottle brown and orange (red, black) | Light grey, cream, light orange | Loops with curved hooks, in vestibule | Wide |
W. buetschlii | Grey-brown (red, yellow-brown) | Dark grey, light grey, cream | No penial sheath. Internal longitudinal ridges | Narrow, in membrane attached to body wall |
W. gracile | Brown (yellow, brown with patches of yellow, orange, or red) | Light yellow-orange | Narrow tube within penial sheath | Narrow, in membrane attached to body wall |
W. nangkauriense | Extremely variable: grey, red, yellow, black, orange, brown, green | Light grey, cream (dark grey, white) | Narrow tube within vestibule | Extremely long, slightly narrow |
W. ater | Extremely variable: grey, red, yellow, black, brown, green | Grey, cream, yellow-grey, yellow-orange | Loops form a coil in vestibule | Wide |
W. graniferum | Brown, orange, yellow | Beige-orange, cream or white | Bears straight hooks, in vestibule | Wide |
W. achleitneri | Brown-grey | Light yellow-grey | Narrow, within vestibule | Slightly narrow |
W. comendadori | Brown, black (with patches brown, yellow, grey, red, black) | Yellow-orange, grey, or both | Narrow, within penial sheath | Narrow |
W. melanesiensis | Grey, black (red-black), brown | Light grey, bluish-grey | Narrow, within penial sheath | Narrow |
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A Dorsal view, 25 mm long [5070], Halmahera (UMIZ 00010) B Holotype, dorsal view, 22 mm long [2751], Ambon (UMIZ 00004) C Dorsal view, 30 mm long [2752], Ambon (UMIZ 00006) D Dorsal view, 28 mm long [2843], Ambon (UMIZ 00008) E Dorsal view, 15 mm long [3138], Bali (UMIZ 00005) F Dorsal view, 25 mm long [5080], Halmahera (UMIZ 00011) G Ventral view, same as F H Ventral view, same as B.
(Fig.
External morphology and digestive system, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A Anterior region, ventral view, Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2268] (UMIZ 00005) B Posterior region, ventral view, Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2268] (UMIZ 00005) C Dorsal notum (papillae with dorsal eyes), Halmahera, scale bar 2.6 mm [5056] (UMIZ 00009) D Digestive system, dorsal view, Sulawesi, scale bar 1 mm [2268] (UMIZ 00005). Abbreviations: a anus ddg dorsal lobe of digestive gland f foot fo female opening hn hyponotum i intestine mo male opening ol oral lobe ot ocular tentacle pdg posterior lobe of the digestive gland pn pneumostome ppg peripodial groove st2 stomach chamber 2.
(Figs
Radula, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Bali, scale bar 10 μm [3138] (UMIZ 00008) B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Halmahera, scale bar 20 μm [5079] (UMIZ 00011) C Transition from inner to outer lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm, same as B D Outer lateral teeth, scale bar 40 μm, same as B E Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm, same as B F Outermost lateral teeth, Ambon, scale bar 20 μm [2843] (UMIZ 00007). Abbreviations: bls basal lateral spine (of lateral tooth) nls no lateral spine.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2268] (UMIZ 00005) B Anterior, male copulatory parts, Halmahera, scale bar 3 mm [5079] (UMIZ 00011) C Anterior, male copulatory parts, Bali, scale bar 1 mm [3138] (UMIZ 00008) D Penis (fully evaginated), Halmahera, scale bar 0.5 mm [5079] (UMIZ 00011). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca v vestibule.
(Figs
Penis, Wallaconchis uncinus, Indonesia. A Two most distal loops of fully evaginated penis (the loop on the right is proximal to the loop on the left), Halmahera, scale bar 0.5 mm [5079] (UMIZ 00011) B Two most distal loops of (nearly fully evaginated) penis (the loop on the right is proximal to the loop on the left), Ambon, scale bar 300 μm [2843] (UMIZ 00007) C Proximal region of penis, detail view of curved hooks, Sulawesi, scale bar 100 μm [2268] (UMIZ 00005) D Distal region of penis which is not fully evaginated, scale bar 300 μm, same as C. Abbreviations: ch curved hooks ih immature hooks rh rounded hooks.
Onchidium
buetschlii
Stantschinsky, 1907: 383–386, pl. 12, figs 10–12, pl. 13, figs 20a, 20b, 22, 35;
Onchidium
gracile
:
Australien: Queensland [Queensland, Australia]. Stantschinsky indicated that the syntypes were collected from the state of Queensland by Professor Simroth, but no detailed information about the locality is available in either the original description or the jar of the type material. Fresh material was collected from the type locality (see below, additional material).
Lectotype, 19/17 mm, designated here (SMF 333595/2). The lectotype was dissected prior to the present study and its posterior end is missing. A lectotype is designated here because its remaining anterior, male parts can be used for species identification. The two other syntypes (30/22 mm and 30/29 mm) become paralectotypes (SMF 333595/2). Both paralectotypes were dissected prior to the present study and their male parts are missing. According to the original description, there were four syntypes, so one syntype has been lost or destroyed.
Indonesia, North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 2 specimens 31/14 mm [2120] and 27/14 mm [2122], st 84, old Sonneratia and Avicennia mangrove (UMIZ 00021); North Sulawesi, Bahoi, 01°43.36'N, 125°01.23'E, 1 specimen 22/18 mm [2189], st 85, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00022); North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 1 specimen 23/14 mm [2249], st 90, old mangrove forest with Avicennia, Sonneratia, and Rhizophora, with rocks (UMIZ 00024); North Sulawesi, Mantehage Island, 01°41.88'N, 124°46.74'E, 1 specimen 32/22 mm [2310], st 91, rocks behind a mangrove of Sonneratia and Rhizophora (UMIZ 00025); Ambon, Haruku Island, 03°36.52'S, 128°25.07'E, 1 specimen 46/21 mm [2722], st 127, rocky Sonneratia mangrove with coral rubble (UMIZ 00026); Ambon, Wai, 03°34.65'S, 128°19.53'E, 1 specimen 31/16 mm [2853], st 132, narrow band of old Avicennia trees on sandy mud, old logs on ground (UMIZ 00027); Seram, 02°58.24'S, 128°07.07'E, 1 specimen 21/17 mm [2872], st 135, mud next to a mangrove (UMIZ 00028); Maluku, Kei Islands, Tual City, Fiditan, 05°35.96'S, 132°45.11'E, 2 specimens 30/16 mm [2928] and 30/15 mm [2933], st 144, rocks behind muddy mangrove of Rhizophora (UMIZ 00029); Lombok, Don Don, 08°54.54'S, 116°21.50'E, 2 specimens 43/23 mm [2982] and 43/23 mm [2989] st 149, old, Avicennia forest with coral rubble (UMIZ 00030); Bali, Gilimanuk, 08°10.16'S, 114°26.65'E, 1 specimen 24/15 mm [3123], st 156, sandy mudflat outside Rhizophora and Avicennia mangrove (UMIZ 00032); Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, 08°08.61'S, 114°32.33'E, 1 specimen 27/17 mm [3128], st 157, coral rubble, rocks and mud with a few Avicennia (UMIZ 00033); North Maluku, Ternate, Bastiong, 00°46.41'N, 127°22.76'E, 1 specimen 32/19 mm [5016], st 203, muddy rocks near a mangrove (UMIZ 00034); Halmahera, Sofifi, 00°45.47'N, 127°35.90'E, 1 specimen 37/20 mm [5067], st 205, Sonneratia mangrove (UMIZ 00035); Timor, Oesapa, 10°08.73'S, 123°38.10'E, 1 specimen 44/26 mm [5898], st 250, sandy area with Sonneratia and Avicennia (UMIZ 00072). Australia, Queensland, Cairns, Yule Point, 16°34.23'S, 145°30.58'E, 2 specimens 43/23 mm [2554] and 16/10 mm [2555], st 100, sand flat outside mangrove with dense Rhizophora (st100, MTQ). Philippines, Mindanao, [no information on the collecting date], 1 specimen 28/20 mm, paralectotype of W. gracile, [no information on the collector] (ZMB 103082b); Luzon, Batangas, Lian, 13°59.76'N, 120°37.43'E, 1 specimen 52/34 mm [3159], st 181, sandy, open Avicennia forest (PNM 041209); Bohol, Guindulman, 09°44.06'N, 124°27.63'E, 1 specimen 31/25 mm [3631], st 197, rocks, coral rubble, and sand near a few Avicennia trees (PNM 041210); Bohol, Loay, 09°36.23'N, 123°59.72'E, 1 specimen 35/20 mm [3637], st 198, mostly sand, and a few Avicennia (PNM 041211); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.28'N, 123°49.39'E, 2 specimens 36/17 mm [3409] and 18/13 mm [3410], st 202, coral rubble with sand and algae, near Sonneratia (PNM 041212).
Australia: Queensland (type locality). Indonesia: Ambon, Bali, Halmahera, Kei Islands, Lombok, Seram, Sulawesi, and Timor. Philippines: Bohol and Luzon. All records, except the type locality, are new.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis buetschlii. A Indonesia, Sulawesi, Wori, tall mangrove forest of Sonneratia and some Avicennia with a rocky area and dead logs (st 84) B Australia, Queensland, Yule Point, sandy area with a few Rhizophora and Avicennia trees (st 100) C Indonesia, Ambon, Wai, narrow band of old Avicennia trees on sandy mud, with old logs on ground (st 132) D Indonesia, Lombok, Don Don, old Avicennia forest, with coral rubble (st 149) E Indonesia, Sulawesi, Mantehage Island, rocks behind a mangrove of Sonneratia and Rhizophora (st 91) F Indonesia, Bali, Gilimanuk, sandy mudflat outside Rhizophora and Avicennia mangrove (st 156).
(Table
Internally, the penis is diagnostic of W. buetschlii: it is not protected by a penial sheath or a vestibule and bears internal longitudinal ridges. The oviduct attached to the posterior wall of the visceral cavity is peculiar but it also occurs in W. gracile. However, the penis of W. gracile is protected by a penial sheath and extends into the vestibule.
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis buetschlii. A Dorsal view, 46 mm long [2722], Indonesia, Ambon (UMIZ 00026) B Dorsal view, 31 mm long [2853], Indonesia, Ambon (UMIZ 00027) C Dorsal view, 23 mm long [2249], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00024) D Dorsal view, 30 mm long [2928], Indonesia, Kei Islands (UMIZ 00029) E Dorsal view, 52 mm long [3159], Philippines, Luzon (PNM 041209) F Dorsal view, 36 mm long, [3409], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041212) G Ventral view, 44 mm long [5898], Indonesia, Timor (UMIZ 00072) H Ventral view, same as F I Ventral view, 43 mm long [2982], Indonesia, Lombok (UMIZ 00030).
There are many papillae on the dorsal surface, which are usually bright yellow in color, or occasionally brown. Between six and 14 papillae bear eyes, with three or four eyes per papilla. There is a large, retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, and it is often raised several millimeters above the dorsal surface.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis buetschlii (A–D) Indonesia, Sulawesi [2120] (UMIZ 00021) (E) Australia, Queensland [2554] (MTQ st100) (F) Australia, Queensland [2555] (MTQ st100). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 10 μm B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 40 μm C Inner lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm D Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm E Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 10 μm F Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, with the basal lateral spine revealed on the underside of the inner lateral teeth at the bottom, scale bar 30 μm.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis buetschlii. A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Indonesia, Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2120] (UMIZ 00021) B Anterior, male copulatory parts, Australia, Queensland, scale bar 1 mm [2555] (MTQ st100) C Anterior, male copulatory parts, Indonesia, Kei, scale bar 1 mm [2933] (UMIZ 00029). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland of oviduct fibers attaching to the inner wall of the visceral cavity ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Penis, Wallaconchis buetschlii, Indonesia. A Longitudinal ridge on the internal surface of the penis, Kei Islands, scale bar 60 μm [2933] (UMIZ 00029) B Close-up of a groove between two longitudinal ridges showing smooth internal surface (no hooks), Sulawesi, scale bar 20 μm [2120] (UMIZ 00021).
Stantschinsky’s Onchidium buetschlii refers to a Wallaconchis species because of the unique combination of characters of the lectotype (intestine of type I, no penial accessory gland, no rectal gland). Stantschinsky’s original description of the penis (confirmed by our examination of the lectotype) matches exactly the penial anatomy of the species described here. The unique attachment of the oviduct to the posterior body wall was not described by Stantschinsky but is clearly present in the lectotype as well. Because the male parts of the two paralectotypes of W. buetschlii are missing, it cannot be confirmed that they are part of W. buetschlii. The anatomy of the posterior (female) reproductive parts of the paralectotypes matches that of the lectotype (with an oviduct attached to posterior body wall), indicating that they could be part of either W. buetschlii or W. gracile.
The two syntypes used by Stantschinsky to describe Onchidium gracile are part of two distinct species; therefore, one specimen is designated as the lectotype (see Wallaconchis gracile). The paralectotype of O. gracile is part of W. buetschlii. Both species share the unique attachment of the oviduct to the posterior body wall and are anatomically extremely similar. However, the penis (of the lectotype) of W. gracile is within a penial sheath, while the penis (of the lectotype) of W. buetschlii lacks a penial sheath. The penis of the paralectotype of W. gracile matches perfectly that of (the lectotype of) W. buetschlii. The written description of O. gracile (
Onchidium gracile Stantschinsky, 1907: 380–383, pl. 12, figs 7–9, pl. 13, fig. 25 (as Oncidium gracile).
Mindanao, Philippines. No fresh material was collected from the type locality. However, fresh material was collected from Bohol (Philippines), just north of Mindanao, and from Halmahera (Indonesia), just south of Mindanao.
Lectotype, 25/20 mm, designated here (ZMB 103082a). The lectotype was opened previously but all internal organs remain. The other syntype (28/20 mm), which becomes a paralectotype (ZMB 103082b) was dissected by Stantschinsky, but all of the internal organs remain. The paralectotype of W. gracile is part of W. buetschlii, which is not an issue because it is no longer a name-bearing type (see the remarks on both W. gracile and W. buetschlii).
Indonesia, North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 4 specimens 20/13 mm [2280], 19/15 mm [2252], 9/5 mm [2276], and 8/5 mm [2277], st 90, old Avicennia, Sonneratia, and Rhizophora mangrove with rocks (UMIZ 00055); Bali, Gilimanuk, 08°10.26'S, 114°26.61'E, 3 specimens 22/22 mm [#1], 19/9 mm [3107] and 17/10 mm [3106], st 155, muddy-sandy beach near a mangrove (UMIZ 00056); North Maluku, Ternate, 00°45.18'N, 127°20.17'E, 2 specimens 15/10 mm [5158] and 15/9 mm [5159], st 220, sandy beach behind a rock wall (UMIZ 00057); Timor, Oesapa, 10°08.69'S, 123°38.21'E, 1 specimen 27/18 mm [5932], st 254, mangrove with fine sand (UMIZ 00074). Philippines, Bohol, Loay, 09°36.23'N, 123°59.72'E, 1 specimen 10/5 mm [3633], st 198, mostly sand, and a few Avicennia (PNM 041230); Bohol, Loon, 09°49.91'N, 123°48.33'E, 3 specimens 25/10 mm [3653], 25/10 mm [3652] and 21/11 mm [3648], st 201, fine sand in front of Rhizophora forest (PNM 041231).
Indonesia: Bali, Halmahera, Sulawesi, and Timor. Philippines: Bohol and Mindanao (type locality). All records are new except for the type locality.
(Fig.
(Table
Internally, the attachment of the oviduct to the body wall distinguishes W. gracile from the species with a similar penial anatomy (i.e., W. sinanui, W. comendadori, and W. melanesiensis), but is shared with W. buetschlii. The penial sheath enclosing the penis of W. gracile distinguishes it from W. buetschlii. Also, the retractor muscle is thicker in W. gracile than in W. buetschlii.
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis gracile. A Dorsal view, 19 mm long [3107], Indonesia, Bali (UMIZ 00056) B Dorsal view, 15 mm long [5158], Indonesia, Halmahera (UMIZ 00057) C Dorsal view, 21 mm long [3648], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041231) D Dorsal view, 19 mm long [2252], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00055) E Dorsal view, 15 mm long [5159], Indonesia, Halmahera (UMIZ 00057) F Dorsal view, 27 mm long [5932], Indonesia, Timor (UMIZ 00074) G Dorsal view, 25 mm long [3652], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041231) H Frontal view, same as F I Ventral view, 25 mm long [3653], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041231) J Ventral view, same as F.
Between six and eight dorsal papillae bear eyes, with three or four per papilla. There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which may be slightly raised above the dorsal surface.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis gracile, Indonesia, Bali (A–C) [3106] (UMIZ 00056) (D) [spm #1] (UMIZ 00056). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 6 μm B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm C Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm D Left lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm E Left lateral teeth, gradually increasing in length towards the left, scale bar 40 μm F Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis gracile, Indonesia. A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2280] (UMIZ 00055) B Anterior, male copulatory parts, Bali, scale bar 2 mm [3106] (UMIZ 00056). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland of oviduct fibers attaching to the inner wall of the visceral cavity ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Onchidium gracile refers to a Wallaconchis species due to a unique combination of characters (intestinal loops of type I, no accessory penial gland, and no rectal gland). Stantschinsky’s original description was based on two syntypes which are actually part of two species, hence the necessity of designating a lectotype. The anatomy of one of the former syntypes is in agreement with the species described here, so it is designated as the lectotype to clarify the application of the name W. gracile. The other former syntype, now a paralectotype without a name-bearing function, is anatomically indistinguishable from W. buetschlii. This nomenclatural decision helps avoid having to create a new species name for the species described here. Wallaconchis gracile and W. buetschlii are similar anatomically (Table
Onchidium nangkauriense Plate, 1893: 170–171, pl. 12, figs 84, 93–95 (as Oncidium nangkauriense).
Paraoncidium
nangkauriense
:
Nangkauri, eine Insel der Nicobaren [Nancowry, Nicobar Islands, Indian Ocean]. No fresh material was collected from the type locality (access to the Nicobar Islands is extremely restricted). However, fresh material was collected from the Andaman Islands, just north of the Nicobar Islands (see below, additional material).
Lectotype, 19/14 mm, designated here (ZMB 45659a). The lectotype was dissected prior to the present study but is well preserved, with all organs remaining except for the penis. The lectotype is designated because it still displays the diagnostic characters of the species (a retractor muscle inserted within the left side of the body wall). The paralectotype (22/15 mm) also was dissected prior to the present study (ZMB 45659b). A piece of the notum is missing, as well as the digestive glands, and a part of the female reproductive system.
India, Andaman Islands, South Andaman, Burman Nala, 11°33.23'N, 92°44.00'E, 2 specimens 25/12 mm [1074] and 24/10 mm [1075], st 53, rocky shore with a patch of Rhizophora, sand and coral rubble, but no mud. (BNHS 50). Indonesia, Sumatra, Lampung, Penegahan, 05°40.40'S, 105°33.76'E, 4 specimens 42/25 mm, 28/15 mm [1787], 23/15 mm [1788], and 23/15 mm [1786], st 78, coral rubble on beach exposed to estuary (UMIZ 00012); North Sulawesi, Bahoi, 01°43.36'N, 125°01.23'E, 2 specimens 25/14 mm [2161] and 18/13 mm [2156], st 85, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00013); North Sulawesi, Tamperong, 01°41.51'N, 125°00.80'E, 1 specimen 20/13 mm [2192], st 87, rocks behind mangrove of small Rhizophora trees (UMIZ 00014); North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 1 specimen 30/20 mm [2257], st 90, old mangrove forest with Avicennia, Sonneratia, and Rhizophora, with rocks (UMIZ 00016); Ambon, Haruku Island, 03°36.52'S, 128°25.07'E, 1 specimen 22/14 mm [2731], st 127, rocky Sonneratia mangrove with coral rubble (UMIZ 00017); Lombok, Seriwe Bay, 08°54.55'S, 116°22.22'E, 1 specimen 39/28 mm [2972], st 148, rocks with Avicennia trees (UMIZ 00018); Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, 08°08.61'S, 114°32.33'E, 2 specimens 20/12 mm [3136] and 18/12 mm [3129], st 157, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (UMIZ 00020). Philippines, Luzon, Batangas, Lian, 13°59.76'N, 120°37.43'E, 1 specimen 28/17 mm [3162], st 181, sandy, open Avicennia forest (PNM 041204); Luzon, Batangas, Calatagan, 13°55.32'N, 120°37.26'E, 2 specimens 30/17 mm [3208] and 24/14 mm [3217], st 183, rocks in Avicennia and Rhizophora mangrove (PNM 041205); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.02'N, 123°47.45'E, 3 specimens 32/20 mm [3269], 32/23 mm [3268], and 28/20 mm [3276], st 191, coral rubble with sand (PNM 041206); Bohol, Loay, 09°36.23'N, 123°59.72'E, 1 specimen 21/14 mm [5763], st 198, mostly sand, and a few Avicennia (PNM 041229); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.02'N, 123°47.45'E, 2 specimens 28/16 mm [3396] and 18/12 mm [3401], st 200, coral rubble with sand at night (PNM 041207); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.28'N, 123°49.39'E, 1 specimen 28/16 mm [3427], st 202, coral rubble with sand and algae, near Sonneratia (PNM 041208).
India: Nicobar Islands (type locality) and Andaman Islands. Indonesia: Ambon, Bali, Lombok, Sulawesi, and southeastern Sumatra. Philippines: Bohol and Luzon. All records are new except for the type locality.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis nangkauriense. A Indonesia, Sulawesi, sand, rocks, pieces of wood behind narrow coastal mangrove (st 85) B India, Andaman Islands, Burman Nala, slugs were on the stilt roots (st 53) C Indonesia, Ambon, Haruku Island, narrow mangrove of Sonneratia trees on rocky beach (st 127) D Close up (same locality as C) E Indonesia, Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (st 157) F Philippines, Bohol, Maribojoc, coral rubble of uplifted coral reef (st 191).
(Table
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis nangkauriense. A Dorsal view, 28 mm long [3162], Philippines, Luzon (PNM 041204) B Dorsal view, 23 mm long [1786], Indonesia, Sumatra (UMIZ 00012) C Dorsal view, 18 mm long [2156], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00013) D Dorsal view, 23 mm long [1788], Indonesia, Sumatra (UMIZ 00012) E Dorsal view, 34 mm long [3269], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041206) F Dorsal view, 24 mm long [2161], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00013) G Dorsal view, 32 mm long [3268], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041206) H Dorsal view, 28 mm long [1787], Indonesia, Sumatra (UMIZ 00012) I Dorsal view, 24 mm long [3217], Philippines, Luzon (PNM 041205) J Ventral view, same as G K Ventral view, 28 mm long [3427], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041208) L Ventral view, 22 mm long [2731], Indonesia, Ambon (UMIZ 00017).
The number of dorsal papillae with eyes (three or four per papilla) is between five and 15, but, exceptionally, 25 papillae were observed in one specimen. There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which may be slightly raised above the dorsal surface.
(Fig.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis nangkauriense. A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Philippines, Bohol, scale bar 4 mm [3276] (PNM 041206) B Anterior, male copulatory parts, Indonesia, Sulawesi, scale bar 5 mm [2192] (UMIZ 00014) C Anterior, male copulatory parts (vestibule removed around the penis), Indonesia, Sumatra, scale bar 2 mm [1788] (UMIZ 00012). Abbreviations: bc body cavity bw lateral left body wall dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct p penis ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Onchidium nangkauriense belongs to Wallaconchis because it shares its unique combination of characters (intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, no dorsal gills, no penial accessory gland). Also, there is strong evidence that the name W. nangkauriense applies to the species being described here. Indeed,
In the same publication, Plate also described Onchidium simrothi from the same type locality as O. nangkauriense (Nangkauri, Nicobar Islands, India). Onchidium simrothi is transferred here to Wallaconchis but is regarded as a nomen dubium because important characters are not mentioned in the original description and could not be observed in the type material. The two syntypes of O. simrothi are small (10/6 and 10/5 mm) and in very poor condition (they previously dried, and most of the organs are missing, with the exception of parts of the female reproductive system and of the digestive system). Plate does not indicate whether the rectal gland is present or absent, but the intestine of type I and the absence of an accessory penial gland indicate that the two syntypes of O. simrothi belong to a Wallaconchis species or a Platevindex species. However, the male opening of O. simrothi (below the right tentacle) and its central dorsal tubercle with multiple eyes are inconsistent with Platevindex. We therefore consider that O. simrothi belongs to Wallaconchis. Given that both W. simrothi and W. nangkauriense were described from the Nicobar Islands, that the Nicobar Islands are within the geographic range of only one Wallaconchis species (W. nangkauriense) and are very far from the limits of distribution of all other Wallaconchis species, it is most likely that both names are synonyms. According to Plate, the difference between O. simrothi and O. nangkauriense is the length of their penis (4 mm long and 55 mm, respectively). However, our observations show that the small specimens (< 20 mm long) of W. nangkauriense from the Andaman Islands (which are very close to the Nicobar Islands) have a smaller penis with a retractor muscle inserted halfway down the body, which could explain the shorter penis described by Plate in the tiny (10 mm long) syntypes of O. simrothi. However, strictly speaking, neither Plate’s original description of O. simrothi nor the dried remains of its type material can be used to apply this name to any species. Therefore, O. simrothi is transferred to Wallaconchis but is regarded as a nomen dubium.
Onchidium nangkauriense was transferred by
Onchidium
ater
Lesson, 1830: 300;
Onchidium
keiense
Hoffmann, 1926: 18–24, figs 1–5;
Scaphis
atra
:
Paraoncidium
keiense
:
Lessonina
ferruginea
:
(O. ater). Havre de Doréry (for Dorey), à la Nouvelle Guinée [Manokwari, West Papua, Indonesia]. No fresh material was collected from the type locality. However, fresh material was collected from Halmahera, approximately 700 kilometers from the type locality in West Papua (see below, additional material).
Type locality (O. keiense). Toeal (Kei-Inseln) [Kei Islands, Moluccan Islands, Indonesia]. Fresh specimens were collected from the type locality (see below, additional material).
Type material (O. ater). Two syntypes: 30/17 and 28/15 mm (MNHN 22950). Both syntypes were previously dissected and some internal organs are missing. The posterior (female) reproductive parts remain in the smaller syntype and only the oviduct remains in the larger syntype. The male (anterior) parts are missing in both syntypes. The digestive system is present in both syntypes, but the intestinal loops are not preserved.
Type material (O. keiense). Lectotype, 32/21 mm, designated here (ZMUC). Thirty paralectotypes (35/24 to 11/8 mm) are well preserved (ZMUC), although several specimens were dissected prior to the present study and the male parts were previously removed (ZMUC). The lectotype was dissected for this study and all organs left in vials inside the jar. The species name on the label is Onchidium mortenseni. However, the rest of the information on the label (specimens collected by Mortensen from Toeal and studied by Hoffmann) is identical to the information in Hoffmann’s original description of O. keiense (the collector is not mentioned in the species description, but the title of the paper indicates the species are described based on collections from Mortensen’s expedition). The only other onchidiid species described by Hoffmann from the Kei Islands was Onchidium verruculatum Cuvier, 1830, which Hoffmann recognized thanks to the presence of gills on the posterior notum (O. verruculatum actually belongs to the genus Peronia). Gills are not visible on any of the syntypes labeled O. mortenseni, which strongly suggests that those specimens are the type material of O. keiense and that Hoffmann changed his mind for the specific name (i.e., he replaced mortenseni by keiense).
Indonesia, North Sulawesi, Bahoi, 01°43.36'N, 125°01.23'E, 5 specimens 37/15 mm [2170], 30/15 mm [2145], 26/16 mm [2164], 25/14 mm [2157] and 25/11 mm [2177], st 85, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00049); North Sulawesi, Bahoi, 01°43.36'N, 125°01.23'E, 3 specimens 30/18 mm [2221], 29/16 mm [2220] and 26/17 mm [2228], st 88, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00050); North Sulawesi, Wori, 01°36.06'N, 124°51.73'E, 1 specimen 33/22 mm [2283], st 90, old Avicennia, Sonneratia, Rhizophora mangrove (UMIZ 00038); North Sulawesi, Mantehage Island, 01°41.88'N, 124°46.74'E, 1 specimen 25/16 mm [2330], st 91, rocks behind a Sonneratia and Rhizophora mangrove (UMIZ 00039); Ambon, Haruku Island, 03°36.52'S, 128°25.07'E, 1 specimen 9/8 mm [2727], st 127, rocky Sonneratia mangrove with coral rubble (UMIZ 00040); Maluku, Kei Islands, Tual City, Fiditan, 5°35.96'S, 132°45.11'E, 1 specimen 17/9 mm [2939], st 144, rocks behind muddy mangrove of Rhizophora trees (UMIZ 00041); Lombok, Seriwe Bay, 08°51.70'S, 116°32.87'E, 1 specimen 18/10 mm [2966], st 147, small beach of coral rubble and rocks by bay (UMIZ 00042); Lombok, Seriwe Bay, 08°54.55'S, 116°22.22'E, 2 specimens 43/20 mm [2970] and 35/24 mm [2974], st 148, rocks behind mangrove with Avicennia trees (UMIZ 00043); Lombok, Don Don, 08°54.54'S, 116°21.50'E, 2 specimens 35/19 mm [2986] and 25/13 mm [2978] st 149, old Avicennia forest with coral rubble (UMIZ 00051); Bali, Gilimanuk, 08°10.26'S, 114°26.61'E, 1 specimen 18/14 mm [3591], st 155, large rocks near a patch of Rhizophora (UMIZ 00052); Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, 08°08.61'S, 114°32.33'E, 3 specimens 22/12 mm [3137], 20/11 mm [3132], and 14/8 mm [3130], st 157, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (UMIZ 00053); North Maluku, Ternate, Bastiong, 00°46.41'N, 127°22.76'E, 1 specimen 38/17 mm [5057], st 203, muddy rocks near a mangrove (UMIZ 00046); Halmahera, Akelamo, 01°01.33'N, 127°39.09'E, 1 specimen 35/20 mm [5078], st 207, sandy-muddy beach at margin of mangrove (UMIZ 00047); Halmahera, Foli, 01°14.66'N, 128°10.61'E, 1 specimen 28/16 mm [5121], st 217, rocky shore near a beach (UMIZ 00048); Halmahera, Foli, 01°14.66'N, 128°10.61'E, 1 specimen 25/10 mm [5125], st 217, rocky shore near a beach (UMIZ 00054). Philippines, Luzon, Batangas, Calatagan, 13°55.32'N, 120°37.26'E, 3 specimens 30/16 mm [3215], 29/16 mm [3212] and 26/12 mm [3210], st 183, rocks in Avicennia and Rhizophora mangrove (PNM 041221); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.02'N, E 123°47.45'E, 6 specimens 36/20 mm [3266], 34/21 mm [3271], 33/18 mm [3265], 33/22 mm [3272], 32/20 mm [3277], and 30/17 mm [3270], st 191, uplifted coral rubble with sand (PNM 041222); Bohol, Mabini, 09°51.59'N, 124°34.16'E, 2 specimens 21/12 mm [3373] and 14/8 mm [3370], st 196, open Avicennia and Sonneratia mangrove with sand, and coral rubble (PNM 041223); Bohol, Guindulman, 09°44.06'N, 124°27.63'E, 2 specimens 38/15 mm [3624] and 22/13 mm [3629], st 197, rocks and coral rubble near a few Avicennia trees (PNM 041216); Bohol, Loay, 09°36.23'N, 123°59.73'E, 1 specimen 33/19 mm [3634], st 198, mostly sand, and a few Avicennia (PNM 041217); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.02'N, 123°47.45'E, 2 specimens 29/16 mm [3393] and 19/12 mm [3404], st 200, coral rubble with sand, at night (PNM 041218); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.28'N, 123°49.39'E, 4 specimens 37/17 mm [3420], 33/23 mm [3406], 26/16 mm [3405] and 21/11 mm [3408], st 202, uplifted coral rubble with sand and algae, near Sonneratia trees (PNM 041224).
Indonesia: Bali, Edam (near Jakarta), Halmahera, Kei Islands (type locality of O. keiense), Lombok, Seram, Sulawesi, and West Papua (type locality of O. ater). Philippines: Bohol, Luzon, and Mindanao. All records are new except for the type localities as well as the presence of O. ater in Edam and Mindanao (
(Figs
Mangrove habitats, Wallaconchis ater. A–B Indonesia, Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (st 157) C–D Indonesia, Lombok, Don Don, old Avicennia forest, with coral rubble (st 149) E–F Philippines, Bohol, Mabini, open Avicennia and Sonneratia mangrove with sand and coral rubble (st 196).
Coral rubble habitats, Wallaconchis ater. A Indonesia, Sulawesi, Bahoi, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (st 88) B Philippines, Bohol, Maribojoc, uplifted, dead, coral flat covered with sand and algae adjacent to a few mangrove trees (st 202) C Philippines, Bohol, Maribojoc, coral rubble of uplifted coral reef (st 191) D Indonesia, Halmahera, Foli, rocky shore by beach (st 217).
(Table
(Figs
Live specimens, dorsal view, Wallaconchis ater. A 33 mm long [3265], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041214) B Dorsal view, 34 mm long [3271], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041222) C 26 mm long [3210], Philippines, Luzon (PNM 041213) D 26 mm long [3405], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041219) E 26 mm long [2164], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00036) F 38 mm long [5057], Indonesia, Halmahera (UMIZ 00046) G Dorsal view, 22 mm long [3137], Indonesia, Bali (UMIZ 00053) H 25 mm long [2157], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00036).
Live specimens, Wallaconchis ater. A Dorsal view, 43 mm long [2970], Indonesia, Lombok (UMIZ 00043) B Dorsal view, 37 mm long [2170], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00036) C Ventral view, 35 mm long [2974], Indonesia, Lombok (UMIZ 00043) D Ventral view, 36 mm long [3266], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041214) E Ventral view, 26 mm long [3405], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041219) F Ventral view, 33 mm long [3272], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041214) G Ventral view, 32 mm long [3277], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041222) H Ventral view, 37 mm long [3420], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 0412224).
Between six and 18 papillae bear dorsal eyes (three or four per papilla). There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which may be slightly raised above the dorsal surface.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis ater, Indonesia (A–B) Bali [3137] (UMIZ 00053) (D) Sulawesi [2330] (UMIZ 00039) (C, E–F) Sulawesi [2220] (UMIZ 00050). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm B Rachidian and left innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm C Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 50 μm D Rachidian and right innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 50 μm E Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 10 μm F Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, scale bar 40 μm.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Wallaconchis ater, Indonesia A Lombok, scale bar 2 mm [2970] (UMIZ 00043) B Sulawesi, scale bar 3 mm [2220] (UMIZ 00050). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis ater, Indonesia. A Anterior, male copulatory parts (vestibule removed, showing the coiled and U-shaped penis), Halmahera, scale bar 2 mm [5078] (UMIZ 00047) B Penis (coil of loops removed from vestibule), Sulawesi, scale bar 2 mm [2283] (UMIZ 00038) C Anterior, male copulatory parts, scale bar 5 mm, same as B D Anterior, male copulatory parts, Kei Islands, scale bar 1 mm [2939] (UMIZ 00041). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct dpp distal penial projections p penis ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle v vestibule.
Reproductive system, anterior, male copulatory parts, Wallaconchis ater. A Vestibule removed, showing the coiled and U-shaped penis, Indonesia, Sulawesi, scale bar 3 mm [2220] (UMIZ 00050) B Vestibule with coiled penis inside, Philippines, Bohol, scale bar 3 mm [3270] (PNM 041220). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct dpp distal penial projections p penis ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle v vestibule.
Penis, Wallaconchis ater, Indonesia. A Detail of distal portion when fully relaxed (with distal penial projections) and partial view of the coil, Indonesia, Halmahera, scale bar 500 μm [3393] (PNM 041218) B Detail of distal portion when fully relaxed (with distal penial projections) and partial view of the coil, Halmahera, scale bar 500 μm [5125] (UMIZ 00054) C Partial view of the coil (with six loops), Philippines, Bohol, scale bar 500 μm [3266] (PNM 041214) D Cross-section showing the longitudinal fold, Bali, scale bar 300 μm [3137] (UMIZ 00053).
Lesson’s original description of Onchidium ater was brief, mostly based on the external morphology, and lacked illustrations of the internal anatomy. Fortunately, some organs remain in the syntypes which display the diagnostic characters of Wallaconchis (intestinal loops of type I and no rectal gland).
The male parts were removed from both syntypes by Labbé when he re-described them for his 1934 monograph. Therefore, only Lesson’s original description of the male parts and their re-description by Labbé can be used to determine the application of the name O. ater.
The unique combination of characters observed on the lectotype of Onchidium keiense (intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, male opening below the right tentacle, and no accessory penial gland) indicates that O. keiense belongs to Wallaconchis. The re-examination of the lectotype and most paralectotypes available for O. keiense revealed no difference with the two syntypes of O. ater for the penial anatomy and the enlarged oviduct, therefore O. keiense is identified here as a junior synonym of W. ater. However, not all paralectotypes of O. keiense are part of W. ater: at least one paralectotype of O. keiense belongs to the genus Peronia (due to the presence of an accessory gland and a different intestinal type). The designation of the lectotype makes it clear that the name O. keiense applies to the species described by Hoffmann without an accessory gland.
Hoffmann did not illustrate the coiled penis of O. keiense (the penial complex was illustrated with the vestibule and did not show the loops inside), which made it difficult for others to identify the diagnostic character of O. keiense. Labbé did not recognize the similarity between the syntypes of O. ater which he examined and Hoffmann’s description of O. keiense. Labbé moved O. keiense to his genus Paraoncidium Labbé, 1934, which he created for a series of Onchidium species with no accessory gland and no rectal gland, but he did not examine any new material for O. keiense. Note that Paraoncidium is a junior synonym of Onchidina (
Another species, Onchidium ferrugineum Lesson, 1830 was described from the same type locality as O. ater (Manokwari, West Papua, Indonesia). The number of syntypes was not included in Lesson’s original description, but
Onchidium
graniferum
Semper, 1880: pl. 19, fig. 13, pl. 23, fig. 3; Semper 1882, 273–274, pl. 21, fig. 10;
Paraoncidium
reevesii
:
Onchidella
sp.:
Bohol (Philippines).
Three syntypes (ZMB 39032), between 22/14 mm and 11 mm, according to Semper (no width was provided by Semper for the smaller specimen). The syntypes were destroyed prior to the present study, and it is only through Semper’s description that it could be ascertained that there were originally three syntypes. Only small pieces of dorsal notum and of one digestive system (stomach, intestine, and digestive glands) now remain.
Indonesia, Timor, Oesapa, 10°08.73'S, 123°38.10'E, 1 specimen 30/19 mm [5902], st 250, sandy part of mangrove with Sonneratia and Avicennia trees (UMIZ 00073). Philippines, Luzon, Lian, Batangas, 13°59.76'N, 120°37.43'E, 1 specimen 46/27 mm [3163], st 181, sandy, open Avicennia forest (PNM 041227); Bohol, Loay, 09°36.23'N, 123°59.72'E, 6 specimens 28/17 mm [3636], 26/18 mm [3638], 26/15 mm [3635], 18/12 mm [5760], 16/13 mm [5762] and 16/11 mm [5761], st 198, mostly sand, and a few Avicennia (PNM 041228).
Indonesia: Timor. Philippines: Bohol (type locality) and Luzon. China. All records are new except for the type locality.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis graniferum. A Philippines, Bohol, Loay, mostly sand, very few rocks, and a few small Avicennia trees (st 198) B Close up of sand with shells and Avicennia roots (same locality as A) C Indonesia, Timor, Oesapa, sandy area of mangrove with Avicennia and Sonneratia trees spread out D Close up of sediment and onchidiid tracks (same locality as C).
(Table
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis graniferum, Philippines. A Dorsal view, 46 mm long [3163], Luzon (PNM 041227) B Dorsal view, 30 mm long [5902], Indonesia, Timor (UMIZ 00073) C Dorsal view, 28 mm long [3636], Bohol (PNM 041228) D Dorsal view, 26 mm long [3635], Bohol (PNM 041228) E Ventral view, same as A, F Ventral view, same as B.
Approximately three to twelve papillae bear dorsal eyes, with three or four eyes per papilla. There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which may be slightly raised above the dorsal surface.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis graniferum, Philippines. A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Bohol, scale bar 20 μm [3636] (PNM 041228) B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Luzon, scale bar 30 μm [3163] (PNM 041227) C Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, Bohol, scale bar 30 μm [3635] (PNM 041228) D Outermost lateral teeth, Bohol, scale bar 30 μm [3636] (PNM 041228).
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Wallaconchis graniferum, Philippines. A Luzon, scale bar 5 mm [3163] (PNM 041227) B Bohol, scale bar 2 mm [3638] (PNM 041225). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Reproductive system, anterior, male copulatory parts, Wallaconchis graniferum, Philippines. A Penis with two proximal regions of hooks separated from a third distal region of hooks by a gap with no hooks (the hooks of the first, most proximal region are on the other side of the penis and cannot be seen here), Luzon, scale bar 0.7 mm [3163] (PNM 041227) B Anterior male copulatory parts scale bar 3.6 mm same as A. C Penis partially evaginated inside the vestibule (removed) Bohol scale bar 1 mm [3638] (PNM 041225). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct pr1 first most proximal penial region (with hooks on the other side) pr2 second proximal penial region (with hooks) pr3 third distal penial region (with hooks) ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle sr smooth region of the penis (with no hooks) v vestibule.
Evaginated penis, Wallaconchis graniferum, Philippines (A–C) Luzon [3163] (PNM 041227) (D) Bohol [3636] (PNM 041228) (E) Bohol [3638] (PNM 041225). A Proximal region of evaginated penis with hooks, scale bar 400 μm B Middle region of evaginated penis with long slender hooks on one side, and shorter hooks on the other side, scale bar 400 μm C Distal region of evaginated penis with distal hooks, scale bar 300 μm D Partially evaginated penis with proximal hooks (more distal hooks are inside the rest of the invaginated penis), scale bar 200 μm E Partially evaginated penis with most proximal hooks (more distal hooks are invaginated inside), scale bar 200 μm. Abbreviations (from proximal to distal): ph proximal hooks (first penial region) lh long slender hooks (second penial region) sh short hooks (second penial region) nh no hooks (gap) dh distal hooks (third penial region).
Penis, Wallaconchis graniferum, not evaginated and opened, Philippines, Bohol (A–B) [5762] (PNM 041226) (C) [5761] (PNM 041228). A Penis invaginated inside the penial sheath opened to reveal regions of penial hooks, scale bar 200 μm B Most proximal region of penis invaginated inside the penial sheath opened to reveal penial hooks, scale bar 200 μm C Penis invaginated inside penial sheath (both opened to reveal the penial hooks), scale bar 0.5 mm. Abbreviations (from proximal to distal): ph proximal hooks (first penial region) lh long slender hooks (second penial region) sh short hooks (second penial region) nh no hooks (gap) dh distal hooks (third penial region).
Habitats and live specimens, Wallaconchis achleitneri, Australia, Queensland, Bowen, Doughty Creek. A–B Type locality, sandy area with Avicennia and Rhizophora trees in narrow band by the creek (st 117) C–D Dorsal view, approximately 14 mm long (MTQ st117) E Ventral view, approximately 14 mm long (MTQ st 117).
Onchidium graniferum must be transferred to Wallaconchis because the diagnostic combination of characters of Wallaconchis is found in Semper’s original description and in what remains of the syntypes.
The only issue in
The publication dates of various sections of the volume on Landmollusken by Carl Semper in the Reisen im Archipel der Philippinen series were clarified by
The copulatory organs of the syntypes were all destroyed prior to the present study (likely by Semper himself), but Semper (1882: 274, translated from German) described the penis of O. graniferum as a “cartilaginous tube” with only a “tooth-bearing portion” and “cartilage teeth of very different sizes.” Semper (1882: 274, our translation from German) also indicated a specific order in which penial hooks (which he called teeth) of different sizes are organized, which is in agreement with the arrangement of hooks described here: “The foremost ones are very irregular and broad; they are on average 80 μm long. Then a section with teeth three times as long, of 180 μm, then again another with small ones; but in the last part great ones are found. The large teeth are very tightly pressed.” Semper illustrated these penial hooks of different sizes individually, but not the hooks together in situ, so the exact arrangement of the penial hooks that he observed cannot be known with certainty. Semper also did not indicate whether the penis was evaginated or not, but it can be assumed that his “foremost” hooks are at the base (i.e., proximal on the penis when evaginated). So, overall, Semper’s description of the arrangement of penial hooks of different sizes is consistent with the pattern of penial hooks observed here from the proximal base of the penis to its evaginated tip. Semper’s illustrations of a thick penial sheath and the shapes of the penial hooks are also consistent with the species described here. Finally, Semper described the penis as slightly shorter than the retractor muscle. The retractor muscle was found to be shorter than the penis in the species described here, but this trait varies within Wallaconchis species and is not useful for identification.
Finally,
Australia, Queensland, Bowen, Doughty Creek, 20°01.26'S, 148°14.35'E, st 117, Avicennia and Rhizophora trees by a creek with sandy mud.
Holotype, 7/5 mm [3534], designated here (st 117, MTQ).
Australia, Queensland, Bowen, Doughty Creek, 20°01.26'S, 148°14.35'E, 64 specimens 16/10 mm [#3] to 8/5 mm [3535]; 14/8 mm [#1], 14/8 mm [#2], 14/8 mm [#4] and 9/6 mm [2645], st 117, Avicennia and Rhizophora trees by a creek with sandy mud (st 117, MTQ).
Australia: Queensland (type locality).
(Fig.
Wallaconchis achleitneri is dedicated to Stefan Achleitner, a team member in our expedition to Queensland, and whose German translation helped to clarify parts of old and challenging species descriptions.
(Table
(Fig.
The number of dorsal papillae with eyes is three to four papillae with three to four eyes per papilla. There is a retractable papilla with three to four eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, but which is not raised above the other papillae.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis achleitneri, Australia, Queensland (MTQ st117). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 6 μm [#1] B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, holotype, scale bar 20 μm [3534] C Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, holotype, scale bar 30 μm [3534] D Outermost lateral teeth, holotype, scale bar 10 μm [3534] E Lateral teeth with basal lateral spine decreasing in size from right to left, scale bar 10 μm [#1] F Left lateral teeth, scale bar 100 μm [#2].
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis achleitneri, Australia, Queensland (MTQ st117). A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, scale bar 1 mm [#4] B Anterior, male copulatory parts, scale bar 1 mm [#1]. Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca v vestibule.
(Figs
Philippines, Bohol, Guindulman, 09°44.06'N, 124°27.63'E, st 197, rocks and coral rubble near a few Avicennia trees.
Holotype: 12/11 mm [3626], designated here (PNM 041232).
Indonesia, Sulawesi, Mantehage Island, 01°41.88'N, 124°46.74'E, 1 specimen 15/7 mm [2315], st 91, rocks behind a mangrove of Sonneratia and Rhizophora (UMIZ 00060); Ambon, Haruku Island, 03°36.52'S, 128°25.07'E, 2 specimens 12/7 mm [2725] and 7/6 mm [3539], st 127, rocky Sonneratia mangrove with coral rubble (UMIZ 00061); Lombok, Don Don, 08°54.54'S, 116°21.50'E, 2 specimens 18/12 mm [2985] and 7/6 mm [2983], st 149, old Avicennia forest with coral rubble (UMIZ 00063); Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, 08°08.61'S, 114°32.33'E, 2 specimens 16/8 mm [3133] and 13/9 mm [3131], st 157, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia (UMIZ 00064). Philippines, Bohol, Guindulman, 09°44.06'N, 124°27.63'E, 2 specimens 30/11 mm [3627] and 19/15 mm [3630], st 197, rocks and coral rubble near a few Avicennia trees (PNM 041233); Bohol, Maribojoc, 09°44.020'N, 123°47.45'E, 2 specimens 22/13 mm [3385] and 21/16 mm [3400], st 200, coral rubble with sand, low tide at night (PNM 041234).
Indonesia: Ambon, Bali, Lombok, and Sulawesi. Philippines: Bohol.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis comendadori. A Type locality, Philippines, Bohol, Guindulman, rocks and coral rubble near a few Avicennia trees (st 197) B View of the shore (same locality as A) C Indonesia, Bali, Pemuteran, Labuhan Lalang Harbor, coral rubble, rocks and a few Avicennia trees (st 157) D Indonesia, Lombok, Don Don, old Avicennia forest, with coral rubble (st 149).
This species is dedicated to Joseph Comendador, from the National Museum of the Philippines. Our expedition in the Philippines would not have been possible without his help with logistics, and we enjoyed exploring mangroves with him.
(Table
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis comendadori. A Dorsal view, 16 mm long [3133], Indonesia, Bali (UMIZ 00064) B Dorsal view, 18 mm long [2985], Indonesia, Lombok (UMIZ 00063) C Dorsal view, 13 mm long [3131], Indonesia, Bali (UMIZ 00064) D Dorsal view, 12 mm long [2725], Indonesia, Ambon (UMIZ 00061) E Dorsal view, 7 mm long [2983], Indonesia, Lombok (UMIZ 00063) F Dorsal view, holotype, 12 mm long [3626], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041232) G Ventral view, same as B H Ventral view, 15 mm long [2315], Indonesia, Sulawesi (UMIZ 00060) I Ventral view, 22 mm long [3385], Philippines, Bohol (PNM 041234).
Between five and seven papillae bear eyes (with three or four eyes per papilla) but more may be retracted. There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which is not raised above the other papillae.
(Fig.
Radula, Wallaconchis comendadori. A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Philippines, Bohol, scale bar 20 μm [3385] (PNM 041234) B Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, Indonesia, Lombok, scale bar 20 μm [2985] (UMIZ 00063) C Rachidian and inner lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm, same as B D Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, arrow shows basal lateral spine, scale bar 30 μm, same as B E Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm, same as B F Outermost lateral teeth, Indonesia, Ambon, scale bar 20 μm [3539] (UMIZ 00061).
(Fig.
Reproductive system, Wallaconchis comendadori. A Hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Indonesia, Lombok, scale bar 3 mm [2985] (UMIZ 00063) B Anterior, copulatory parts, Philippines, Bohol, scale bar 2 mm [3385] (PNM 041234). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Papua New Guinea, Madang, SW Hargun Island, 05°01.60'S, 145°47.90'E, st PM24, night tide.
Holotype, 13/10 mm [5417], designated here (IM-2013-13761).
Indonesia, Lombok, Seriwe Bay, 08°51.70'S, 116°32.87'E, 1 specimen 27/14 mm [2963], st 147, small beach of coral rubble and rocks (UMIZ 00070); Sulawesi, Tamperong, 01°41.51'N, 125°00.80'E, 1 specimen 8/7 mm [2202], st 85, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00066); Sulawesi, Bahoi, 01°43.36'N, 125°01.23'E, 1 specimen 26/17 mm [2215], st 88, sand and small rocks outside a mangrove (UMIZ 00067); Ambon, Haruku Island, 03°36.52'S, 128°25.07'E, 3 specimens 31/25 mm [2735], 31/25 mm [2732], and 13/8 mm [2733], st 127, rocky Sonneratia mangrove with coral rubble (UMIZ 00068); Halmahera, Sofifi, 00°45.40'N, 127°35.47'E, 1 specimen 15/8 mm [5065], st 204, muddy, rocky intertidal (UMIZ 00065); Halmahera, Foli, 01°14.66'N, 128°10.61'E, 4 specimens 27/17 mm [5133], 25/19 mm [5131], 23/18 mm [5132], and 22/13 mm [5026], st 217, large rocks with algae high in intertidal of beach (UMIZ 00069). Papua New Guinea, Madang, SW Hargun Island, 05°01.60'S, 145°47.90'E, 1 specimen 17/14 mm [5421], st PM24, night tide (IM-2013-14039); Madang, SW Hargun Island, 05°01.60'S, 145°47.90'E, 1 specimen 7/6 mm [5446], st PM24, night tide (IM-2013-14046); New Ireland, Kavieng, 02°41.00'S, 150°57.00'E, 1 specimen 19/18 mm [6089], st KM05, mixed hard platform and seagrass bed at outlet of rivulet (IM-2013-53524); New Ireland, Kavieng, 02°41.00'S, 150°57.00'E, 1 specimen 20/15 mm [6090], st KM05, mixed hard platform and seagrass bed at outlet of rivulet (IM-2013-53522). Vanuatu, Santo Rose Point, 15°34.90'S, 167°02.40'E, 1 specimen 14/13 mm [5483], st VM02, intertidal, coral sand (IM-2013-62405); Santo Rose Point, 15°34.90'S, 167°02.40'E, 1 specimen 14/12 mm [5484], st VM02, intertidal, coral sand (IM-2013-62406).
Indonesia: Ambon, Halmahera, and Sulawesi. Papua New Guinea: Madang and Kavieng. Vanuatu.
(Fig.
Habitats, Wallaconchis melanesiensis, Indonesia. A Halmahera, Foli, large rocks with algae high in intertidal (st 217) B Close-up of boulder showing the algae where the onchidiid was found (same locality as A) C Lombok, Seriwe Bay, narrow rocky beach between a cliff and the sea water D Halmahera, Sofifi, muddy, rocky intertidal (st 204).
Wallaconchis melanesiensis is named after the region of Melanesia, as it is the only Wallaconchis species found in Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu.
(Table
(Fig.
Live specimens, Wallaconchis melanesiensis, Indonesia. A Dorsal view, 25 mm long [5131], Halmahera (UMIZ 00069) B Dorsal view, 27 mm long [5133], Halmahera (UMIZ 00069) C Holotype, dorsal view, 15 mm long [5065], Halmahera (UMIZ 00065) D Dorsal view, 23 mm long [5132], Halmahera (UMIZ 00069) E Dorsal view, 27 mm long [2963], Lombok (UMIZ 00070) F Dorsal view, 43 mm long [2735], Ambon (UMIZ 00068) G Ventral view, same as B H Ventral view, same as C.
Between eight and ten papillae bear dorsal eyes (three or four per papilla). There is a retractable papilla with eyes in the center of the dorsal notum, which is not raised above the other papillae.
(Figs
Radula, Wallaconchis melanesiensis, Indonesia (A–C) Halmahera [5132] (UMIZ 00069) (D) Ambon [2733] (UMIZ 00068). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm B Rachidian and inner left lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm C Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, scale bar 30 μm D Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm.
Radula, Wallaconchis melanesiensis, Vanuatu [5484] (IM-2013-62406). A Rachidian and innermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm B Rachidian and inner left lateral teeth, scale bar 50 μm C Transition between inner lateral teeth and outer lateral teeth, scale bar 100 μm D Outermost lateral teeth, scale bar 20 μm E Hook of left lateral teeth from underneath, without basal lateral spine, scale bar 30 μm F Hook of left lateral teeth from underneath, without basal lateral spine, scale bar 20 μm.
(Fig.
Reproductive system, hermaphroditic (female), posterior parts, Wallaconchis melanesiensis. A Indonesia, Halmahera, scale bar 2 mm [5131] (UMIZ 00069) B Vanuatu, scale bar 1 mm [5484] (IM-2013-62406) C Indonesia, Lombok, scale bar 2.4 mm [2963] (UMIZ 00070). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct fgm female gland mass hd hermaphroditic duct hg hermaphroditic gland ov oviduct rs receptaculum seminis sp spermatheca.
(Figs
Reproductive system, anterior, male copulatory parts, Wallaconchis melanesiensis. A Vanuatu, scale bar 1 mm [5484] (IM-2013-62406) B Indonesia, Halmahera, scale bar 2 mm [5132] (UMIZ 00069) C Indonesia, Lombok, scale bar 2 mm [2963] (UMIZ 00070). Abbreviations: dd deferent duct p penis ps penial sheath rm retractor muscle v vestibule.
Wallaconchis melanesiensis is the only Wallaconchis species found in New Ireland (Papua New Guinea), which is the type locality of Onchidium granulosum Lesson, 1826. Lesson’s (1826: pl. 14, fig. 2) illustration of the dorsal notum and his written description of small, dorsal tubercles (
The application of Onchidium cinereum Quoy & Gaimard, 1832 (with a type locality in Tonga) has remained confusing. The original description is short and uninformative. The type material was not located. At this stage, it cannot be determined whether Onchidium cinereum applies to a species of Peronia, Wallaconchis, or another genus. Therefore, Onchidium cinereum is regarded here as a nomen dubium. Semper re-described O. cinereum based on Tonga specimens from the collections of the Museum Godeffroy (not part of the type series), and these specimens are part of a Wallaconchis species (based on the anatomical characters mentioned). The specimens that Semper examined indicate that a Wallaconchis species lives in Tonga, which could be W. comendadori, W. melanesiensis, or even a distinct species, but this could not be tested here because we did not have access to Tonga material. Finally, note that
Intra-specific genetic divergence is higher in W. melanesiensis than in other Wallaconchis species. Specimens from Vanuatu are 3.8% to 5.6% genetically divergent from the other specimens (from Indonesia and Papua New Guinea). High genetic divergences are even observed between specimens from the same locality (e.g., 3.4% within Vanuatu and Halmahera, and 4.4% within Kavieng, Papua New Guinea). The genetic divergence between the individuals from Vanuatu and those from Papua New Guinea and Indonesia could simply be an artifact of the geographic isolation of Vanuatu. Also, intra-specific divergences up to 5.5% were observed within other onchidiid species (
A key is provided here to help identify the ten species of Wallaconchis. The majority of Wallaconchis species cannot be distinguished externally; therefore the key is based on internal characters of reproductively mature specimens.
1 | The oviduct is extremely long and convoluted | W. nangkauriense |
– | The oviduct is not extremely long and convoluted | 2 |
2 | The distal part of the oviduct is approximately twice as wide as the proximal part | 3 |
– | The oviduct is approximately the same width along its length (narrow) | 5 |
3 | The penis forms loops which do not bear hooks | W. ater |
– | The penis bears hooks | 4 |
4 | The penis bears hooks in two regions which are separated by a large gap without hooks | W. graniferum |
– | Penis bears large, flattened hooks, which are distributed across the length of the penis (not separated by a large gap) | W. uncinus |
5 | Part of the oviduct forms a loop attached to the visceral cavity wall by a fibrous membrane | 6 |
– | The oviduct is not attached to the visceral cavity wall | 7 |
6 | The penis is not protected by a penial sheath and has longitudinal ridges internally | W. buetschlii |
– | The penis is narrow and protected within a penial sheath | W. gracile |
7 | The spermatheca is spherical | 8 |
– | The spermatheca is apple-shaped or lobed | 9 |
8 | Oviduct is slightly wider than the deferent duct, the penis is within the base of the vestibule | W. sinanui |
– | Oviduct is more than twice the width of the deferent duct, the penis is free within the vestibule | W. achleitneri |
9 | Deferent duct extremely convoluted | W. comendadori |
– | Deferent duct is slightly convoluted | W. melanesiensis |
The monophyly of Wallaconchis is highly supported by all analyses of mitochondrial and nuclear loci (Figs
Ten species of Wallaconchis can be recognized based on internal anatomy, i.e., essentially the anatomy of the reproductive system (Table
However, there is some incongruence between mitochondrial and nuclear trees regarding three species: W. ater, W. graniferum, and W. melanesiensis. Wallaconchis ater, which forms a single unit in nuclear trees, is split in two distinct molecular units in mitochondrial trees, and the same thing goes for W. graniferum, and W. melanesiensis. For each species, the two mitochondrial units are more than 20% divergent for COI sequences (Table
If the two mitochondrial haplotypes (or units) found in each species were simply the result of a simple case of population structure, we would expect to find them to be sister groups and much less divergent from each other. In this particular case, population structure is more complex than usual. Interestingly, the extremely high mitochondrial genetic divergence observed within each of these three species (> 20 %) is accompanied by high divergence in amino acid sequences: namely, the amino acid COI sequences of W. ater unit #2, W. graniferum unit #2, and W. melanesiensis unit #2 are very different from those all other Wallaconchis species. These divergent amino acid sequences do not contain any stop codons: they are perfectly functional and are not due to a frame shift mutation. Also, all COI sequences included here most closely match other onchidiid sequences in GenBank and they are not due to contamination.
We hypothesize that the divergent COI sequences in W. ater unit #2, W. graniferum unit #2, and W. melanesiensis unit #2, are due to an ancestral sequence maternally transmitted through generations in three distinct lineages. It probably was present in other species as well but was ultimately lost or not sampled yet. The fact that the amino acid COI sequences of W. ater unit #2 and W. graniferum unit #2 are fairly similar to each other suggests that the ancestral haplotypes were present in a common ancestor and that the mitochondrial haplotypes that code for these amino acids are ancestral and predate more recent diversification events. The fact that the amino acid COI sequence of W. melanesiensis unit #2 is more closely related to W. melanesiensis unit #1 and W. comendadori is also consistent with this theory: Wallaconchis melanesiensis is within clade A, which diverged from clade B very early in the evolution of Wallaconchis. So, as the genus diversified, and new species formed, the ancestral haplotypes were only retained in a few lineages. Because both 16S and 12S evolve in the same way as COI, the trees based on concatenated mitochondrial COI, 16S, and 12S DNA sequences yielded identical results with respect to the delineation and relationships of molecular units. Overall, the delineation of W. ater, W. graniferum, and W. melanesiensis is therefore based on nuclear DNA sequences and morphology, and each of these three species is not split in two, as suggested by mitochondrial DNA sequences.
Integrating mitochondrial DNA, nuclear DNA, and anatomy as multiple lines of evidence has been key to delineating Wallaconchis species. Six out of ten Wallaconchis species are consistently differentiated by all three sources of data, but neither mitochondrial DNA nor nuclear DNA sequences were able to delineate all ten species. One species, W. uncinus, has a highly distinct penial anatomy and can be recognized using mitochondrial DNA, while nuclear ITS sequences do not distinguish it from W. graniferum. On the other hand, delineating W. ater, W. graniferum, and W. melanesiensis was possible with nuclear ITS sequences and morphology, but not possible with mitochondrial DNA.
Ten Wallaconchis species are described here, including five new species. The five species with existing names were known only from the type material prior to the present study, and the numerous new records provided here greatly expand their geographic distribution (Fig.
Given that few characters can be used to classify onchidiids at the genus level and that nobody knew what those characters were before our lab started working on the revision of the entire family, it is not surprising that only through an integrative approach, could such a diverse genus be formally recognized and named. Also, the great diversity of reproductive parts in Wallaconchis makes it difficult to recognize that the species are related and belong to a single genus. Access to fresh material preserved for DNA analysis, combined with a broad range of data (microhabitat where each specimen was collected, color of each live animal, etc.), has been essential in revising the taxonomy of this diverse but poorly known group.
All Wallaconchis species are externally cryptic. No external feature can be used for species identification. However, all species are internally distinct. The high diversity of copulatory organs observed in Wallaconchis is unusual in the Onchidiidae. Usually, differences in the copulatory organs of closely-related species are subtle. Even when species are distinguished based on the presence or the absence of an accessory penial gland, reproductive parts are anatomically similar, as in Melayonchis for instance (
The geographic distribution of Wallaconchis species is also unique in the Onchidiidae. Many Wallaconchis species are sympatric in the Coral Triangle, a region with the highest diversity of reef-building corals and associated fishes (
The low intra-specific genetic divergences observed in some Wallaconchis species suggest that high dispersal has been maintained between populations of the same species within the center of the Coral Triangle (Indonesia and the Philippines), or that populations have undergone a bottleneck and experienced a recent population expansion. Slightly higher intra-specific divergences (but still < 3.2%) tend to be observed between populations from localities on the edge of the Wallaconchis distribution range (Andaman Islands, Sumatra, Queensland, and Vanuatu), suggesting lower dispersal between those more isolated populations and those in the Coral Triangle. The very high mitochondrial divergence between unit #1 and #2 in W. graniferum, W. ater, and W. melanesiensis is likely due to the maintenance over time of ancestral haplotypes (see above). Geographic isolation may have played a role in the formation of divergent haplotypes in the early history of Wallaconchis, but further studies are needed to understand the evolution of these mitochondrial haplotypes.
After recognizing the existence of this genus and its ten distinct species, its unique combination of traits (no dorsal gills, intestinal loops of type I, no rectal gland, and no accessory penial gland) was used to help determine whether existing genus- and species-group names could apply to these taxa. The types of all existing onchidiid names were examined and all species descriptions were read meticulously. All existing names were considered because supra-specific relationships in onchidiids have been notoriously confusing (
The confusing nomenclature of the Onchidiidae has clearly hindered biodiversity knowledge. The fact that all existing names had to be considered before any new species could be described has kept taxonomists away from the Onchidiidae for more than 80 years (
The fact that Wallaconchis species live in different microhabitats is unique among the onchidiids. In other onchidiid genera, all species are found in the same microhabitat(s). For example, Onchidium species live in mangroves, where they are found on (or inside) old logs and on mud; Melayonchis species are found in mangroves, on tree roots and trunks as well as old logs; Peronina species are found in mangroves, on mud saturated with water; and Peronia species are found on rocks in the rocky intertidal. The different microhabitats on which Wallaconchis species live are frequently in close proximity to coastal mangroves, and it was only by photographing many specimens in the field that we were able to determine that the species were found on different substrates. The adaptation of Wallaconchis species to different microhabitats is perfectly illustrated by our station 198, on the southern coast of Bohol, Philippines, where an ideal combination of microhabitats (coral rubble, fine sand, and sandy mud) brought all five Wallaconchis species from clade B present in the Philippines (there are three other species in clade B but they are not found in the Philippines) to a single site of only 100 square meters (Fig.
The adaptation of Wallaconchis species to distinct microhabitats likely is essential to the existence of so many species at the same sites, which would otherwise compete for limited food resources. In other onchidiid genera, species live in the same microhabitat and thus probably utilize the same resources. Ultimately, this may largely explain the distinct patterns of species richness observed in Wallaconchis in comparison to the two other onchidiid genera with a similar number of species (Peronia and Platevindex). Indeed, in Peronia and Platevindex, species richness peaks at three or four species within any given region, while eight Wallaconchis species are sympatric and broadly distributed in the Coral Triangle (Fig.
Microhabitat adaptation can be mapped onto our Wallaconchis phylogenetic tree, to form hypotheses about the diversification processes and microhabitat shifts that possibly took place during the evolutionary history of Wallaconchis (Fig.
Phylogenetic relationships of Wallaconchis species, with shifts in habitat and character state mapped (for the details on node support and numbers of specimens included in each species, see Figs
Wallaconchis is among the most diverse genera of onchidiids in the tropical Indo-West Pacific (Peronia and Platevindex being slightly more diverse), and the ability of Wallaconchis lineages to colonize new microhabitats has likely been instrumental in its diversification. The high diversity in Wallaconchis is especially remarkable considering that Peronia is distributed much more widely (from South Africa and the Red Sea all the way to Hawaii and French Polynesia). However, unlike Wallaconchis, Peronia is restricted to a single habitat (rocky intertidal) and its diversification must have been driven by other factors than transitions to new habitats.
The diversity of reproductive parts (especially the male copulatory ones) in Wallaconchis is truly exceptional in comparison to other onchidiids. In other genera, species occasionally differ with respect to the presence or absence of penial hooks or of an accessory penial gland, but otherwise the morphology of the copulatory organs is generally similar. All Wallaconchis species can be distinguished using reproductive parts, and the highly distinct penial hooks and loops found in some Wallaconchis species have not been observed in any other genera.
Mapping the different reproductive parts onto the Wallaconchis phylogenetic tree shows that the ancestral state likely was a narrow penis and a narrow oviduct, because it is shared by all species in clade A and the three most basal species in clade B (Fig.
Most Wallaconchis species are common. However, W. sinanui and W. achleitneri were each found at only one site and may be micro-endemic. It would have been impossible to discover such rare and endemic species without extensive sampling (gastropods were collected at more than 260 stations across the Indo-West Pacific, especially in South-East Asia). Now that Wallaconchis is well delineated and characterized and all ten known species have been described with modern tools, additional species will likely be discovered.
The majority of Wallaconchis species, like most other onchidiid species (
We are extremely grateful to all the people who helped us with field work in various ways, by hosting us at their institutions, helping with logistics, or accompanying us in the field. Our study would have been impossible without their generous help and efforts: Deepak Apte, Vishal Bhave, Sudhir Sapre, and C.R. Sreeraj in India; Neil Bruce in Queensland; Richard Willan in Northern Territory; Vivian Ang, Don Dumale, Joseph Comendador, and Marivene Manuel in the Philippines. We thank Philippe Bouchet (Muséum national d’histoire naturelle, Paris) for allowing us to study some material collected during an expedition he led in Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu. Accessing mangrove sites would have been impossible without help from local fishermen and villagers. We are grateful to Rahul C. Salunkhe and Yogesh Shouche (Bombay Natural History Society, Mumbai, and National Center for Cell Science, Pune) for their help with the DNA sequencing of the specimens from India. We also thank Rani Chapla and David Piperato for assisting with DNA extractions in our lab at the Pennsylvania State University. We would also like to thank the collection managers of various institutions for accepting to host our material in their collections and sending us specimens on loan: Bombay Natural History Society, Mumbai, India; Muséum national d’histoire naturelle, Paris, France; Museum of Tropical Queensland, Townsville, Queensland, Australia; National Museum of the Philippines, Manila, Philippines; Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany; Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin, Germany; Zoological Museum of the University of Copenhagen, Denmark. Specimens were collected following local regulations, as overseen by Deepak Apte (India), Marivene Manuel (Philippines), and Munawar Khalil (Indonesia). Collecting in New South Wales, Queensland, and Northern Territory was done with permits from local institutions. We thank the Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education, Republic of Indonesia (Ristek-Dikti) that issued a research permit to Benoît Dayrat (Ristek #134/SIP/FRP/E5/Dit.KI/VI/2017). We also wish to thank the Universitas Malikussaleh, Sumatra, Indonesia, for being our home base institution in Indonesia. This work was supported by the Eberly College of Science at the Pennsylvania State University and by a REVSYS (Revisionary Syntheses in Systematics) award from the US National Science Foundation (DEB 1419394). We also thank Nathalie Yonow, Adrienne Jochum and Antonio M. de Frias Martins for their careful attention to this manuscript and their constructive comments which have greatly improved this manuscript.