Research Article |
Corresponding author: José F. Goméz ( jf.gomez@bio.ucm.es ) Academic editor: Michael S. Engel
© 2017 José F. Goméz, María Hernández Nieves, Severiano F. Gayubo, Jose Luis Nieves-Aldrey.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Gómez JF, Nieves MH, Gayubo SF, Nieves-Aldrey JL (2017) Terminal-instar larval systematics and biology of west European species of Ormyridae associated with insect galls (Hymenoptera, Chalcidoidea). ZooKeys 644: 51-88. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.644.10035
|
A systematic study of the genus Ormyrus (Chalcidoidea, Ormyridae) was conducted based on the morphology and biology of the terminal-instar larvae of ten west European species that are parasitoids of gall wasps and gallflies of the families Cynipidae, Eurytomidae and Tephritidae. The first detailed descriptions are provided of the terminal-instar larvae of these ten species using SEM images to illustrate diagnostic characters with systematic values. A key is provided for the identification of ormyrid larvae associated with galls in Europe, which is based particularly on characters of the head, mouthparts and mandibles. Although only limited informative variation in body shape was found, the setation of the head provided several characters of potential taxonomic value. The larval biology of the ten ormyrid species inhabiting different galls is also summarised. Although Ormyrus larvae are usually solitary idiobiont ectoparasitoids of the host larva of various gall-inhabiting insects, evidence of secondary phytophagy was observed in some species.
Chaetotaxy, cynipid galls, cryptic species, identification keys, immature stages, mouthparts Ormyrus, parasitoid
The superfamily Chalcidoidea is the second largest superfamily of parasitoid Hymenoptera (
The ormyrids are chalcidoids that are morphologically well characterised by their usually bright metallic colours, coarsely crenulated sculpture of the metasoma, well-developed hind coxae, short stigmal veins and two stout and curved metatibial spurs.
The family has never been catalogued or revised worldwide. References to European and Palaearctic faunas of Ormyridae are found in
The larval ormyrids are typically solitary idiobiont ectoparasitoids of various gall-forming insects. Most Holarctic species are associated with gall wasps (Hymenoptera, Cynipidae) in temperate regions, with some species linked to gall midges and gallflies (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae and Tephritidae, respectively) (
Twenty-nine ormyrid species have been recorded in Europe, of which only seven are relatively common and widely distributed in western Europe, whereas three species, O. salmanticus, O. monegricus and O. cupreus, are restricted to the Iberian Peninsula. Approximately 75% of the European species of Ormyrus are associated with galls of Cynipidae on herbs or oak trees, with the other species linked to gall midges (Cecidomyiidae), gallflies (Tephritidae) and eurytomid galls (Eurytomidae).
Taxonomy and classification of the Ormyridae is based almost entirely on the morphological characters of the adults, with molecular data for this family remaining virtually absent (but see
Studies on the immature stages of Ormyridae are scarce or rare in the literature.
This study is the first comprehensive analysis of the larval morphology of the more common species of Ormyrus of Europe. The work is part of a wider study examining the larval morphology, biology and phylogeny of Chalcidoidea associated with gall wasps in Spain and western Europe. Studies of the larval morphology of Torymidae, Eurytomidae and Pteromalidae are completed (
Selected taxa and specimens. A total of 135 larval specimens belonging to ten species of Ormyridae was examined. Host galls were collected from a range of plants at sites in Spain. Sampling data are presented in Table
Summary of the host gall, host plant and sample site data for the ormyrid species included in the study. Chalcid outgroups accounted are also annotated. Depository: JLNA, JFGS and MHN; J. L. Nieves-Aldrey collection, Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid, Spain.
Species | Specimens (n) | Host | Plant species | Collection data |
---|---|---|---|---|
1. Ormyrus capsalis | 22 | Aylax minor (Cynipidae) | Papaver spp. (Papaveraceae) | Spain: Monte Pajares, Rivas-Vaciamadrid, Valdemorillo (Madrid); Cabezón-San Martín de Valveni (Valladolid) (JLNA) |
2. Ormyrus cupreus | 1 | Eurytoma gallephedrae (Eurytomidae) | Ephedra nebrodensis (Gnetaceae) | Spain: Monte Pajares (Madrid) (JLNA) |
3. Ormyrus diffinis | 36 | Liposthenes kerneri (Cynipidae) | Nepeta hispanica (Lamiaceae) | Spain: Casa Eulogio, Rivas Vaciamadrid (Madrid) (JLNA) |
4. Ormyrus gratiosus | 11 | Isocolus scabiosae (Cynipidae) | Centaurea scabiosa (Asteraceae) | Spain: Pozo de Guadalajara (Guadalajara) (JLNA) |
5. Ormyrus nitidulus | 2 | Andricus hispanicus (Cynipidae) | Quercus pyrenaica (Fagaceae) | Spain: Algatocín (Málaga); Laguna de San Marcos (Salamanca) (JLNA) |
6. Ormyrus orientalis | 1 | Unidentified Tephritidae (Diptera) | Microlonchus salmanticus (Asteraceae) | Spain: La Flecha (Salamanca) (JLNA) |
7. Ormyrus papaveris | 8 | Aylax papaveris (Cynipidae) | Papaver rhoeas/dubium (Papaveraceae) | Spain: El Cardoso de la Sierra (Guadalajara); Rivas Vaciamadrid (Madrid) (JLNA); San Andrés (Soria) (JFG/JLNA) |
8. Ormyrus pomaceus | 1 1 1 11 |
Andricus grossulariae asex. (Cynipidae) Trigonaspis mendesi (Cynipidae) Plagiotrochus fusifex (Cynipidae) Plagiotrochus razeti (Cynipidae) |
Quercus faginea (Fagaceae) Quercus faginea (Fagaceae) Quercus coccifera (Fagaceae) Quercus ilex (Fagaceae) |
Spain: La Suara (Cádiz) (JLNA) Spain: Boadilla del Monte (Madrid) (JLNA) Spain: Arganda (Madrid) (JLNA) Spain: Villanueva del Pardillo (Madrid) (JLNA) |
9. Ormyrus rufimanus | 41 | Xestophanes potentillae (Cynipidae) | Potentilla reptans (Rosaceae) | Spain: Cotos de Monterrey, Villalvilla, Villar del Olmo (Madrid); Colldejou (Tarragona) (JLNA) |
10 Ormyrus wachtli | 1 | Neaylax verbenacus | Salvia verbenaca (Lamiaceae) | Spain: Arganda (Madrid) (JLNA) |
EUPELMIDAE | ||||
11. Eupelmus cerris | 1 | Synophrus politus (Cynipidae) | Quercus suber (Fagaceae) | Spain: El Pardo (Madrid) (JLNA) |
EURYTOMIDAE | ||||
12. Eurytoma aspila | 1 | Timaspis urospermi (Cynipidae) | Urospermum picroides (Asteraceae) | Spain: Algatocín (Málaga) (JLNA) |
PTEROMALIDAE | ||||
13. Cecidostiba geganius | 1 | Andricus quercusradicis asex. (Cynipidae) | Quercus pyrenaica (Fagaceae) | Spain: Miraflores (Madrid (JLNA) |
TORYMIDAE | ||||
14. Torymus nobilis | 1 | Andricus testaceipes asex. (Cynipidae) | Quercus pyrenaica (Fagaceae) | Spain: Miraflores (Madrid (JLNA) |
Some parasitoid species in the families Eupelmidae, Eurytomidae, Pteromalidae and Torymidae (Hym., Chalcidoidea) associated with cynipid-galls were included in the study for comparative purposes in the systematic analysis of terminal-instar larvae (Table
Sampling and rearing. Samples were collected in the spring and autumn during the last 15 years with more intensive sampling in 2002–2007. Some of the galls from each sample were dissected to obtain larvae, and the remaining galls were kept separately outdoors in the open in labelled bags or were stored in rearing cages to obtain adults for identification. Some larvae from freshly dissected galls were preserved in absolute ethanol, whereas the remainder were allowed to develop to adulthood in small gelatine capsules as described by
Preparation for morphological studies. Larvae were transferred directly from absolute ethanol to a SEM stub for observation using a FEI Quanta 2000TM scanning electron microscope at low vacuum without prior fixation or coating, following the method described by
Terminology. General terminology used in the larval descriptions follows
Morphological measurements and ratios of studied specimens meaning as follows: body maximun length/width (L/W); head maximun length/width (HW/HL); distance between antennae/length of the antero-medial setae of the antennal area (LAA/SA); distance between antennae/distance between the antero-medial setae of vertex (DAV/SA); distance between the antennae to the anterior margin of clypeus/distance between the antennae to the upper margin of vertex (AC/AV); maximum length/width of the mandible tooth (L/W 1T).
Species | L/W | HW/HL | LAA/SA | DAV/SA | AC/AV | L/W 1T |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ormyrus capsalis | 1.82 | 1.16 | 0.52 | 0.68 | 0.82 | 1.42 |
Ormyrus cupreus | 1.93 | 1.10 | 0.22 | 1.08 | 1.33 | – |
Ormyrus diffinis | 1.87 | 1.15 | 0.50 | 0.83 | 1.27 | 1.61 |
Ormyrus gratiosus | 1.74 | 1.09 | 0.32 | 0.84 | 0.89 | 1.50 |
Ormyrus nitidulus | 2.01 | 1.10 | 0.04 | 0.93 | 0.77 | 1.64 |
Ormyrus orientalis | 1.74 | 0.89 | 0.41 | 0.76 | 1.22 | – |
Ormyrus papaveris | 2.00 | 0.89 | 0.10 | 0.77 | 2.00 | 1.64 |
Ormyrus pomaceus ex Plagiotrochus | 2.01 | 0.86 | 0.04 | 0.92 | 1.33 | – |
Ormyrus pomaceus ex Trigonaspis | 1.94 | 0.83 | 0.24 | 0.81 | 1.07 | 1.39 |
Ormyrus rufimanus | 2.01 | 1.00 | 0.20 | 0.93 | 1.10 | 1.80 |
Ormyrus wachtli | 2.09 | 0.86 | 0.02 | 0.56 | 1.44 | – |
Systematic analysis: Coding of morphological characters. Ormyrid nomenclature followed
The appearance of terminal-instar larvae of Ormyrus is hymenopteriform (
The labrum of Eurytomidae and Ormyridae is also similar in being divided into a medial and two lateral lobes; however, while the medial part of the labrum of Eurytoma is usually divided into five lobes, the medial lobe in Ormyrus is usually undivided or superficially divided into three lobes.
Body segmentation (Fig.
General morphology of body. A Lateral view of Ormyrus cupreus B ventral view of Ormyrus diffinis. Letters refer to the terminology used for general description (see text): ABS1-ABS9, abdominal segments; adp, anterodorsal protuberances; ANS, anal segment; THS1-THS3, thoracic segments; D, dorsal; P, pleural; V, ventral; vlr, ventrolateral region; vmr, ventromedial region.
General morphology in ventral view (Fig.
General morphology in lateral view (Fig.
Spiracles (Fig.
Head (Fig.
Ormyrus nitidulus. A Anterior view of head illustrating terminology used for general description (see text). Abbreviations: af, antennal foramina; am, antero-medial setae on the antennal region; an, antenna; anr, antennal area; cl, clypeus; cs, clypeal seate; fr, frons; gn, genal setae; gr, genal region; hr, hypostomal region; hs, hypostomal setae; lb, labrum; lcs, lateral clypeal setae; vam, antero-medial setae of vertex; vr, vertex region B Anterior view of mouthparts. Abbreviations: clypeus (cl); clypeal setae (cs); labrum (lb); lateral flaps of sides of labrum (lfsl); lateral lobe of labrum (lll); lateral clypeal setae (lcs); labral setae (lbs); medial lobe of labrum (mll). The under-lip complex (Mpu) is formed by labium (lbi) and maxillae (mx); maxillary palps (mp); Mpu setae: maxillary setae (ms) and antero-medial labial setae (ul).
Mouth parts (Figs
Mandibles (Figs
Taxonomy. Descriptions of the taxa were based primarily on preserved material but with additional observations from living larvae. The diagnosis of the genus Ormyrus was based entirely on SEM observations and partly on previous work by
1 | Body and head integument with predominant blister-like sculpture (Figs |
2 |
– | Body and head integument for the most part smooth; blister-like sculpture only on the genal area (Fig. |
5 |
2 | Supraclypeal setae present (Fig. |
Ormyrus wachtli |
– | Supraclypeal setae absent (Figs |
3 |
3 | Thoracic setae long, at least as long as the length of a thoracic segment (Figs |
Ormyrus cupreus |
– | Thoracic setae short; shorter than the length of a thoracic segment (Figs |
4 |
4 | Large size larvae; length reaching 3 mm (Figs |
Ormyrus nitidulus |
– | Smaller size larvae, which length rarely exceed 2 mm (Figs |
Ormyrus pomaceus |
5 | Upper margin of vertex rounded continuous; convex at the medial area (Fig. |
Ormyrus orientalis |
– | Upper margin of vertex slightly interrupted, the medial area of vertex appearing concave or depressed (Fig. |
6 |
6 | Anteromedial setae of the antennal area situated at the same level or slightly above antennae (Fig. |
7 |
– | Anteromedial setae of the antennal area situated clearly above antennae (Fig. |
8 |
7 | Body short and wide, not abruptly tapering towards anal segment from the middle of the body (Fig. |
Ormyrus diffinis |
– | Body elongated and narrow, abruptly tapering towards the anal segment from the middle segments (Fig. |
Ormyrus rufimanus |
8 | Body elongated and narrow, abruptly tapering towards the anal segment from the middle of the body (Fig. |
Ormyrus papaveris |
– | Body shorter and wide, not abruptly tapering towards anal segment from the middle (Figs |
9 |
9 | Lateral clypeal setae situated slightly above clypeal setae; distance between lateral clypeal setae and clypeal setae, twice the distance separating clypeal setae (Fig. |
Ormyrus gratiosus |
– | Lateral clypeal setae situated at the same level of clypeal setae (Fig. |
Ormyrus capsalis |
A Galls of Aylax minor on Papaver spp. B detail of cells of Aylax minor on Papaver spp. C larvae of Ormyrus capsalis on of non-parasitized larvae of A. minor D Detail of solitarious larvae of O. capsalis inside gall cell of A. minor E galls of Eurytoma gallephedrae on Ephedra nebrodensis F galls of Eurytoma flaveola on Ephedra nebrodensis G larvae of Ormyrus cupreus inside the gall cell H larvae of Ormyrus cupreus inside the gall cell with debris of adult specimen of the same species I gall of Liposthenes kerneri on Nepeta hispanica J ventral view of larvae of O. diffinis inside the gall cell K lateral view of larvae of O. diffinis inside the gall cell.
Fully (A) and dissected (B) galls of Isocolus scabiosae in achenes of heads of Centaurea scabiosa. C detail of larvae of Ormyrus gratiosus inside cells of I. scabiosae gall D galls of Andricus hispanicus on Quercus pyrenaica E cross-section of gall of Andricus hispanicus with larvae of Ormyrus nitidulus within gall cell F detail of head and thorax in anterior view of larvae of Ormyrus nitidulus within gall cell of A. hispanicus G gall of Myopites limbardae on Inula viscosa H cross-section of gall of Myopites limbardae on Inula viscosa I detail of larva of Ormyrus orientalis within gall cell of Tephritidae on Microlonchus salmanticus J galls of Aylax papaveris on poppy heads K cross-section of poppy head shown cells of galls of A. papaveris L larvae of Ormyrus papaveris with debris of dead host within gall cells of A. papaveris.
A cross-section of poppy head with galls of Barbotinia oraniensis B larvae of Ormyrus papaveris within gall of B. oraniensis C larvae of Ormyrus papaveris with debris of dead host within gall cells of B. oraniensis D gall of Andricus grossulariae (asexual) on Quercus pyrenaica E cross-section of gall Andricus grossulariae (asexual) F larvae of Ormyrus pomaceus ex gall of A. grossulariae G gall of Andricus pictus on Q. pyrenaica H cross-section of gall Andricus pictus I larvae of Ormyrus pomaceus ex gall of A. pictus J galls of Trigonaspis mendesi on Q. faginea K larvae of O. pomaceus within galls of Trigonaspis mendesi on Q. faginea L galls of Trigonaspis brunneicornis on Q. faginea.
A larvae of O. pomaceus and Trigonaspis brunneicornis within gall cells B gall of Plagiotrochus razeti (asexual) on Quercus C galls of Plagiotrochus quercusilicis on Quercus D larvae of Ormyrus pomaceus within cells of galls of P. razeti E detail of larva of Ormyrus pomaceus within cell of gall of P. razeti F galls of Xestophanes potentillae on subterranean rhizome of Potentilla reptans G galls of X. potentillae on air runners of P. reptans H larvae of O. rufimanus on larvae of X. potentillae within gall cell I larvae of O rufimanus with debris of dead host within gall cells of X. potentillae. J galls of Neaylax verbenacus on Salvia verbenaca K larvae of O. wachtli on larvae of N. verbenacus within gall cell L pupae of O. wachtli within gall of Neaylax salviae.
ex gall Aylax minor Hartig on Papaver spp., Spain, Guadalajara: Valdenoches, 31.VII.01, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1); Madrid: Monte Pajares, 7.IX.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 11); Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 14.V.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1); Madrid: Valdemorillo, 13.VI.04, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 2); Valladolid: Cabezón-San Martín de Valveni, 22.VI.02, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 7).
n = 22; Body length: 1.68 ± 0.33 mm (min-max: 1.13-2.20 mm), width: 0.92 ± 0.16 mm (min-max: 0.67-1.20 mm). Body fusiform, relatively short and wide, slightly wider at the level of ABS2-ABS3, but not tapering abruptly towards ANS (Figs
This species is a common parasitoid in poppy galls of Aylax minor Hartig, 1840 (Hym., Cynipidae) (Fig.
Notably, in some cases, we observed terminal-instar larvae of Ormyrus inside cells of Aylax minor, which apparently were not consumed (Fig.
ex gall Eurytoma gallephedrae Askew on Ephedra nebrodensis, Spain, Madrid: Monte Pajares, 24.I.04, J. L. Nieves leg (n=1).
n = 1; Body length: 1.5 mm, width: 0.61 mm. Body fusiform, broader at the level of abdominal segments ABS2-ABS3 and tapering posteriorly towards ANS; ANS broader than long (Figs
The larva of O. cupreus was described as a specific parasitoid of galls induced by Eurytoma gallephedrae Askew (Chalcidoidea, Eurytomidae) on Ephedra nebrodensis stems (Fig.
ex gall Liposthenes kerneri (Wachtl) on Nepeta hispanica Spain, Madrid: Casa Eulogio, 01.VI.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 8); Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 01.VI.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 5); Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 13.VI.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1); Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 17.V.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 22)
n = 36; Body length: 1.56 ± 0.34 mm (min-max: 1.00-2.40 mm), width: 0.83 ± 0.12 mm (min-max: 0.60-1.00 mm). Body fusiform, not tapering abruptly towards anal segment (Figs
On clypeus lcs situated at the same level of cs; lateral lobes of labrum strongly remarked and incompletely fused with the medial lobe; posterior margin of medial piece of labrum convex (Fig.
The species is a common parasitoid reared from cynipid galls of Liposthenes kerneri (Wachtl) on fruits of Nepeta ssp. (Lamiaceae; Fig.
ex gall Isocolus scabiosae (Giraud) on Centaurea scabiosa, Spain, Guadalajara: Pozo de Guadalajara, 31.VII.02, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 4); Pozo de Guadalajara, 03.X.04, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 7).
n = 11; Body length: 2.22 ± 0.63 mm (min-max: 1.40-3.60 mm), width: 1.28 ± 0.31 mm (min-max: 0.67-1.87 mm). The species differs from O. capsalis in the following characters: head 1.1 times as wide as high; genal area, vertex and first thoracic segment with blister-like sculpture; antennae mid-situated in anterior view of the head; antennal setae 0.35 as long as distance between antennae; lcs situated above lc (Figs
Larvae of O. gratiosus are oligophagous idiobiont ectoparasitoids of species of Isocolus that induce galls on flower heads of Centaurea and Serratula species (Asteraceae) (
ex gall Andricus hispanicus on Quercus canariensis, Spain, Málaga: Algatocín, 19.VIII.02, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1); ex gall Andricus hispanicus on Quercus faginea, Spain, Salamanca: Laguna de San Marcos, 26.VIII.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1)
n = 2; Body length: 4.28 ± 0.87 mm (min-max: 3.67-4.90 mm), width: 2.13 ± 0.18 mm (min-max: 2.00-2.25 mm).
The larva of this species is the largest among all the European species. Is quite similar in most diagnostic characters to the larvae of the related species O. pomaceus, being differentiated by its large size and the blister like sculpture much less conspicuous. Other diagnostic characters are as follows: body short and wide, not tapering towards the anal segment. Setae of thoracic segments shorter than ½ length of a thoracic segment; ratio AC/AV 0.77, the shortest among all the studied species (Table
The species O. nitidulus is a member, with the closely allied O. pomaceus, of the parasitoid community associated with oak gall wasps (Hymenoptera, Cynipini). The two species were reared from more than 50 different species of cynipids associated with Quercus species in the west Palaearctic (
ex gall of an undetermined Tephritidae (Diptera) on Microlonchus salmanticus, Spain, Salamanca: La Flecha (23/X/02), J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1).
n = 1; Body length: 2.35 mm, width: 1.35 mm
Body fusiform, short and wide, slightly wider at the level of ABS2-ABS3, but not tapering abruptly towards ANS (Fig.
On clypeus lcs situated at the same level of cs, both equal in length (Fig.
In contrast to most European species of Ormyrus, the larvae of O. orientalis attack dipteran galls induced by tephritids (Diptera, Tephritidae) in the heads of different species of Asteraceae. On the Iberian Peninsula, tephritid galls containing O. orientalis were found on Microlonchus salmanticus (Asteraceae) (Fig.
ex gall Aylax papaveris on Papaver spp., Spain, Guadalajara: El Cardoso de la Sierra, 30.VI.02, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 4); Soria: San Andrés, 14.VII.05, J. L. Nieves & J. F. Gómez leg. (n = 1); ex gall Barbotinia oraniensis on Papaver spp., Spain, Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 25.V.02, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 2); Madrid: Rivas-Vaciamadrid, 13.VI.04, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 1).
n = 8; Body length: 1.88 ± 0.24 mm (min-max: 1.53-2.13 mm), width: 0.94 ± 0.19 mm (min-max: 0.67-1.20 mm). This species is similar to Ormyrus capsalis from which may be distinguished in the body fusiform, slightly wider at the level of body segments ABS2-ABS3, tapering towards the ANS (Figs
The larvae of O. papaveris are common ectoparasitoids in poppy galls of different Aylacini (Cynipidae) species, primarily Aylax papaveris and Barbotinia oraniensis (Figs
ex gall Andricus grossulariae asex. on Quercus faginea, Spain, Cádiz: La Suara-Jérez, 16.X.04, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 1); ex gall Plagiotrochus fusifex on Quercus coccifera, Spain, Madrid: Arganda, 01.VI.03, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 1); ex gall Plagiotrochus razeti on Quercus ilex, Spain, Madrid: Villanueva del Pardillo, 07/X/02, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 11). ex gall Trigonaspis mendesi on Quercus faginea, Spain, Madrid: Boadilla del Monte, 23/IX/02, J. L. Nieves leg. (n = 1).
Ex gall Andricus grossulariae asex., on Quercus faginea, n = 1; Body length: 2.73 mm, width: 1.67 mm; ex gall Plagiotrochus fusifex on Quercus coccifera, n = 1; Body length: 1.13 mm, width: 0.53 mm; ex gall Plagiotrochus razeti on Quercus ilex, n = 11; Body length: 2.21 ± 0.46 mm (min-max: 1.80–3.40 mm), width: 1.10 ± 0.10 mm (min-max: 0.93–1.27 mm); ex gall Trigonaspis mendesi on Quercus faginea, n = 1; Body length: 1.55 mm, width: 0.80 mm.
The morphology of the terminal larva of this species is very similar to that of the Ormyrus nitidulus larva. The larvae of O. pomaceus from galls of Andricus and Trigonaspis species were distinguished from those of O. nitidulus by the following characters: integument of thoracic and abdominal segments with conspicuous blister-like sculpture; distance among vertex setae longer than the distance between antennae; am 0.47 as long as the distance between antennae; lcs situated above the level of cs, being separated from cs by 1.2-fold the distance between cs; and maxillary palps not visible (Table
For the O. pomaceus larvae that inhabited Plagiotrochus galls (Figs
Ormyrus pomaceus is a polyphagous ectoparasitoid that attacks more than 56 different cynipid galls on Quercus trees (Figs
ex gall Xestophanes potentillae on Potentilla reptans, Spain, Madrid: Cotos de Monterrey, 24.VI.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 2); Madrid: Villalvilla, 26.VIII.05, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 9); Madrid: Villar del Olmo, 03.X.04, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 23); Tarragona: Colldejou, 14.VIII.03, J. L. Nieves leg (n = 7).
n = 41; Body length: 1.69 ± 0.39 mm (min-max: 1.13–2.53 mm), width: 0.84 ± 0.22 mm (min-max: 0.47-1.27). Body fusiform, abdominal segments tapering abruptly towards ANS (Figs
This species is extremely host-specific and is exclusively associated with galls on the runners and roots of Potentilla reptans (Rosaceae) induced by Xestophanes potentillae (Retzius) (Fig.
In the first stages, the larva of O. rufimanus and the paralyzed host larva co-occurred; in later stages, the remains of the host larva appeared on the ventral surface of the O. rufimanus larva. In dissected galls, the larvae of O. rufimanus were extracted from irregularly shaped larval gall cells, which indicated that vegetal material was consumed at the terminal larval stage, as observed with other Ormyrus species such as O. papaveris. Based on additional observations, we found larvae of Eupelmus vesicularis (Chalcidoidea, Eupelmidae) were hyperparasitoids of O. rufimanus pupae.
ex gall Neaylax verbenacus on Salvia verbenaca, Spain, Madrid: Dehesa de Arganda, 09.VI.02 J. L. Nieves leg (n = 1).
n = 1; Body length: 1.67 mm, width: 0.80 mm. The larva of this species is similar to the larva of O. diffinis, from which may be distinguissed as follows: body fusiform, wider at the level of segments ABS2-ABS3, tapering progresively towards ANS; anal segment wider tan length; adp absent; integument of the abdominal and thoracic segments blister-like. Head 1.18 as wide as high (Fig.
The larva of O. wachtli is a solitary ectoparasitoid of larvae of cynipids, inducing galls on fruits of Salvia (Lamiaceae). Along the Iberian Peninsula and in southern Europe, the species is associated with galls of Neaylax salviae (Giraud) on Salvia lavandulifolia (Fig.
As discussed in published studies on other families of Chalcidoidea (
The larvae of Ormyridae have a combination of traits that differentiate this family from other related chalcidoid families with a similar lifestyle as parasitoids of gall-inducer insects. Compared with larvae of Torymidae or Pteromalidae (
Nevertheless, larvae of Ormyridae resemble those of Eurytomidae in the relative length of body setae, with the thoracic setae relatively longer than those of the abdominal segments (
Based on unpublished results of combined morphological and molecular data, three primary clades defined the phylogenetic relationships of European species of Ormyrus, which were mostly congruent with host gall and plant data (
The presence or absence of a blister-like sculpture was one larval feature that was moderately congruent with this division. Although the terminal-instar larvae of the Ormyrus species that are parasitoids of herb gall wasps did not present the blister-like sculpture, the sculpturing was found in the species associated with oak gall wasps (Cynipini) and in O. cupreus, the species associated with eurytomid galls. However, O. wachtli and O. rufimanus were exceptions, although the blister-like sculpture was found on the thorax of O. rufimanus. For O. wachtli, the conspicuous blister-like sculpture is one of the distinctive diagnostic characters, in combination with a pair of supraclypeal setae, which is absent in the other species.
Identification of the larvae of Ormyrus species is usually relatively easy based on their host and plant specificity. Nevertheless, for polyphagous species, such as the complex of O. pomaceus and O. nitidulus associated with cynipid galls on Quercus and those species that share hosts, the identification is more difficult. In many cases, the relative size of the larvae of the two species is a useful diagnostic tool because the larvae of O. nitidulus always exceeded 3 millimetres in size and the blister-like sculpture was not as conspicuous as with O. pomaceus. The preference of O. nitidulus for occupying the central cell of the gall, as a primary parasitoid of their hosts, was another useful trait to separate these two species. By contrast, the larvae of O. pomaceus may parasitize inducer and lethal inquilines, both from the genus Synergus, which occupy secondary larval chambers inside the galls.
The morphological characters described in this work on the systematics of terminal-instar larvae of Ormyridae were constant across species within the genus Ormyrus. The differences among species were not marked, although some small differences in morphological traits allowed the separation of some species or groups of species. We consider the data presented in this study to be a preliminary contribution to increasing information on the immature stages of one of the less studied families of Chalcidoidea. Therefore, the study must be expanded to include larvae of species from other zoogeographical regions and larvae of those species with biological traits different from that of the European species, such as the species associated with fig wasps on Ficus in tropical areas.
Ormyridae are cosmopolitan inhabitants of different ecosystems worldwide, although the highest diversity is reported in Holarctic and Australasian regions, with only a few species cited from other zoogeographic regions such as Afrotropical and Neotropical, but these few species are likely a function of a lack of revisions of these faunas (
With reference to the diversity of the genus Ormyrus in the Palaearctic region, the 34 species recorded cover a wide range of insect host species, all of which are associated with different types of galls (
Of the ten European species examined in this study, eight species formed part of the parasitoid community associated with cynipid galls, and two were associated with gall tephritids and gall eurytomids. With reference to the species associated with gall wasps, as with the related Torymidae (
Some of the ormyrid species that we studied were dominant in the parasitoid communities associated with their host galls. For example, O. papaveris was the most abundant parasitoid species in galls on poppy heads induced by Aylax papaveris. Similarly, O. gratiosus (attacking Isocolus scabiosae) and O. diffinis and O. wachtli (attacking galls of Liposthenes kerneri on Nepeta and Neaylax ssp. on Salvia, respectively) are the most abundant parasitoid species in those gall parasitoid communities (
Ormyrus cupreus occupies a unique position within the parasitoid community of Eurytoma gallephedrae (
According to previous molecular and morphological phylogenetic analyses (
The “trigonaspis” group was composed of O. pomaceus “sensu lato” specimens that attacked small leaf galls induced by species of Trigonaspis, a genus which is circumscribed primarily on the Iberian Peninsula and is represented by at least three endemic species: Trigonaspis mendesi, T. brunneicornis and T. baeticus (
The “pomaceus” sensu stricto group was composed of the core individuals of O. pomaceus reared from the other cynipid-galls on several species of Quercus, with approximately 84 different cynipid host gall species recorded (
The larvae of O. pomaceussensu stricto were located in dissected galls of asexual generations of A. pictus (Fig.
The community of ormyrid parasitoids of cynipid galls is usually composed of solitary ectoparasitoids. Notably, in this work, we reported some cases of secondary phytophagy in several ormyrid species. For example, the larvae of O. papaveris were observed moving inside the gall cell and touching the walls with their mandibles, which was similar to the behaviour of O. rufimanus; as a result, the gall cells became larger and deformed. Larval phytophagy has been described for some species of Eurytomidae (
The external morphology of final instar ormyrid larvae has been documented and the potential use of the characters in the taxonomy and systematics of this poorly studied Chalcidoidea group explored. Our data will assist in the reliable identification of the species of this chalcidoid family during studies of cynipid gall communities and food webs in which the accurate identifications of species are of great importance. However, much further work is required, including investigations of a wider selection of ormyrid species and descriptions of the other immature stages, in addition to more detailed observations of their parasitic behaviour.
We thank both Dr Simon v. Noort and Dr Andrew Polaszek for helpful comments and suggestions on a previous version of this manuscript. We also thank our friend Dr R. R. Askew for helping in many ways, particularly by verifying the identifications of adult specimens. Laura Tormo provided technical assistance in the production of the SEM photographs. The Spanish Ministry of Education and Science research projects CGL2010-15786/BOS and MINECO/FEDER, UE) CGL2015-66571-P to JLNA provided financial support for this paper.
Characters of Ormyrus larvae used for systematic study
Data type: species data
Explanation note: Characters are listed by body region, for the body, head and under lip complex, which for the latter is subdivided between labrum, maxillae and mandibles.
Character states of Ormyrus larvae included in the systematic study
Data type: species data
Explanation note: Observed character states of characters listed in Appendix 1. Explanation of symbols: monomorphic states 0–3; not applicable (*); unknown (?). Characters are unordered.