Research Article |
Corresponding author: Tanner A. Matson ( tanner.matson@uconn.edu ) Academic editor: Axel Hausmann
© 2020 Tanner A. Matson, David L. Wagner.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Matson TA, Wagner DL (2020) A new Stamnodes from the southwestern United States (Lepidoptera, Geometridae, Larentiinae). ZooKeys 923: 79-90. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.923.48290
|
Stamnodes fergusoni sp. nov. occurs from extreme southeastern Arizona through southern New Mexico east into western Texas, USA. Identity of the new species can be reliably determined by external features, genitalic characters, and COI haplotypes. Larvae are believed to be specialists on Salvia pinguifolia and S. ballotiflora. The adult and larval stages and male and female genitalia are illustrated, available DNA barcode data that support the recognition of the new Stamnodes are reviewed, and its life history briefly characterized.
COI, DNA barcodes, Lamiaceae, Salvia, shrubby blue sage, Stamnodini
Stamnodes Guenée is one of the most handsome, species-rich, and taxonomically problematic genera of North American Geometridae. Several species remain undescribed and much disagreement surrounds the validity of many recognized species and their current synonymies. The description of Stamnodes fergusoni is long overdue; for nearly three decades this species has been known by moth collectors and photographers of west Texas as undescribed (
Here we describe Stamnodes fergusoni from southwestern Texas’s hill country, westward through New Mexico into extreme southeastern Arizona. The new taxon is believed to be a specialist on woody mints, feeding on Salvia pinguifolia (Lamiaceae) in New Mexico and Arizona and presumably on Salvia ballotiflora (Lamiaceae) over the core of its range in southwest Texas. We describe and illustrate the larval and adult stages of the new species, illustrate the male and female genitalia, give diagnostic differences that separate this taxon from two phenotypically similar North American congeners: Stamnodes fervefactaria (Grote, 1881) and Stamnodes deceptiva (Barnes and McDunnough, 1917), and provide a brief account of its biology and distribution.
Adults were obtained by light trapping with UV and mercury-vapor lights. Larvae were collected from Salvia pinguifolia (Lamiaceae) near Carrizozo, New Mexico and Warren, Arizona. The holotype was collected by Jim Vargo in Val Verde Co., TX. The adult description of S. fergusoni is based on 74 pinned specimens and 15 additional photographic records; the larval description is based on five larvae (DLW Lot: 2018J32, 2018J35, and 2018J133). 139 genitalic slides of Stamnodes were examined: 73 examined from the National Museum of Natural History (
Over the course of this study we examined the Nearctic Stamnodes holdings (including primary types) of the American Museum of Natural History (
Stamnodes fergusoni can be immediately separated from most Stamnodes by its orange ground color and pattern of lead-gray patches across the forewing and hindwing. North of Mexico, Stamnodes fergusoni may only be confused with Stamnodes deceptiva or Stamnodes fervefactaria, neither of these species occur in southwest Texas. Although superficially close (and sometimes confused in collections), S. fergusoni can be quickly distinguished from the other two species. Stamnodes fergusoni can be reliably determined by the bright, white reticulate pattern of the underside of the hindwing and costal area of the forewing (Fig.
Adult Stamnodes. 1 Stamnodes fergusoni [HOLOTYPE], TX: Val Verde Co., Ranch Road 189 (30.1823°, -100.06°), 19 September 2018, J. Vargo coll., a dorsal view, b ventral view; 2 Stamnodes fervefactaria, Colorado: El Paso Co., ssw of Colorado Springs Hwy. #115 at mkr. #30.2 Los Pinos housing entry [38.5797, -104.9308], 6480ft, 14 August 2004, Chuck Harp coll., BOLD Process ID: LNAUW1876-17, Museum ID:
Male genitalia (Fig.
Male genitalia. 7 Stamnodes fergusoni (USNM58902), a genital capsule, b aedeagus with everted vesica; 8 Stamnodes fervefactaria (USNM55242), a genital capsule, b aedeagus; 9 Stamnodes deceptiva (USNM58903), a genital capsule, b aedeagus with everted vesica. Scale bars: 0.85 mm (9a), 0.25 mm (9b).
Adult male.
Forewing length: 14–16mm (Fig.
Female.
Forewing length: 16–17mm (N = 9). Outwardly undifferentiated from male. Female genitalia (Fig.
(Figs
Integument roughened and transversely furrowed. Extensively peppered with minute melanized patches which are most visible over each lobe of head and posterior abdominal segments (especially in cleared preparations). Prothoracic spiracle subequal to those on A1-A6 (~0.12 mm high); spiracle on A7 and A8 (~0.16 mm high). Planta of A6 with 20 or 21 secondary setae below level of SV seta, bearing 25 or 26 crochets mostly of two alternating lengths.
Holotype male
, TX: Val Verde Co., Ranch Road 189 (30.1823°, -100.06°), Elev. 1676’, 19 September 2018, Jim Vargo coll. dry pinned (
Paratype adults. (52♂, 18♀): NM: Lincoln Co., Valley of Fires Recreation Area (33.67977°, -105.92708°), 11 August 2014, Black light trap, Leg. J. Luig & J. Metlevski, Voucher Codes: (363203, 363204), (2♂) (KSU-MEPAR); NM: Lincoln Co., Valley of Fires Recreation Area (33.681795°, -105.923486°), 4–5 September 2015, At light, Leg. J. Metlevski, Voucher Codes: (363197, 363198), (2♂) (KSU-MEPAR); NM: Lincoln Co., Valley of Fires Recreation Area (33.678049°, -105.927135°), 4 September 2015, Mercury vapor light, Leg. J. Metlevski, Voucher Codes: (363193–363196), (4♀) (KSU-MEPAR, TAMUIC); NM: Lincoln Co., Valley of Fires Recreation Area (33.678167°, -105.927492°), 4 September 2015, Black light trap, Leg. J. Metlevski, Voucher Codes: (363199–363202, 367370–367375), (9♂, 1♀) (TAMUIC,
Adults.
TX: (County Unknown), Langley [Langtry], 25 October 1945, (collector unknown), BOLD Process ID: LNAUV1794-17, Museum ID:
(Fig.
The species is named in honor of the late Douglas C. Ferguson, a reigning and much respected authority on the geometrid fauna of North America for more than four decades. Dr. Ferguson’s notes, dissections, and collections were valuable assets that guided this effort. Dr. Ferguson was in the process of describing this species before his passing (
The larvae are believed to be specialists on woody Salvia (Lamiaceae). Stamnodes fergusoni larvae were collected and reared to maturity on Salvia pinguifolia (rock sage) from Carrizozo Malpais, New Mexico (BOLD Process ID: WAGL1235-18, BOLD Sample ID: DLW-001425). A middle instar larva was collected from Salvia pinguifolia in Warren, Arizona (BOLD Process ID: WAGL1401-19, BOLD Sample ID: DLW-001401). In the Southwestern Hill Country of Texas, the species is believed to feed on Salvia ballotiflora (shrubby blue sage) as this is the only woody Salvia at the localities where this species has been taken.
The larvae of S. fergusoni were first discovered on Salvia pinguifolia plants growing at the bottom of large gas bubbles that formed during the deposition of the Carrizozo Malpais lava field, west of Carrizozo, New Mexico. When the top of a bubble erodes away, the remaining volcanic pit acts as a catch basin for rain and dust, and over time comes to support diverse gardens in an otherwise black ultraxeric landscape. Larvae were found on plants growing within these bubbles, especially where overhanging lava shelves shield plants from full sun. Smaller, water-stressed plants growing in full sun yielded no S. fergusoni larvae. The purple pigments in the caterpillar appear to be derived from the flowers of its host (Fig.
Stamnodes fergusoni has a single late-summer generation that appears to be tied to the flowering time of its preferred host. The moth is locally common in New Mexico and southwestern Hill Country of Texas with peak adult activity in September and October. Adults fly earlier (first weeks of September) in New Mexico. Several worn individuals were taken in March (2002) from the Guadalupe Mountains, by Roy Kendall.
In June of this year, while working at the
All larval collections are from Salvia pinguifolia, a plant that does not occur in southwestern Texas where Stamnodes fergusoni is locally common. The woody mint in this region is instead, Salvia ballotiflora (shrubby blue sage), which is seemingly the only candidate host for Stamnodes fergusoni. In conversations with DLW, Ed Knudson had mentioned that the moth was most commonly encountered in the Tamaulipan scrub associations of Val Verde County, Texas. DLW went to areas described by Knudson in November 2018, and found S. ballotiflora to be common through the county, although the third week of November was too late to find larvae and verify that shrubby blue sage is the primary host for this moth in south Texas.
We had access to barcode data for 457 Stamnodes and Stamnoctenis Warren specimens representing approximately 63 species-level taxa (bins), 378 of the 457 were used (failed sequences excluded). Surprisingly, barcode data placed S. fergusoni well outside of a sister relationship with S. fervefactaria and S. deceptiva, and offered no likely indication of its placement within Stamnodes. Uncorrected genetic divergence between the three taxa was greater than six percent for every relationship. Nuclear markers will be required to determine the placement of S. fergusoni within Stamnodes.
The most recent North American checklist of Lepidoptera (Ferguson, 1983), lists 34 valid species and numerous synonyms for Stamnodes. Much disagreement surrounds the validity of the currently recognized species and their synonymies. On-line identification sites (e.g., iNaturalist) and genetic databases (e.g., GenBank and Barcodes of Life) are riddled with misapplied names and generic-level (only) identifications. Institutional collections and published literature also reflect considerable taxonomic confusion. Our field collections of larvae for more than a twenty western Stamnodes and Stamnoctenis species, reveal considerable intraspecific variability in larval phenotypes, a matter further complicated by considerable host overlap across the genus. Such being the case, larvae and associated life history data will be of limited help in sorting out the species-level entities across the genus. Until a modern revisionary treatment employing nuclear markers, genitalic study, and larvae and their attendant life histories can be completed, databases, collections, and on-line resources treating North American Stamnodini will remain plagued with misidentifications and taxonomic uncertainty.
We would like to thank the National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution for their generous contribution of genetic data. In particular, Dr. Scott E. Miller collected much of the DNA barcode data used in this study. We would like to thank Kansas State University’s Museum of Entomological and Prairie Arthropod Research, specifically Jan Metlevski for collecting some of the type material, and Gregory Zolnerowich for arranging the loan of this material. Charlie Covell sent material from the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity, provided Ferguson’s unfinished manuscript, and much encouragement. David Wikle alerted us to the abundance of Stamnodes fergusoni at Carrizozo, New Mexico, and the likelihood that the hostplant, whatever it is, would be found at the bottom of the gas bubbles that had formed in the lava flow. Jim Vargo donated four type specimens including the holotype. Anne Hendrickson sent photographs, collected type material, and provided lodging for the authors. Dave and Tracy Barker also hosted the authors and sent photographs of adults from their home on the Devil’s River in Texas. Mimi Kamp led us to stands of Salvia pinguifolia in Warren, AZ that yielded a caterpillar of the new species. A special thank you to the late Ed Knudson and Charles Bordelon (Texas Lepidoptera Survey) for their donation of many specimens and willingness to share their knowledge of Texas Stamnodes both with us and others. Jaan Viidalepp, Charlie Covell, and Axel Hausmann provided helpful suggestions that improved earlier versions of this manuscript. DLW is supported by USFS Co-op Agreement 14-CA-11420004-138 and an award from the Richard P. Garmany Fund (Hartford Foundation). TAM was supported by the University of Connecticut’s Ecology and Evolutionary Biology Department’s EEB Student Award and the Smithsonian Institution’s Graduate Student Fellowship.
Stamnodes fergusoni collection records
Data type: species data