Research Article
Print
Research Article
Natural history collections as a basis for sound biodiversity assessments: Plexauridae (Octocorallia, Holaxonia) of the Naturalis CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions
expand article infoÍris Sampaio§|, Marina Carreiro-Silva§, André Freiwald|, Gui Menezes§, Manfred Grasshoff
‡ Marine and Environmental Sciences Centre of the Institute of Marine Research, Horta, Portugal
§ University of the Azores, Horta, Portugal
| Senckenberg am Meer, Abteilung Meeresforschung, Wilhelmshaven, Germany
¶ Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut, Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Open Access

Abstract

Mapping biodiversity is the marathon of the 21st Century as an answer to the present extinction crisis. A century in which science is also characterised by large scientific datasets collected through new technologies aiming to fill gaps in our knowledge of species distributions. However, most species records rely on observations that are not linked to specimens, which does not allow verification of species hypotheses by other scientists. Natural history museums form a verifiable source of biodiversity records which were made by taxonomists. Nonetheless, these museums seem to be forgotten by biologists in scientific fields other than taxonomy or systematics. Naturalis Biodiversity Center (NBC) in Leiden is care keeper of large collections of marine organisms, which were sampled in the Northeast Atlantic during the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions (1976–1988). Many octocorals were sampled and deposited in the NBC collection, where they became available for study and were partially identified by the senior author (M.G.) in the 1980s. Nonetheless, no checklist or taxonomic revision was published so far with the complete results. In 2016 the first author visited NBC to examine NE Atlantic Plexauridae octocorals. Plexauridae octocoral-vouchered records were listed and mapped to reveal high standard primary biodiversity records unreported so far for the NE Atlantic Ocean. Twenty-four Plexauridae species with ~ six putative new species to science were discovered and eleven new biogeographical records were made from distinct Macaronesian archipelagos. Finally, new depth range records were found for three species at sea basin level and for eight species at a regional scale.

Keywords

Alcyonacea, CANCAP project, deep water, geographical distribution, Tyro Mauritania II, zoological collections

Introduction

The rate of biodiversity loss is accelerating, leading to a tendency for “Big Data” production on species observation-based occurrences instead of specimen-based occurrences as a way to map and protect biodiversity (Troudet et al. 2018). While unvouchered observations may lead to the rapid production of large datasets, specimen-based records are essential for species descriptions and for the scientific repetition principle (Cotterill 1997; Rocha et al. 2014; Troudet et al. 2018). A specimen should be available for further verification or reinterpretation, a fundamental principle of science, because properly labelled specimens are biodiversity raw data based on a researcher interpretation, from which metadata is derived (e.g., their occurrence information) (Hoeksema et al. 2012; Schilthuizen et al. 2015; Troudet et al. 2018). Moreover, vouchered records not only increase precision but are also more complete by providing ancillary data a posteriori, such as geographical positions, images or DNA sequences, which are useful for richer present and future analyses (Hoeksema 2015; Troudet et al. 2018).

Natural history museum collections (NHMC) are rich repositories representing a variety of all known life forms (Kemp 2015; Funk 2018). During 300 years of biodiversity exploration, many organisms were collected, catalogued, identified and stored under a systematic order. The name-bearing specimens deposited there are an important source of ancillary data over a long time span (Suarez and Tsutsui 2004).

The Earth’s estimated biodiversity is in the order of 10 million species, from which only 10–20% are currently known to science, while the rest still lacks a name, a description and basic knowledge on its biology (Krishtalka and Humphrey 2000; Wilson 2003; Costello et al. 2015). This lack of information on extant species is consequently reflected in an absence of understanding on which species are threatened with extinction or introduced in new environments and what is their distribution (Wilson 2003; Frey 2009; Kemp 2015). Subsequently, there is a lack of fundamental knowledge to understand the biology of species and the human-induced changes in their environment. Regarding the known biodiversity, collections-based science recognizes the value of NHMC as a source of biodiversity data in various disciplines of research (Krishtalka and Humphrey 2000; Graham et al. 2004; Costello et al. 2013; Funk 2018). NHMC species and their distribution datasets from the past, can be used to compare with present-day datasets and understand the species conservation status, prioritize and plan future studies and species management plans (Graham et al. 2004, Lister and Climate Change Research Group 2011, Funk 2018).

NHMC from remote localities or environments that are otherwise difficult to access have additional value. For example, biodiversity data collection faces higher technical challenges at distant habitats such as the deep sea, which is the Earth’s largest ecosystem. Therefore, deep sea data gathering is reflected in a few pieces of a puzzled map of discoveries. Tentative exploration of the deep sea is thought to have begun in 1521 with Fernão de Magalhães attempting to sound the Pacific Ocean between two coral islands (Murray and Hjort 1912). Yet, despite recent technological developments, it is still difficult to sample this inaccessible environment due to strong currents, rough bottoms and high costs. Therefore, the deep sea is the least surveyed marine environment although having eminent species richness (Hernández-Ávila et al. 2018).

During modern deep-sea surveys, the systematic collection of benthic marine invertebrates to characterise local fauna is usually secondary, with priority being given to long-distance transects by use of deep-sea imaging technology for species occurrence data and habitat mapping. Despite a paucity in biodiversity data, benthic marine invertebrate samples tend only to be collected as by-catch after which they are only identified at high taxonomical levels or misidentified due to the absence of taxonomists onboard (Renaud et al. 2015). At the same time, new species await an average of 21 years on shelves of NHMC for the unique eye of a trained taxonomist to be described (Fontaine et al. 2012; Costello et al. 2015, Kemp 2015). Historical benthic diversity datasets gathered at NHMC, have proven to be accurate sources of baseline data on species diversity and distribution across the Atlantic Ocean for marine benthos of the Canadian Arctic and for deep-sea reef building scleractinian coral species off the southeastern United States (Ross et al. 2012; Roy and Gagnon 2016). Based on these museum records, distribution of corals and other benthic species was confirmed and new areas for exploration were suggested (Ross et al. 2012, Roy and Gagnon 2016). However, even considering the widespread use of NHMC data, there is still much work to do in order to educate scientists about specimen importance, underutilised collections and the value of NHMC as a way to improve museum collections, support taxonomy and, most of all, the quality and reproducibility of biodiversity knowledge (Costello et al. 2013; Ward et al. 2015).

Naturalis Biodiversity Center (NBC), the national museum of natural history of the Netherlands, preserves marine benthos collected during eight explorative Dutch expeditions to the subtropical and tropical parts of the Eastern North Atlantic islands and seamounts (Figure 1). The CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions took place from the Azores to Cape Verde from 1976 to 1988 on board HNLMS Onversaagd and HNLMS Tydeman, passing through all the Macaronesian archipelagos down to the west coast of Africa in Mauritania and Senegal, while sampling from the surface to 4000 m depth (Den Hartog 1984; Van der Land 1987, 1988). After the expeditions of Prince Albert I of Monaco (Thomson 1927), the CANCAP (CANarian – CAPe Verdean Deep-Sea Basin) project was the most representative set of campaigns taking place in the southern NE Atlantic Ocean with the aim of building a representative inventory and collection of organisms from 1260 sampling stations in poorly explored or unexplored regions (Den Hartog 1984). Numerous studies were published on marine benthos collected during these expeditions (see for instance Van Soest 1988; Fransen 1991; Ansín-Agís et al. 2001; Van der Linden 1998; Dijkstra and Goud 2002; Vervoort 2006), including some on octocorals: Spinimuricea atlantica (Johnson, 1862) from Madeira (Grasshoff 1992), the genus Alcyonium Linnaeus, 1758 (Stokvis and Ofwegen 2006; Sampaio et al. 2016) and some Alcyonacea of the Azores (Braga-Henriques et al. 2013). Yet, several octocorals deposited at NBC have since remained unstudied for 40 years.

Figure 1. 

The National Museum of Natural History of The Netherlands. Naturalis Biodiversity Center in 2016 (a), Marine Invertebrate Collection (b), part of the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II consulted collection (c, d).

Global octocoral taxonomy has been in the hand of fewer than ten scientists during the 20th Century in the time of the taxonomic impediment (see Coleman 2015). This concept is based on decreased investment in taxonomy, NHMC, qualification of scientists in taxonomy and replacement or recruitment of curators and taxonomists that is associated to limited knowledge on biodiversity (Taylor 1976). With most experts currently retired, taxonomic work on octocorals is now a part-time job or hobby for some of them. The number of experts has since decreased and the interest of the new generations for this discipline is reduced or not supported. Currently, there is no curator for Octocorallia in any of the most important natural history museums of Europe. Dr. Leen P. van Ofwegen, curator of Octocorals at NBC (Leiden), was the last when he retired in 2017.

Most recent octocoral taxonomic studies in the Atlantic Ocean have focused on the northwestern Atlantic, with the northeast Atlantic receiving less attention. Within Octocorallia, the family Plexauridae Gray, 1859 is characterised by mostly arborescent colonies, branches appearing laterally, dichotomously or pinnately. Plexauridae polyps are retractile or have calyces where the anthocodiae is withdrawn and their axis has a large, hollow and cross-chambered central core encircled by gorgonin and horny loculated spaces with non-sclerite calcareous matter (Bayer 1956). Plexauridae is one of the most diverse and abundant families of octocorals, with 47 valid genera (Cordeiro et al. 2019) and several of its species known to form coral gardens (Grasshoff 1977). However, it is not the main study object of any of the current leading experts on Octocorallia taxonomy.

At the NE Atlantic Ocean, a Plexauridae species was described by Johnson (1861) for Madeira. Later, the scientific campaigns of Prince Albert I of Monaco resulted in two volumes including new plexaurid species of this area (Studer 1901; Thomson 1927), which were later revised by Carpine and Grasshoff (1985). Thomson (1929) also described some species and the French expedition Biaçores resulted in several records of Plexauridae from the Azores (Tixier-Durivault and D’Hondt 1974). In the 1970s, more species were found at the Mediterranean Sea (Carpine and Grasshoff 1975). Moreover, the last taxonomic revision of this family (still under the name Paramuriceidae Bayer, 1956) was published at the end of the decade (Grasshoff 1977). Twenty-three species in eight genera, occurring from the coast of Ireland to the Gulf of Guinea including the Macaronesian archipelagos, nearby seamounts, and the Mediterranean Sea, were accepted (Grasshoff 1977). Since this revision, little has been added in terms of biodiversity, with only one new species described, Thesea talismani Grasshoff 1986 (see Grasshoff 1986). Another species is also considered for Europe by the European Register of Marine Species (ERMS) (Costello et al. 2001) but this species is Swiftia pallida, which is a synonym of S. dubia (Grasshoff 1986). So far in the southern part of the NE Atlantic Ocean, 17 of the 23 valid NE Atlantic and Mediterranean Sea plexaurid species have been recorded (Grasshoff 1977; Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1986).

Plexauridae specimens collected during the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions deposited at the NBC were identified by the last author (Table 1; Figure 2). However, his work was never published, with the exception of some records (Grasshoff 1992). With the aim of documenting this valuable source of unpublished information, the Plexauridae specimens collected during these expeditions were examined by the first author: 1) to make available a list of plexaurid octocorals collected during CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions; 2) to use Plexauridae records to produce maps of their geographic and depth ranges in the NE Atlantic Ocean to inform future research, field surveys and management plans; and 3) to demonstrate the value of museum records as a source of high quality biodiversity information.

Figure 2. 

CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II Plexauridae collection: a label of a catalogued record of Thesea talismani in Mauritania b label of previously unidentified and uncatalogued record from the Azores archipelago c different colonies of a new species from a coral garden filmed in situ in 2016 but stored in NBC since 1988 d cf. Placogorgia sp. I (RMNH. COEL. 42336) found mixed with specimens of the primnoid Callogorgia verticillata (Pallas, 1766) e the putative new record of Paramuricea macrospina in the NE Atlantic Ocean f detail of a new record for the Azores archipelago, Paramuricea biscaya (RMNH. COEL. 423339). Scale bars: 1 cm.

Table 1.

Plexauridae collected during CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions. Geographical and bathymetrical distribution on the southern NE Atlantic archipelagos and at Mauritania including the previous data available (references) and new records (remarks). Bold script indicates new regional records.

Species Depth Range (m) Azores (m) Madeira (m) Selvagens Islands (m) Canary Islands (m) Cape Verde (m) Mauritania (m) Remarks References
Bebryce mollis Philippi, 1842 71–1250 105–1250 95–330 875–900 New lower depth limit in Canary Islands (330 m). Studer 1901; Thomson 1927; Aurivillius 1931; Stiasny 1939, 1940; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977, 1985a, 1989, 1992; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Brito and Ocaña 2004
Muriceides lepida Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975 79–1350 500–550 300–400 180–330 1000–1350 New lower depth limit for the species (1350m). Specified regional depth ranges. Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1985
Muriceides paucituberculata (Marion, 1882) 51–2165 454–1350 1968 x 515 51 New at Cape Verde. New lower depth limit at Azores (1350m). Studer 1901; Thomson 1927; Thomson 1929; Pax and Müller 1954; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1982b, 1986, 1989; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Brito and Ocaña 2004
Paramuricea biscaya Grasshoff, 1977 1094–4152 1650–2050 2100–2500 1200–1500 Specified regional depth range at the Azores and Selvagens Islands. Grasshoff 1982a; Brito and Ocaña 2004; Molodtsova et al. 2008
Paramuricea candida Grasshoff, 1977 1069–1350 1069–1350 New lower depth limit for the species and at the Azores (1350m). Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, Mironov and Krylova 2006
Paramuricea grayi (Johnson, 1861) 20–2195 125–2195 40–600 225–1311 40–51 Johnson 1861; Thomson 1929; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Grasshoff 1977, 1982a, 1986, 1989, 1992; Altuna 1991; Brito and Ocaña 2004
Paramuricea aff. macrospina (Koch, 1882) 224–350 224–350
cf. Paramuricea sp. I 200 200
cf. Paramuricea sp. II 280–330 280–330
Placogorgia coronata Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975 50–2200 x 990–1000 550–1800 51 New lower and higher depth limit at the Canary Islands. Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1985b, 1986, 1989; Brito and Ocaña 2004
Placogorgia cf. graciosa (Tixier Durivault & d’Hondt, 1974) 1100–1300 1100–1300
Placogorgia aff. graciosa (Tixier Durivault & d’Hondt, 1974) 1200 1200 -
Placogorgia intermedia (Thomson, 1927) 800–1350 800–1350 New lower depth limit for the species and at the Azores (1350m). Pax and Müller 1954; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, 1982a, 1985b; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Mironov and Krylova 2006
Placogorgia terceira Grasshoff, 1977 170–2200 599 200 1311 Specified regional depth at the Canary Islands. Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1985a, 1985b, 1992
Placogorgia aff. terceira Grasshoff, 1977 200–1350 200 214–1350
Placogorgia sp. I 590–602 590–602
cf. Placogorgia sp. II 1200 1200
Spinimuricea atlantica (Johnson, 1862) 20–875 80–84 145 875 Johnson 1862; Thomson 1927; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, 1992; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Brito and Ocaña 2004; Ocaña et al. 2017
Swiftia sp. 500 500
Swiftia cf. dubia (Thomson, 1929) 1320–1350 1320–1350
Swiftia aff. dubia (Thomson, 1929) 85 85
Thesea talismani Grasshoff, 1986 462–1090 462–1090 Grasshoff 1986, 1989; Matos-Pita et al 2016; Ramos et al. 2017
Thesea sp. 200 200
Villogorgia bebrycoides (Koch, 1887) 56–845 105–845 x 63–400 Thomson 1927; Stiasny 1940; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, 1985a, 1992; Carpine and Grasshoff 1985; Brito and Ocaña 2004

Materials and methods

The CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions from 1976 until 1988 onboard HNLMS Onversaagd, HNLMS Tydeman and RV Tyro operated in the area at 14°31'–39°41'N and 08°43'–39°41'W. These expeditions used a great variety of gear like trawls, dredges and van Veen grabs for the collection of biological samples, which were subsequently deposited at the NBC (Den Hartog 1984; Figures 1, 2). The electronic database of the NBC, Bioportal, was consulted for records of the Octocorallia collection resulting from these expeditions. A visit of two weeks (17–30 April 2016) allowed the first author to locate, photograph and subsample the Plexauridae gorgonians collected during the above-mentioned campaigns.

The provenance data associated with the specimens was written on original museum specimen labels, which included more information than presented in the previously published station lists (Van der Land 1987, 1988). Information on these specimen labels, which was partially unavailable at NBC’s online catalogue (https://bioportal.naturalis.nl/), was consulted to build a reference database containing 15 data fields per museum sample (Table 2).

Table 2.

Database structure with metadata fields from museum labels of Plexauridae collected during CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions in the NE Atlantic Ocean.

Metadata Description
Museum Number Museum catalogue number
Taxa Species name
Identifier Name of expert who identified the specimen
Expedition name Scientific campaign in which the gorgonian was sampled
Expedition code Scientific campaign code in which the gorgonian was sampled
Station Station from where the gorgonian was sampled
Location Location from where the gorgonian was sampled
Latitude Latitude of sampling station where the gorgonian was sampled
Longitude Longitude of sampling station where the gorgonian was sampled
Depth Depth where the gorgonian was sampled
Substrate type Bottom type at the location from where the gorgonian was sampled
Sampling method Gear with which the gorgonian was sampled
Sampling date Date in which the gorgonian was sampled
N specimens Number of specimens covered by the catalogue number
Other notes Other details about the specimen or sampling

Museum scientists and technicians were consulted to clarify questions regarding the metadata or to add additional information like catalogue numbers to uncatalogued specimens. Species names and taxonomy were cross-checked using World Register of Marine Species (WoRMS) Cordeiro et al. (2019) in addition to Grasshoff (1977) and Sampaio et al. (2019) to include only valid scientific names. Unidentified specimens were identified based on the revision of the family Plexauridae (Grasshoff 1977), the original descriptions of each species of Plexauridae known to occur in the NE Atlantic Ocean, and reference material from various museums.

Specimens records were organised and plotted in ArcGIS 10.6 to visualise the geographical distribution and a depth plot was prepared to visualise the vertical distribution of the gorgonians. This data was compared with previous zoogeographical and bathymetrical distribution knowledge on Plexauridae species of the NE Atlantic (e.g., Studer 1901; Thomson 1927; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Carpine and Grasshoff 1975, 1985; Grasshoff 1977, 1986, 1989; Brito and Ocaña 2004). New species records were analysed by region as well as new geographical and vertical distribution records.

Results

Biodiversity of Plexauridae from CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II

Approximately 24 species of Plexauridae were found after studying 86 colonies, 27 fragments of gorgonians and ~24 colonies or colony fragments of gorgonians, which were sampled during the cruises of CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II at the southern NE Atlantic Ocean (Tables 1, 3). The specimens were identified by the last author (M.G.) (13 species), by Dr. L.P. van Ofwegen (one species) and the first author (15 species) after the discovery of uncatalogued and unidentified specimens that were partly separated from or mixed with the catalogued species (Figures 2, 3; Table 3). Moreover, seven species were identified by two specialists (I.S. and M.G. or I.S. and L.P. van O.) (Tables 1, 3). Of the 24 plexaurid species, six lack certainty in their identification (listed as cf. or aff.) and six seem to represent species new to science (listed as sp., sp. I, and sp. II) (Tables 1, 3). The taxonomic description of these species will be presented in future works. The study produced 49 additional records of Plexauridae species that are mostly not encountered elsewhere in the NE Atlantic Ocean (Figures 25; Table 3).

Figure 3. 

Map of Plexauridae collected during CANCAP and Tyro II Mauritania cruises except uncertain Cape Verdean records (see Figure 4).

Table 3.

Museum records of Plexauridae octocorals collected during CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions in the NE Atlantic Ocean. N corresponds to number of colonies and/or fragments. Other sampling details can be found on the list of stations published by Van der Land (1987, 1988). Bold: denotes taxonomically accurate new records, *: species identification without taxonomic accuracy and #: putative new species.

Species Collection number N Identifier Scientific campaign Station Location Gear Subtrate type
Bebryce mollis Philippi, 1842 RMNH.COEL. 24337 11 fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.004, 28°03'N, 14°29'W, 180–330 m Canary Islands, S of Fuerteventura, Punta de Jandia rectangular dredge epifauna of mixed bottom
RMNH.COEL. 24338 6 specimens/fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.014, 28°03'N, 14°29'W, 200 m Canary Islands, S of Fuerteventura, Punta de Jandia rectangular dredge many sponges, other epizoa
RMNH.COEL. 24339 3 fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.010, 37°41'N, 25°31'W, 150 m Azores, S of São Miguel van Veen grab coarse sand, gravel, calcareous stones
RMNH.COEL. 24340 4 specimens/fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.153, 39°26'N, 31°06'W, 150–168 m Azores, E of Flores rectangular dredge chama bed with fossil shells
RMNH.COEL. 24341 7 specimens/fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.166, 39°30'N, 31°06'W, 150 m Azores, NE of Flores rectangular dredge shells
RMNH.COEL. 42337 1specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.096, 29°08'N, 13°25'W, 125 m Canary Islands, E of Lanzarote rectangular dredge
Muriceides lepida Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975 RMNH.COEL. 24357 3 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Onversaagd Madeira-Marokko – CANCAP I 1.104, 32°37'N, 16°49'W, 400 m S of Madeira triangular and rectangular dredge
RMNH.COEL. 24358 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.004, 28°03'N, 14°29'W, 180–330 m Canary Islands, S of Fuerteventura, Punta de Jandia rectangular dredge epifauna of mixed bottom
RMNH.COEL. 24359 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Madeira-Mauritania – CANCAP III 3.054, 32°43'N, 16°44'W, 300–320m SE Madeira rectangular dredge
RMNH.COEL. 24360 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.187,
39°27'N, 31°05'W, 500–550 m
Azores, E of Flores rectangular dredge fossil corals
RMNH.COEL. 24361 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VI 6.096, 16°36'N, 24°39'W, 1000–1350 m Cape Verde Islands, SW of Razo rectangular dredge rocky bottom with epifauna
Muriceides paucituberculata (Marion, 1882) RMNH.COEL. 24356 3 specimens, 1 fragment Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.090, 38°09'N, 28°31'W, 1320–1350 m Azores, S of Pico 1.2 m Agassiz trawl hard bottom with fossil corals
RMNH.COEL. 24376 7 fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.026, 14°52'N, 23°33'W, 515 m Cape Verde Islands, S of Santiago 1.2 m Agassiz trawl
Paramuricea biscaya Grasshoff, 1977 RMNH.COEL. 24342 3 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.107, 30°03'N, 15°52'W, 2100–2500 m Selvagens archipelago 2.4 m Agassiz trawl
RMNH.COEL.42339 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.005, 37°55'N, 24°46'W, 1650–2050 m Azores, NE of São Miguel 2.4 m Agassiz trawl deep sea clay with pumice and clinkers
Paramuricea candida Grasshoff, 1977 RMNH.COEL. 24343 3 specimens, a few fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.090, 38°09'N, 28°31'W, 1320–1350 m Azores, S of Pico 1.2 m Agassiz trawl hard bottom with fossil corals
Paramuricea grayi (Johnson, 1861) RMNH.COEL. 17911 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.047, 28°11'N, 14°02'W, 100–125 m Canary Islands, SE of Fuerteventura, Punta de Gran Tarajal 1.2 m Agassiz trawl mixed bottom
RMNH.COEL.17912 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Onversaagd Madeira-Marokko – CANCAP I 1.094, 32°39'N, 16°49'W, 125–150 m S of Madeira triangular dredge mainly shells and shell agglomerates
Paramuricea aff. macrospina (Koch, 1882) * RMNH.COEL. 24344 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.172, 16°53'N, 25°07'W, 300–350 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Vicente, canal of São Vicente rectangular dredge small catch
RMNH.COEL. 24345 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.113, 16°42'N, 23°01'W, 224–248 m Cape Verde Islands, W of Sal, off Palmeira 1.2 m Agassiz trawl calcareous nodules
cf. Paramuricea sp. I # RMNH.COEL. 42372 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.171, 16°54'N, 25°06'W, 200 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Vicente, canal of São Vicente rectangular dredge no sediment, only epizoa
cf. Paramuricea sp. II # RMNH.COEL. 42344 2 specimens, 3 fragments Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.179, 16°58'N, 25°03'W, 280–330 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Vicente, canal of São Vicente 3.5m Agassiz trawl sponges and soft corals
Placogorgia coronata Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975 RMNH.COEL. 24347 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.131, 27°40'N, 18°10'W, 1200–1800 m Canary Islands, SW of Hierro, off Punta de Orchilla 1.2 m Agassiz trawl
RMNH.COEL. 24348 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.162, 27°35'N, 17°59'W, 550–800 m Canary Islands, S of Hierro, off Punta de la Restinga rectangular dredge volcanic rocks
Placogorgia cf. graciosa (Tixier Durivault & d’Hondt, 1974) * RMNH.COEL. 42341 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VI 6.049, 14°52'N, 24°32”W, 1100–1300 m Cape Verde Islands, SW of Fogo Agassiz trawl basaltic rocks and sandy clay
Placogorgia aff. graciosa (Tixier Durivault & d’Hondt, 1974) * RMNH.COEL. 42342 3 specimens/fragments Íris Sampaio 2018 (unknown identifier of the genus level) Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.140, 16°35'N, 24°36'W, 1200 m Cape Verde Islands, S of Razo rectangular dredge old lobster spot with about 500m nylon rope, with numerous epizoa
Placogorgia intermedia (Thomson, 1927) RMNH.COEL. 24349 1 specimen, 2 fragments Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.090, 38°09'N, 28°31'W, 1320–1350 m Azores, S of Pico 1.2 m Agassiz trawl hard bottom with fossil corals
Placogorgia terceira Grasshoff, 1977 RMNH.COEL. 42369 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.153, 28°38'N, 17°59'W, 200 m Canary Islands, SW of Palma 1.2m Agassiz trawl
Placogorgia aff. terceira Grasshoff, 1977 * RMNH.COEL. 42370 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.153, 28°38'N, 17°59'W, 200 m Canary Islands, SW of Palma 1.2 m Agassiz trawl
RMNH.COEL. 24350 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VI 6.096, 16°36'N, 24°39'W, 1000–1350 m Cape Verde Islands, SW of Razo rectangular dredge rocky bottom with epifauna
RMNH.COEL. 24351 5 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VI 6.021, 15°01'N, 23°44'W, 600–400 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Tiago rectangular dredge mud and basalt rocks
RMNH.COEL. 24352 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.041, 14°57'N, 24°38'W, 580 m Cape Verde Islands, E of Cima 1.2 m Agassiz trawl gorgonians and sponges
RMNH.COEL. 24353 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.052, 15°06'N, 23°15'W, 594 m Cape Verde Islands, SW of Maio van Veen grab practically no sediment
RMNH.COEL. 24354 1 specimen Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.136, 16°33'N, 24°17'W, 214 m Cape Verde Islands, SE of São Nicolau, off Preguiça rectangular dredge calcareous nodules/algae
RMNH.COEL. 24355 2 specimens Manfred Grasshoff 1989 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.174, 16°45'N, 25°07'W, 1070- 1130 m Cape Verde Islands, SW of São Vicente 1.2 m Agassiz trawl basaltic gravel with echinoderms
RMNH.COEL. 42345 RMNH.COEL. 42371 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.179, 16°58'N, 25°03'W, 280–330 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Vicente, canal of São Vicente 3.5 m Agassiz trawl sponges and soft corals
Placogorgia sp. I # RMNH.COEL. 42336 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.131, 16°32'N, 24°16'W, 590- 602 m Cape Verde Islands, SE of São Nicolau 1.2 m Agassiz trawl muddy bottom with gorgonids and sponges
cf. Placogorgia sp. II # RMNH.COEL. 42371 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 (unknown identifier of the genus level) Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.140, 16°35'N, 24°36'W, 1200 m Cape Verde Islands, S of Razo rectangular dredge old lobster spot with about 500m nylon rope, with numerous epizoa
Spinimuricea atlantica (Johnson, 1862) RMNH.COEL. 17910 Specimen not located Onversaagd Madeira-Marokko – CANCAP I 1.092, 32°39'N, 16°50'W, 80–84 m S of Madeira rectangular dredge corals (mainly dead) and shells
Swiftia sp. # RMNH.COEL. 42327 RMNH.COEL. 42328 RMNH.COEL. 42329 11 specimens Genus level: Manfred Grasshoff. Íris Sampaio is describing the new species. Tyro Mauritania II MAU 040, 18°51'N, 16°53'W, 500 m off Mauritania 3.5 m Agassiz trawl fossil coral debris, macrourids
Swiftia cf. dubia (Thomson, 1929)* RMNH.COEL. 42340 3 specimens Genus level: Manfred Grasshoff 1989; Species level: Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.090, 38°09'N, 28°31'W, 1320–1350 m Azores, S of Pico 1.2 m Agassiz trawl hard bottom with fossil corals
Swiftia aff. dubia (Thomson, 1929)* RMNH.COEL. 42374 1 specimen Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Madeira-Mauritania – CANCAP III 3.158, 19°22'N, 16°51'W, 85 m off Mauritania 2.4 m Agassiz trawl hard bottom, sponges, brown algae
Thesea talismani Grasshoff, 1986 RMNH.COEL. 24371 1 specimen L.P. van Ofwegen Tyro Mauritania II MAU 041, 18°51'N, 16°56'W, 800–840 m off Mauritania 3.5 m Agassiz trawl muddy bottom, tubeworms, asteroids, red shrimp
RMNH.COEL. 24372 3 specimens L.P. van Ofwegen Tyro Mauritania II MAU 134, 20°44'N, 17°48'W; depth 530–700 m Mauritania, off Cap Blanc 3.5 m Agassiz trawl mainly fish (macrourids, thrachichthyids, Lophius), shrimp, asteroids, tube worms
RMNH.COEL. 42373 2 specimens Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Canary Islands – CANCAP II 2.058, 27°58'N, 13°24'W, 500 m Morocco, W of Cape Yubi 5 m beam trawl muddy bottom
Thesea sp. # RMNH.COEL. 42343 4 specimens/fragments Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VII 7.171, 16°54'N, 25°06'W, 200 m Cape Verde Islands, W of São Vicente, canal of São Vicente rectangular dredge no sediment, only epizoa
Villogorgia bebrycoides (Koch, 1887) RMNH.COEL. 24370 3 specimens Manfred Grasshoff Tydeman Azores – CANCAP V 5.153, 39°26'N, 31°06'W, 150–168 m Azores, E of Flores rectangular dredge chama bed with fossil shells
RMNH.COEL. 42338 3 specimens Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.153, 28°38'N, 17°59'W, 200 m Canary Islands, SW of Palma 1.2 m Agassiz trawl
RMNH.COEL. 42346 7 specimens Íris Sampaio 2018 Tydeman Selvagens-Canary Islands – CANCAP IV 4.143, 28°38'N, 17°58'W, 110–86 m Canary Islands, SW of Palma rectangular dredge muddy bottom with oysters

Biogeography of Plexauridae from CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II

Geographical coordinates associated with the specimens were plotted in a map of the NE Atlantic Ocean. Specimens were from all Macaronesian archipelagos, as well as from off the Mauritanian coast (Table 1; Figure 3). The Cape Verde archipelago has appeared as the region with the highest species richness (11 species in four genera) followed by the Azores archipelago where eight species of six genera were recorded, the Canary Islands (seven species in five genera), the Madeira islands (three species in three genera) and Mauritania (three species in two genera), and lastly the Selvagens Islands and Morocco (one species each) (Figures 3, 4; Table 3). The generic diversity of Plexauridae is higher in the Azores than in other NE Atlantic regions. Moreover, species identified in the Azores have a more accurate identification, especially if compared with the Cape Verde plexaurid fauna, where 11 species represent four genera but, near half of them are putative new species to science (Figures 3, 4; Table 3). The uncertainty associated with the identification of another four species from the Cape Verde islands, namely Paramuricea aff. macrospina, Placogorgia cf. graciosa, Placogorgia aff. graciosa, Placogorgia aff. terceira, may also represent new fauna (Figure 4; Tables 1, 3).

Figure 4. 

Map of Plexauridae collected during Tydeman Cape Verde Islands – CANCAP VI and VII cruises.

Specimens ancillary data has also revealed new species records. Some plexaurids are known to occur in most of the NE Atlantic basin; however, within it, the CANCAP records have widened their distribution ranges on a regional scale. Here we report Muriceides lepida Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975 in Madeira, Canary and Cape Verde archipelagos (Figures 3, 4; Table 1, 3) for the first time. In the Cape Verde archipelago, Muriceides paucituberculata (Marion, 1882), Paramuricea aff. macrospina (Koch, 1882), Placogorgia aff. graciosa (Tixier-Durivault and d’ Hondt, 1974), Placogorgia cf. graciosa (Tixier-Durivault and d’Hondt, 1974), and Placogorgia aff. terceira Grasshoff, 1977 are newly reported (Figures 3, 4; Tables 1, 3). Placogorgia aff. terceira was also found at the Canary Islands along with P. terceira (Figure 3; Tables 1, 3). Finally, Paramuricea biscaya Grasshoff, 1977 has its geographic distribution extended to the Selvagens Islands and the Azores (Figure 3; Tables 1, 3).

Bathymetric distribution update of Plexauridae

In terms of bathymetric distribution, the depth range of various plexaurids is now also upgraded. Overall, most species were collected from their known bathymetrical range during CANCAP (Table 1). However, three species have increased their depth range in the NE Atlantic Ocean: Muriceides lepida Carpine & Grasshoff, 1975, Paramuricea candida Grasshoff, 1977 and Placogorgia intermedia (Thomson, 1927) (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). Muriceides lepida, previously reported to live at 79–718 m depth (Carpine and Grasshoff 1975) is now reported at its deeper record from 1000–1350 m depth at the Cape Verde archipelago (Tables 1, 3; Figures 4, 5). Paramuricea candida Grasshoff, 1977 known to inhabit the range of 1069–1235 m depth (Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977) is now known to live down to 1350 m depth (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). The same new high depth record of 1350 m depth is herein reported for P. intermedia, previously known to occur between 800–1235 m depth (Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977) (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). Also, if Paramuricea aff. macrospina is in fact P. macrospina, this species widens its geographical distribution as it expands its greater depth limit to 350 m in the NE Atlantic Ocean (Cape Verde islands) (Tables 1, 3; Figures 4, 5). So far it is only known to occur at the Mediterranean, where it lives at 38–200 m depth (Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977).

Figure 5. 

Bathymetric distribution of Plexauridae identified to species at different sampling stations of CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II cruises on the NE Atlantic Ocean. Symbols represent precise records while bars represent distribution ranges. Colours represent distinct regions: Azores (blue), Madeira (yellow), Selvagens (white), Canary Islands (orange), Cape Verde (green) and Mauritania (rose).

While the overall depth range has increased for three species, the vertical distribution range has increased or has been specified at a regional level in eight of the species identified with certainty. The exceptions are Villogorgia bebrycoides (Koch, 1887), Paramuricea grayi (Johnson, 1861), Spinimuricea atlantica (Johnson, 1862) and Thesea talismani Grasshoff, 1986 (Table 1). Considering the available data and the new records (Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1985a), we now know M. lepida’s specific depth ranges at the Azores, Madeira, Canary and Cape Verde archipelagos (Tables 1, 3; Figures 3, 5). In the Azorean archipelago, three species have increased their greater depth limit to 1350 m: M. paucituberculata, P. candida and P. intermedia (Pax and Müller 1954; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977) (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). There is a new depth record of P. biscaya from 1650–2050 m (Table 1, Figure 5). In Madeira is presently known that M. lepida occurs at 300–400 m depth and that P. biscaya occurs at Selvagens between 2100 and 2500 m depth (Table 1, Figure 5). At Canary Islands, Bebryce mollis Philippi, 1842 has a greater depth limit at 330 m (Brito and Ocaña 2004) (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). Moreover, P. coronata has increased its regional depth range from 1200 m to 550–1800 m depth (Brito and Ocaña 2004) (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5). Also, M. lepida is now known to occur between 180 and 320 m depth and P. terceira at 200 m depth (Table 1, Figure 5).

In the Cape Verde archipelago, M. lepida has a record between 1000 and 1350 m depth and M. paucituberculata at 515 m depth (Tables 1, 3; Figures 4, 5). Moreover, there are many depth records at the archipelago with taxonomic uncertainty (Table 1). Lastly, at Mauritania M. paucituberculata is present at 51 m depth, Swiftia aff. dubia (Thomson, 1929) at 85 m depth and a new species of Swiftia sp. at 500 m depth (Tables 1, 3; Figure 5).

Discussion

CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II are the 20th Century’s most comprehensive scientific expeditions after the earlier campaigns of Prince Albert I of Monaco in the Northeast Atlantic Ocean (Sampaio et al. 2019). By visiting NBC and examining the octocoral specimens collected during the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions, reliable and new taxonomic records were discovered, and a complete dataset was built based on the specimens and their labels in the museum collection. The value of handwritten specimen labels cannot be overstated considering the history they harbour on the collection and collector. Fortunately, most labels are still preserved with specimens or stored in special files of NHMC. While 131 specimens/fragments were photographed and subsampled for future taxonomic studies, the auxiliary data consulted from labels was compiled in a database used to map the geographic distributions and depth ranges of various Plexauridae (Table 2; Figures 2, 3, 4). Some records were already published or are available on the Bioportal database (Grasshoff 1992; Braga-Henriques et al. 2013). However, this is the first complete inventory of Plexauridae collected during the NBC campaigns.

The Plexauridae collected during these expeditions led to reference specimens of 12 species and new records of 24 species (Table 3). It also led to the discovery of ~ six putative new species in Mauritania and Cape Verde archipelago, representing an increased sampling effort applied to previously unexplored subtropical NE Atlantic areas (Van der Land 1987, 1988, Figures 3, 4). Future taxonomic investigations will clarify the taxonomic assignment of some of the specimens, e.g., Placogorgia aff. terceira, which can either represent new fauna or new records of known fauna. Provenance data stored with specimens in this NHMC have produced an extended geographical distribution range for six plexaurid species in the Cape Verde islands, three in the Canary islands, and one each in the Azores and Selvagens Islands (Figures 3, 4). Moreover, they increased the knowledge on the bathymetric distribution of three species at the NE Atlantic scale but also of eight species within each Macaronesian archipelago (Figure 5).

Reference material for comparisons with recently collected specimens in taxonomic studies, new species and new records of Plexauridae within the NE Atlantic Ocean would have not been possible without examination of the material at Leiden and assistance from museum scientists and technicians. Moreover, clarification on data incongruences and the discovery of uncatalogued records at the NHMC has provided the museum with new data to be updated and made available to scientists (e.g., Villogorgia bebrycoides RMNH. COEL. 42338; Table 3). Without examination of museum material, uncatalogued specimens would not have been identified, mapped and made available for future studies.

Henceforth, the present study has provided a more complete inventory of Plexauridae diversity in six regions of the NE Atlantic based on material at NBC that was collected 40 years earlier. This new knowledge will provide an important biodiversity baseline of the species occurring in the NE Atlantic, which will enable the detection of changes in species diversity and composition due to recent anthropogenic and climate change impacts.

Biodiversity of NE Atlantic Plexauridae

The CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions collected 15 species of the known Plexauridae through the southern NE Atlantic Ocean, representing 62.5 % of the 24 described species known to occur in this area (Grasshoff 1977, 1986, 1992; Table 3). Only the genus Dentomuricea was not represented in these samples. This taxon is known from the Great Meteor complex of seamounts and its known biotopes in the Azores that were not visited by the Dutch expeditions. Nonetheless, some species are still missing a definite taxonomic status, meaning that so far only 12 of the 15 identified species can be used as reference records for future studies. If Paramuricea aff. macrospina is indeed P. macrospina, the most expressive extension of the geographical species is here reported. This species was known as endemic to the Mediterranean Sea and therefore this may represent its first report in the NE Atlantic at the Cape Verde archipelago (Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Table 2, Figure 4).

New regional records were found in distinct Macaronesian archipelagos. While the easier taxonomic assignments were found in Azorean specimens, the most difficult were found in Cape Verdean specimens (Figures 3, 4). Easier taxonomic assignments were found in Azorean specimens due to the higher deep-sea exploration and the effort in octocoral taxonomy within the region (Sampaio et al. 2019). Nonetheless, difficult taxonomic assignments were found for the Cape Verdean specimens due to the lack of knowledge on octocoral diversity of that archipelago (Figures 3, 4). The sampling and research effort of Azorean octocorals is much higher than those in other southern areas of the NE Atlantic Ocean, like Cape Verde, which explains why the octocoral fauna of those areas is mostly unknown (Pérez et al. 2016; Sampaio et al. 2019). As expected based on previous knowledge for the area, Azorean CANCAP plexaurids have a high species and genus richness and have revealed a new record for the region (Sampaio et al. 2019). Paramuricea biscaya has its type locality in the Gulf of Biscaya, and was further mentioned to occur in Tenerife, Canary Islands, the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and the Gulf of Mexico (Grasshoff 1977, 1985; Brito and Ocaña 2004; Molodtsova et al. 2008; Thoma 2013). Therefore, we know now that more than 50% of the Plexauridae species of the NE Atlantic inhabit the Azorean marine waters (Sampaio et al. 2019). Herein, we also report the first record of P. biscaya for Selvagens Islands (Table 3; Figures 2, 3). In the Canary Islands we raise the number of plexaurid octocorals from seven to ten with three new records for the archipelago according to previous data (Brito and Ocaña 2004): Muriceides lepida, Placogorgia coronata and P. terceira (Table 3; Figure 3).

Despite some sparse records found in the taxonomic literature (e.g., Acanella arbuscula (Johnson, 1862)) and a vast number of gorgonians mentioned for the area, no thorough revision of Octocorallia of Cape Verde was completed at this point (Molodtsova et al. 2008; Raddatz et al. 2011; Hansteen et al. 2014). In this study we report the highest number of species of Plexauridae collected in this archipelago, reflecting the two Tydeman expeditions that exclusively explored this area: Cape Verde islands CANCAP VI and CANCAP VII (Table 3; Figure 4). Moreover, two newly recorded species are reported for the archipelago with certainty, Muriceides lepida and M. paucituberculata, and three are still considered uncertain records Paramuricea aff. macrospina, Placogorgia aff. graciosa and Placogorgia cf. graciosa. Aditionally, in this archipelago, there are five species that seem to be new to science and are in need of further taxonomic investigation (Figures 2, 4; Table 3).

As undescribed marine species are commonly found in museum collections (Appeltans et al. 2012), also a sixth new species was discovered on the shelves of this NHMC (Sampaio et al., personal observation). After observing the samples and videos collected during the German expedition MSM 16/3 in 2010, the first author, in 2016, discovered that a new species of the genus Swiftia was preliminarily collected during the Tyro Mauritania II expedition in 1988 and identified until the genus level by the senior author (M.G.). Also from Mauritania, Thesea talismani, was reported as a new record for this location in 2016 based on the same German expedition and two Spanish expeditions Maurit-0911 and Maurit-1011 (Matos-Pita et al. unpublished data). However, it had been also sampled in 1988, identified and stored at NBC (Table 2; Figures 2a, 3).

Plexaurid species are commonly found forming coral ecosystems of high density (e.g., Dentomuricea meteor at the plateau of Great Meteor seamount) (Grasshoff 1977; Tempera et al. 2013). The existence of multiple colonies under a single museum collection number indicate that the colonies were collected during a single sampling event and may be present at the seafloor in high densities such as octocoral gardens. For example, 11 specimens of Bebryce mollis were collected at Punta de Jandia, South of Fuerteventura (Canary Islands) and 11 specimens of a new species of Swiftia sp. were sampled off Mauritania, potentially indicating coral garden communities dominated by these species in each area (Table 3).

Biogeography of NE Atlantic Plexauridae

Zoogeographical regions of the North Atlantic Ocean have clustered for deep-sea Scleractinia by Cairns and Chapman (2001) and were further adapted for deep-sea corals in general and octocorals in particular (Watling et al. 2011; Braga-Henriques et al. 2013). These studies cluster species known from the Mediterranean Sea with NE Atlantic species of the Lusitanian region which are denominated as Lusitanian-Mediterranean species. Therefore, the majority of the species of this study (twelve) would be considered exclusively Lusitanian-Mediterranean (IIIA) while three, Paramuricea biscaya, Paramuricea grayi and Spinimuricea atlantica, would inhabit also the New England and Corner seamounts, Bermuda (IIC) (Watling et al. 2011; Table 4). P. biscaya is also known from the Gulf of Mexico (Thoma 2013). This would be in accordance with the trend found for the Azorean Alcyonacea, where most species are Lusitanian-Mediterranean (Braga-Henriques et al. 2013).

Table 4.

Zoogeographical affinities of the Plexauridae species from CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions. Abbreviations: I based on Grasshoff (1977); AA: amphi-Atlantic, MS: Mediterranean Sea and NEA: Northeast Atlantic; II based on Cairns and Chapman (2001) and Watling et al. (2011); IIIA: Lusitanian-Mediterranean; IIC: New England and Corner Seamounts, Bermuda.

Species Zoogeographical Affinity I Zoogeographical Affinity II
Bebryce mollis NEA & MS IIIA
Muriceides lepida NEA & MS IIIA
Muriceides paucituberculata NEA IIIA
Paramuricea biscaya AA IIIA & IIC
Paramuricea candida NEA IIIA
Paramuricea grayi AA IIIA & IIC
Paramuricea aff. macrospina NEA & MS IIIA
Placogorgia coronata NEA & MS IIIA
Placogorgia cf. graciosa; P. aff. graciosa NEA IIIA
Placogorgia intermedia NEA IIIA
Placogorgia terceira; P. aff. Terceira NEA IIIA
Spinimuricea atlantica AA IIIA
Swiftia cf. dubia; Swiftia aff. dubia NEA & MS IIIA
Thesea talismani NEA IIIA
Villogorgia bebrycoides NEA & MS IIIA

Nonetheless, if we consider the regions defined by Grasshoff (1977) for the Paramuriceidae (now Plexauridae) and take into account the boundary he suggested between the gorgonians of the NE Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea, then six species of the 12 known Plexauridae species identified here are exclusively inhabitants of the NE Atlantic Ocean (Table 4). Muriceides paucituberculata and Placogorgia graciosa are widespread and live from the temperate waters in Ireland to the tropical waters of the West coast of Africa. Placogorgia terceira occurs on the vicinity of the Tropic of Cancer, between temperate and tropical waters of the southern NE Atlantic Ocean, while two species are uniquely known from the Azores, namely Paramuricea candida and Placogorgia intermedia. Thesea talismani is exclusive to the west coast of Africa (Grasshoff 1977, 1986). All the new putative species are exclusively known to inhabit the southern NE Atlantic Ocean, with Swiftia sp. only found in the West of Africa.

Six plexaurid species from the CANCAP records live in the “natural whole” (Ekman, 1935), the NE Atlantic Ocean (Lusitanian, Moroccan, Mauritanian and Macaronesian territories) and Mediterranean region, representing all five species mentioned by Grasshoff (1977) plus Paramuricea aff. macrospina. Here this species is mentioned as being located in the NE Atlantic Ocean; however, this record needs to be considered carefully, as explained above. Moreover, Paramuricea biscaya, P. grayi, and Spinimuricea atlantica are amphi-Atlantic (Watling et al. 2011; Table 4).

The distribution of marine invertebrates is highly influenced by oceanographic conditions (Ansín-Agís et al. 2001). Several oceanic currents and different climates influence the Macaronesian archipelagos (Amorim et al. 2017). The Equatorial counter-current, for example, seems to influence the distribution of scleractinian corals in the deep sea. Scleractinian corals at the Canary Islands, a warm temperate area, cluster together with corals from Cape Verde archipelago at the tropics. Additionally, Scleractinia from temperate areas like the Azores and Madeira archipelagos make up the large cluster of the Lusitanian Province (Cairns and Chapman 2001). However, NE Atlantic plexaurid octocorals seem to be more influenced by the climate. Further taxonomy and biogeographical analyses need to be done in order to make conclusive comments. Notwithstanding, the plexaurid species of the Canary Islands are also present at the Madeira and Azores archipelagos, while the new putative plexaurid octocoral species of Cape Verde indicate a distinction between species in temperate cold deep-sea waters and those at cold deep-sea tropical climates.

Depth zonation of NE Atlantic Plexauridae

The present study has altered the known bathymetrical distribution ranges of a few plexaurid octocorals in the NE Atlantic (Figure 5). One species, Paramuricea aff. macrospina, had its depth range increased by 150 m and is now known from the upper mesophotic to the upper bathyal (40–350 m depth) (Grasshoff 1977). Spinimuricea atlantica (20–875 m), Villogorgia bebrycoides (63–845 m), Bebryce mollis (71–1250 m) and Muriceides lepida (80–1350 m), the last with its depth range increased by 650 m, inhabit the lower sublittoral down to the bathyal (Stiasny 1940; Tixier-Durivault and D´Hondt 1974; Carpine and Grasshoff 1975; Grasshoff 1977, 1985, 1992; Brito and Ocaña 2004). Species exclusively inhabiting the bathyal zone are Thesea talismani (462–1090 m), Placogorgia cf. graciosa (769–1300 m), which increased its depth range by 360 m, Placogorgia intermedia (800–1400 m), increasing its depth by 285 m, and Paramuricea candida with an additional 165 m (1069–1400 m depth) (Tixier-Durivault and d’Hondt 1974; Grasshoff 1977, 1985; Alvarez-Claudio 1993; Matos-Pita et al. unpublished data). Moreover, five species are eurybath having ranges from sublittoral or mesophotic depths until upper abyssal depths: Muriceides paucituberculata (51–2100 m), Paramuricea grayi (20–2195 m), Placogorgia coronata (50–2080 m), Swiftia aff. dubia (10–2400 m), and Placogorgia terceira (170–3200 m) (Grasshoff 1977, 1981, 1985, 1989; Altuna et al. 2010). Finally, the deepest plexaurid of the NE Atlantic is Paramuricea biscaya (1200–4152 m), an inhabitant of bathyal and abyssal depths (Brito and Ocaña 2004; Molodtsova et al. 2008).

The importance of natural history museum collections for deep-sea research

Natural history museum collections harbour long-term biodiversity collection data. Museum data collected over time are prone to being incomplete (e.g., by lacking geographic locality information) (Soberón and Peterson 2004; Ross et al. 2012). Therefore, NHMC data are often overlooked in marine biodiversity assessments. CANCAP geo-referenced records from the 1970s and 80s have a low position accuracy in comparison with precise records sampled with modern submersibles and remote operated vehicles (ROVs) (see for example Englebert et al. 2015; Hoeksema et al. 2017). Most samples from the Dutch expeditions were collected by dredges and trawls which operated through transects, while only a single point position was recorded for each sampling location, detailing coordinates exclusively in degrees and minutes (Table 3).

While digitisation is improving museum data quality and standardisation, it is still essential to visit NHMC in order to have an accurate source of information on specific taxa (Roy and Gagnon 2016). Yet, even when having access to all the data available in NHMC, there are some problems to sort out. For example, among the octocorals deposited in NBC collected during CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions, some specimens were not yet catalogued, other specimens were mixed with specimens from a different family of octocorals having the same catalogue number for different taxa and, a specimen of Spinimuricea atlantica, present on Bioportal, could not be located in the museum at present time.

Similar concerns can be raised by mapping published species records without checking the original record and its auxiliary information (Ross et al. 2012). Unvouchered records can be easily misidentified without proper local taxonomic knowledge or observable taxonomical characters essential to identify the species (Henry and Roberts 2013). In consequence, poor quality data can be used in studies that model distribution of species and may lead to overestimation of their putative distributions (Davies and Guinotte 2011; Bullimore et al. 2013; Henry and Roberts 2013). Unvouchered records in deep-sea ecology studies need to be identified with care, particularly if plexaurid octocorals are present. Plexaurids are extremely diverse and difficult to identify in video transects and in situ images, despite high definition and highly magnified imagery. Colony morphology is not the main distinctive taxonomic feature of most octocorals, including the Plexauridae. Consequently, some plexaurid species identification based on imagery can be easily mistaken as species of different families like Acanthogorgiidae and Gorgoniidae when the sclerome of the specimens is not analysed.

Even when a specimen is available, plexaurids have a remarkable and little studied variability of their sclerites, which hampers an easy identification and description of new species (Grasshoff 1977). Moreover, genetic markers currently used in the DNA barcoding of octocorals are not as effective as it would be desirable to discriminate at species level. Notwithstanding, currently it is important to consider genetics when describing new octocoral species and their cryptic diversity (Breedy and Guzman 2011; Reijnen et al. 2014). Museum specimens, when suitable for genetics, may be used to sequence vouchered reference DNA barcodes (Morín et al. 2019). Antique octocoral reference samples can be compared with recently collected samples like some of the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II Plexauridae, which were already sequenced with this goal.

Deep-sea exploration is expensive and constrained to specific areas of the vast, unexplored and difficult to sample deep sea. Likewise, deep-sea sampling cruises are limited to specific sampling gears and determined depth strata. Therefore, locations where well-curated deep-sea specimens are well identified and stored through decades, or even centuries, represent inestimable access to baseline knowledge on deep-sea biodiversity. NHMC with type and reference octocoral deep-sea specimens are money savers because they decrease the need of much new expensive and time-consuming fieldwork (Suarez and Tsutsui 2004). Museum records already proved to be useful for cold-water scleractinian reef building species off the southeastern United States and for Canadian Arctic marine benthos distribution based on online databases, selected publications and visits to museums (Ross et al. 2012; Roy and Gagnon 2016). Besides, CANCAP deep-sea plexaurids represent high standard accounts for this family because their identification was made by leading experts on taxonomy of gorgonians. Additionally, they increase the knowledge on Plexauridae, a neglected but important octocoral family, with many structural species which form vulnerable marine habitats. Therefore, visits to NHMC should be encouraged to greatly increase known biodiversity, to gather reference samples with credible taxonomic status and auxiliary data associated to specimens. Visits to museums are also essential to correct errors that are hampering the accessibility to this knowledge.

More value needs to be given to NHMC like the Octocorallia collection stored at NBC. Reliability on taxonomic knowledge, which is fundamental for the quality of the following biological knowledge, is dependent on NHMC (Suarez and Tsutsui 2004). Contemporary biodiversity studies rely on the 300 years of historical research deposited in museums to have accurate knowledge on species distribution and their changes under anthropogenic pressures and climate change (Roy and Gagnon 2016). This is particularly true for deep-sea invertebrates for which there is little taxonomical knowledge, especially in unexplored geographical areas. In some cases, like the Plexauridae from Cape Verde islands herein mentioned, NHMC store the unique existing data (Graham et al. 2004; Funk 2018).

Still, many countries have no or very limited funding for taxonomy, their natural history museums have limited personal to curate and investigate collections, there are shifts in the scientific focus of NHC towards molecular studies and a trend in the scientific community in publishing biodiversity studies based on unvouchered records (Kemp 2015; Troudet et al. 2018). This raises concerns on the reliability of identifications that cannot be verified (Costello et al. 2013). Moreover, taxonomic papers are published in low-citation indexed journals and NHMC are in high risk of not being preserved in the long run (Andreone et al. 2014). The consequence of a lack of taxonomical knowledge is the loss of irreplaceable sources of high-quality biodiversity data, and the proliferation of unvouchered misidentified records with poor or no auxiliary data which, in turn, results in a doubtful source of knowledge for future generations (Yesson et al. 2007; Funk 2018; Troudet et al. 2018). This trend is alarming, particularly in the light of a biodiversity extinction crisis.

A taxonomist-ecologist partnership would benefit museums and ecological studies improving long-term storage of ecological specimens and the quality and reproducibility of ecological studies (Ward et al. 2015). Therefore, collections-based research would complement field surveys in all biodiversity disciplines to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the taxa under study and to discover biodiversity hotspots that can be considered priority for future conservation (Minton and Perez 2010).

Threats to biodiversity emphasise the need to decrease the Linnean shortfall by gathering information on known species based in specimen collection and also in describing new species, as rapidly as possible, to understand their vulnerability and to conserve them (Costello et al. 2015; Hortal et al. 2015; Ceríaco et al. 2016; Troudet et al. 2018). Henceforth, the understanding of the current state and future effects on the NE Atlantic Plexauridae relies on a complete data gathering exercise. Considering the heterogeneous octocoral taxonomy effort in the Macaronesian archipelagos and West Africa, historical literature and specimen collection data have a great value to fill in gaps in areas where biodiversity is still unknown (e.g., at greater depths) (Sampaio et al. 2019). The present study has generated accurate baseline octocoral taxonomic status records reliable for species distribution, biodiversity and conservation studies. This Plexauridae museum database will be beneficial to decide future field surveys in geographic and taxonomic unexplored areas and for a better management of deep-sea areas where plexaurid species are rare or form vulnerable marine ecosystems (VMEs).

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank Dr Filipe Porteiro for bringing the Azorean records of the CANCAP campaigns to our attention. We are thankful to Dr Leen P. van Ofwegen for introducing the NBC Octocorallia collection to the first author during her first visit in 2012 to the museum and for hosting her during her visit in 2016. To Dr Bert W. Hoeksema we are thankful for his availability to be a host in NBC, for providing specific literature on the CANCAP and Tyro Mauritania II expeditions and for the opportunity of communicating the project during the Marine Biodiversity Meeting in NBC. Thanks also to Dr Lívia Moura Oliveira for welcoming the first author to NBC, and to Mr. Koos van Egmond and Ms. Karen van Dorp for providing access the specimens and for curational support. We are also grateful to Dr Luís Ceríaco for sharing literature on natural history museums research. For revision of the introduction structure we are grateful to Gerald Taranto and for English corrections we are grateful to Ms. Emily Friesen and Ms. Devon Turner. Special thanks to the editor and three referees who made important comments and suggestions for the improvement of the manuscript.

The first author is funded by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) Doctoral grant SFRH/BD/101113/2014. She received a Marine and Environmental Sciences Centre (MARE) travel grant to visit NBC, Leiden within the project ‘Improving the taxonomic knowledge of Plexauridae octocorals in the Northeast Atlantic: insights into the Dutch CANCAP and Mauritania expeditions’. This work has received funding from a Marie-Curie IRG Fellowship to MCS (CoralChange, project no 231109) and the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme, under grant agreement No 678760 (ATLAS).

References

  • Altuna A, Sinniger F, Aldrey JM (2010) Occurrence of Savalia savaglia (Anthozoa: Zoantharia) in the Ría de Arousa (Galicia, north-western Spain, north-eastern Atlantic). Marine Biodiversity Records 3: e110. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755267210000965
  • Álvarez CC (1995) Octocoralarios (Cnidaria: Anthozoa) de la plataforma y talud continental de Asturias (Mar Cantábrico). Thalassas 11: 87–92.
  • Amorim P, Perán AD, Pham CK, Juliano M, Cardigos F, Tempera F, Morato T (2017) Overview of the ocean climatology and its variability in the Azores region of the North Atlantic including environmental characteristics at the seabed. Frontiers in Marine Science 4: 56. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2017.00056
  • Andreone F, Bartolozzi L, Boano G, Boero F, Bologna MA, Bon M, Bressi N, Capula M, Casale A, Casiraghi M, Chiozzi G, Delfino M, Doria G, Durante A, Ferrari M, Gippoliti S, Lanzinger M, Latella L, Maio N, Marangoni C, Mazzotti S, Minelli A, Muscio G, Nicolosi P, Pievani T, Razzetti E, Sabella G, Valle M, Vomero V, Zilli A (2014) Italian natural history museums on the verge of collapse? Zookeys 456: 139–146. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.456.8862
  • Ansín-Agís J, Ramil F, Vervoort W (2001) Atlantic Leptolida (Hydrozoa, Cnidaria) of the families Aglaopheniidae, Halopterididae, Kirchenpaueriidae and Plumulariidae collected during the CANCAP and Mauritania-II expeditions of the National Museum of Natural History, Leiden, The Netherlands. Zoologische Verbandelingen 333: 1–268. https://www.repository.naturalis.nl/document/46286
  • Appeltans W, Ahyong ST, Anderson G, Angel MV, Artois T, Bailly N, Bamber R, Barber A, Bartsch I, Berta A, Błażewicz-Paszkowycz M, Bock P, Boxshall G, Boyko CB, Brandão SN, Bray RA, Bruce NL, Cairns SD, Chan T-Y, Cheng L, Collins AG, Cribb T, Curini-Galletti M, Dahdouh-Guebas F, Davie PJ, Dawson MN, De Clerck O, Decock W, De Grave S, de Voogd NJ, Domning DP, Emig CC, Erséus C, Eschmeyer W, Fauchald K, Fautin DG, Feist SW, Fransen CH, Furuya H, Garcia-Alvarez O, Gerken S, Gibson D., Gittenberger A., Gofas S, Gómez-Daglio L, Gordon DP, Guiry MD, Hernandez F, Hoeksema BW, Hopcroft RR, Jaume D, Kirk P, Koedam N, Koenemann S, Kolb JB, Kristensen RM, Kroh A, Lambert G, Lazarus DB, Lemaitre R, Longshaw M, Lowry J, Macpherson E, Madin LP, Mah C, Mapstone G, McLaughlin PA, Mees J, Meland K, Messing CG, Mills CE, Molodtsova TN, Mooi R, Neuhaus B, Ng PK, Nielsen C, Norenburg J, Opresko DM, Osawa M, Paulay G, Perrin W, Pilger JF, Poore GC, Pugh P, Read GB, Reimer JD, Rius M, Rocha RM, Saiz-Salinas JI, Scarabino V, Schierwater B, Schmidt-Rhaesa A, Schnabel KE, Schotte M, Schuchert P, Schwabe E, Segers H, Self-Sullivan C, Shenkar N, Siegel V, Sterrer W, Stöhr S, Swalla B, Tasker ML, Thuesen EV, Timm T, Todaro MA, Turon X, Tyler S, Uetz P, Van der Land J, Vanhoorne B, van Ofwegen LP, van Soest RW, Vanaverbeke J, Walker-Smith G, Walter TC, Warren A, Williams GC, Wilson SP, Costello MJ (2012) The magnitude of global marine species diversity. Current Biology 22: 2189–2202. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2012.09.036
  • Bayer FM (1956) Octocorallia. Treatise on invertebrate paleontology. Part F Coelenterata, Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, Lawrence, Kansas, F166–F231.
  • Braga-Henriques A, Porteiro FM, Ribeiro PA, Matos VD, Sampaio Í, Ocaña O, Santos RS (2013) Diversity, distribution and spatial structure of the cold-water coral fauna of the Azores (NE Atlantic). Biogeosciences 10: 529–590. https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-10-4009-2013
  • Brinker AM, Raskin I (2005) Determination of triptolide in root extracts of Tripterygium wilfordii by solid-phase extraction and reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Chromatography A 1070: 65–70. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chroma.2005.02.083
  • Brito A, Ocaña O (2004) Corales de las Islas Canarias. Editorial Lemus, La Laguna, 477 pp.
  • Bullimore R, Foster N, Howell K (2013) Coral-characterized benthic assemblages of the deep Northeast Atlantic: defining “Coral Gardens” to support future habitat mapping efforts. ICES Journal of Marine Science 70: 511–522. https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fss195
  • Carpine C, Grasshoff M (1975) Les gorgonaires de la Méditerrannée. Bulletin de l’Institut Océanographique de Monaco 2: 1–146.
  • Carpine C, Grasshoff M (1985) Catalogue critique des Octocoralliaires des collections du Musée océanographique de Monaco I. Gorgonaires et Pennatulaires. Bulletin de l’Institut Océanographique de Monaco 73: 1–72.
  • Ceríaco LM, Gutierrez EE, Dubois A et al. [490 signatories] (2016) Photography-based taxonomy is inadequate, unnecessary, and potentially harmful for biological sciences. Zootaxa 4196: 435–445. https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4196.3.9
  • Coleman CO (2015) Taxonomy in times of the taxonomic impediment-examples from the community of experts on amphipod crustaceans. Journal of Crustacean Biology 35: 729–740. https://doi.org/10.1163/1937240X-00002381
  • Costello MJ, Emblow C, White RJ (2001) European register of marine species: a check-list of the marine species in Europe and a bibliography of guides to their identification. Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle Paris 50: 1–463.
  • Costello MJ, Wilson S, Houlding B (2012) Predicting total global species richness using rates of species description and estimates of taxonomic effort. Systematic Biology 61: 871–883. https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syr080
  • Costello MJ, Bouchet P, Boxshall G, Fauchald K, Gordon D, Hoeksema BW, Poore GCB, Van Soest RWM, Stöhr S, Walter TC, Vanhoorne B, Decock W, Appeltans W (2013) Global coordination and standardisation in marine biodiversity through the World Register of Marine Species (WoRMS) and related databases. PLoS ONE 8: e51629. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0051629
  • Costello MJ, Vanhoorne B, Appeltans W (2015) Conservation of biodiversity through taxonomy, data publication, and collaborative infrastructures. Conservation Biology 29: 1094–1099. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.12496
  • Den Hartog JC (1984) An introduction to the CANCAP-project of the Dutch Rijksmuseum von Natuurlijke Historie (RMNH), with special reference to the CANCAP-VI expedition (1982) to the Cape Verde lslands. Courier Forschungs-Institut Senckenberg 68: 5–15.
  • Dijkstra HH, Goud J (2002) Pectinoidea (Bivalvia, Propeamussiidae & Pectinidae) collected during the Dutch CANCAP and MAURITANIA expeditions in the south-eastern region of the North Atlantic Ocean. Basteria 66: 31–82.
  • Englebert N, Bongaerts P, Muir P, Hay K, Hoegh-Guldberg O (2015) Deepest zooxanthellate corals of the Great Barrier Reef and Coral Sea. Marine Biodiversity 45: 1–2. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12526-014-0221-8
  • Fransen CHJM (1991) Preliminary report on Crustacea collected in the eastern part of the North Atlantic during the CANCAP and Mauritania expeditions of the former Rijksmuseum van Natuurlijke Historie, Leiden. Nationaal Naturhistorisch Museum, Leiden, 200 pp.
  • Graham CH, Ferrier S, Huettman F, Moritz C, Peterson AT (2004) New developments in museum-based informatics and applications in biodiversity analysis. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 19: 497–503. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2004.07.006
  • Grasshoff M (1977) Die Gorgonarien des östlichen Nordatlantik und des Mittelmeeres: III. Die Familie Paramuriceidae (Cnidaria: Anthozoa). “Meteor“ – Forschungs – Ergebnisse D 27: 5–76.
  • Grasshoff M (1981) Gorgonaria und Pennatularia (Cnidaria: Anthozoa) vom Mittelatlantischen Rücken SW der Azoren. Steenstrupia 7: 213–230.
  • Grasshoff M (1985) Die Gorgonaria und Antipatharia der Großen Meteor-Bank und der Josephine-Bank. (Cnidaria: Anthozoa). Senckenbergiana Biologica 17: 65–87.
  • Grasshoff M (1989) Die Meerenge von Gibraltar als Faunen-Barriere: Die Gorgonaria, Pennatularia und Antipatharia der Balgim-Expedition (Cnidaria: Anthozoa). Senckenbergiana Maritima 20: 201–223.
  • Grasshoff M (1992) Die Flachwasser-Gorgonarien von Europa und Westafrika (Cnidaria, Anthozoa). Courier Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg 149: 1–135.
  • Hansteen T, Kwasnitschka T, Klügel A (2014) Cape Verde Seamounts – Cruise No. M80/3 – December 29, 2009 – February 1, 2010 – Dakar (Senegal) – Las Palmas de Gran Canaria (Spain). DFG-Senatskommission für Ozeanographie, Bremen, Germany, 42 pp. https://doi.org/10.2312/cr_m80_3
  • Henry LA, Roberts JM (2013) Recommendations for best practice in deep-sea habitat classification: Bullimore et al. as a case study. ICES Journal of Marine Science 71(4): 895–898. https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fst175
  • Hernández-Ávila I, Guerra-Castro E, Bracho C, Rada M, Ocaña FA, Pech D (2018) Variation in species diversity of deep-water megafauna assemblages in the Caribbean across depth and ecoregions. PloS ONE 13: e0201269. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0201269
  • Hoeksema BW (2015) Latitudinal species diversity gradient of mushroom corals off eastern Australia: a baseline from the 1970s. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 165: 190–198. Https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecss.2015.05.015
  • Hoeksema BW, van der Land J, van der Meij SET, van Ofwegen LP, Reijnen BT, van Soest RWM, de Voogd NJ (2011) Unforeseen importance of historical collections as baselines to determine biotic change of coral reefs: the Saba Bank case. Marine Ecology 32: 135–141. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1439-0485.2011.00434.x
  • Hoeksema BW, Bongaerts P, Baldwin CC (2017) High coral cover at lower mesophotic depths: a dense Agaricia community at the leeward side of Curaçao, Dutch Caribbean. Marine Biodiversity 47: 67–70. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12526-015-0431-8
  • Hortal J, de Bello F, Diniz-Filho JAF, Lewinsohn TM, Lobo JM, Ladle RJ (2015) Seven shortfalls that beset large-scale knowledge of biodiversity. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution and Systematics 46: 523–549. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-ecolsys-112414-054400
  • Johnson JY (1861) Description of a second species of Acanthogorgia (J. E. Gray) from Madeira. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London: 296–299.
  • Koch G (1882) Vorläufige Mittheilungen über die Gorgonien (Alcyonaria axifera) von Neapel und über die Entwicklung der Gorgonia verrucosa. Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel 3: 537–550. https://biostor.org/reference/181568
  • Koch G (1887) Die Gorgoniden des Golfes von Neapel und der angrenzenden Meeresabschnitte. Erster Theil einer Monographie der Anthozoa Alcyonaria. Fauna und Flora des Golfes von Neapel 15: 1–90. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.13749
  • Marion AF (1882) Les Alcyonaires du Golfe de Marseille. Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences, Paris 94: 985–988.
  • Minton RL, Perez KE (2010) Analysis of museum records highlights unprotected land snail diversity in Alabama. American Malacological Bulletin 28(2): 91–95. https://doi.org/10.4003/006.028.0224
  • Molodtsova TN, Sanamyan NP, Keller NB (2008) Anthozoa from the northern Mid-Atlantic Ridge and Charlie-Gibbs Fracture Zone. Marine Biology Resources 55: 112–130. https://doi.org/10.1080/17451000701821744
  • Morín J, Venera-Pontón D, Driskell A, Sánchez JA, Lasker H, Collin R (2019) Reference DNA barcodes and other mitochondrial markers for identifying Caribbean Octocorals. Biodiversity Data Journal 7: e30970. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.7.e30970
  • Pallas PS (1766) Elenchus zoophytorum sistens generum adumbrationes generaliores et specierum cognitarum succintas descriptiones cum selectis auctorum synonymis. Hague Comitum, The Hague, 451 pp. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.6595
  • Pérez CD, Neves BM, Cordeiro RTS, Williams GC, Cairns SD (2016) Diversity and Distribution of Octocorallia. In: Goffredo S, Dubinsky Z (Eds) The Cnidaria, Past, Present and Future. The world of Medusa and her sisters. Springer, Berlin, 109–123. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-31305-4_8
  • Raddatz J, López Correa M, Rüggeberg A, Dullo WC, Hansteen T (2011) Bioluminescence in deep-sea isidid gorgonians from the Cape Verde archipelago. Coral Reefs 30: 579. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00338-011-0743-5
  • Reijnen BT, McFadden CS, Hermanlimianto YT, van Ofwegen LP (2014) A molecular and morphological exploration of the generic boundaries in the family Melithaeidae (Coelenterata: Octocorallia) and its taxonomic consequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 70: 383–401. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2013.09.028
  • Rocha LA, Aleixo A, Allen G, Almeda F, Baldwin CC, Barclay MVL, Bates JM, Bauer AM, Benzoni F, Berns CM, Berumen ML, Blackburn DC, Blum S, Bolanos F, Bowie RCK, Britz R, Brown RM, Cadena CD, Carpenter K, Ceriaco LM, Chakrabarty P, Chaves G, Choat JH, Clements KD, Collette BB, Collins A, Coyne J, Cracraft J, Daniel T, Carvalho MR de, Queiroz Kde, Di Mario F, Drewes R, Dumbacher JP, Engilis JrA, Erdmann MV, Eschmeyer W, Feldman CR, Fisher BL, Fjeldsä J, Fritsch PW, Fuchs J, Getahun A, Gill M, Gomon M, Gosliner T, Graves GR, Griswold CE, Guralnick R, Hartel K, Helgen KM, Ho H, Iskandar DT, Iwamoto T, Jaafar Z, James HF, Johnson D, Kavanaugh D, Knowlton N, Lacey E, Larson HK, Last P, Leis JM, Lessios H, Liebherr J, Lowman M, Mahler DL, Mamonekene V, Matsuura K, Mayer GC, Mays JrH, Mccosker J, Mcdiarmid RW, Mcguire J, Miller MJ, Mooi R, Mooi RD, Moritz C, Myers P, Nachman MW, Nussbaum RA, Foighil DO, Parenti LR, Paham JF, Paul E, Paulay G, Perez-Eman J, Perez-Matus A, Poe S, Pogonoski J, Rabosky DL, Randall JE, Reimer JD, Robertson DR, Rödel M-O, Rodrigues MT, Roopnarine P, Rüber L, Ryan MJ, Sheldon F, Shinohara G, Short A, Simison WB, Smith-Vaniz WF, Springer VG, Stiassny M, Tello JG, Thompson CW, Trnski T, Tucker P, Valqui T, Vecchione M, Verheyen E, Wainwright PC, Wheeler TA, White WT, Will K, Williams JT, Williams G, Wilson EO, Winker K, Winterbottom R, Witt CC (2014) Specimen collection: An essential tool. Science 344: 814–815. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.344.6186.814
  • Ross SW, Carlson MCT, Quattrini A (2012) The utility of museum records for documenting distributions of deep-sea corals off southeastern United States. Marine Biology Research 8: 101–114. https://doi.org/10.1080/17451000.2011.628680
  • Sampaio Í, Stokvis F, van Ofwegen LP (2016) New name for the soft coral Alcyonium rubrum Stokvis & van Ofwegen, 2006 (Alcyonacea, Alcyoniidae): Alcyonium burmedju nom. n. ZooKeys 619: 163–165. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.619.10086
  • Sampaio Í, Freiwald A, Porteiro FM, Menezes G, Carreiro-Silva M (2019) Census of Octocorallia (Cnidaria: Anthozoa) of the Azores (NE Atlantic): a nomenclature update. Zootaxa 4550(4): 451–498. https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4550.4.1
  • Schilthuizen M, Vairappan CS, Slade EM, Mann DJ, Miller JA (2015) Specimens as primary data: museums and ‘open science’. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 30(5): 237–238. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2015.03.002
  • Sluys R (2013) The unappreciated, fundamentally analytical nature of taxonomy and the implications for the inventory of biodiversity. Biodiversity and Conservation 22: 1095–105. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-013-0472-x
  • Soberón J, Peterson T (2004) Biodiversity informatics: managing and applying primary biodiversity data. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 359: 689–698. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2003.1439
  • Stiasny G (1940) Gorgonides et Alcyonides des collections du Muséum National d‘Histoire Naturelle (Première Partie). Archives du Muséum d' Histoire Naturelle Paris 6(16): 109–145.
  • Studer T (1901) Alcyonaires provenant des campagnes de l’Hirondelle (1886–88). Résultats des campagnes scientifiques du prince Albert Ier de Monaco 20, 1–64. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.58246
  • Taylor RW (1976) A submission to the inquiry into the impact on the Australian environment of the current woodchip industry programme. Senate Hansard: transcripts of reports to the Australian standing committee on science and environment, Canberra: 3724–3731.
  • Thoma JN (2013) Molecular and Morphological Diversity of Sea Fans with Emphasis on Deep-sea Octocorals of the Order Alcyonacea Lamouroux, 1812. Ph.D. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Louisiana at Lafayette, 170 pp.
  • Thomson JA (1927) Alcyonaires provenant des campagnes scientifiques du prince Albert Ier de Monaco. Résultats des campagnes scientifiques du prince Albert Ier de Monaco 73: 1–77.
  • Thomson JA (1929) Alcyonaires des environs de Monaco et de localités diverses. Bulletin de l’Institut océanographique 534: 1–10.
  • Tixier-Durivault A, D’Hondt MJ (1974) Les octocoralliaires de la campagne Biaçores. Bulletin du Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris, Zoologie 3(252): 1361–1433.
  • Troudet J, Vignes-Lebbe R, Grandcolas P, Legendre F (2018) The increasing disconnection of primary biodiversity data from specimens: How does it happen and how to handle it? Systematic biology: syy044. https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syy044
  • Van der Land J (1987) Report on the CANCAP‐Project for marine biological research in the Canarian – Cape Verdean Region of the North Atlantic Ocean (1976–1986). Part I. List of stations. Zoologische Verhandelingen 243: 1–94. https://www.repository.naturalis.nl/document/148941
  • Van der Land J (1988) Tyro Mauritania-II Expedition List of Stations: 1–9. – Rijksmuseum an Natuurlijke Historie, Leiden. [mimeographed]
  • Van der Linden J (1998) The Metaxiinae dredged by the CANCAP expeditions, with the new species Metaxia carinapex and Metaxia hapax from the Cape Verde Islands (Gastropoda, Heteropoda: Triphoridae). Basteria 61: 115–122. http://natuurtijdschriften.nl/record/597122
  • Vervoort W (2006) Leptolida (Cnidaria; Hydrozoa) collected during the CANCAP and Mauritania-II expeditions of the National Museum of Natural History, Leiden, The Netherlands (Anthoathecata, various families of Leptothecata and addenda). Zoologische Medelingen 80: 181–318.
  • Yesson C, Brewer PW, Sutton T, Caithness N, Pahwa JS, Burgess M, Gray WA, White RJ, Jones AC, Bisby FA, Culham A (2007) How global is the Global Biodiversity Information Facility? PLoS ONE 2: e1124. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0001124
login to comment