Research Article |
Corresponding author: Nicolas Lavesque ( nicolas.lavesque@u-bordeaux.fr ) Academic editor: Christopher Glasby
© 2019 Nicolas Lavesque, Guillemine Daffe, Jacques Grall, Joana Zanol, Benoit Gouillieux, Pat Hutchings.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Lavesque N, Daffe G, Grall J, Zanol J, Gouillieux B, Hutchings P (2019) Guess who? On the importance of using appropriate name: case study of Marphysa sanguinea (Montagu, 1813). ZooKeys 859: 1-15. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.859.34117
|
The common bait worm Marphysa sanguinea (Montagu, 1813), originally described from the south coast of England, is the type species of the genus. This species has been widely reported from all around the world and has been considered as cosmopolitan until recently. This is partly because the original description was very brief and poorly illustrated, and also because all species superficially look similar. In order to clarify the situation, M. sanguinea was redescribed and a neotype was designated by Hutchings and Karageorgpoulos in 2003. Recently, specimens from Cornwall, close to the type locality, were sampled, examined morphologically, and used to obtain COI gene sequences for this species. Molecular results permitted us to confirm the identity and presence of M. sanguinea along the French coasts and to highlight the presence of inaccurate sequences of this species on GenBank. Use of this “false” cosmopolitan species at a worldwide scale by many biologists is also discussed in this paper.
Bait worms, cosmopolitan species, misidentification, molecular, taxonomy
Eunicidae Berthold, 1827 is a very speciose family with eleven recent genera and more than 400 valid species distributed worldwide (
In the absence of type material,
In this study, we test the identification of M. sanguinea cytochrome oxidase I (COI) sequences in GenBank, comparing them with those of specimens from the type locality (Cornwall, UK). We have also carefully checked and described the studied material.
Specimens were collected in subtidal turf slabs in Arcachon Bay, in intertidal soft rocks in Bay of Brest (France) and in rocks easily split to extract the worms in Plymouth Sound (Cornwall, UK), close to the type locality. Specimens from Brest and Cornwall were fixed and preserved in 96% ethanol. For the Arcachon specimen, several posterior parapodia were removed and fixed in 96% ethanol for molecular studies. The rest of specimen was fixed in 4% formaldehyde seawater solution, then transferred to 70% ethanol for morphological analyses. Preserved specimens were examined under a Nikon SMZ25 stereomicroscope and a Nikon Eclipse E400 microscope and photographed with a Nikon DS-Ri 2 camera. Measurements were made with the NIS-Elements Analysis software. Selected parapodia along the body were removed from one specimen from Brest (
Morphological terminology is based on previous studies of Paxton (2000) and
The studied material is deposited at the Australian Museum, Sydney (
Sub-samples for DNA analysis were removed from specimens, placed in ethanol 96% and frozen at -20 °C. Extraction of DNA was done with QIAamp DNA Micro Kit (QIAGEN) following protocol supplied by the manufacturers. Approximately 600 bp of COI (cytochrome c oxidase subunit I) gene was amplified, using primers polyLCO and polyHCO COI (
Overlapping sequence (forward and reverse) fragments were merged into consensus sequences and aligned using Clustal Omega. COI sequences were translated into amino acid alignment and checked for stop codons in order to avoid pseudogenes. The minimum length coverage was around 590 bp.
Pairwise Kimura 2-parameter (K2P) genetic distance and Maximum Likelihood tree using K2P model and non-parametric bootstrap branch support (1000 replicates) was performed using MEGA version 7.0.26. Tree-based analysis was obtained with all Marphysa species and available (and exploitable) sequences of M. sanguinea in GenBank. Other genera of Eunicidae were considered as outgroup.
Type species. Nereis sanguinea Montagu, 1813
Body relatively long, with complete individuals ranging from 48.1 (ca. 138 chaetigers) to 163.1 mm (ca. 270 chaetigers) in length and from 3.7 to 6.6 mm in width (chaetiger 10 with parapodia), with same width throughout, slightly tapering at anterior end and abruptly tapering at posterior end. Body cylindrical on anterior chaetigers, becoming dorsoventrally flattened. Prostomium slightly shorter than anterior ring of peristomium, as wide as peristomium, bilobed with buccal lips separated by deep ventral and dorsal notch with each lobe rounded (Fig.
Marphysa sanguinea: A anterior part, dorsolateral view (
First few parapodia smaller than subsequent ones but all similar in structure. Notopodial cirri elongate and triangular (Figs
Chaetae arranged in two bundles: supra-acicular and sub-acicular, separated by a row of aciculae. Aciculae dark, tapering, very protruding, 1–4 per parapodium in anterior chaetigers and 2–3 in mid and posterior chaetigers. Single subacicular bifid hook present from chaetiger 21–25 to nearly end of body, dark on base to middle and translucent at the distal end (Figs
SEM images of Marphysa sanguinea: A isodont, symmetrical pectinate chaetae from anterior chaetiger (
Pygidium with only one pair of relatively short pygidial cirri on ventral margin (approximately as long as last five chaetigers), anus slightly crenulated.
Specimens both from British and French coasts agree with the description of the neotype and with voucher
COI gene was successfully sequenced and published at NCBI GenBank for the tree specimens sampled in Cornwall near the locality type (Table
List of terminal taxa used in molecular analysis, GenBank accession numbers, status of the species, locality of analysed specimen, and voucher specimen catalogue numbers.
Species | GenBank accession number | Status | Locality | Voucher specimen |
---|---|---|---|---|
Eunice cf. violaceomaculata Ehlers, 1887 | GQ497542 | valid | Carrie Bow Cay, Belize | |
Palola viridis Gray in Stair, 1847 | GQ497556 | valid | Kosrae, Micronesia | |
Leodice rubra (Grube, 1856) | GQ497528 | valid | Ceará, Brazil | |
M. aegypti Elgetany, El-Ghobashy, Ghoneim & Struck, 2018 | MF196968 | valid | Suez Canal, Egypt | |
M. bifurcata Kott, 1951 | KX172177 | valid | Lizard Island, Australia | |
M. brevitentaculata Treadwell, 1921 | GQ497548 | valid | Quintana Roo, Mexico | |
M. californica Moore, 1909 | GQ497552 | valid | California, USA | |
M. disjuncta Hartman, 1961 | GQ497549 | valid | California, USA | |
M. fauchaldi Glasby & Hutchings, 2010 | KX172165 | valid | North Australia | |
M. kristiani Zanol et al., 2016 | KX172141 | valid | Cowan Creek, Australia | |
M. mossambica (Peters, 1854) | KX172164 | valid | Australia | |
M. mullawa Hutchings & Karageorgopoulos, 2003 | KX172166 | valid | Careel Bay, Australia | |
M. pseudosessiloa Zanol, da Silva & Hutchings, 2017 | KY605405 | valid | Careel Bay, Australia | |
M. victori Lavesque, Daffe, Bonifácio & Hutchings, 2017 | MG384997 | valid | Arcachon, France | |
M. viridis Treadwell, 1917 | GQ497553 | valid | Ceará, Brazil | |
M. sanguinea (Montagu, 1813) | GQ497547 | valid | Callot Island, France | |
MK541904 | valid | Cornwall, UK |
|
|
MK950851 | valid | Cornwall, UK |
|
|
MK950852 | valid | Cornwall, UK | MNRJP002048 | |
MK950853 | valid | Arcachon, France |
|
|
MK967470 | valid | Brest, France |
|
|
MH826265 | invalid | USA | ||
KP255196 | invalid | USA | ||
KR916873 | invalid | Portugal | ||
AY040708 | invalid | ? | ||
KY129890 | invalid | East China Sea | ||
KY129891 | invalid | East China Sea | ||
KF733802 | invalid | Yellow Sea, China | ||
EU352317 | invalid | China? | ||
EU352316 | invalid | China? |
First of all, molecular analysis distinguished M. sanguinea from other species with sequences available in GenBank (Fig.
Finally, a comparison of sequences of COI of a specimen from the type locality (
This study provides a molecular baseline for future taxonomic works. Among the M. sanguinea sequences in GenBank, molecular analyses only confirmed the identification of sequence GQ497547 (
This study, therefore, confirms the presence of M. sanguinea along the French coasts, from the English Channel to the Bay of Biscay. Except for specimens from the French part of the English Channel (
Among the GenBank sequences that have been misidentified as M. sanguinea, the most astonishing is the sequence that is part of the complete mitochondrial genome of a species from the coast of the Yellow Sea (China) (GenBank accession number: KF733802) (
As well as being (wrongly) considered as a cosmopolitan species for decades (
Authors wish to thank sailors of ‘Planula IV’ for their help during sampling. We would like to thank Sue Lindsay who mounted the parapodia for the SEM and took the images, and Ingo Burghardt for his support with molecular analysis. We also deeply thank Keith Hiscock (Marine Biological Association UK) and Jason Hall-Spencer (Plymouth University) for their essential help during the sampling in Cornwall. Finally, we also thank Chris Glasby, Idris Izwandy, and an anonymous reviewer to provide helpful comments on the submitted manuscript.