Research Article |
Corresponding author: Christina I. Ellison ( cellison@uoregon.edu ) Academic editor: Jon Norenburg
© 2024 Christina I. Ellison, Madeline R. Frey, Eric Sanford, Svetlana Maslakova.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Ellison CI, Frey MR, Sanford E, Maslakova S (2024) Ribbon worms (phylum Nemertea) from Bodega Bay, California: A largely undescribed diversity. ZooKeys 1204: 15-64. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1204.117869
|
The diversity of nemerteans along the Pacific coast of the United States is regarded as well characterized, but there remain many cryptic, undescribed, and “orphan” species (those known only in their larval form). Recent sampling of nemerteans in Oregon and Washington has begun to fill in these taxonomic gaps, but nemertean diversity in California has received relatively little attention over the past 60 years. During the summers of 2019 and 2020, nemertean specimens were collected from 20 locations in the Bodega Bay region of northern California, USA, including rocky intertidal shores, sandy beaches, mudflats, and other habitats. Based on morphological assessment and DNA sequence analysis (partial Cytochrome Oxidase I and 16S rRNA genes), our surveys identified 34 nemertean species. Only 13 of these (38%) can be confidently assigned to described species. Another 11 represent species that are new to science, including members of the genera Riserius, Nipponnemertes, Poseidonemertes, Zygonemertes, Nemertellina, Oerstedia, and three species of uncertain affiliation. The remaining ten species include undescribed or cryptic species of uncertain status that have been found previously along the Pacific Coast of North America. Our surveys also document extensions of known geographic ranges for multiple species, including the first records in California of Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola, Cephalothrix hermaphroditica, and Maculaura oregonensis. This is the first report of the genus Nemertellina in the northeast Pacific and Riserius in California. Overall, our findings highlight how much remains to be learned about the diversity and distribution of nemerteans in the northeast Pacific.
Biodiversity, cryptic species, Hoplonemertea, invertebrate, marine, Palaeonemertea, Pilidiophora
Nemerteans, or ribbon worms, are a phylum of approximately 1300 species (
Nemerteans are challenging to identify given their relatively small number of external features, many of which do not fall into discrete character states (e.g., color and shape of body), and the fact that many species have been described and are known only from histological study of formalin-preserved material. The phylum is known to possess large numbers of cryptic species, that is, morphologically indistinguishable, but nevertheless distinct, species (e.g.,
The nemertean fauna of the Cold Temperate Northern Pacific province (as per
The Bodega Bay region in northern California supports biodiverse ecosystems including rocky shores, kelp forests, sandy beaches, seagrass beds, and mudflats. The diversity of nemerteans in the Bodega Bay region has received some attention historically. A student report by
During the summers of 2019 and 2020, we collected samples from 20 locations around Bodega Bay, California (Fig.
Nemertean collection locations in the Bodega Bay region. Locations #8 and #11–#18 are within the Bodega Marine Reserve.
Station | GPS Coordinates | Site Description |
---|---|---|
1 | 38.2573, -122.9713 | Dillon Beach: wave-exposed, intertidal habitat with boulders and rocky outcrops |
2 | 38.3055, -123.0171 | Pinnacle Gulch: wave-exposed, intertidal habitat with boulders and rocky outcrops |
3 | 38.3064, -123.0514 | Doran Beach: subtidal, soft sediment habitat |
4 | 38.3059, -123.0524 | Bodega Harbor North Jetty: intertidal jetty with boulders |
5 | 38.3106, -123.0556 | Bodega Harbor: intertidal flats with soft sediments |
6 | 38.3131, -123.0514 | Bodega Harbor, near Coast Guard dock: intertidal breakwater with boulders |
7 | 38.3141, -123.0515 | Bodega Harbor, near Coast Guard dock: intertidal breakwater with boulders |
8 | 38.3135, -123.0543 | Bodega Harbor, Gaffney Point: intertidal flats with soft sediments |
9 | 38.3289, -123.0573 | Bodega Harbor, Spud Point Marina: subtidal fouling community on floating docks |
10 | 38.3002, -123.0617 | Bodega Head, south end: wave-exposed, rocky intertidal habitat with shaded caves |
11 | 38.3150, -123.0712 | Bodega Head, Horseshoe Cove: subtidal holdfasts of bull kelp (Nereocystis luetkeana) |
12 | 38.3159, -123.0693 | Bodega Head, south side of Horseshoe Cove: rocky intertidal benches, among the roots of surfgrass (Phyllospadix sp.) |
13 | 38.3162, -123.0691 | Bodega Head, Horseshoe Cove Beach: intertidal sandy beach with coarse sediments |
14 | 38.3168, -123.0709 | Bodega Head, north side of Horseshoe Cove: rocky intertidal benches, among the roots of surfgrass (Phyllospadix sp.) |
15 | 38.3161, -123.0719 | Bodega Head, Horseshoe Cove Point: wave-exposed rocky intertidal benches at northern edge of the cove |
16 | 38.3185, -123.0740 | Bodega Head: wave-exposed rocky intertidal benches |
17 | 38.3235, -123.0785 | Bodega Head, Mussel Point: wave-exposed rocky intertidal benches |
18 | 38.3231, -123.0766 | Bodega Head: rocky intertidal benches south of Salmon Creek Beach |
19 | 38.3631, -123.0709 | Coleman Beach: wave-exposed, intertidal habitat with boulders and rocky outcrops |
20 | 38.3747, -123.0789 | Schoolhouse Beach: wave-exposed, intertidal habitat with boulders and rocky outcrops |
Species identity, collection location, and accession numbers of nemertean specimens from Bodega Bay, CA. “Station” refers to collection location (Fig.
Specimen ID | OTU (ASAP subset) | Species ID | Station | BOLD process ID | GenBank accession number | USNM voucher |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
B01 | BOBA001 | Maculaura oregonensis Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | 6 | NONEP001-21 | COI: OQ075685 16S: OQ075747 | USNM 1673940 |
B02 | BOBA009 | Paranemertes sp. BOBA009 | 6 | NONEP002-21 | COI: OQ075698 16S: OQ075759 | USNM 1673941 |
B03 | BOBA011 | Nemertellina sp. BOBA011 | 6 | NONEP003-21 | COI: OQ075690 16S: OQ075753 | N/A |
B04 | BOBA029 | Tetrastemma sp. BOBA029 | 6 | NONEP004-21 | COI: OQ075707 | N/A |
B05 | BOBA012 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012 | 6 | NONEP005-21 | COI: OQ075710 16S: OQ075767 | N/A |
B06 | BOBA012 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012 | 6 | NONEP006-21 | COI: OQ075709 | N/A |
B07 | BOBA014 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 | 6 | NONEP007-21 | COI: OQ075721 16S: OQ075778 | N/A |
B08 | BOBA014 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 | 6 | NONEP008-21 | COI: OQ075717 16S: OQ075774 | N/A |
B09 | BOBA012 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012 | 6 | NONEP009-21 | 16S: OQ075773 | N/A |
B10 | BOBA031 | Tubulanus sexlineatus (Griffin, 1898) | 10 | NONEP010-21 | COI: OQ075708 16S: OQ075766 | USNM 1673942 |
B11 | BOBA007 | Riserius sp. BOBA007 | 13 | NONEP011-21 | COI: OQ075703 16S: OQ075764 | USNM 1673943 |
B12 | BOBA025 | Cephalothrix simula (Iwata, 1952) | 9 | NONEP012-21 | COI: OQ075671 16S: OQ075732 | USNM 1673944 |
B13 | BOBA026 | Cephalothrix hermaphroditica (Gibson, Sánchez & Méndez, 1990) | 15 | NONEP013-21 | COI: OQ075668 16S: OQ075729 | USNM 1673945 |
B14 | BOBA010 | Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA010 | 3 | NONEP014-21 | COI: OQ075700 16S: OQ075761 | USNM 1673946 |
B15 | BOBA016 | Eumonostilifera sp. BOBA016 | 9 | NONEP015-21 | COI: OQ075687 16S: OQ075750 | USNM 1673947 |
B16 | BOBA027 | Emplectonema viride Stimpson, 1857 | 1 | NONEP016-21 | COI: OQ075674 16S: OQ075735 | USNM 1673948 |
B18 | BOBA021 | Tetrastemma bilineatum Coe, 1904 | 1 | NONEP017-21 | COI: OQ075705 | USNM 1673949 |
B19 | BOBA006 | Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015 | 16 | NONEP018-21 | COI: OQ075682 16S: OQ075743 | USNM 1673950 |
B20 | BOBA017 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA017 | 16 | NONEP019-21 | COI: OQ075662 16S: OQ075723 | USNM 1673951 |
B21 | BOBA011 | Nemertellina sp. BOBA011 | 9 | NONEP020-21 | COI: OQ075691 16S: OQ075754 | N/A |
BON01 | BOBA019 | Tetrastemma nigrifrons Coe, 1904 | 17 | NONEP021-21 | COI: OQ075706 | USNM 1673952 |
BON02 | BOBA002 | Micrura verrilli | 18 | NONEP022-21 | COI: OQ075686 16S: OQ075748 | USNM 1673953 |
BON03 | BOBA003 | Kulikovia sp. BOBA003 | 10 | NONEP023-21 | COI: OQ075675 16S: OQ075736 | USNM 1673954 |
BON04 | BOBA026 | Cephalothrix hermaphroditica (Gibson, Sánchez & Méndez, 1990) | 10 | NONEP024-21 | COI: OQ075670 16S: OQ075731 | USNM 1673955 |
BON06 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 6 | NONEP025-21 | COI: OQ075679 16S: OQ075740 | USNM 1673956 |
BON10 | BOBA001 | Maculaura oregonensis Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | 8 | NONEP026-21 | 16S: OQ075746 | USNM 1673957 |
BON11 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 8 | NONEP027-21 | COI: OQ075681 16S: OQ075742 | USNM 1673958 |
BON13 | BOBA028 | Nipponnemertes sp. BOBA028 | 7 | NONEP028-21 | COI: OQ075693 16S: OQ075756 | USNM 1673959 |
BON16 | BOBA018 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA018 | 19 | NONEP029-21 | COI: OQ075660 16S: OQ075722 | USNM 1673960 |
BON24 | BOBA032 | Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905 | 8 | NONEP030-21 | COI: OQ075667 16S: OQ075728 | USNM 1673961 |
BON27 | BOBA013 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013 | 7 | NONEP031-21 | COI: OQ075716 16S: OQ075772 | N/A |
BON32 | BOBA022 | Oerstedia sp. BOBA022 | 4 | NONEP032-21 | COI: OQ075694 16S: OQ075757 | N/A |
BON33 | BOBA022 | Oerstedia sp. BOBA022 | 4 | NONEP033-21 | COI: OQ075695 16S: OQ075758 | N/A |
BON35 | BOBA033 | Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA033 | 8 | NONEP034-21 | COI: OQ075699 16S: OQ075760 | USNM 1673962 |
BON36 | BOBA024 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA024 | 18 | NONEP035-21 | COI: OQ075658 | USNM 1673963 |
BON38 | BOBA026 | Cephalothrix hermaphroditica (Gibson, Sánchez & Méndez, 1990) | 18 | NONEP036-21 | COI: OQ075669 16S: OQ075730 | USNM 1673964 |
BON40 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 2 | NONEP037-21 | COI: OQ075680 16S: OQ075741 | USNM 1673965 |
BON41 | BOBA034 | Micrura wilsoni (Coe, 1904) | 7 | NONEP038-21 | 16S: OQ075749 | USNM 1673966 |
BON44 | BOBA018 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA018 | 18 | NONEP039-21 | COI: OQ075663 | USNM 1673967 |
BON47 | BOBA017 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA017 | 18 | NONEP040-21 | COI: OQ075661 | USNM 1673968 |
BON50 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 2 | NONEP041-21 | COI: OQ075676 16S: OQ075737 | USNM 1673969 |
BON51 | BOBA025 | Cephalothrix simula (Iwata, 1952) | 9 | NONEP042-21 | COI: OQ075672 16S: OQ075733 | USNM 1673970 |
BON59 | BOBA004 | Siphonenteron gen. sp. BOBA004 | 15 | NONEP043-21 | COI: OQ075704 16S: OQ075765 | USNM 1673971 |
BON60 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 15 | NONEP044-21 | COI: OQ075677 16S: OQ075738 | USNM 1673972 |
BON61 | BOBA024 | Amphiporus sp. BOBA024 | 14 | NONEP045-21 | COI: OQ075659 | USNM 1673973 |
BON62 | BOBA015 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015 | 14 | NONEP046-21 | COI: OQ075715 | USNM 1673974 |
BON63 | BOBA015 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015 | 14 | NONEP047-21 | COI: OQ075714 16S: OQ075771 | N/A |
BON64 | BOBA007 | Riserius sp. BOBA007 | 13 | NONEP048-21 | COI: OQ075701 16S: OQ075762 | USNM 1673975 |
BON65 | BOBA007 | Riserius sp. BOBA007 | 13 | NONEP049-21 | COI: OQ075702 16S: OQ075763 | USNM 1673976 |
BON67 | BOBA023 | Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola (Stricker, 1985) | 14 | NONEP050-21 | COI: OQ075664 16S: OQ075724 | USNM 1673977 |
BON68 | BOBA023 | Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola (Stricker, 1985) | 14 | NONEP051-21 | COI: OQ075665 16S: OQ075725 | USNM 1673978 |
BON69 | BOBA011 | Nemertellina sp. BOBA011 | 14 | NONEP052-21 | COI: OQ075689 16S: OQ075752 | N/A |
BON70 | BOBA008 | Cerebratulus sp. BOBA008 | 5 | NONEP053-21 | COI: OQ075673 16S: OQ075734 | USNM 1673979 |
BON75 | BOBA020 | Tetrastemma sp. BOBA020 | 13 | NONEP054-21 | COI: OQ075688 16S: OQ075751 | N/A |
BON76 | BOBA013 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013 | 10 | NONEP055-21 | COI: OQ075718 16S: OQ075775 | USNM 1673986 |
BON77 | BOBA030 | Ototyphlonemertes sp. BOBA030 | 13 | NONEP056-21 | COI: OQ075696 | N/A |
BON78 | BOBA030 | Ototyphlonemertes sp. BOBA030 | 13 | NONEP057-21 | COI: OQ075697 | N/A |
BON80 | BOBA013 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013 | 10 | NONEP058-21 | COI: OQ075719 16S: OQ075776 | USNM 1673980 |
BON81 | BOBA015 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015 | 10 | NONEP059-21 | COI: OQ075720 16S: OQ075777 | USNM 1673981 |
BON83 | BOBA006 | Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | 12 | NONEP060-21 | COI: OQ075684 16S: OQ075745 | USNM 1673982 |
BON85 | BOBA006 | Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | 12 | NONEP061-21 | COI: OQ075683 16S: OQ075744 | USNM 1673983 |
BON86 | BOBA005 | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | 10 | NONEP062-21 | COI: OQ075678 16S: OQ075739 | USNM 1673984 |
BON87 | BOBA013 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013 | 11 | NONEP063-21 | COI: OQ075711 16S: OQ075768 | N/A |
BON88 | BOBA014 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 | 6 | NONEP064-21 | COI: OQ075712 16S: OQ075769 | USNM 1673985 |
BON91 | BOBA014 | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 | 6 | NONEP065-21 | COI: OQ075713 16S: OQ075770 | N/A |
BON93 | BOBA032 | Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905 | 8 | NONEP066-21 | 16S: OQ075726 | USNM 1673987 |
BON94 | BOBA032 | Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905 | 8 | NONEP067-21 | COI: OQ075666 16S: OQ075727 | USNM 1673988 |
BON95 | BOBA028 | Nipponnemertes sp. BOBA028 | 7 | NONEP068-21 | COI: OQ075692 16S: OQ075755 | USNM 1673989 |
We selected the locations to encompass a variety of habitat types, including rocky substrate and soft sediments in both wave-exposed/outer coast and wave-protected, estuarine/harbor environments. Most of our collections were from the intertidal zone, but some subtidal collections were made as well. In the field, we haphazardly searched for visible nemerteans and additionally collected complex habitat material to extract small worms in the laboratory. Complex material (e.g., sedentary/colonial animals, algal holdfasts, surfgrass roots, sand, mud, etc.) was collected in the field and placed into sealed plastic bags. In the laboratory, we transferred these materials into clear aquaria, and covered the material with seawater. These samples were left for several days and checked regularly to remove any nemerteans observed crawling on the walls or water’s surface. After several days, we broke apart and sorted through complex habitat material to remove hidden worms. Colonial ascidians and other invertebrates from samples of benthic communities tended to deteriorate rapidly in the laboratory and caused any nemertean specimens to become unusable, so these materials were sorted soon after collection.
Photographs and videos of worms were taken using a Leica MC170HD digital camera mounted to a Leica M125 dissecting microscope or a Leica DM1000 compound microscope, with accompanying software (Leica Application Suite v. 4.4). For hoplonemerteans, the stylet and basis of living specimens were photographed, when possible, using a compound microscope. We made initial species identifications using available morphological keys and geographically relevant inventories of Nemertea (
We extracted DNA from 76 individuals using DNEasy Blood and Tissue Kit (Qiagen) following the manufacturer’s protocol. We attempted to PCR–amplify portions of two mitochondrial genes, cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) and 16S rRNA, from each individual, using universal and nemertean–specific primers (Table
Locus | Primer name | Primer sequence | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
COI | LCO1490 HCO2198 | 5’ GGTCAACAAATCATAAAGATATTGG 5’ TAAACTTCAGGGTGACCAAAAAATCA |
|
COI | COI LF | 5’ TTTCAACAAATCATAAAGATAT 5’ GAGAAATAATACCAAAACCAGG |
|
COI DR | |||
16S | 16SARL 16SBRH | 5’ CGCCTGTTTATCAAAAACAT 5’ CCGGTCTGAACTCAGATCACGT |
|
16S | 16S AF 16S KR | 5’ TCGTCTGTTTATCAAAAACATAGY 5’ AATAGATAGAAACCAACCTGGC |
|
Each PCR was performed in a 20 μl volume, with 1 unit per reaction of Go Taq Polymerase (Promega) with supplied buffer, 200 μM dNTPs, and 500 nM of each primer. We used the following thermocycle profile: 95 °C 2 min; 34 cycles of: 95 °C 40 s, 45 °C (COI) 48–50 °C (16S) 40 s, and 72 °C 1 min; followed by final extension for 2 min (72 °C). Some DNA extracts required dilution (~ 1:20) for PCR success. PCR products were assessed with gel electrophoresis, purified with Wizard SV Gel and PCR Clean Up Kit (Promega), and sequenced at Sequetech (Mountain View, CA) in both directions using PCR primers. We used Geneious Prime for sequence analysis. Sequences with initial HQ < 50% were discarded. Each sequence was manually trimmed to eliminate primers and low–quality end regions. Forward and reverse strands were aligned, proofread against each other using quality PHRED scores and chromatograms, and contigs used to generate consensus sequences. Nucleotides with combined PHRED score of less than 20 in consensus sequences were trimmed off or converted to “N”. We translated each COI nucleotide sequence into amino acids using the Invertebrate Mitochondrial translation table and checked for the presence of stop codons.
Consensus sequences were checked against the NCBI database (GenBank) using nucleotide BLAST to screen for contamination and to aid with specimen identification. A 4% p-distance divergence was previously identified as appropriate for species delineation in large scale COI-barcoding studies of nemerteans (e.g.,
Of the 76 specimens from which DNA was extracted, we were able to successfully obtain sequences from 68; a total of 64 COI sequences and 57 16S sequences (see Table
Nemertean species identified from Bodega Bay, California. The term “unresolved” refers to cryptic species of uncertain taxonomic status.
Class | Species | Status | OTU code (this study) | BOLD Barcode Identification Number (BIN) |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Palaeonemertea | Cephalothrix hermaphroditica (Gibson, Sánchez & Méndez, 1990) | described | BOBA026 | BOLD:ADM3467 | - |
Palaeonemertea | Cephalothrix simula (Iwata, 1952) | described | BOBA025 | BOLD:AAM5519 | - |
Palaeonemertea | Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905 | described | BOBA032 | BOLD:AEJ8707 | - |
Palaeonemertea | Tubulanus sexlineatus (Griffin, 1898) | described | BOBA031 | BOLD:ADM0945 | OTU 83 |
Pilidiophora | Cerebratulus sp. BOBA008 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA008 | BOLD:AAE9633 | OTU 62 |
Pilidiophora | Kulikovia sp. BOBA003 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA003 | BOLD:ADX1401 | OTU 49 |
Pilidiophora | Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | described | BOBA006 | BOLD:AAP1201 | OTU 54 |
Pilidiophora | Maculaura oregonensis Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a | described | BOBA001 | BOLD:ADM2641 | OTU 61 |
Pilidiophora | Riserius sp. BOBA007 | new to science | BOBA007 | BOLD:AEJ1230 | - |
Pilidiophora | Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904 | described | BOBA005 | BOLD:ADS0049 | OTU 45 |
Pilidiophora | Micrura verrilli Coe, 1901 | described | BOBA002 | BOLD:ADW4746 | OTU 65 |
Pilidiophora | Micrura wilsoni (Coe, 1904) | described | BOBA034 | BOLD:ADW9830 | OTU 90 |
Pilidiophora | Siphonenteron gen. sp. BOBA004 | new to science | BOBA004 | BOLD:ADR9817 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Nipponnemertes sp. BOBA028 | new to science | BOBA028 | BOLD:AEJ7531 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Amphiporus sp. BOBA024 | new to science | BOBA024 | BOLD:AEI5687 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Amphiporus sp. BOBA017 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA017 | BOLD:ADR7530 | OTU 6 |
Hoplonemertea | Amphiporus sp. BOBA018 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA018 | BOLD:AEA1922 | OTU 5 |
Hoplonemertea | Emplectonema viride Stimpson, 1857 | described | BOBA027 | BOLD:AAP1200 | OTU 17 |
Hoplonemertea | Ototyphlonemertes sp. BOBA030 | previously reported, unresolved | BOBA030 | BOLD:ADM3126 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Paranemertes sp. BOBA009 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA009 | BOLD:ADM0221 | OTU 10 |
Hoplonemertea | Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA010 | new to science | BOBA010 | BOLD:AEK1697 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA033 | new to science | BOBA033 | BOLD:AEK1698 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Tetrastemma nigrifrons Coe, 1904 | described | BOBA019 | BOLD:ADX0572 | OTU 18 |
Hoplonemertea | Tetrastemma sp. BOBA029 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA029 | BOLD:ADW8618 | OTU 20 |
Hoplonemertea | Tetrastemma sp. BOBA020 | new to science | BOBA020 | BOLD:AEJ7493 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012 | previously reported, unresolved | BOBA012 | BOLD:ADL9636 | OTU 23 |
Hoplonemertea | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013 | previously reported, unresolved | BOBA013 | BOLD:ADW7912 | OTU 26 |
Hoplonemertea | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 | new to science | BOBA014 | BOLD:AEK0256 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015 | new to science | BOBA015 | BOLD:AEJ0120, BOLD:ADR7155 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Eumonostilifera sp. BOBA016 | previously reported, undescribed | BOBA016 | BOLD:AEJ6897 | OTU 13 |
Hoplonemertea | Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola (Stricker, 1985) | described | BOBA023 | BOLD:ACH3602 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Nemertellina sp. BOBA011 | new to science | BOBA011 | BOLD:AEJ4336 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Oerstedia sp. BOBA022 | new to science | BOBA022 | BOLD:AEJ2779 | - |
Hoplonemertea | Tetrastemma bilineatum Coe, 1904 | described | BOBA021 | BOLD:ADW8130 | OTU 29 |
Because of the ubiquitous presence of cryptic species among nemerteans, species distributions listed below refer to reports verified by DNA sequence data, unless otherwise noted. Undescribed species, as well as species of uncertain status, were assigned temporary alphanumeric OTU codes (e.g., BOBA0XX) for tracking purposes, until their taxonomy is resolved.
Order Archinemertea Iwata, 1960
Family Cephalotrichidae McIntosh, 1873
Genus Cephalothrix Örsted, 1843
A species-rich genus of mostly white, thread-like worms, which have a long pre-oral region and lack ocelli as adults. Given their general lack of distinguishing features, the species therein are difficult to differentiate morphologically (e.g.,
Cephalothrix hermaphroditica (Gibson, Sánchez & Méndez, 1990)
Procephalothrix hermaphroditicus
Cephalothrix hermaphroditicus:
BIN. BOLD:ADM3467.
Material examined. B13, BON4, BON38.
Morphology. Filiform body, 15–51 mm long. Body color orange with translucent margins, somewhat paler ventrally, with a deeper orange anterior tip (Fig.
Identification. Our specimens share high sequence similarity (99–100% COI) with specimens reported as C. hermaphroditicus from Chile (KU840171), France (MH681952), Spain (KM230034), and Argentina (KM230037). The type locality of the species is Cocholgue, Chile, but given the comparatively low haplotype diversity in Chile, and high haplotype diversity in France,
Habitat. Collected from wave-exposed, rocky intertidal habitats, among colonial ascidians. Stations 10, 15, 18 (Fig.
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study); Coquimbo, Chile (
Notes. The only available sequences of Cephalothrix hermaphroditica from Chile were collected ~ 1,000 km north of its type locality. Given that biogeographical patterns among nemertean species are variable, we tentatively include the species as synonymous with the species we encountered in our surveys. This is the first report of the species in the Cold Temperate Northern Pacific, and first 16S barcode for the species. Cephalothrix hermaphroditica provides the only known example of hermaphrodism among the Palaeonemertea. Reproductive features were not observed by us.
Cephalothrix simula (Iwata, 1952)
Procephalothrix simulus Iwata, 1952: 132.
Cephalothrix simula:
Cephalothrix simula:
Cephalothrix sp.:
BIN. BOLD:AAM5519.
Material examined. B12, BON51.
Morphology. Filiform body, ~ 50 mm long, pale yellowish to orange, color brighter in the head and foregut regions, paler and somewhat translucent posteriorly (Fig.
Identification. Our specimens share high (99.6% COI) sequence similarity to the topogenetype of C. simula (GU726622), and other C. simula sequences, as defined by
Habitat. Collected among fouling organisms on marina docks (station 9).
Distribution. Changdao, China (
Notes. Previously reported from southern California (
Order Tubulaniformes Chernyshev, 1995
Family Carinomellidae Chernyshev, 1995
Genus Carinomella Coe, 1905
A monotypic genus. Morphology resembles Tubulanus; likely related to Carinella, Parahubrechtia and other unpigmented tubulanids (
Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905
Carinomella lactea Coe, 1905: 127, pls V–XI, figs 45–61, 63–72.
BIN. BOLD:AEJ8707.
Material examined. BON24, BON93, BON94.
Morphology. Eyeless white worm 65–87 mm long (Fig.
Identification. Specimens at hand most resemble Carinomella lactea described by
Habitat. Mudflats. Collected among polychaete tubes on intertidal mudflats, just below the surface of the sediments (station 8).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study). The species has been reported from the Atlantic (
Notes. Species not previously sequenced.
Family Tubulanidae sensu Chernyshev, 2022
Genus Tubulanus Renier, 1804
Tubulanus sexlineatus (Griffin, 1898)
Carinella sexlineata Griffin, 1898: 201, fig. 15;
Carinella dinema Coe, 1901: 15, pl. I, figs 2, 3.
BIN. BOLD:ADM0945.
Material examined. B10.
Morphology. Slender reddish brown worm with elaborate white markings (Fig.
Identification. Morphology agrees with Tubulanus sexlineatus, a species described from Puget Sound, Washington and Alaska, and DNA sequences show high percent similarity to previously published sequences of T. sexlineatus. Also resembles T. punctatus (Takakura, 1898) from Japan, and T. superbus (Kölliker, 1845) from the Mediterranean. Two described Tubulanus species from the northeast Pacific with similar coloration have no published sequences but can be differentiated from T. sexlineatus by pattern: T. cingulatus (Coe, 1904) is deep brown, with four dorsal longitudinal white lines, and T. capistratus (Coe, 1901) is brown with many narrow white rings, and only three white longitudinal lines (
Habitat. Relatively common in the Bodega Bay region. Collected from the wave-exposed, rocky intertidal zone, among colonial ascidians (stations 2, 10, 15), and observed among surfgrass roots (stations 12, 14), kelp holdfasts (station 7), and on the underside of rocks in pale cellophane-like tubes of its own secretion (station 2, 7).
Distribution. Discovery Island, BC, Canada (QHAK2597-22, QHAK2649-22 in BOLD); Puget Sound, WA, USA (
Order Heteronemertea Bürger, 1892
Family Lineidae
Genus Cerebratulus Renier, 1804
Cerebratulus is one of three non-monophyletic mega-genera in the Class Pilidiophora, with Lineus and Micrura (e.g., see
Cerebratulus sp. BOBA008
Cerebratulus marginatus:
Cerebratulus cf. marginatus:
BIN. BOLD:AAE9633.
Material examined. BON70.
Morphology. Large (25 cm long), dorsoventrally flattened dull reddish brown worm with lateral margins distinct both in color (pale) and shape (flattened). Spade-shaped head bordered by deep cephalic slits, with a long slit-like mouth located posterior to their endings on the ventral side (Fig.
Pilidiophoran nemerteans of Bodega Bay A, B Riserius sp. BOBA007, a new species, individual BON064 B close up of head in transmitted light showing ocelli (arrowhead) C Cerebratulus sp. BOBA008, individual BON070, ventrolateral view of head D Maculaura cerebrosa, individual BON085 E Maculaura oregonensis, individual B1 F Kulikovia sp. BOBA003, anterior end of individual BON003 G Micrura wilsoni, individual BON041 H Micrura verrilli, individual BON002 I, J Siphonenteron gen. sp. BOBA004, a new species, individual BON059 J close up of anterior end, showing ocelli (arrowhead) K–M Lineus flavescens K, L individual BON040 L close up of head showing ocelli (arrowhead) M individual BON006, a color morph with a white anterior patch and reddish ocelli. Abbreviations: cg – cerebral ganglia, cs – cephalic slit, m – mouth, pp – proboscis pore.
Identification. A common intertidal mudflat species, previously reported from Washington and Oregon as Cerebratulus marginatus or Cerebratulus cf. marginatus (
Habitat. Intertidal mudflats in areas with sandy sediments; often > 30 cm below the surface (station 5).
Distribution. Discovery Islands, BC, Canada (QHAK2554-22 in BOLD), Puget Sound, WA, USA (
Genus Kulikovia
Kulikovia sp. BOBA003
Lineus sp.:
Lineus sp. 2:
BIN. BOLD:ADX1401.
Material examined. BON3.
Morphology. Body 27 cm long, reddish brown with a white anterior tip (Fig.
Identification. Resembles Kulikovia spp., and several other species in the Siphonenteron clade (see Lineidae incertae sedis below). COI sequences show that it is conspecific (99–100% similarity) with one of two sister lineages previously reported from southern Oregon in their larval form as Lineus sp. 2 by
Habitat. Collected from a sandy, low intertidal pool, under stones (station 10).
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. This is the first record of the species in California.
Genus Maculaura Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a
The genus Maculaura was erected for five cryptic species occurring in NE Pacific that were previously recognized under the name Micrura alaskensis Coe, 1901. A phylogenetic analysis by
Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a
Maculaura cerebrosa Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a: 628, fig. 4G–J.
BIN. BOLD:AAP1201.
Material examined. B19, BON83, BON85.
Morphology. Body 15–18 mm long. Anterior tip white, with lateral cephalic slits, no ocelli, and pink cerebral ganglia visible through the body wall (Fig.
Identification. Bodega Bay individuals conform to the morphological description of Maculaura spp., and COI sequences exhibit 99–100% similarity to those of M. cerebrosa from Oregon (
Habitat. Collected from the open coast among the roots of surfgrass (Phyllospadix sp., station 12) and in mid-intertidal mussel beds (station 16). In southern Oregon, this species has also been found within estuaries, especially under rocks at the edges of mudflats (
Distribution. Wrangell, AK, USA (MOBIL9484-19 in BOLD); Bamfield, BC, Canada (OPQCS038-10 in BOLD); Charleston, OR, USA; Crescent City, CA, USA (
Maculaura oregonensis Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a
Maculaura oregonensis Hiebert & Maslakova, 2015a: 630, 4L–Q.
BIN. BOLD:ADM2641.
Material examined. B1.
Morphology. Body ~ 18 mm long; anterior tip white, eyeless, with lateral cephalic slits, the rest of the body pink. Anterior tip rounded in extension, head not demarcated from the body. Cerebral ganglia rosy and visible through the body wall (Fig.
Identification. Bodega Bay individuals conform to the morphological description of Maculaura spp., and COI sequences exhibit > 99% similarity to those of M. oregonensis from Oregon (
Habitat. Collected from Bodega Harbor within the holdfast of subtidal Giant Kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) at a depth of 3–4 m (station 6). In Oregon, individuals have also been found intertidally in sand and mud (
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. This is the first record of the species in California.
Genus Riserius Norenburg, 1993
Riserius is the only known genus of Pilidiophora to exhibit a mesopsammic lifestyle, i.e., living interstitially among sand grains. Its members display a curious suite of features: lack of cutis, cerebral organs opening via lateral pits rather than longitudinal slits, and a transverse cephalic furrow that encircles the body in front of the mouth. Possesses a unique sock-like pilidium recurvatum larva (
Riserius sp. BOBA007
BIN. BOLD:AEJ1230.
Material examined. B11, BON64, BON65.
Morphology. Thread-like cream-colored worm, 50–100 mm long (Fig.
Identification. Morphology of our specimens agrees with that of Riserius spp. (
Habitat. Collected on wave-exposed, sandy beaches from among very coarse sand in the low intertidal zone at ~ -0.15 m to +0.30 m above Mean Lower Low Water (MLLW, station 13). Small numbers of individuals were also observed on other local beaches among very coarse sand (station 20).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science. First record of the genus in California.
Lineus and Micrura are non-monophyletic mega-genera within the family Lineidae (e.g., see
Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904
Lineus flavescens Coe, 1904: 184, pl. XVII, figs 3, 4.
BIN. BOLD:ADS0049.
Material examined. BON6, BON11, BON40, BON50, BON60, BON86.
Morphology. Body 8–52 mm long, with significant variation in color: pale (semi-transparent), tan, reddish brown, and rosy-orange varieties observed (Fig.
Identification. The six individuals included here match closely (99–100% similarity, COI) to Lineus flavescens reported from southern Oregon (
Habitat. Collected from among colonial ascidians, algae, and other low intertidal organisms on rocky intertidal shores (stations 2, 6, 10, 15). Also collected just below the surface on intertidal mudflats (station 8).
Distribution. Puget Sound, WA, USA (BBPS722-19 in BOLD); Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. With Kulikovia sp. BOBA003 (above) and Siphonenteron gen. sp. BOBA004 (below), this species belongs to the Siphonenteron clade, defined by
Micrura verrilli Coe, 1901
Lineus striatus Griffin, 1898: 214.
Micrura verrilli Coe, 1901: 68, pl. V, figs 1–3.
BIN. BOLD:ADW4746.
Material examined. BON2.
Morphology. Body ~ 12 cm long, margins and ventral surface white, dorsally with an orange patch at the anterior tip, bordered posteriorly by white, and followed by a broad purple stripe, which is interrupted at intervals by thin, transverse white lines (Fig.
Identification. Morphologically, specimens from Bodega Bay resemble Lineus striatus briefly described by
Habitat. Collected from the low intertidal zone among colonial ascidians (station 18) and observed among kelp holdfasts washed ashore in the Bodega Bay region.
Distribution. Bamfield, BC, Canada (
Notes. The species reported here belongs to a clade of lineids with orange or magenta red anterior tip that may be synonymous with Evelineus (
Micrura wilsoni (Coe, 1904)
Lineus wilsoni Coe, 1904: 195, pl. XVI, figs 10, 11.
BIN. BOLD:ADW9830.
Material examined. BON41.
Morphology. Dark brown worm, ~ 45 mm long, slightly paler ventrally, cephalic lobe bordered by white at the anterior tip and along the lateral cephalic slits; thin white transverse bands at irregular intervals along most of the body length (Fig.
Identification. Conforms to the description of Micrura wilsoni (Coe, 1904), described from Monterey and San Pedro, California. No look-alikes are currently known in the northeast Pacific. Although we were not able to obtain a high–quality COI sequence, 16S rRNA sequence from the Bodega Bay individual is 99–100% identical to those of M. wilsoni reported by
Habitat. Collected from kelp holdfasts (Macrocystis pyrifera) in the subtidal (station 6) and very low intertidal zones (station 7), also among holdfasts of subtidal bull kelp (Nereocystis luetkeana) washed ashore. In southern Oregon found on the exposed rocky shore under boulders and in rock crevices of the low intertidal zone.
Distribution. British Columbia, Canada (Gustav Paulay et al., unpublished BOLD records), Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. According to a recent phylogenetic analysis of the family Lineidae this species is not closely related to the type species of the genus, Micrura fasciolata, but is a member of a clade called “lineid lineage G” by
Siphonenteron gen. sp. BOBA004
BIN. BOLD:ADR9817.
Material examined. BON59.
Morphology. Body 97 mm long, uniformly orange (Fig.
Identification. BON59 resembles other species from the Siphonenteron clade (defined by
Habitat. Collected from a wave-exposed, rocky intertidal habitat among colonial ascidians and coralline algae (station 15).
Distribution. Discovery Island, Canada (QHAK2948-23 in BOLD); Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Order Monostilifera Brinkmann, 1917
Suborder Cratenemertea
Familial classification suspended as per Kajihara, 2021
Genus Nipponnemertes Friedrich, 1968
Of the seven Nipponnemertes species described from the northeast Pacific, N. bimaculata (Coe, 1901), N. drepanophoroides (Griffin, 1898), N. fernaldi Iwata, 2001, N. occidentalis (Coe, 1905), N. pacifica (Coe, 1905), N. punctatula (Coe, 1905), and N. rubella (Coe, 1905), only two have been reported and/or barcoded in recent years, N. bimaculata and N. punctatula. The type locality of the latter species is southern California, but the only available barcodes are from Japan (
Nipponnemertes sp. BOBA028
BIN. BOLD:AEJ7531.
Material examined. BON13, BON95.
Morphology. Body 55–67 mm long, broad, reddish brown dorsally, much paler (almost white) ventrally. Head white, pointed, narrower than the body, with two maroon, triangular pigment patches placed symmetrically on either side of a mid-dorsal ridge (Fig.
Hoplonemerteans of Bodega Bay A Nipponnemertes sp. BOBA028, a new species, individual BON95. Dorsal and ventral (inset) view of the anterior, showing cerebral organ furrows with numerous secondary furrows (arrowhead) and pink cerebral ganglia B Amphiporus sp. BOBA024, a new species, individual BON61. Inset a close up lateral view of the anterior, showing red blood vessels (arrowhead) C, D Amphiporus sp. BOBA018 individual BON44 D close up of head in transmitted light, showing pattern of ocelli E, F Amphiporus sp. BOBA017 individual B20 F close up of head in transmitted light, showing pattern of ocelli G Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA010, a new species, individual B14. Inset a close up of the head showing ocelli H Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA033, a new species, individual BON35, full body. Inset a close up of the head showing ocelli I Tetrastemma nigrifrons, anterior end of BON01 J Tetrastemma sp. BOBA029, close up of head of B04 in transmitted light K Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012, individual B09 L Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014, a new species, close up of anterior of BON88 in reflected light, showing post-cerebral ocelli (arrowheads) M, N Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013, individual BON87 N close up of anterior showing post cerebral ocelli (arrowheads) O Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015, a new species, individual BON63 P Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola, individual BON67 Q Nemertellina sp. BOBA011, new to science, individual BON69 R–S Oerstedia sp. BOBA022, new to science, showing differences in color pattern R individual BON32 S individual BON33 T Tetrastemma bilineatum, individual B18.
Identification. The specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of Nipponnemertes bimaculata (Coe, 1901) except for the shape of the cephalic patches, which are triangular in our specimens as opposed to oval in the original description. However,
Habitat. Collected from the holdfasts of kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) in the very low intertidal zone (station 7).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Familial classification suspended as per
Genus Amphiporus Ehrenberg, 1831
A diverse and non-monophyletic genus of the class Hoplonemertea with 74 species listed in the WoRMS database, many more having been declared nomen dubium, or transferred to other genera (
Amphiporus sp. BOBA024
BIN. BOLD:AEI5687.
Material examined. BON36, BON61.
Morphology. Body slender, 13 mm long, yellowish white (Fig.
Stylets of Hoplonemerteans of Bodega Bay A Amphiporus sp. BOBA024, individual BON61 B Amphiporus sp. BOBA018, individual BON16 C Amphiporus sp. BOBA017, individual B20 D Ototyphlonemertes sp. BOBA030, individual BON78 E Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA010, individual B14 F Tetrastemma nigrifrons, individual BON01 G Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012, individual B06 H Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014, individual B07 I Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013, individual BON76 J Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015, individual BON62 K Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola, individual BON67 L Nemertellina sp. BOBA011, individual BON69 M Oerstedia sp. BOBA022, individual BON32 N Eumonostilifera sp. BOBA016, individual B15 O Tetrastemma sp. BOBA020, individual BON75.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay resemble Amphiporus cruentatus Verrill, 1879, originally described from Vineyard Sound, Massachusetts, but later reported from Puget Sound, Washington to San Diego, California (
Habitat. Collected from wave-exposed rocky shores among surfgrass roots and other low intertidal organisms (stations 14, 18).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Amphiporus imparispinosus Griffin, 1898 species complex
Amphiporus sp. BOBA017
Amphiporus imparispinosus:
BIN. BOLD:ADR7530.
Material examined. B20, BON47.
Morphology. Body 63 mm long, pale yellow to pale peach color (Fig.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of Amphiporus imparispinosus Griffin, 1898 from Port Townsend, Washington and Sitka, Alaska. Two similar species have been described from the northeast Pacific: Amphiporus leuciodus Coe, 1901, from Victoria, BC, Canada and New Metlakatla and Glacier Bay, Alaska, and Amphiporus similis Coe, 1905, from Monterey, California, though Coe later treated the former as a synonym (1905), and the latter as a variety (1940) of A. imparispinosus. Subsequent authors retained all three as valid species (
Habitat. Collected from wave-exposed, rocky intertidal habitats (stations 16, 18), including on holdfasts of the kelp Egregia menziesii and within mid-intertidal mussel beds; among algal turf.
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (
Amphiporus sp. BOBA018
Amphiporus imparispinosus:
BIN. BOLD:AEA1922.
Material examined. BON16, BON44.
Morphology. Body 38–70 mm long, white. Head rounded and wider than body (Fig.
Identification. See Amphiporus sp. BOBA018 above. The presence of three pouches of accessory stylets and the length of the worms suggest that this is not A. similis, but an undescribed cryptic species.
Habitat. Collected from wave-exposed, rocky intertidal habitats (stations 18, 19), including on holdfasts of the kelp Egregia menziesii and crawling across other low intertidal surfaces.
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. This is the first record of the species in California.
Genus Emplectonema Stimpson, 1857
Emplectonema viride Stimpson, 1857
Emplectonema viride Stimpson, 1857: 163.
Emplectonema gracile:
BIN. BOLD:AAP1200.
Material examined. B16.
Morphology. Body long and slender, green dorsally, cream-colored ventrally. Head not especially demarcated from the body. With numerous ocelli distributed along the colorless anterolateral margins of the head. Pink cerebral ganglia. Basis of central stylet much longer than the slightly curved central stylet.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of Emplectonema viride Stimpson, 1857, as redescribed by
Habitat. Collected from a mid-intertidal mussel bed (station 1), and commonly observed in many intertidal habitats throughout the Bodega Bay region. Typically associated with acorn barnacles, which it preys upon.
Distribution: Amaknak (MZ580909) and Fox (MZ580901) Islands, AK, USA; Bamfield (MG423290) and Discovery Islands (QHAK2422-22, QHAK2449-22 in BOLD), BC, Canada; Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. For photographs of this species, see
Genus Ototyphlonemertes Diesing, 1863
Species of Ototyphlonemertes are exclusively mesopsammic, living in the interstices of well-sorted, coarse marine sediments. They are easily distinguished from other small, slender, white eumonostiliferans by the presence of a pair of statocysts in the cerebral ganglia, and the lack of ocelli in adults, but most of the described species appear to represent cryptic species complexes (e.g.,
Ototyphlonemertes sp. BOBA030
Ototyphlonemertes lactea:
BIN. BOLD:ADM3126.
Material examined. BON77, BON78.
Morphology. Body 3.5 mm long and less than 1 mm wide, white; foregut region transparent, intestinal region cream-colored. Head slightly demarcated from the body by a transverse cephalic groove. With a pair of statocysts, one in each of the two ventral cerebral ganglia. Statocysts of the polygranular type. Basis slender, irregularly cylindrical, and longer than the spirally sculpted central stylet (Fig.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of O. americana Gerner, 1969 from Puget Sound, Washington, but DNA sequence data are not available from Puget Sound region to confirm identification. COI sequences from Bodega Bay specimens in this study match closely (> 99% similarity, COI) with a species previously reported from San Diego, California as Ototyphlonemetes lactea by
Habitat. Collected from low intertidal, coarse marine sediments on a wave-exposed sandy beach (station 13).
Distribution. Wright’s Beach, CA, USA (
Genus Paranemertes Coe, 1901
Paranemertes sp. BOBA009
Paranemertes peregrina:
Paranemertes sp.:
BIN. BOLD:ADM0221.
Material examined. B2.
Morphology. Body ~ 5 cm long, orangish purple dorsally, paler ventrally. Head slightly demarcated from the body, with red cerebral ganglia visible through the body wall. Stylet apparatus not observed.
Identification. Paranemertes peregrina is a cryptic species complex composed of at least seven distinct lineages (
Habitat. Collected from kelp holdfasts in shallow subtidal zone within Bodega Harbor (station 6).
Distribution. Unalaska Island, AK, USA (DUTCH345-19 in BOLD); Discovery Islands, BC, Canada (QHAK177-20 in BOLD); Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes.
Genus Poseidonemertes Kirsteuer, 1967
Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA010
BIN. BOLD:AEK1697.
Material examined. B14.
Morphology. Stout, pale, rust-colored worm with thick, clear margins; body widens posteriorly. Anterior end sharply pointed, with two ocelli near its tip (Fig.
Identification. The two Poseidonemertes specimens from this study (B14 and BON35 listed below) resemble Poseidonemertes collaris Roe & Wickham, 1984 described from Bodega Bay, California, and other light-colored members of the genus, e.g., Poseidonemertes maslakovae Chernyshev, 2002 and Poseidonemertes sp. 508 from the Sea of Japan. P. collaris is the only member of the genus previously reported from the Pacific coast of the U.S. COI sequence data suggest B14 represents a distinct OTU (8.2% divergent) from what was reported as P. collaris by
Habitat. Collected just offshore, < 200 m from an open coast beach, among subtidal sand/mud sediments from a depth of 6–7 m (station 3).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Poseidonemertes sp. BOBA033
BIN. BOLD:AEK1698.
Material examined. BON35.
Morphology. Stout, cream-colored worm, ~ 25 mm long, with branched intestinal diverticula, greenish in color, highly visible through the body wall (Fig.
Identification. See B14 above.
Habitat. Collected from an intertidal mudflat, just below the surface of the sediment, among polychaete tubes (station 8).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Genus Tetrastemma Ehrenberg, 1831
This non-monophyletic genus of small four eyed eumonostiliferans containing > 100 species was recently redefined by
Tetrastemma nigrifrons Coe, 1904
Tetrastemma nigrifrons Coe, 1904: 159, pl. XV, fig. 7, pl. XVI, figs 6–9, pl. XVII, fig. 1, pl. XX, fig. 16, pl. XXI, figs 15–23;
Quasitetrastemma nigrifrons Chernyshev, 2004: 154;
BIN. BOLD:ADX0572.
Material examined. BON1.
Morphology. Body 27 mm long, brown dorsally, pale ventrally. Head rounded with colorless margins and a broad brown patch, differentiated only slightly from the body by the colorless transverse band (Fig.
Identification. Fits the description of Tetrastemma nigrifrons Coe, 1904, described from Monterey Bay, California. A look-alike, Tetrastemma stimpsoni Chernyshev, 1992 occurs in the northwest Pacific and the Sea of Japan (
Habitat. Collected from the low intertidal zone among red algal blades and colonies of the kamptozoan Barentsia conferta (station 17). Similar specimens also observed intertidally among low zone tunicates and algae (station 2), kelp holdfasts (station 7), and surfgrass roots (station 14). Subtidally, among organisms on marina docks (station 9).
Distribution. Unalaska, AK, USA (DUTCH209-19 in BOLD); Canada (
Notes. This species has variable coloration, both in terms of pattern and the amount of pigmentation (
Tetrastemma sp. BOBA029
Tetrastemma sp. 1:
Tetrastemma sp.:
BIN. BOLD:ADW8618.
Material examined. B4.
Morphology. Small and slender, transparent, fast-moving worm; internal structures appear yellowish through the body wall. Anterior tip with a small white patch. With four ocelli (Fig.
Identification. Anterior white patch and otherwise featureless body distinguishes this from other species of Tetrastemma reported from northeast Pacific (
Habitat. Collected from Bodega Harbor within the holdfasts of subtidal Giant Kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) at a depth of 3–4 m (station 6). In Oregon, collected from among surfgrass (Phyllospadix spp.) in the rocky intertidal zone (
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. First record of the species in California. This species is very common in southern Oregon. Reproductive individuals were found in July in southern Oregon, and deposited egg masses in laboratory dishes upon collection, with crawl-away juveniles hatching a week or two later.
Tetrastemma sp. BOBA020
BIN. BOLD:AEJ7493.
Material examined. BON75.
Morphology. Body 1.7 mm long, transparent, with an orange gut. With four eyes and two pairs of cephalic furrows: cerebral organ furrows at the level of the posterior pair of eyes, and a V-shaped neck furrow posteriorly, overlying the anterior portion of the cerebral ganglia. Conical basis, significantly longer than the central stylet (Fig.
Identification. Resembles other featureless species of Tetrastemma. COI sequences show it to be distinct from any previously sequenced species.
Habitat. Collected from low intertidal, coarse marine sediments on a wave-exposed sandy beach (station 13).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Genus Zygonemertes Montgomery, 1897
Members of the genus Zygonemertes are distinct from other eumonostiliferans in having a single row of post cerebral ocelli on each side, along the lateral nerve cords, in addition to the more typical ocelli found in rows or groups on the head. In addition, all species we have had the opportunity to examine possess sickle-shaped microscopic inclusions in the epidermis, and most have a characteristically truncated basis of the central stylet.
Three species of Zygonemertes are reported from the northeast Pacific coast: Z. albida Coe, 1901, Z. thalassina Coe, 1901, and Z. virescens (Verrill, 1879). The first two were described by Coe from British Columbia and Alaska, respectively. Zygonemertes thallasina has never been reported outside its type locality, Z. albida was subsequently reported by Coe to occur as far south as Ensenada, Mexico (
Zygonemertes thalassina was regarded as being extremely similar to Z. virescens, except often longer (to 60 mm), darker in color (olive green), with a smaller S/B ratio, a shorter, stubbier central stylet, and with five stylets per accessory pouch, rather than two or three (
Zygonemertes sp. BOBA012
Zygonemertes sp. 1:
Zygonemertes sp.:
Nemertea sp.: Leray and Paulay unpublished (MH242861).
BIN. BOLD:ADL9636.
Material examined. B5, B6, B9.
Morphology. Body somewhat transparent, greenish yellow with clear margins; 15–25 ocelli arranged in two irregular rows on each side of the head, with a single row of post cerebral ocelli on each side along the lateral nerve cords. Cerebral ganglia pink, visible through the body wall (Fig.
Identification. See above on species of Zygonemertes. COI sequences from Bodega Bay specimens match those of Nemertea sp. from Puget Sound, Washington (Paulay and Leray, unpublished, MH242862) and those reported as Zygonemertes sp. 1 (
Habitat. Collected from Bodega Harbor within the holdfasts of subtidal Giant Kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) at a depth of 3–4 m (station 6).
Distribution. Puget Sound, WA, USA (MH242861; Maslakova, unpublished); Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. Species not previously reported from California. In the first round of PCR with universal primers, we apparently amplified the gut contents of these worms, the barnacle Balanus glandula. Like another barnacle-eating nemertean, Emplectonema viride, some specimens of this species have a long, slender basis of central stylet. The basis in this species appears slightly narrower than in other species of Zygonemertes.
Zygonemertes sp. BOBA013
Zygonemertes sp. 1:
Zygonemertes sp.:
BIN. BOLD:ADW7912.
Material examined. BON27, BON76, BON80, BON87.
Morphology. Body 4–15 mm long; color ranging from white with a tinge of yellow to orange, sometimes with dark pigment spots along the sides of the body or at the posterior (Fig.
Identification. See above on species of Zygonemertes. COI sequences from Bodega Bay specimens match a subset of those reported as Zygonemertes sp. 1 (
Habitat. Collected from the low intertidal zone among colonial ascidians and polychaete worm tubes (stations 7, 10). Collected subtidally from within holdfasts of bull kelp (Nereocystis luetkeana), station 11.
Distribution. Amaknak (MZ580839) and Unalaska Islands, AK, USA (MZ580813); San Juan Island, WA, USA (Maslakova, unpublished), Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. First record of the species in California. Reproductive individuals encountered in August in Bodega Bay.
Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014
BIN. BOLD:AEK0256.
Material examined. B7, B8, BON88, BON91.
Morphology. Body up to 31 mm long, greenish yellow, digestive tract appearing bright reddish orange ventrally. With ~ 15 ocelli on each side of the head, arranged in four irregular rows, and a single row of post-cerebral ocelli (~ 8) along each lateral nerve cord (Fig.
Identification. See above on species of Zygonemertes.
Habitat. Collected from Bodega Harbor within the holdfasts of subtidal Giant Kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) in the shallow subtidal zone (< 5 m depth, station 6).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science. Closely related to Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015 (6% divergence, COI).
Zygonemertes sp. BOBA015
BIN. BOLD:AEJ0120, BOLD:ADR7155.
Material examined. BON62, BON63, BON81.
Morphology. Body 4–15 mm long, brownish, with numerous ocelli arranged in four irregular rows on the head, ~ 25+ on each side (Fig.
Identification. See above on species of Zygonemertes.
Habitat. Low intertidal zone among surfgrass roots (station 14) and colonial ascidians (station 10).
Distribution. Calvert Island, BC, Canada (BHAK2541-20 in BOLD). Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study); Point Mugu, CA, USA (DISA797-19 in BOLD).
Notes. Species new to science. Closely related to Zygonemertes sp. BOBA014 (6% divergence, COI).
Amphiporina incertae sedis
Eumonostilifera sp. BOBA016
Monostilifera sp.:
BIN. BOLD:AEJ6897.
Material examined. B15.
Morphology. Body orange, with 15 ocelli on each side of the cephalic lobe. Basis nearly conical, rounded at the bottom, a bit shorter than the central stylet (Fig.
Identification. Resembles individuals of Amphiporus sp. BOBA017 and BOBA018 described above, but COI sequences do not match any previously sequenced species, and do not group closely with Amphiporus cf. imparispinosus. Taxonomic affiliation is uncertain until a more thorough phylogenetic analysis (with more conservative markers than COI and 16S) is carried out. Overall morphology and 16S tree (Fig.
Habitat. Among fouling organisms on marina docks (station 9).
Distribution. San Juan Island, WA, USA (Maslakova, unpublished); Charleston, OR, USA (
Notes. First record of the species in California. The eggs of this species (which have a polyhedral chorion) have been collected in the plankton in Charleston, OR (
Infraorder Oerstediina Kajihara, 2021
Family Oerstediidae Chernyshev, 1993
Genus Antarctonemertes Friedrich, 1955
Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola (Stricker, 1985)
Tetrastemma phyllospadicola Stricker, 1985: 682, figs 1–28;
BIN. BOLD:ACH3602.
Material examined. BON67, BON68.
Morphology. Body short and stout, pale yellow to pale peach color, 6–7 mm long (Fig.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of Antarctonemertes phyllospadicola (Stricker, 1985) described from San Juan Island, Washington, and the COI sequences match those of A. phyllospadicola from San Juan Island, Washington (
Habitat. Collected with intertidal samples of surfgrass, Phyllospadix scouleri (station 14). In the San Juan Islands, WA this species is found on blades and inside female inflorescences of P. scouleri in the low intertidal zone.
Distribution. Bamfield Marine Science Centre, Canada (
Notes. This is the first record of this genus and species for California.
Genus Nemertellina Friedrich, 1935
The genus Nemertellina has never been reported from the northeast Pacific and currently contains five valid species, three occurring in Kiel Bay, Germany, and one each in Madagascar and Japan. Members of this genus have four eyes, with the anterior and posterior pairs widely separated; small and simple cerebral organs located far anterior to the brain and opening ventrally near the tip of the head; short rhynchocoel; conical or pear-shaped basis, with 2–4 accessory stylet pouches. Nemertellina canea Friedrich, 1935b, N. minuta Friedrich, 1935a, N. oculata Friedrich, 1935b and N. tropica Kirsteuer, 1965 are reported to completely lack cephalic furrows, while N. yamaokai Kajihara, Gibson & Mawatari, 2000 has two pairs.
Nemertellina sp. BOBA011
BIN. BOLD:AEJ4336.
Material examined. B3, B21, BON69.
Morphology. Body small and slender, ~ 15 mm long, cylindrical in cross-section (Fig.
Identification. The species encountered here is most similar to Nemertellina yamaokai in possessing two sets of cephalic furrows. The Bodega Bay specimens are ~ 10% divergent (COI) from N. yamaokai, suggesting the presence of a sixth Nemertellina species, and the first reported from the northeast Pacific.
Habitat. Collected subtidally in Bodega Harbor from kelp holdfasts (station 6) and among fouling organisms on boat marina docks (station 9). Collected intertidally from rocky shores on the open coast among surfgrass roots (station 14).
Distribution. Charleston, OR, USA (Maslakova, unpublished); Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science, and new record of the genus for North America.
Genus Oerstedia Quatrefages, 1846
Oerstedia sp. BOBA022
BIN. BOLD:AEJ2779.
Material examined. BON32, BON33.
Morphology. Short and stout cylindrical body, 3–6 mm long, with a head narrower than the body. One individual pale, with a bright orange gut (Fig.
Identification. The only species of Oerstedia reported to occur in the northeast Pacific (from Washington to Mexico) is Oerstedia dorsalis (Abildgaard, 1806). The type locality of O. dorsalis is northern Europe, but the species has been reported throughout the northern hemisphere and is famously polymorphic.
Habitat. Collected among low intertidal red algae on the rocky boulders of a breakwater (station 4).
Distribution. Bodega Bay, CA, USA (this study).
Notes. Species new to science.
Oerstediina incertae sedis
Tetrastemma bilineatum Coe, 1904
Tetrastemma bilineatum Coe, 1904: 164, pl. XIV, fig. 6, pl. XXI, figs 13, 14, pl. XXII, fig. 4.
BIN. BOLD:ADW8130.
Material examined. B18.
Morphology. Small, slender worm with two dorsal longitudinal brown stripes, each 1/3 of the body width, upon a cream-colored background (Fig.
Identification. Specimens from Bodega Bay conform to the description of Tetrastemma bilineatum Coe, 1904, originally from San Diego, California, though sequence data are not available from southern California. COI sequence of the Bodega Bay specimen matches those of T. bilineatum individuals reported from southern Oregon (
Habitat. Collected from a wave-exposed mussel bed (station 1) and found in similar habitat in southern Oregon.
Distribution. Bamfield Marine Science Centre, Canada (
Notes.
The geographic distributions and abundances of coastal species are changing in response to a variety of human impacts (
Our study extends the geographic focus of recent taxonomic work on nemerteans to include northern California where relatively little work has been done on nemertean diversity during the past 60 years. Notably, only 13 of the 34 species (38%) we collected and barcoded can be unambiguously assigned to described species. This highlights that nemertean diversity remains poorly known in the northeast Pacific despite more than a century of study. That the majority of the observed diversity cannot be assigned to described species renders the few existing geographically relevant identification guides (e.g.,
Eleven species (32%) reported here are new to science, and ten (29%) comprise previously reported undescribed species, or cryptic species whose taxonomic status cannot be resolved with data at hand (Table
Twenty two of the 34 species have not been previously confirmed by DNA barcodes to occur in northern California. This includes two species that appear to have been introduced from other parts of the world (Cephalothrix simula from the northwest Pacific, and Cephalothrix hermaphroditica from European waters, possibly via Chile or another point of entry along the Pacific Coast of the Americas). In fact, our study is the first to report C. hermaphroditica from the northeast Pacific. Introduction of C. simula may be of concern to aquaculture due to its association with oysters, and high levels of tetrodotoxin in its tissues (
Historical surveys of nemertean diversity in the Bodega Bay region (
Several species recorded in historical surveys of the Bodega Bay region were absent from our surveys. For example,
Our findings demonstrate how much there is to learn about the diversity and distribution of nemerteans of the northeast Pacific, particularly among southern regions that have received the least amount of attention. Lack of baseline occurrence data (supported by DNA barcodes) hinders our ability to detect shifts in the distribution and abundance of these species. Further sampling and DNA barcoding along the west coast of North America is needed to obtain a more accurate picture of the diversity in this region. Sampling type localities of previously described species will help resolve some of the taxonomic ambiguities associated with species already encountered.
For field assistance in the Bodega Bay region, we thank Isaiah Bluestein, Michael Brito, Erin de Leon Sanchez, Jason Herum, Shelby Kawana, Helen Killeen, John Liu, Gabriel Ng, Sarah Merolla, Alisha Saley, Jackie Sones, Evan Tjeerdema, and Jenna Quan. The authors acknowledge the students of the Marine Molecular Biology classes at the Oregon Institute of Marine Biology taught by S.M. in Fall 2019 and 2020, for their help with DNA extraction and PCR. We are grateful to the University of California Natural Reserve System for access to Bodega Marine Reserve. We extend our gratitude to an anonymous reviewer and Jon L Norenburg for their thoughtful reviews of this manuscript.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This project was supported by a Field Science Fellowship from the University of California Natural Reserve System to M.F. and E.S. Additional support was provided by NSF grant OCE-1851462 to E.S. C.I.E. was partially supported by the NSF grant DEB-1856363 to S.M.
CIE Data curation, Formal Analysis, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft; MRF Funding acquisition, Conceptualization, Investigation, Visualization; ES Funding acquisition, Investigation, Visualization, Writing – review and editing; SM Funding acquisition, Methodology, Formal Analysis, Validation, Visualization, Writing – review and editing.
Christina I. Ellison https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1856-386X
Eric Sanford https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9053-6826
Svetlana Maslakova https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3629-6638
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
Reference sequences used in species delimitation (ASAP), alignments, and trees
Data type: xlsx