Research Article |
Corresponding author: Charlene Janion-Scheepers ( cjanion@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Wanda M. Weiner
© 2021 Mikhail Potapov, Louis Deharveng, Charlene Janion-Scheepers.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Potapov M, Deharveng L, Janion-Scheepers C (2021) Taxonomy of the Proisotoma complex. VI. Rediscovery of the genus Bagnallella Salmon, 1951 and epitoky in Bagnallella davidi (Barra, 2001), comb. nov. from South Africa. ZooKeys 1072: 167-186. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1072.71307
|
The genus Bagnallella Salmon is restored and given a diagnosis. It takes an intermediate position between Proisotoma Börner and Cryptopygus Willem complexes and is characterized by the separation of the two last abdominal segments (like in Proisotoma) and 3 and 5 s-chaetae on the fourth and fifth abdominal segments (like in Cryptopygus and its allies). A list of and key to species belonging to Bagnallella is given. Bagnallella biseta comb. nov., B. dubia comb. nov., B. sedecimoculata comb. nov., and B. tenella comb. nov. are commented and redescribed. Morphology of Bagnallella davidi (Barra), comb. nov. is described from the specimens from South Africa. So far B. davidi appears to be a complex of forms differing in size of the furca and macrochaetae. Two types of strongly modified males were found and described. Antennae, ventral side of abdomen, posterior edge of abdominal tergites, and mandibles are affected with epitoky. The nature of the discovered strong polymorphism is unclear.
Collembola, polymorphism, supermale
Knowledge on the Collembola of South Africa has increased significantly over the last decade, with most new species described from the Western Cape Province where the majority sampling has been made (
A.B. A. Bedos
Abd. I–VI abdominal segments I–VI
Ant. I–IV antennal segments I–IV
bms basal micro s-chaeta on antennal segments
C.J. C. Janion-Scheepers
L.D. L. Deharveng
M macrochaeta
ms> micro s-chaeta(e) (= microsensillum(a) auct.)
PAO postantennal organ
s-chaetae macro s-chaeta or s-chaetae (= macrosensillum(a) or sensillum(a) auct.)
Th. II–III thoracic segments II and III
Ti tibiotarsus
Folsomia sedecemoculata Salmon, 1943
Anurophorinae with all abdominal segments clearly separated and a Proisotoma-like furca: manubrium with few anterior chaetae (1+1-3+3), dens slender, crenulated, with rather numerous anterior and posterior chaetae, mucro clearly set off from dens, with two or three teeth. 7+7-8+8 ocelli in known species. With simple or bifurcate maxillary palp and four sublobal hairs, two or four prelabral chaetae. Macro s-chaetae 22235 on Abd.I-V. Tergal macro s-chaetae on abdomen situated in front of p-row of chaetae. B-row of chaetae on Ti.1–2 complete (both B4 and B5 present). Ventral chaetae on Th.III present or absent. Sexual dimorphism present or absent.
To date an appropriate generic name did not exist for the small group species related to Proisotoma Börner, 1901 sensu lato which were discussed in the monograph of
Recently, one more species, Proisotoma sedecimoculata (Salmon, 1943), became a probable candidate to belong to this group (
The incertae sedis genus Bagnallella combines the characters of two large generic groups by the separation of its two last abdominal segments and the presence of three and five s-chaetae on Abd.IV and V respectively in characteristic position. The former character is a diagnostic feature of the Proisotoma Börner, 1901 complex, the latter indicates basic set of s-chaetae in Cryptopygus Willem, 1902 and related genera belonging to Cryptopygus complex (
Bagnallella. The genus is distributed worldwide. More local species (B. davidi, B. douglasi, B. mishai, B. biseta, B. koepckei) are distributed in the Southern Hemisphere that indicates further relation to the “austral” genus Cryptopygus. Due to apparent ruderal B. tenella and pioneer B. ripicola, the genus also occurs in the Northern Hemisphere. The ecology of the former species is especially remarkable, as B. tenella is often recorded in mass abundances (
Bagnallella biseta (Rapoport, 1963), comb. nov.
Bagnallella davidi (Barra, 2001), comb. nov.
Bagnallella dubia (Deharveng, 1981), comb. nov.
Bagnallella douglasi (Mendonça, Queiroz & Silveira, 2015), comb. nov.
? Bagnallella koepckei (Winter, 1967), comb. nov.
Bagnallella mishai (Mendonça et Silveira, 2019), comb. nov.
? Bagnallella nigromaculosa (Folsom, 1932), comb. nov.
? Bagnallella paronai (Börner, 1907), comb. nov.
Bagnallella ripicola (Linnaniemi, 1912), comb. nov.
Bagnallella sedecimoculata (Salmon, 1943), comb. nov.
Bagnallella tenella (Reuter, 1895), comb. nov.
Below we give the diagnosis, description, remarks, and distribution, with, if possible, ecological remarks of all species of Bagnallella. Some sections may be omitted if the associated species have good morphological descriptions in the literature.
Proisotoma biseta Rapoport, 1963
Adult male from Argentina under label “Tucuman, 19/4/59, entre maderas ...”, deposited in the Museum national d’Histoire naturelle (
Maxillary palp bifurcate, four prelabral chaetae. Dens with ~50 anterior chaetae. Mucro bidentate. Anterior side of manubrium with 3+3 chaetae. 33/22235 s and 11/111 ms on body. Ventral chaetae absent on Th.III.
Maxillary outer lobe with four sublobal hairs, maxillary palp bifurcate. Labral formula as 4/5,5,4. Guard chaeta e7 present on labium. Ant. III without bms and with five distal s (including one lateral), without additional s-chaetae. Th. I, II, and III without ventral chaetae. S-formula as 33/22235 (s), 11/111 (ms). Tibiotarsal tenent chaetae (1,1,1) clearly clavate. Tibiotarsi 1–2 with more than 24 chaetae. Ventral tube with 6+5 chaetae (in the adult male studied). Retinaculum with 4+4 teeth and two chaetae. Dens long and slender, with numerous crenulations, many (~50) anterior and 17 (in the adult male studied) posterior chaetae. Anterior side of manubrium with 3+3 chaetae. Mucro bidentate.
Our redescription is based on one individual of E. Rapoport, and more material is needed to complete the understanding of B. biseta. The species obviously belongs to the genus Bagnallella by separation of two last abdominal segments and s-chaetotaxy of Abd.IV and V. After chaetotaxy of tibiotarsi, ventral tube, and dens, B. biseta appears to be a more polychaetotic species than its congeners. The close relation of B. biseta and B. tenella (sharing 3+3 manubrial chaetae) is doubtful due to difference in maxillary palp (bifurcate vs simple). The independence of B. koepckei and B. paronai from B. biseta call for further verification. Bagnallella paronai is not included in the key due to the incomplete diagnosis.
Argentina and Chile (see
Cryptopygus dubius Deharveng, 1981
New Zealand, South Island, Central Otago, Pisa Range and Old Man’s Range, high alpine zone, different sites, 17.02.2014, M. Minor leg.
Maxillary palp bifurcate, two prelabral chaetae. Dens with 12–16 anterior chaetae. Mucro bidentate. Anterior side of manubrium with 1+1 chaetae. 33/22235 s and 10/100 ms on body. 2+2 ventral chaetae on Th.III.
Colour grey. Cuticle, ocelli, outer mouth parts, and antennae as in B. sedecimoculata. PAO as long as 0.8–0.9 Ant. I and as 1.4–1.5 as long as Claw III. Ventral side of head with 4+4 postlabial chaetae. Th.III with 2+2 ventral axial chaetae.
Macrochaetae weakly differentiated, medial ones on Abd.V about as long as 0.4–0.5 of tergal midline. S-chaetae weakly differentiated. S-formula as 43/22235 (s), 10/100 (ms) (Fig.
This species was named after its dubious position in generic system of Proisotoma/Cryptopygus (
Bagnallella dubia was described from Marion Island and recorded in Macquarie Island (
Proisotoma douglasi Mendonca, Queiroz & Silveira, 2015.
The species can be attributed to Bagnallella by the two key characters of the genus. It is characterized by 33/22235 s, 11/111 ms, bifurcate maxillary palp, long polychaetotic dens (34-35/14), and bidentate mucro. The presence of seven ocelli and 2+2 chaetae on anterior side of manubrium are two unique characters among members of the genus.
This species is currently only known from SE Brazil.
Scutisotoma misha Mendonca & Silveira, 2019
It is an easily recognizable species by 43/22235 s, 11/111 ms, simple maxillary palp, dens (15-16/12-13), and tridentate mucro.
One locality in southeastern Brazil.
Proisotoma ripicola Linnaniemi, 1912
Maxillary palp bifurcate, four prelabral chaetae. Ant. I with many additional chaetae. Dens long and slender, with 20–30 anterior chaetae or more. Mucro bidentate. Anterior side of manubrium with 1+1 chaetae. 33/22235 s and 11/111 ms on body. Lateral s-chaetae on Abd.IV shifted to ventral side. Without ventral chaetae on Th.III.
The full redescription is given by
Europe. It prefers sandy places along the edge of water.
Folsomia sedecimoculata Salmon, 1943
Holotoma sedecimoculata (Salmon, 1943)
Proisotoma sedecimoculata (Salmon, 1943)
South Africa, Western Cape, Stellenbosch, Jonkershoek Nature Reserve, canyon to waterfall, SAF-086, 34.005570°S, 18.992067°E, 15/03/2008, forest litter, Berlese, L.D. and A.B. leg.; Somerset, Helderberg, SAF-107, SAF-109, SAF-116, 34.040883°S, 18.873649°E, alt. 600 m, 04/03/2009, native forest litter, L.D. and A.B. leg.; Cape Town, Wynberg, Table Mountain, second collapse, SAF-141, 33.987637°S, 18.405750°N, alt. 725 m, 10/03/2009, native forest litter, L.D. and A.B. leg.; Constantia, Silvermine, in a small forest patch above Tokai, SAF-235, 34.038273°S, 18.395478°E, alt. 390 m, 06/11/2010, dead wood, D. Porco leg.; Kalk Bay, Echo Valley, Spes Bona forest, SAF-555, 01/03/2019, Afromontane forest, moss on rock, L.D. and A.B. leg.
New Zealand. NZL-049, Rotoiti: Lakes Rototongata and Rotoatua, 08/01/1996, primary forest, litter, L.D. and A.B. leg.
Australia. Victoria, July 2010, University Ballarat, St. Helens, 37.629979°S, 143.890801°E, Eucalyptus plantation, moss, P. Greenslade. leg.
Macquarie Island, Bauer Bay, 54.5549°S, 158.8760°E, April 2016, Turf sample, Berlese extraction, L. Phillips leg.
Maxillary palp bifurcate, two prelabral chaetae. Dens slender, with 16–20 anterior chaetae. Mucro bidentate. Anterior side of manubrium with 1+1 chaetae. 33/22235 s and 10/100 ms on body. Without ventral chaetae on Th.III.
Colour grey. Cuticle outwardly smooth. 8+8 ocelli, G and H smaller. PAO about as long as 0.8 Ant. I and as 1.1–1.3 Claw III. Maxillary outer lobe with four sublobal hairs and bifurcate maxillary palp. Labral formula as 2/554. Labium full set of guards (e7 present), three proximal and four basomedian chaetae. Ventral side of head with 4–5+4–5 postlabial chaetae. 11 chaetae on Ant.I, with three basal micro s-chaetae (bms), of which one bms large, and two ventral s-chaetae (s), Ant.II with three bms and one laterodistal s, Ant.III with one bms and six distal s (including two lateral). Thorax without ventral axial chaetae.
Macrochaetae weakly differentiated, medial ones on Abd.V as long as 0.4–0.5 of tergal midline. S-chaetae weakly differentiated. S-formula as 43/22235 (s), 10/100 (ms). S-chaetae on Abd.I–III in mid-tergal position. General pattern of chaetotaxy as in B. dubia (Fig.
Bagnallella sedecimoculata was described from New Zealand and was designated as type species for the genus Bagnallella (see the discussion to the genus above). The type specimen from New Zealand was studied (
Probably widely distributed. So far with scattered records in the South Hemisphere (New Zealand, Australia, South Africa, Macquarie Island).
Isotoma tenella Reuter, 1895
Proisotoma tenella (Reuter, 1895)
Proisotoma simplex Folsom, 1937
Proisotoma alba Yosii, 1939
South Africa, Western Cape, Haarwegskloof, Swellendam, 34.3425°S, 20.3167°E, 18.vii.2017, litter trap (R17) with Dicerothamnus rhinocerotis litter, O. Cowan leg.; Haarwegskloof, Swellendam, 34.3444°S, 20.3225°E, 18.vii.2017, litter trap (A17) with Medicago sativa litter, O. Cowan leg.; Eastern Cape, Baviaanskloof, 33.7311°S, 23.9655°E, 24.iv.2013, BAV_F_49, A. Liu leg.; Free State Province, Bankfontein Farm, 30.0567°S, 24.8942°E, 24.iv.2019, Berlese-Tullgren, tree leaf litter, H. Badenhorst leg.
Cuba, Cienfuegos Province, 1984, J. Banasco-Almenteros leg.
Indonesia, Lombok Island, vic. Toko Nusa Sari, marine beech, 8.7411° S, 116.0011° E, 4.IV.2017, V. Makarov leg.
Brazil, Espirito Santo, Domingos Martins, Arace, 4.VII.2000, M. Culik leg.
Maxillary palp simple. Four prelabral chaetae. Dens slender, with ca 20–30 anterior chaetae. Mucro bidentate. Anterior side of manubrium with 3+3 chaetae. 33/22235 s and 11/111 ms on body. No ventral chaetae on Th.III.
Colour grey of different intensity. Cuticle outwardly smooth. 8+8 ocelli, G and H smaller. PAO (Fig.
The species belongs to the genus Bagnallella by having two last abdominal segments separated and three and five s-chaetae on Abd. IV and V. It shares 3+3 anterior chaetae on manubrium with B. biseta, B. koepckei, and B. paronai from South America from which it differs by fewer chaetae on dens.
Number of posterior chaetae on dens, clavate tibiotarsal chaetae, and chaetae on retinaculum vary. We treat all this variation within one species, but further study is needed. The independence of Proisotoma nigromaculosa (Hawaiian Islands) is doubtful.
Although we have no material from Europe,
Widely distributed cosmopolitan species. Common in tropics. In higher latitudes only in protected soils.
Proisotoma davidi Barra, 2001
. Typical form: South Africa, Free State Province, Bankfontein Farm, 30.0567°S, 24.8942°E, 24.iv.2019, Berlese-Tullgren: tree leaf litter, H. Badenhorst leg.; South Africa, Western Cape, Haarwegskloof, Swellendam, 34.3422°S, 20.3169°E, 18.vii.2017, litter trap (G18) with Pentameris eriostoma litter, O. Cowan leg., South Africa, SAF 583 (11.m CJ SWB); Prince Albert: Swartberg North: road to Swartberg Pass, 11/03/2019, meadow, moss, C.J. leg.
Short-haired form: South Africa, Western Cape, Haarwegskloof, Swellendam, 34.3534°S, 20.3042°E, 18.vii.2017, litter trap (A4) with Medicago sativa litter, O. Cowan leg.; Cederberg Wilderness area, Litter trap CED588; South Arica, Western Cape, Cederberg Wilderness area, Litter trap CED394; Jonkershoek Nature Reserve, 33.9891°S, 18.9575°E, 05.ix.2011, Litter trap (J4, 124); Jonkershoek Nature Reserve, 33.9891°S, 18.9575°E, 30.vii.2009, Litter trap, C.J. leg.; J2, 32.1; Landdroskop, Jan. 2012, H. Basson leg.; Prince Albert, Swartberg North, Swartberg crest, 12/03/2019, SAF-612, SAF-618, meadow, litter and soil, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.
Intermediate form: South Africa, Western Cape, Haarwegskloof, Swellendam, 34.3345°S, 20.3187°E, 18.vii.2017, litter trap (R24) with Dicerothamnus rhinocerotis litter, O. Cowan leg.; Prince Albert, Swartberg North, Swartberg crest, SAF-612, 12/03/2019, meadow, litter, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.; Prince Albert, Swartberg North, Swartberg crest, SAF-618, 12/03/2019, meadow, soil, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.; Prince Albert, Swartberg North, road to Swartberg Pass, SAF-601, 12/03/2019, meadow, litter and soil, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.; Prince Albert, Swartberg North, Swartberg crest, SAF-614, 12/03/2019, moss on rock, Berlese, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.
“Clasping supermales”: SAF-601, South Africa: Western Cape: Prince Albert: Swartberg North: road to Swartberg Pass, 12/03/2019, meadow, litter and soil, L.D., C.J. and A.B. leg.
“Spiny supermales”: SAF-554; South Africa: Western Cape: Kalk Bay: Echo Valley: Spes Bona forest, 01/03/2019, Afromontane forest, moss and lichen on rock, L.D. and A.B. leg.
3+3 postlabial chaetae. Maxillary palp simple. Dens with four anterior and four posterior chaetae. Mucro tridentate, teeth arranged in a line. Anterior side of manubrium with 1+1 chaetae. 43/22235 s and 10/100 ms on body (Figs
Maxillary outer lobe with four sublobal hairs, maxillary palp simple. Labral formula as 4/5,5,4. Labium with five usual papillae (–Е) and labial formula A1B4C0D4E6, guard chaeta e7 absent, three proximal and four basomedian chaetae. Ventral side of head with 3+3 chaetae. PAO shorter than Ant.I width (0.6–0.8). Ant. I with 11 common chaetae, two ventral s-chaetae (s) and three bms, of which one dorsal long, chaeta-like (this ms was calculated together with common chaetae in first description, 12 at whole); Ant. II with three bms and one latero-distal s; Ant. III with one bms and with six distal s (including two lateral), without additional s-chaetae. Organite pin-like, not very small. Empodial appendage about half as long as Claw. Anterior and posterior furcal subcoxae with 9–14 and 7–8 chaetae, respectively. Male spurs on tibiotarsi 3 thin, stick-like. Th. I–III without ventral chaetae. Ratio manubrium : dens : mucro as 4.4-5.0 : 3.3-3.8 : 1; dens : Claw as 3.3–3.6 (for the typical form).
Bagnallella davidi is a rather peculiar species of the genus due to few chaetae on dens (vs many more chaetae both on anterior and posterior sides), tridentate mucro (shared with B. mishai only), and 3+3 postlabial chaetae (vs 4+4 or more in other species). The first description is almost complete and, therefore, we made very few additions concerning mouth parts. The species exhibits high variation in length of macrochaetae and show different modifications of males. All the forms (described below) can indicate either high plasticity of a single species or the complex of separate although closely related species, calling for further morphological, biological, ecological, and molecular investigations.
Eastern Cape, Amatola Mountains (type location) and widely in the Western Cape and Free State (our material) provinces of South Africa.
We also found individuals with middle-sized macrochaetae (as in Fig.
Each studied population consists of only one of the forms, and we have not found a continuous range of macrochaetae variability, apart from short-haired clasping adult supermales occurring in “normal” populations.
Unmodified males are much more frequent than the two male forms described above. In most populations, only unmodified males are known. They can show all possible length of macrochaetae and belong to associated forms (Figs
1 | Mucro tridentate (Fig. |
2 |
– | Mucro bidentate (Fig. |
3 |
2 | Dens with 4 anterior and 4 posterior chaetae (Fig. |
B. davidi (Barra), South Africa |
– | Dens with 15–16 anterior and 12–13 posterior chaetae | B. mishai (Mendonça & Silveira), Brazil |
3 | Manubrium with 1+1 anterior chaetae (Fig. |
4 |
– | Manubrium with 2–3+2–3 anterior chaetae (Fig. |
6 |
4 | Dens with more than 20 anterior and 15 posterior chaetae. 4 prelabral chaetae | B. ripicola (Linnaniemi), Europe |
– | Dens with fewer than 17 anterior and 8 posterior chaetae (Figs |
5 |
5 | Ventrum of Th.III with chaetae | B. dubia (Deharveng), sub-Antarctic |
– | Ventrum of Th.III without chaetae | B. sedecimoculata (Salmon), New Zealand |
6 | Manubrium with 2+2 anterior chaetae, 7 ocelli | B. douglasi (Mendonça, Queiroz & Silveira), Brazil |
– | Manubrium with 3+3 anterior chaetae, 8 ocelli | 7 |
7 | Dens with more than 40 anterior chaetae |
B. biseta (Rapoport), Argentina, B. koepckei (Winter), Peru |
– | Dens with fewer than 30 anterior chaetae (Fig. |
B. tenella (Reuter), cosmopolitan, B. nigromaculosa (Folsom), Hawaii Is2 |
If present, the clasping organ of Collembola is formed by two symmetrical complexes associated with, respectively, left and right antennae, or, more rarely, other limbs. Paired “clasps” are evolutionary formed in different taxa, for example, in the family Sminthurididae, Vertagopus reuteri (Schött, 1893), Rhodanella minos Denis, 1928, Seira raptora (Zeppelini & Bellini, 2006) (
The function of the spiny row in “spiny supermales” of B. davidi is more difficult to explain. The armature of the posterior row on Abd.IV somewhat resembles backward-shifting macrochaetae in males of Scutisotoma acorrelata Potapov, Babenko & Fjellberg, 2006, while strong lateral macrochaetae on Abd. VI indicate some similarity to Ephemerotoma huadongensis (Chen, 1985), which shows similar armature on both Abd. V and VI (described by
This work was partly funded by the SA (NRF) / Russia (RFBR) Joint Science and Technology Research Collaboration project no. 19-516-60002 (FRBR) and no. 118904 (NRF) awarded to M. Potapov and C. Janion-Scheepers, respectively, and SA-France (Protea I and II) awarded to L. Deharveng. We thank D. Porco, P. Greenslade, O. Cowan, H. Badenhorst, H. Basson, V. Makarov, and M. Culik for providing their material for study, and SANParks and Cape Nature for collecting permits.