Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Royce T. Cumming ( roycecumming@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Nina Sinichenkova
© 2021 Royce T. Cumming, Stephane Le Tirant.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC0 Public Domain Dedication.
Citation:
Cumming RT, Tirant SL (2021) Drawing the Excalibur bug from the stone: adding credibility to the double-edged sword hypothesis of coreid evolution (Hemiptera, Coreidae). ZooKeys 1043: 117-131. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1043.67730
|
A new genus and species of exaggerated antennae Coreidae is described from Myanmar amber of the Late Cretaceous (Cenomanian stage). Ferriantenna excalibur gen. et sp. nov. appears related to another Cretaceous coreid with exaggerated antennae, Magnusantenna Du & Chen, 2021, but can be differentiated by the fourth antennal segment which is short and paddle-like, the undulating shape of the pronotum and mesonotum, and the shorter and thicker legs. The new coreid, with elaborately formed antennae and simple hind legs instead of the typical extant coreid morphology with simple antennae and elaborately formed hind legs, begs the question: why were the elaborate features of the antennae lost in favor of ornate hind legs? Features that are large and showy are at higher risk of being attacked by predators or stuck in a poor molt and subjected to autotomy and are therefore lost at a higher rate than simple appendages. We hypothesize that because elaborate antennae play an additional significant sensory role compared to elaborate hind legs, that evolutionarily it is more costly to have elaborate antennae versus elaborate hind legs. Thus, through the millenia, as coreid evolution experimented with elaborate/ornate features, those on the antennae were likely selected against in favor of ornate hind legs.
Autotomy, Burmese, Cenomanian, Cretaceous, extinct, fossil, leaf-footed bugs, Mesozoic
The coreids (leaf-footed bugs) are a diverse group of hemipterans with a cosmopolitan distribution (of ~3100 species in ~260 genera;
Examples of ornamentation in live extant coreids. Images A–C, G with expansions on the hind tibiae. Images D–H with hind leg spination D with expansions to the third antennal segment. Images B, C, E–H photographed by Andreas Kay (Ecuador), other images with appropriate citations given individually A Anisocelis flavolineata from Veraguas Province, Panama, photographed by Dirk van der Made (Netherlands) B Unidentified Coreidae from Ecuador C Anisoscelis foliacea from Ecuador D Thasus sp. from Santa Cruz County, Arizona, USA, photographed by Alan Schmierer (USA) E Unidentified Coreidae from Ecuador F Unidentified Coreidae from Ecuador G Melucha quinquelineata from Ecuador H Piezogaster cf. humeralis from Ecuador.
The first reported Coreidae species from Cretaceous Burmese amber was the recently described Magnusantenna wuae Du & Chen, 2021 (Fig.
Artist recreation of the presently known three Cretaceous coreids with elaborate antennae. Illustrations by Liz Sisk (USA). Dorsal habitus scaled to same uniform length to highlight the antennae to body ratios. Colorations are artistic recreations based upon extant coreids rather than the actual specimen, whose color was not preserved in the amber A Ferriantenna excalibur gen. et sp. nov. B Ferriantenna “club-like antennae” C Magnusantenna wuae.
Unfortunately, with the fossil record of coreids rather fragmented and often from partial or nymphal specimens this still leaves a great deal of confusion surrounding their evolutionary history. Thankfully with nymphal antennae morphology rather stable into adulthood (
The amber containing the holotype specimen was collected from the well-known Hukawng Valley in northern Myanmar, a prolific site of amber excavation (
Illustrations were done by scientific illustrator Liz Sisk (Washington D.C., USA) using either photographs of the holotype, photographs saved from various online sources illustrating non-type specimens or recreated from the photographs/illustration presented in
The holotype specimen is deposited within the Montreal Insectarium, Montreal, Quebec, Canada (IMQC).
Order Hemiptera Linnaeus, 1758
Family Coreidae Leach, 1815
Subfamily Coreinae Leach, 1815
Ferriantenna excalibur gen. et sp. nov., herein designated
The taxonomic placement of this genus is rather uncertain, largely owing to the lack of adult specimens to allow review of genitalia, wing venation, and presence or lack of ocelli. Morphologically this genus appears to be closely related to Magnusantenna Du & Chen, 2021 based upon the elaborate antennae, square head shape, and long abdomen with parallel margins. Based upon this assumed close relationship we tentatively place this new genus and species within the Coreinae alongside Magnusantenna but would not be surprised if a taxonomic adjustment is necessary once adult specimens are hopefully one day recovered. Additional higher taxonomic possibilities, which can be ruled out, are Yuripopovinidae due to the lack of a distinct collar in our new taxon (
The general morphological features of this genus fit well within Coreinae, namely the expanded antennal segments, the length ratios of the various antennomeres (the second and third segments of similar lengths), the smooth pronotum, and the straight femora and tibiae (
Within the Coreinae there are several tribes which have an antennomere that is enlarged (e.g., Nematopini or Chariesterini with only the singular third antennomere flattened; Fig.
Antennae four segmented, long, but not longer than the body (head, thorax, and abdomen). First antennal segment short and robust (slightly longer than wide or about equal in length and width; always shorter than head length); second and third segments ornamented and quite variable in form interspecifically (can be marked throughout with granulation, setation, or prominent tubercles with margins straight or with spination), each at least three times longer than wide, with the third segment slightly wider and longer than the second segment; and the fourth segment is only slightly longer than head length, flat, and paddle-like, lacking intricate features/expansions as present on the second and third segments. Head approximately as long as wide, compound eyes spherical and variable in their size (can be large, occupying most of the lateral margins, or narrower, restricted to the center third and strongly protruding), located on the center of each side of the head. Pronotum with a margin that expands to the posterior third then contracts slightly. Mesonotum gently expands to the midline and then gently contracts to the posterior. Metanotum with margins that can be parallel or slightly rounded. Abdomen slender, notably longer than wide, with parallel margins. Legs stout, not particularly long. Femora approximately two times as wide as the tibiae, but of similar lengths. Tarsi with two segments, bearing two claws.
Several features differentiate the new genus from the assumed closely related genus Magnusantenna Du & Chen, 2021. First, the length ratios of the exaggerated antennal segments differ as Magnusantenna has the fourth segment approximately as long as, but notably broader than the third segment, versus Ferriantenna gen. nov. which has the fourth segment notably shorter than the third segment, appearing paddle-like. Additionally, the thickness and lengths of the legs differentiate these two genera as Magnusantenna has long thin legs (such as the hind legs which exceed the apex of the abdomen), versus Ferriantenna gen. nov. which has femora which are notably thicker than the tibiae, and specifically for the hind leg it appears that when fully outstretched they fall short or at most reaching the apex of the abdomen but do not exceed it. The thorax and abdomen of Ferriantenna gen. nov. are also notably broader than the head width versus Magnusantenna which has a very slender and long abdomen, thinner than the width of the quadrate head. Finally, the pro- and mesonotum differ slightly between these two genera as Magnusantenna has a pronotum which expands steadily from the anterior to the posterior and the mesonotum is parallel sided, versus Ferriantenna gen. nov. which has the pronotum expanding for the anterior two thirds then slightly contracting, and the mesonotum appears to expand to approximately the middle and then contract to the posterior.
Typically, Heteroptera have five instars, as in hemimetabolous insects which they resemble the adults in most morphological features. Our examined specimen which is the type species for this new genus appears to be a fourth instar nymph like was described within
In addition to our herein described species, we have also seen images shared online of an additional species within Ferriantenna gen. nov. distinctly different from our Ferriantenna excalibur gen. et sp. nov. This second, undescribed Ferriantenna species has similar characteristics of the thorax, abdomen, and legs, and the fourth antennomere which is notably smaller and paddle-like (Fig.
The difference in leg lengths between Magnusantenna and Ferriantenna gen. nov. is likely due to the size of the antennae in relation to the body, as the Ferriantenna gen. nov. are notably less expanded and therefore require less leverage to maintain a stable footing, versus Magnusantenna which needed the longer legs to create a larger footprint to balance the massive antennae.
The generic name is derived from Latin prefix ferri (meaning weapon) and Latin antenna (meaning yardarm of a ship/sail yard which was the origin of the “feeler or horn” of an insect; https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=antenna). This genus epithet is referring to the weapon-like appearance of the antennae of these insects (Fig.
Holotype: Amber specimen #BHM10200800678. Flat and round rectangular piece of amber, approximately 1.0 cm by 1.1 cm with high clarity and small debris throughout that does not black visibility of the specimen (Fig.
Kachin State, Myanmar; Upper Cretaceous ~98.79 ± 0.62 million years old (
At present this is the only formally described species within this new genus. Refer to the differentiation within the above genus section for discussion on the closely related Magnusantenna wuae. We are aware of a second, undescribed Ferriantenna gen. nov. species (Fig.
Mostly complete nymph which appears to be fourth instar. Sex unknown due to the instar stage and missing terminalia of the abdomen. Specimen complete except for the terminal two or three abdominal segments (Fig.
Head. Antennal socket protruding from the front of the head (Fig.
Antennae. Antennae tetramerous (Fig.
Thorax. Pronotum approximately an isosceles trapezium, anterior three fifths gradually expanding to the widest point, then the posterior two fifths converge slightly to the posterior (Fig.
Legs. All legs of a similar morphology, only slight differences in length differentiate them (Fig.
Abdomen. Abdomen notably damaged in the holotype. Disconnected from the body following the second segment, the remainder is mostly crushed, and the terminal two or three segments are missing (Fig.
Noun in apposition, given for Excalibur, the mythical “sword in the stone” which was first described in the epic poem Merlin (about the mythical advisor to King Arthur), written by the French poet Robert de Boron sometime between 1195–1210 (
Our understanding of antennae diversity of the region and period is expanded with the description of this new genus and species of elaborately antennaed coreid from Cretaceous amber. These elaborate features have for the most part been lost from the antennae through the millennia and are now primarily found on the hind legs. Extant coreids primarily have the expansions on antennae restricted to a single antennal segment (Fig.
First, we feel the presence of elaborate structures on the hind legs versus the antennae is likely much more manageable for terrestrial movement due to a lower center of gravity (such as escape from predators of nymphs which cannot fly) and for flight in adults (as it is likely that such large/relatively heavy antennae would be difficult for flight/have significant wind resistance when on the anterior of the individual).
Also, it is most often large, elaborate appendages on insects that are reported as being lost at a higher rate to potential predators or to an imperfect molt than simple limbs/antennae (
Perhaps the selection pressures discussed above have acted against having elaborate (potentially likely to be lost) structures on the receptor valuable antennae, and instead the much more expendable hind legs have become the target for evolutionary experimentation for elaborate structures within the coreids. The extinct lace bug Gyaclavator kohlsi Wappler, Guilbert, Wedmann, Labandeira, 2015 lends credibility to this idea of evolutionary experimentation leading to elaborate antennae, which are subsequently lost. This fossil Eocene lace bug has an expanded fourth antennomere, a feature previously unknown within Tingidae, which has not survived into extant species (
An additional likely possibility/contributing factor is that this lineage of elaborate antennaed coreids fell victim to the Cretaceous–Paleogene (K–Pg) mass extinction which occurred approximately 66 million years ago and marked the end of the Cretaceous (
Typically, only one segment is expanded in extant coreids with the most elaborate antennae (Fig.
Thank you to our scientific illustrator Liz Sisk (USA) who did a beautiful job of illustrating these interesting fossils so that their living glory may be appreciated. Thank you to Simon Chen (Canada) for recognizing the importance of the holotype specimen and sending it to the authors. We thank Michel Saint-Germain, head of collections and research and Maxim Larrivé, director of the Montreal Insectarium for their support of our research. Thank you to our peer reviewers for their extremely helpful feedback and suggestions.