Research Article |
Corresponding author: James K. Liebherr ( jkl5@cornell.edu ) Academic editor: Thorsten Assmann
© 2021 James K. Liebherr.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Liebherr JK (2021) Hawaiian Paratachys Casey (Coleoptera, Carabidae): small beetles of sodden summits, stony streams, and stygian voids. In: Spence J, Casale A, Assmann T, Liebherr JК, Penev L (Eds) Systematic Zoology and Biodiversity Science: A tribute to Terry Erwin (1940-2020). ZooKeys 1044: 229-268. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1044.59674
|
Five Hawaiian species of Paratachys Casey are revised, including four newly described: Paratachys terryli from Kauai; P. perkinsi from Moloka‘i; P. haleakalae from Maui; and P. aaa from Hawai‘i Island. A lectotype is designated for the fifth Hawaiian species currently combined with Paratachys, Tachys arcanicola Blackburn, 1878 of Oahu. Hawaiian Paratachys spp. known from more than one specimen exhibit some degree of ocular polymorphism, that variation being extreme in P. terryli where individuals range in ocular development from macrophthalmic with broadly convex eyes to microphthalmic with small, flat eyes. All Hawaiian Paratachys species comprise individuals with vestigial wings, with the exception of P. terryli, where a single macropterous, macrophthalmic female complements the other 18 brachypterous specimens. Based on a transformation series of characters from the male aedeagus, the biogeographic history of Hawaiian Paratachys is consistent with progressive colonization of the Hawaiian Island chain. Three of the species do not appear to represent species of conservation concern, with P. terryli and P. haleakalae known from terrestrial deep soil, litter, and streamside microhabitats in montane wet rain forest, and the troglobitic P. aaa occupying the dark zone of numerous, recently developed lava tube caves within the Mauna Loa and Kilauea volcanic massifs. The conservation status of the other two species is much more dire, with P. arcanicola of O‘ahu not seen in nature since the early 20th Century, and P. perkinsi known only from a single specimen fortuitously collected in 1894 near sea level on Moloka‘i.
Brachyptery, flight-wing dimorphism, ocular polymorphism, troglobite
“Tachys ...
The species of this genus are of comparatively little interest...
They are most obscure, minute insects of a kind
that occurs in various other parts of the world
(Sharp 1903: 287).”
Terry Erwin conducted doctoral dissertation research with Professor George E. Ball at the University of Alberta on arguably the most charismatic group of carabid beetles; the bombardier beetles (
This contribution presents a taxonomic revision of the native Hawaiian carabid beetles assignable to the genus Paratachys Casey in the sense of
There is a single previously described Hawaiian species, P. arcanicola (Blackburn) of Oahu, currently assigned to Paratachys Casey (
This revision is based on 90 specimens which are deposited in the following institutions: Bernice P. Bishop Museum, Honolulu, HI (
Beetles were collected by aspirating or hand-picking specimens from streamside habitats and forest-floor litter siftate spread on a beating sheet. Bulk samples of siftate from approximately 2–3 m2 of forest floor were also transported to a field lab and cooked off in a double-boiler, with the near-boiling water drying the litter and concentrating the microarthropods in the center of the inner pot. Field specimens of the Kauai and Maui species were killed in potassium cyanide charged glass kill jars (1991) or ethyl acetate charged plastic 50 ml centrifuge tubes (2005), then transferred to 70% ethanol 24 hours later. Hawai‘i Island cave beetles were hand collected live and then transferred to 70% ethanol after processing in a field lab (C.A.M. Slay, pers. comm.).
External characters were assessed using dry, pointed specimens examined under halogen light sources. Various ratios were used to describe beetle anatomy, including: ocular ratio (OR), maximum head width across the compound eyes divided by the minimum frons width between the eyes; MPW/BPW, maximum pronotal width divided by the pronotal width measured between the pronotal hind angles; MPW/PL, maximum pronotal width divided by the pronotal length measured along the midline; HuW/MEW, distance between the juncture of the elytral basal groove and the lateral marginal depression (the humerus) divided by maximum elytral width; and EL/MEW, elytral length measured from the front of the elevated triangular portion of the scutellum to the apex of the longer elytron divided by MEW. Body size is presented as the standardized body length, i.e., the sum of the distances from the apical margin of the labrum to the cervical ridge at the back of the vertex, PL, and EL, the latter two measurements as described above.
Elytral setation and striation are presented using the system of
Paratachys
Casey, 1918: 174 (type species Paratachys austinicus Casey by original designation);
Eotachys
Jeannel, 1941: 426 (type species Tachys bistriatus Duftschmid by original designation). Synonymy by
Macrotachys
Kult, 1961: 2 [junior homonym of Macrotachys Uéno, 1953: 42] (type species Bembidium fulvicolle Dejean by original designation). Synonymy under Eotachys by
These beetles can be diagnosed by: deep paramedial pits of the mentum (Figs
Paratachys terryli A–I Kauai: Namolokama Mtn. A, B macrophthalmic, brachypterous female; 23-v-2005 lot 01 A dorsal habitus view B mentum and associated mouthparts, ventral view C–I compound eye, lateral view C macropterous female; 23-v-2005 lot 1 D brachypterous male; 21-v-2005 lot 8 E brachypterous male; 23-v-2005 lot 1 F brachypterous female; 23-v-2005 lot 1 G brachypterous female; 23-v-2005 lot 1 H brachypterous female; 23-v-2005 lot 1 I brachypterous female; 21-v-2005 lot 1 J Kauai: Upper Kawaikoi Stream at Alakai Swamp Trail, 16-v-1971; right metathoracic flight wing of male, vestigial morph (elytron removed); 14-v-1991 stop 91-26B.
For Hawaiian taxa the position of the dorsal seta within the arcuate ARG differs from that in Neotropical Paratachys (
Finally, all Hawaiian species have the cuticular surfaces of head, prothorax, elytra, meso- and metathoracic sternites, abdominal ventrites, and femora covered with a pelage of fine microsetae (Figs
1 | Body size larger, standardized body length 2.2–2.5 mm; apical recurrent groove (ARG) deep, elytral surface broadly depressed mesad groove; elytral interneurs 1–3 evident near midlength, 1 and 2 deeply impressed, 3 traceable to evident near dorsal elytral seta, elytral intervals 1–3 equally convex | 2 |
– | Body size smaller, standardized body length 1.8–2.2 mm; ARG moderately deep, elytral surface convex immediately mesad groove; elytral interneurs 1 and 2 evident near midlength, interneur 1 (i1) impressed with sutural interval broadly elevated on each elytron resulting in a callous-like suture, i2 broadly shallow, i3 obsolete near dorsal elytral seta | 4 |
2 | Pronotum more transverse, MPW/PL = 1.35–1.41; lateral marginal depression narrowly reflexed (Figs |
3 |
– | Pronotum narrower, MPW/PL = 1.29–1.36; lateral marginal depression very narrow, obsolete, margin carinate (Fig. |
Paratachys haleakalae sp. nov. |
3 | Elytral marginal groove curved to join basal groove on humerus (Fig. |
Paratachys terryli sp. nov. |
– | Elytral marginal groove-basal groove juncture angulate (Fig. |
Paratachys perkinsi sp. nov. |
4 | Eyes variable, small but outer surface always more convex than head curvature of gena (Fig. |
Paratachys arcanicola (Blackburn) |
– | Beetles microphthalmic, outer surface of eye nearly flat, not extended beyond curvature of gena (Fig. |
Paratachys aaa sp. nov. |
Paratachys
sp. “USA: Hawaii”,
Holotype
male (point-mounted,
Paratypes. Kauai: Halelea F. R.: Namolokama Mtn., Waioli Str., litter, sift, ohia/ferns, 22°08.00'N, 159°29.85'W, 1340 m el., 21-v-2005, lot 1 Liebherr (
This species shares elongate elytra (EL/MEW = 1.45–1.50; Fig.
Head
robust, frontal grooves shallow, convergent posterad clypeus, divergent to frontal lateral margin at frontoclypeal suture just anterad antennal articulation, broadly, slightly elevated laterally to position of anterior supraorbital seta; eyes variable, from large, macrophthalmic with 12 ommatidia crossed by horizontal diameter and 15 ommatidia crossed by vertical diameter (Fig.
The compound eyes vary dramatically in this species, from fully macrophthalmic (Fig.
Right metathoracic flight wing, dorsal view A Paratachys terryli, macrophthalmic female; Kauai: Namolokama Mtn., 23-v-2005 (
Aedeagal median lobe porrect, parallel-sided with an evenly rounded apex (Fig.
Paratachys spp., male aedeagus, i.e., median lobe and associated smaller right paramere and larger left paramere (right lateral view) A P. terryli; Kauai: Namolokama Mtn., 23-v-2005 (
Bursa copulatrix short, broad (as in Fig.
Paratachys spp., left female gonocoxa, ventral view A P. terryli; Kauai: Namolokama Mtn., 23-v-2005 (
This species honors Terry L. Erwin by combining his first name and middle initial to form the genitive patronym Paratachys terryli. This construction follows that of Bembidion carlhi
This species is known from the Alakai Swamp west of the Wainiha River, and from Namolokama Mountain, a ridge to the east bordered by the Lumahei and Hanalei Rivers (Fig.
Tachys arcanicola
Blackburn, 1878: 158;
Paratachys arcanicola, Erwin, 1974b: 139.
Lectotype
male (
Paralectotypes
: Ins. Oahu, Ind. auth. (= Blackburn) (
Honolulu, Perkins (
This is a small-bodied species, standardized body length 1.9–2.2 mm, with ovoid elytra; EL/MEW = 1.40. The pronotum is transverse, MPW/PL = 1.43–1.48, dimensions shared among Hawaiian Paratachys only with some individuals of P. aaa (Fig.
Head
quadrate, ocular lobes little projected, neck broad; frontal grooves bordering convergently convex frons that narrows from anterior supraorbital setae to clypeal margin, the grooves broad and planar laterad convex frons; clypeus convex; eyes small, only slightly convex (Fig.
Aedeagal median lobe nearly straight for much of length, slightly, evenly downturned to the broad, shovel-nosed tip (Fig.
The Reverend Thomas
Tachys arcanicola,
Holotype
female (
Distinguished among all Hawaiian Paratachys by the elongate sinuation of the pronotal lateral margins before the right hind angles; the subquadrate, elongate elytra; and the angulate humeral juncture of the basal and marginal elytral grooves (Fig.
Head
appearing narrow due to elongate mandibles, mandibular length from dorsal condyle to apex twice distance from condyle to lateroapical angle of labrum; ocular lobes little projected, neck broad, eyes convex but small (Fig.
The single historically collected holotype specimen was not dissected.
This species is named to honor its collector, R.C.L. Perkins, who as a new graduate of Oxford University was sent in 1891 to Hawai‘i, by the British Association for the Advancement of Science to collect zoological specimens in support of the ‘Fauna Hawaiiensis’ project (
The lone specimen representing this species is labelled as Perkins’ lot 170, Kaunakakai, July 1893, sea level. Perkins’ Moloka‘i July collecting commenced on 9 July, however much of his time was spent high in the forests (
Holotype
female (
Paratypes. Three specimens with same collection data as holotype (
Immediately diagnosable among Hawaiian Paratachys by the narrow, more quadrate pronotum that is little constricted basally (Fig.
Head
narrow, ocular lobes little projected (Fig.
Aedeagal median lobe convex dorsally, ventral margin straighter, apex a broadly rounded knob densely covered with sensilla (Fig.
Bursa copulatrix short, broad, with spermathecal duct basal terminus at juncture of bursa and common oviduct (as in Fig.
The species epithet haleakalae represents the first declension genitive form indicating the species is distributed on Haleakalā Volcano, East Maui.
The type locality of P. haleakalae is Dogleg Camp, so named because the site is near a prominence of the upper shelf of Kipahulu Valley at 3000 ft. (910 m) elevation, 20°42.03'N, 156°04.93'W, that overlooks the lower part of the valley drained by Palikea Stream (Fig.
Holotype
male (
Allotypic paratype
female (
Paratypes. Hawai‘i I.: Hamakua District: Pohakuloa Military Training Area, Bobcat Trail, Cave 10265DE, deep zone, 1650 m el., 30-xii-1994, Howarth (
This is a small-bodied, pallid Paratachys with thin, translucent cuticle, and an iridescent sheen to the elytra due to the elongate transverse microsculpture; standardized body length 1.9–2.2 mm. The eyes are small but somewhat variable, with from 3–5 ommatidia crossed by a horizontal diameter of the eye, and from 4–6 ommatidia crossed by a vertical diameter (Fig.
Paratachys aaa A male, dorsal habitus view; Kau, Kona Mala, 21–xi–2017, lot HI00179 B mentum and associated mouthparts, ventral view, of above male specimen C larger ovoid compound eye of female, lateral view; Mountain View, Kazumura Cave, 21–xi–2018, lot HI00722 D moderately sized ovoid compound eye of male, lateral view; also lot HI00722 E smaller rounded compound eye of male, lateral view; Kaimu, Burn Cave, 16–19-iii-1994 F small compound eye of male, lateral view; Kaimu, Burn Cave, 16-iii-1994 G stenopterous left metathoracic flight wing of male (elytron removed), dorsal view; Kau, Kona Mala, 21-xi-2017, lot HI00179.
Head
narrow, ocular lobes nearly flattened anterad the genae in dorsal view (Fig.
A series of five individuals from Kaumana Cave, South Hilo District, include the largest individuals observed for this species. Their standardized body lengths range 2.1–2.2 mm, whereas all other individuals from caves in Hamakua, Puna, and Kau District range 1.9–2.1 mm standardized body length. The Kaumana specimens are also more heavily melanized, though their rufo-brunneous coloration is concolorous with the darkest individuals from the other localities. As neither of these attributes are diagnostic, and variation in male genitalia (below) does not support recognition of the Kaumana Cave individuals as representatives of a distinct species, all individuals described here are considered conspecific.
Aedeagal median lobe straight to slightly expanded near midlength, dorsal surface straight near midlength, evenly narrowed to rounded tip that is densely covered with sensilla (Fig.
Bursa copulatrix short, broad, with spermathecal duct entering near base of common oviduct (Fig.
Paratachys aaa female reproductive tract, ventral view; Mountain View, Kazumura Cave, 21-xi-2018, lot HI00713 (
The species name Paratachys aaa incorporates the Hawaiian word ‘a‘a.‘ā, meaning lava cave (
Paratachys aaa has attained a very broad subterranean distribution that includes lava tube caves within Mauna Loa and Kilauea volcanic flows. The species prefers the deep zone of lava tube caves (
At present we can account for five Hawaiian species of Paratachys, each representing a different major island. Given the relative ages of those islands, spanning Kauai to Hawai‘i Island (
Paratachys terryli exhibits two infraspecific polymorphisms; ocular polymorphism with individuals presenting a more or less continuous range of eye sizes ranging from fully developed, i.e., macrophthalmic (Fig.
Infraspecific ocular variation occurs among carabid beetle species across a broad taxonomic spectrum. Melaenus elegans Dejean (tribe Melaenini) sympatrically exhibits two eye morphs, microphthalmous and euphthalmous, toward the eastern parts of its range in Eritrea, Ethiopia, and Somalia, whereas only large-eyed euphthalmous individuals occur toward the western and southern extents of its African distribution (
Elsewhere within Trechitae, populations of the western European-north African Trechus fulvus Dejean, a species ranging from Western Morocco, Spain, Madeira, and north to the British Isles and the Atlantic coast of Norway (
A second dramatic finding regarding Paratachys beetles is the very broad, subterranean geographic distribution of P. aaa (Fig.
The expansive geographic distribution of P. aaa stands in stark contrast to those of trechine cave carabid beetles of the Azores, where two species, Trechus picoensis
Not all Hawaiian cave organisms are geographically widespread, with the highly restricted distributions of species in the herbivorous Oliarus polyphemus Fennah (Hemiptera: Cixiidae) cave planthopper complex (Wessel 2013) standing in stark contrast to the extensive distribution of the predatory P. aaa. Populations of the O. polyphemus complex have diverged so that six distinct species, definable by mitochondrial haplotype and male mating calls, occur among caves on Hualalai, Mauna Loa and Kilauea. Oliarus hoppers feed exclusively on roots of ohia lehua plants emerging from cave ceilings, and thus populations are tied to the presence of ohia trees living on the surfaces of flows above the caves. Dispersal among different cave systems is considered very rare and so it is hypothesized that populations are repeatedly established by very limited numbers of individuals, leading to founder-flush speciation. The six cave Oliarus species have speciated within subterranean lava tubes that formed during the past 200,000 years (
It is clear from this revision that the conservation status of Hawaiian Paratachys ranges from relatively stable to exceedingly tenuous, even terminal. Paratachys arcanicola was last collected by R.C.L. Perkins in the hills north of Honolulu, O‘ahu in the early 20th Century. These forest habitats were home to a number of species absent from the collecting record since then, with those species presumably extinct (
As Terry Erwin exemplified, all biological research begins in the field, in direct contact with nature. This particular study was made possible by collaboration with colleagues eager and willing to conduct sometimes grueling field work, including David H. Kavanaugh (Kauai 1991), Arthur C. Medeiros, Jr. (Haleakalā, Maui 1991), and Curtis P. Ewing, Dan A. Polhemus, and Andrew E. Z. Short (Kauai 2005). Martha Erickson is thanked for her gracious hospitality during the 1991 field trip to Kauai. The productive 2005 expedition to Namolokama Mountain, Kauai was enhanced by access to the facilities of the Souza Center, Hui o Laka Koke‘e, located in Koke‘e State Park. Additionally, I acknowledge the immense, laborious, and productive contributions of cavers who have accrued the wide-ranging samples of Paratachys aaa described above. These efforts were pioneered by Francis G. Howarth, with later assistance by Scott E. Miller (