Research Article |
Corresponding author: Somsak Panha ( somsak.pan@chula.ac.th ) Academic editor: Frank Köhler
© 2020 Chirasak Sutcharit, Khamla Inkhavilay, Somsak Panha.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Sutcharit C, Inkhavilay K, Panha S (2020) Taxonomic note on Trichelix horrida (Pfeiffer, 1863) from Laos, with a type catalogue of Moellendorffia, Trichelix, and Moellendorffiella (Heterobranchia, Camaenidae). ZooKeys 952: 65-93. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.952.52695
|
Land snail surveys conducted in northern Laos between 2013 and 2014 have led to the discovery of a living population of Trichelix horrida (Pfeiffer, 1863). This species has never been recorded from specimens other than the types, and its distribution and anatomy have remained essentially unknown. The genitalia and radula morphology are documented here for the first time and employed to re-assess the systematic position of this species: the unique morphological characters of T. horrida are a penis similar in length to the vagina, a small and triangular penial verge, gametolytic organs extending as far as the albumen gland, head wart present, and unicuspid triangular radula teeth. The type locality of this species was believed to be from “Lao Mountains, Camboja,” and is restricted herein to be Luang Phrabang Province, northern Laos. The assignment of species to either of three genera, Trichelix Ancey, 1887, Moellendorffia Ancey, 1887, and Moellendorffiella Pilsbry, 1905, based solely on information provided in their original descriptions is difficult. The type specimens of all nominal species presently placed in either of these three genera are examined and illustrated herein. Comparison with the primary type specimens will assist future revisions aiming to resolve the systematics of these taxa. In addition, we transfer Moellendorffia faberiana (Möllendorff, 1888) to the genus Moellendorffiella.
Biodiversity, Indochina, Japan, land snail, limestone, systematics, type specimen
The land snail genus Trichelix Ancey, 1887 has a wide distribution from southeastern China to the northern parts of Laos and Vietnam, Taiwan, and the central Ryukyu Islands of Japan (
Helix horrida Pfeiffer, 1863 was established based on three specimens from the collection of H. Cuming, and these syntypes were collected by H. Mouhot. The type locality was stated to be “Lao Mountains, Camboja,” without any other precise locality information. Localities recorded by Mouhot were usually tentative and based on a broad geographical scale. This has rendered it difficult to infer the type localities of many species that were described based on material collected by Mouhot, including fish (
Here, we report on the examination of examples of T. horrida (Pfeiffer, 1863) collected from northern Laos. The type locality is discussed, and a correction is proposed in accordance with the guidelines of
Shells and living specimens were collected in a limestone forest in Luang Phrabang Province, northern Laos. The live specimens were photographed, euthanized (
Anatomical conventions and abbreviations: In the descriptions of the genitalia, the following abbreviations are used, as defined by
Photos of the type specimens from the Molluscs Collection (IM) of
Trichelix
Helix (Trihelix):
Moellendorffia
(Trihelix [sic]):
Moellendorffia (Trichelix):
Helix horrida Pfeiffer, 1863; by original designation.
Shell small to medium-sized, flattened to concave, rather thin, umbilicate, and corneous to brownish. Spire shrunken; embryonic shell nearly smooth; following whorls granulated and with short to long periostracal hairs arranged in oblique rows along the lines of growth. Last whorl rounded and descending anteriorly. Aperture ventral or subvertical; trigonal or subcircular; with strong or weak barriers inside the aperture at upper periphery and below periphery, and externally marked with strong to weak longitudinal furrows. Peristome expanded and continuous or discontinuous; parietal callus thin or thickened and little elevated.
Genitalia typical of camaenids, without either dart apparatus or accessory glands. Penis and epiphallus long, penial verge present, and flagellum short. Internal wall of penis and vagina with longitudinal pilasters.
Radular teeth arranged in V-shaped rows; central and lateral teeth triangular.
The genus is currently comprised of six nominal species (
Helix horrida
Helix (Trihelix) horrida:
Helix (Moellendorffia) horrida:
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) horrida:
Moellendorffia horrida:
Three specimens originating from H. Cuming’s collection with the original label stating the taxon name and collection location in Pfeiffer’s handwriting are present in the malacological collection of the NHMUK. Of these specimens, the one most closely matching the measurements given in the original description is here designated as the lectotype NHMUK 20200202/1 (Fig.
Trichelix horrida was originally described based on specimens collected by H. Mouhot, with “Lao Mountain, Camboja” as the published type locality. Our survey following Mouhot’s itinerary in the south-western part of Cambodia yielded no specimens that could be identified in this genus. This record type locality seems to be imprecise. On the other hand, our survey in the northern part of Laos, where Mouhot had visited Luang Phrabang in 1861, recorded populations of this species in Muang Ngoi about 90 km north of Luang Phrabang City. Therefore, we restricted the known distribution and propose Luang Phrabang Province, Laos as the correct type locality for this species.
Moist evergreen forest on limestone hills between Ban Pha Toke and Ban Nong Ian, Muang Ngoi (Town), Ngoi District, Luang Phrabang Province, Laos (20°32'31.2"N, 102°38'56.3"E):
From 10 specimens analyzed; shell height ranged from 12.4–14.7 mm (mean 13.5 ± 1.0); shell width ranged from 20.8–23.9 mm (mean 22.0 ± 1.2); and whorl count ranged from 6–6⅛ whorls.
Shell medium-sized, dextral, slightly thin, translucent, depressed globose, biconcave shaped (dorsoventrally concave), and deeply umbilicate. Whorls 5–6, slightly convex, and increasing regularly; suture depressed, spire concave, looking like umbilicus. Embryonic shell large with very fine growth lines. Following whorl with corneous to brownish periostracum; upper surface with long hairs arranged in oblique rows; lower surface with slightly shorter hairs and few hairs around umbilicus. In worn specimens, shell surface possesses rough rows of tubercles running obliquely and descending, relatively smooth around umbilicus. Last whorl well rounded and little convex below periphery. Last whorl descending about ¼ whorl from aperture, and constriction occurs close to apertural lip. Aperture ear-shaped and opened subventrally; lip margin pale corneous, little thickened, and continuously expanded. External furrow aligns with internal apertural lamella or fold. Upper periphery marked with two furrows arranged spirally and correspond with palatal lamella and fold; below periphery with one furrow close to lip aligned with basal lamella. Parietal callus thickened, elevated, emarginated, and obtusely projecting inward. Umbilicus wide, but narrower than apex side which is cascade-shouldered.
Atrium (at) short; penis (p) long; proximally with penial verge and enlarged fold at penial verge base; distally similar in length as proximally and somewhat slender tube. Epiphallus (e) slightly enlarged and almost the same length as penis. Flagellum (fl) very short and small. Vas deferens (vd) a small tube, follows vagina and penis, and connects distally on epiphallus and free oviduct. Penial retractor muscle (pr) slightly thickened and long (Fig.
Internal wall of penis ribbed by a series of swollen longitudinal penial pilasters (pp). Smooth pilasters line introverts penial chamber and encircles penial verge tip. Penial verge (pv) small, short conic with smooth surface (Fig.
Vagina (v) of similar length to proximal penis and held in position by series of muscles attached to foot floor. Gametolytic organ (duct and sac) long, cylindrical, and extending as far as albumen gland. Gametolytic duct (gd) as wide as gametolytic sac (gs) for most of its length but narrows before reaching gametolytic sac. Free oviduct (fo) short, about half of vagina length; oviduct (ov) small. Prostate gland (pg) and oviduct (ov) developed; hermaphroditic duct long and convoluted tube; albumen gland solid and tongue shape (Fig.
Internal wall of vagina possesses several longitudinal vaginal pilasters (vp). Pilasters with smooth surface and line entire vaginal chamber (Fig.
Genitalia and radula of T. horrida specimen
Live animal covered with blackish-brown reticulated skin and dorsally with whitish stripe in middle of the body. A small curved head wart (hw) is located between the posterior tentacles (Fig.
Teeth arranged in anteriorly pointed, V-shaped rows; each row contains about 75 (37-(18–20)-1-(18–20)-38) teeth. Central tooth unicuspid, triangular with blunt cusp. Lateral teeth unicuspid, triangular with blunt tip, gradually taller laterally and little inclined to central tooth. Marginal teeth starting around tooth numbers 18 to 20 outwards from lateral teeth. Tricuspid or bicuspid marginal teeth, endocone usually absent; mesocone large, broad and with curved to blunt cusp; ectocone slightly large, pointed head and located at base of the teeth. Outer marginal teeth rather small; mesocone and ectocone indistinguishable, with undulated cusp (Fig.
Trichelix horrida was previously known only from the type locality (“Lao Mountain, Cambojia” [Cambodia or Laos]). The specimens examined herein were collected from limestone karst in Muang Ngoi Town, about 90 km north of Luang Phrabang City.
Our sampling locality was characterized by monsoonal karst landforms with high humidity. The snails occurred in tropical moist deciduous forest. There was heavy rain before our visit in August 2014. The snails were active, crawling or sitting on moist rotten logs among the limestone outcrops.
Trichelix horrida is distinctly different in shell morphology from all other Moellendorffia species by having a concave spire, rounded last whorl, and two furrows arranged spirally on the upper periphery (Table
Comparison of Trichelix (continental and eastern Asian islands species) and the related genera Moellendorffia and Moellendorffiella.
Characters | Moellendorffia Ancey, 1887 | Trichelix Ancey, 1887 | Moellendorffiella Pilsbry, 1905 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Continental group | Central Ryukyu group | |||
Shell shape | low conic to convex | concave | concave | flat |
Last whorl | round or angular | round | round | shouldered or strong shouldered keel |
Periostracal hair | short to long | short to long | short | absent |
Furrow on upper periphery and alignment on last whorl | – | one or two / spiral alignment | – | – |
Furrow on periphery and alignment on last whorl | two / vertical alignment | – | – | one/ spiral alignment |
Furrow below periphery | one and strong | one and strong | absent or very weak | one and strong |
Parietal callus | long elevated with nodule | short elevated with nodule | thin with cords | thin |
Distribution (Fig. |
Southern China and Indochina | Central China, Indochina and Taiwan | Restricted to the Central Ryukyu Islands, Japan | Central China |
Suggested nominal species (bold = type species) |
blaisei, deflexa, dengi, depressispira, eastlakeana, hensaniensis, loxotata, messageri, sculpticoncha, spurca, trisinuata | biscalpta, hiraseana, horrida | diminuta, eucharista, tokunoensis | erdmanni , faberiana |
The newly collected material from Laos presents valuable additional information for the taxonomic position of Trichelix and its congeners. The relationship of Trichelix with Moellendorffia and Moellendorffiella has been suggested based on shell and genital anatomy characters (
The genus Trichelix s.l. appears to be a heteromorphic assemblage, as noted by
In the following catalogue list, the primary type specimens (i.e., holotype, lectotype, and syntype/s) along with secondary type specimens (paratype/s and paralectotype/s) of Moellendorffia, Trichelix, and Moellendorffiella species are provided. The species-group names are arranged by alphabetical order. The references for the usage of each taxon name have been comprehensively provided by
I. Genus Moellendorffia Ancey, 1887
Moellendorffia
Proctostoma
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffia):
Type species.
Helix trisinuata Martens, 1867; by original designation.
Diagnosis.
Shell flattened to globose-conic, and umbilicate. Periostracum thick and covered with short to long hairs. Last whorl rounded to shoulder and descending anteriorly. Aperture trigonal or squarish, entirely free from preceding whorl; with barriers inside, and externally marked with furrows. Parietal wall elevated to form prominent nodule; one or two palatal lamellae (two lamellae arranged vertically); one columellar lamella.
Remarks.
The genus Moellendorffia can be distinguished from Trichelix s.l. in having low conical to elevated spire, one or two furrows (arranged vertically) on periphery and elevated parietal callus, while Trichelix s.l. has a concave spire. In addition, the continental-Trichelix have one or two furrows (arranged spirally) on the upper periphery and little elevated parietal callus, and the Central Ryukyu-Trichelix performs very weak or absent furrows, and a thin parietal callus.
1. blaisei Dautzenberg & Fischer, 1905
Moellendorffia blaisei
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
A Moellendorffia blaisei, syntype
2. callitricha (Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1899)
Helix (Moellendorffia) callitricha
Moellendorffia callitricha:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Synonym of Moellendorffia eastlakeana (see
Type specimens.
Syntype
3. deflexa Möllendorff, 1901
Moellendorffia spurca deflexa
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffia) spurca deflexa:
Moellendorffia spurca deflexa:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia spurca. Accepted subspecies.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated in
4. dengi Yang, Fan, Qiao & He, 2012
Moellendorffia dengi
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Holotype ZMHN AIMS 1693 (Fig.
5. depressispira (Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1909)
Helix (Moellendorffia) depressispira
Moellendorffia depressispira:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
6. eastlakeana (Möllendorff, 1882)
Helix eastlakeana
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffia) eastlakeana:
Moellendorffia eastlakeana:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated in
7. exasperata (Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1909)
Helix (Moellendorffia) loxotata var. exasperata
Moellendorffia loxotata exasperata:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia loxotata. Accepted subspecies.
Type specimens.
Syntype
A Moellendorffia loxotata exasperata, syntype
8. hensaniensis (Gredler, 1885)
Helix (Polygyra) hensaniensis
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffia) hensaniensis:
Moellendorffia hensaniensis:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated in
9. loxotata (Mabille, 1887)
Helix loxotata
Proctostoma loxotatum:
Moellendorffia loxotata:
Moellendorffia loxotata loxotata:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
10. messageri (Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1899)
Helix (Moellendorffia) messageri Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1899: 33–35, pl. 1, fig. 5. Type locality: entre Lang-Son et That-Khé [That Khe Town, Trang Dinh District, Lang Son Province, Vietnam].
Moellendorffia messageri:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
11. sculpticoncha (Zilch, 1951)
Helix (Polygyra) trisinuata var. sculptilis
Moellendorffia trisinuata sculpticoncha
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia trisinuata sculpticoncha. Accepted subspecies (
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated in
12. sculptilis Möllendorff, 1884
Remarks.
see under “sculpticoncha”.
13. spurca (Bavay & Dautzenberg, 1899)
Helix (Moellendorffia) spurca
Moellendorffia spurca:
Moellendorffia spurca spurca:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
A Moellendorffia spurca, syntype
14. trisinuata (Martens, 1867)
Helix trisinuata
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffia) trisinuata trisinuata:
Moellendorffia trisinuata:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
II. Genus Trichelix Ancey, 1887
Type species.
Helix horrida Pfeiffer, 1863; by original designation.
Diagnosis.
Shell flattened to concave, spire shrunken and umbilicate. Periostracum covered with short hairs. Last whorl well rounded and descending anteriorly. Aperture subcircular, without barrier or with barriers inside, and externally marked with furrows. Parietal callus thin, with cord at margin or a little elevated to form nodule; two palatal lamellae arranged spirally; one columellar lamella.
Remarks.
The genus Trichelix s.l. can be distinguished from Moellendorffiella by having concave spire, and short to long periostracal hairs, while Moellendorffiella have flat spire and without periostracal hair. The Central Ryukyu-Trichelix have a thin parietal callus with cord and very weak furrows below the periphery, and the continental-Trichelix have an elevated parietal callus with a nodule, and there are one or two furrows (arranged spirally) on the upper periphery. In comparison, Moellendorffiella has a thin parietal callus and one furrow on periphery.
15. biscalpta (Heude, 1885)
Helix biscalpta
Moellendorffia biscalpta:
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) biscalpta:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Syntype
Remarks.
The original description does not clearly state how many specimens were available to the author, and a unique name-bearing type was not explicitly designated.
16. diminuta (Pilsbry & Hirase, 1905)
Moellendorffia eucharistus diminuta
Moellendorffia diminuta:
Moellendorffia eucharistus diminuta:
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) diminuta:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated by
17. eucharista (Pilsbry, 1901)
Chloritis eucharistus
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) eucharistus:
Moellendorffia eucharista:
Trichelix eucharistis:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remark.
The lectotype was designated in
18. helleri (Rolle, 1911)
Stegodera (Trichelix) helleri
Moellendorffia hiraseana helleri:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Synonym of Trichelix hiraseana (see
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
19. hiraseana Pilsbry, 1905
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) hiraseana
Moellendorffia hiraseana:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
A Trichelix hiraseana, lectotype
Remarks.
20. horrida (Pfeiffer, 1863)
Helix horrida
Moellendorffia horrida:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype NHMUK 20200202/1 ex. Cuming coll. (Fig.
21. malangensis (Bullen, 1905)
Chloritis malangensis
Moellendorffia eucharista malangensis:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Synonym of Trichelix eucharista (see
Type specimens.
Syntypes NHMUK 19991540 (two shells, Fig.
Remarks.
22. oshimana (Gude, 1901)
Chloritis oshimana
Moellendorffia eucharista oshimana:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Synonym of Trichelix eucharista (see
Type specimens.
Syntype NHMUK 1922.8.29.83 (one shell, Fig.
Remark.
23. tokunoensis (Pilsbry & Hirase, 1905)
Moellendorffia eucharistus tokunoensis
Moellendorffia tokunoensis:
Moellendorffia eucharista tokunoensis:
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) tokunoensis:
Current taxonomic status.
Trichelix. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The original description did not clearly state how many specimens were available to Pilsbry, although he stated “Types No. 90,048, A. N. S. Phila., from No. 1,207 of Mr. Hirase’s collection.” Later,
III. Genus Moellendorffiella Pilsbry, 1905
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffiella)
Moellendorffiella:
Type species.
Helix (Moellendorffia) erdmanni Schmacker & Boettger, 1894; monotypy.
Diagnosis.
Shell flattened and umbilicate. Periostracum thin, corneous. Last whorl shouldered and descending anteriorly. Aperture subcircular with barriers inside and externally marked with furrows. Parietal callus thin; one palatal lamella; one columellar lamella.
Remarks.
The genus Moellendorffiella differs from Moellendorffia in having one furrow on periphery, parietal callus thin, and without periostracal hair. While, Moellendorffia has one or two furrows on periphery, parietal callus elevated with nodule and short to long periostracal hairs.
24. erdmanni (Schmacker & Boettger, 1894)
Helix (Moellendorffia) erdmanni
Moellendorffia (Moellendorffiella) erdmanni:
Moellendorffia erdmanni:
Moellendorffiella erdmanni:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffiella. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Lectotype
Remarks.
The lectotype was designated in
25. faberiana (Möllendorff, 1888) comb. nov.
Helix faberiana
Moellendorffia (Trichelix) faberiana:
Moellendorffia faberiana:
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffiella. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Holotype
Remarks.
The distinguishing characters are depressed conic spire, aperture with elevated parietal callus, furrows on periphery and below periphery. Therefore, we move this species to the genus Moellendorffiella.
mariae (Nobre, 1909)
Stegodera (Moellendorffia) mariae
Moellendorffia mariae:
Current taxonomic status.
Not a member of Moellendorffia, Trichelix, or Moellendorffiella.
Type specimens.
The type specimen could not be located.
Remarks.
This nominal species was described by
polygyrella Yü, 1982
Moellendorffia ? polygyrella Yü in
Current taxonomic status.
Moellendorffia. Valid species.
Type specimens.
Holotype
Remarks.
The species was described based on one specimen. The holotype has a relatively small shell (shell width 8 mm) compared to other recent congeners. This species possesses a smooth shell surface and a narrow umbilicus. The outer surface of the last whorl probably has one spiral furrow on the periphery and two spiral furrows below the periphery. These characters suggest the possibility that it is closely related to the genus Traumatophora Ancey, 1887 (see
The authors are grateful to all members of the Animal Systematics Research Unit, Chulalongkorn University for their kind help during field trips in Laos. Special thanks go to the Faculty of Natural Science, National University of Laos for the preparation of permission documents and data collection in Laos. The authors are also indebted to P. Callomon and E. Wildner (