Research Article |
Corresponding author: Royce T. Cumming ( roycecumming@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Marco Gottardo
© 2020 Royce T. Cumming, Jessa H. Thurman, Sam Youngdale, Stephane Le Tirant.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Cumming RT, Thurman JH, Youngdale S, Tirant SL (2020) Walaphyllium subgen. nov., the dancing leaf insects from Australia and Papua New Guinea with description of a new species (Phasmatodea, Phylliidae). ZooKeys 939: 1-28. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.939.52071
|
A new subgenus, Walaphyllium subgen. nov., is described within Phyllium Illiger, 1798 to accommodate three leaf insect species. One of the species included is newly described herein as Phyllium (Walaphyllium) lelantos sp. nov. from Papua New Guinea. This new subgenus of Phyllium can be diagnosed by a following combination of features. This new species is compared to the two additional new subgenus members, Phyllium zomproi Größer, 2001 and Phyllium monteithi Brock & Hasenpusch, 2003. Also for the first time the male morphology of Phyllium zomproi is described and illustrated. To conclude, a brief biogeographical view of the leaf insects on either side of the Torres Strait is presented, as well as a key to species and a distribution map to the known species of Phyllium (Walaphyllium) subgen. nov.
Biogeography, Djagubay, entomology, Phasmida, Phylliinae, Phyllium, Queensland, taxonomy, walking leaf
The leaf insects (Phylliidae) are leaf-mimicking phasmids with flattened abdomens and tibial and/or femoral lobes enlarged to resemble leaves. These adaptations give them incredible camouflage, which allows them to blend in amongst their host plants (Fig.
The Phylliidae in their extant range can be found throughout tropical Asia, from India and China, through to Australia, New Caledonia, and Fiji. Many of these regions where leaf insects are more commonly encountered, such as the Philippines, Indonesia, or India, have had well-known specimen records since the 1700 and 1800’s (
As is often the case, if a phasmid specialist has not spent ample time working within a collection, the Phylliidae specimens within are often misidentified or left with no species-specific identification. This is likely due to the pronounced sexual dimorphism of the leaf insects and the difficulty of collecting specimens because of their natural camouflage. These hindrances often lead to small type series and largely incomplete museum collections, which has historically resulted in the higher taxonomy within the Phylliidae being minimally assessed.
An example of this neglect from in-depth review is the case of the Australian Phyllium monteithi which was known for 63 years before it was recognized as a valid and unique species endemic to Australia and not simply Phyllium siccifolium as so many specimens have erroneously been called over the years (Brock & Hasenpusch, 2003). Only in recent years have morphological features such as wing venation and egg morphology begun to be extensively reviewed within the Phylliidae (
Upon review of the Phylliidae collection within the Natural History Museum United Kingdom, while focusing on wing morphology, an undescribed species of leaf insect from Papua New Guinea was discovered. After reviewing congenerics, we found that not only was this specimen an undescribed species but that there were two other well-known species which formed a unique clade separate from other Phyllium (Phyllium). We here transfer these two species (Phyllium monteithi Brock & Hasenpusch, 2003 and Phyllium zomproi Größer, 2001), from the siccifolium group of Phyllium (Phyllium) as described in
Photographs of the holotype specimen were taken by René Limoges of the Montreal Insectarium using a Nikon D810 DSLR camera with Nikon Micro-Nikkor 200mm f/4 lens on Manfrotto 454 micrometric positioning sliding plate. Lighting was provided by two Nikon SB-25 flash units with a Cameron Digital diffusion photo box. Adobe Photoshop Elements 13 was used as post processing software. Measurements of the holotype were made to the nearest 0.1 mm using digital calipers. The Phyllium lelantos sp. nov. holotype specimen is deposited in the Natural History Museum United Kingdom collection. The holotype specimen was loaned to the Montreal Insectarium by the Natural History Museum United Kingdom with the assistance of Judith Marshall and Benjamin Price.
Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of female Phyllium monteithi antennae were produced using a Hitachi Tabletop Microscope (Model: TM4000) at the Centre for Microscopy and Microanalysis (CMM) of the University of Queensland, Australia. All specimens were sputter coated with silver (SPI Module Sputter Coater with Carbon Module, Structure Probe, Inc., West Chester, PA) and mounted on a circular specimen-stage. The specimen in Figure
Egg orientation terminology follows Clark (1978). Wing venation terminology follows
The following institutional abbreviations are used:
Coll JHT Jessa H. Thurman private collection, Australia.
Coll RC Royce T. Cumming private collection, U.S.A.
Coll SLT Stéphane Le Tirant private collection, Canada.
The following wing venation abbreviations are used in Figure
C costa
Sc subcosta
R radius
R1 first radius
R2 second radius
Rs radial sector
R–M radius to media crossvein
M media
MA media anterior
MP media posterior
MP1 first media posterior
MP2 second media posterior
M–Cu media to cubitus crossvein
Cu cubitus
CuA cubitus anterior
CuP cubitus posterior
CuP1 first cubitus posterior
CuP2 second cubitus posterior
Cu+1AA cubitus fused with first anterior anal
1AA–7AA anterior anal veins one through seven
1PA–5PA posterior anal veins one through five
1A first anal
Phyllium zomproi Größer, 2001: 96.
This new subgenus is restricted to Papua New Guinea (two species; Fig.
Dorsal view of the known species within the Phyllium (Walaphyllium), scaled to relative size to show the size differences between species A Phyllium zomproi female, Coll SLT B Phyllium zomproi male, Coll RC 17-336 C Phyllium monteithi female dorsal, Coll RC 16-067 D Phyllium monteithi male dorsal, Coll SLT E Phyllium lelantos holotype male,
This new subgenus is easily separated from the other Phyllium subgenera by the following combination of features: [Male] tegmina media vein with an anterior media vein (MA) and two posterior media veins (MP1 and MP2) (Fig.
Features which characterize this new subgenus, but do not necessarily differentiate it from others are: in males well-developed ocelli (Figs
Feature | Pulchriphyllium Griffini, 1898 | Walaphyllium subgen. nov. | Phyllium Illiger, 1798 |
Comptaphyllium |
---|---|---|---|---|
Egg Capsule | No pinnae (surface pitted and brittle) | No Pinnae (instead an irregular porous, sponge-like texture, brittle, not flexible) | Pinnae (rope, feather, or moss-like of various lengths, all flexible) | Pinnae (feather-like) |
Egg Operculum | Conically raised | Conically raised | Flat, margin with rope, or feather-like pinnae or conically raised, with moss-like pinnae | Flat, with a prominent sagittal fan of feather-like pinnae through the center |
Male Tegmina (Radial) | Variable: can be branched once into first radius and radial sector, or branched into the first radius, second radius, and radial sector | Variable: can be branched once into first radius and radial sector, or branched as many as four times | Variable: can be branched once into first radius and radial sector, or branched as many as three times | Branched once into first radius and radial sector |
Male Tegmina (Media) | With an anterior media vein (MA) and two posterior media veins (MP1 and MP2) | With an anterior media vein (MA) and two posterior media veins (MP1 and MP2) | Variable: can simply be branched into the anterior media (MA) and posterior (MP) or with an anterior media vein (MA) and two posterior media veins (MP1 and MP2) | Branched into the anterior media (MA) and posterior (MP) only |
Female Tegmina (Media and Cubitus) | Media and cubitus side by side (touching or or less than one vein width away) until the media posterior diverges to the wing margin | Media and cubitus with spacing between many times wider than the width of a vein for a majority of the length | Media and cubitus with spacing between many times wider than the width of a vein for a majority of the length | Media and cubitus with spacing between many times wider than the width of a vein for a majority of the length |
Female Tegmina (Cubitus Branching) | With an anterior and posterior cubitus only | With an anterior cubitus and a branched posterior cubitus into the first and second posterior cubitus | With an anterior and posterior cubitus only | With an anterior and posterior cubitus only |
Male Vomer | 1 hook | 1 hook | 1 or 2 hooks | 1 hook |
Tibial Exterior Lobes (Male and Female) | Yes | No | Yes or No | No |
Of these three species in this new subgenus, only P. monteithi has been in the phasmid breeding community to date and therefore this is the only species with the newly hatched nymph coloration known. Please see the below P. monteithi section for a description of the nymph coloration.
Walaphyllium meaning “Dancing Leaf”. This subgeneric epithet is a compound of the Latinized name Phyllium, the type genus for the family (from Greek φυλλον, -ου (phyllon, -oy) + -um;
Phyllium (Walaphyllium) zomproi Größer, 2001 (Fig.
Phyllium (Walaphyllium) monteithi Brock & Hasenpusch, 2003 (Fig.
Phyllium (Walaphyllium) lelantos sp. nov. (Fig.
Papua New Guinea: Morobe Province, Aseki (Winduwe) (
Despite being a rarer species in private and museum collections, this is a widespread species, with records from two Papua New Guinea provinces (Morobe and Gulf, Fig.
Body size; females: 80.0–86.0 mm; males: 79.0 mm.
Male. Coloration. Coloration description based on the limited male specimens from within the authors collections and the
Morphology.
Head. Head capsule slightly longer than wide, vertex is lumpy with a smooth texture, not overly granular. Frontal convexity stout with a broad point, apex marked with five to seven thin setae. The posteromedial tubercle is not prominent, only slightly raised from the posterior of the head capsule. Antennae. Antennae consist of 22–23 segments (including the scapus and pedicellus), all segments except the scapus and pedicellus and terminal six are covered in moderately dense tan setae that are as long as the antennae segment is wide. The terminal six segments are covered in tan setae that are about as dense as the setae on the other segments but much shorter (some only slightly raised above the segment surface), and the scapus and pedicellus are without setae. Compound eyes large (taking up about half of the head capsule length) but not notably protruding away from the head (Fig.
Australia, Queensland: Mt. Lewis, near Julatten (Holotype:
Records taken from specimens examined and from
Phyllium monteithi is the most common phylliid species from Australia (the second and only other species being Nanophyllium australianum Cumming, Le Tirant, & Teemsma, 2018 which is exceedingly rare). For the Phyllium (Walaphyllium) new subgenus, this is the most commonly encountered species and has been in the phasmid breeding community for numerous years.
Female Phyllium monteithi can be differentiated from Phyllium zomproi by several morphological features. One is the number of teeth on the stridulatory file of the third antennal segment with 27 to 29 teeth on P. monteithi (Fig.
Body size: males: 61.0–64.0 mm, females: 75.0–76.0 mm.
General color throughout the antennae, head, and thorax is dark brown (Fig.
Holotype ♂: Papua New Guinea, Watut, Morobe Province, I.1992.
The female and eggs are currently unknown; therefore, differentiation is only given for male morphology. This new species is the smallest within the newly erected subgenus, with the holotype only 53.3 mm long, versus males of P. monteithi 61.0–64.0 mm or P. zomproi at 79.0 mm (Figs
Morphologically, P. lelantos sp. nov. appears to be most similar to P. monteithi based on the thorax spination, with the less pronounced mesopleurae tubercles and the anterior prescutum rim with a weakly formed sagittal tubercle (Fig.
Female and egg. Unknown.
Male. Coloration. Coloration description is based on the single preserved holotype specimen. It is expected that live individuals are likely vibrant green in life. Overall coloration green throughout with yellow to tan discoloration in places due to the drying of the specimen. Compound eyes and the four terminal antennae segments are of a rusty brown color darker than the tan on the head or thorax. The rest of the antennae are of a tan to green color. The protibial interior lobe has brown marking throughout most of the surface, this is the only lobe that has brown colorations, the others are a normal green like the rest of the body. The head through to the thorax are more tan than green in the dried specimen but were likely a darker green in life. There are two faint circular eye spots on the fifth abdominal segment with all others lacking markings.
Morphology.
Head. Head capsule slightly longer than wide, with a vertex marked by sparse, small evenly sized nodes. Frontal convexity stout with sides that converge to the point which is slightly recurved, not straight; the surface is sparsely covered in thin transparent setae (Fig.
Noun. Because leaf insects are such cryptic insects so rarely observed, or in this case only known from a single specimen, we felt that the homage of Lelantos the Greek minor Titan of “moving unseen” was fitting. Lelantos’ name is derived from the Greek Ληλαντος (lêthô, lanthanô, and lelathon), meaning “to escape notice”, “move unseen”, or “go unobserved” (
Only known from the holotype specimen from Papua New Guinea, Morobe Province, Watut (Fig.
Length of body (including cerci and head, excluding antennae) 53.3, length/width of head 3.8/2.8, antennae (but slightly bent so measurement is slightly off) 12.0, pronotum 2.5, mesonotum 1.5, length of tegmina 15.1 (left) and 11.8 (right, which appears to be slightly aberrant and dwarfed), length of alae 38.5, greatest width of abdomen 10.5, profemora 7.4, mesofemora 8.8, metafemora 11.0, protibiae 5.8, mesotibiae 5.7, metatibiae 7.5.
The Torres Strait is a narrow body of water which separates mainland points of northern Queensland, Australia from southern New Guinea by approximately 130 km (
The present status of the Torres Strait as a barrier has been debated for different taxa (
While reviewing specimens of this clade we propose herein as Walaphyllium, we found that they contained a combination of morphological features which made it unclear to which taxonomic level it should be placed (as a genus or a subgenus). Presently the genus Phyllium has several morphologically distinct clades which are treated taxonomically as subgenera (Phyllium Illiger, 1798; Pulchriphyllium Griffini, 1898; and Comptaphyllium
Ultimately, we decided to place this clade as a subgenus of Phyllium, but not as a genus of their own due to several morphological factors. First, the two previously described species we here transfer to Walaphyllium (P. monteithi and P. zomproi) have historically been placed within the morphologically diverse siccifolium species group of the Phyllium subgenus, which concealed their unique combination of features (
Features which are shared between the Walaphyllium and the subgenera Comptaphyllium and Phyllium are: females with the media and cubitus veins which have spacing between them several times wider than a single vein width (Pulchriphyllium has these two veins close together, with a distance less than one vein width apart). On the other hand, a shared feature between the Pulchriphyllium and the Walaphyllium that separates them from the other subgenera are the eggs, which lack pinnae, have a brittle pitted surface, and have an operculum which is conically raised. No other features were found that were worth noting as unique between clades, either due to variability within subgenera or simply the features were universal among them and not worth noting (see Table
The only autapomorphy we were able to identify for the Walaphyllium is that the female tegmina have the posterior cubitus branched into the first and second posterior cubitus veins (Fig.
A possible autapomorphy for the Walaphyllium is the morphology of the individual teeth on the stridulatory file of the female third antennomere. Unfortunately, there are very few published SEM images of stridulatory files for the different phylliid clades so our observations lack sufficient support to be considered definitive.
Fortunately, members of the other Phyllium subgenera have had their stridulatory files imaged with a SEM. The Phyllium (Pulchriphyllium) based on an individual of Phyllium bioculatum Gray, 1832 was presented in figure 5 of
In contrast, P. monteithi, instead has teeth which are raised ovoids with a distinct central pit at the apex of each individual tooth (Fig.
Our inclusion of SEM images of the P. monteithi antennae structure is largely an attempt to illustrate the stridulatory file morphology, to visualize this previously unpublished fine detail, and to demonstrate that there is variable morphology at this level which should be included in future revisionary works. Future SEM visualization projects will image all phylliid clades and several representatives within each clade to allow better morphological comparison and possibly reveal underlying morphological relationships.
Despite the Walaphyllium being a small clade of only three species, there are morphological features which suggest the internal relatedness of these species. Based on the spination of the thorax it appears as though P. monteithi and P. lelantos sp. nov. are likely sister species as evident by their weakly formed prescutum anterior sagittal tubercle (Fig.
These morphologically based observations are currently the compelling evidence to differentiate the Walaphyllium from other clades. It is expected that upcoming molecular analyses will help to clarify the higher taxonomy within the Phylliidae, and will reveal if the Walaphyllium is a sublineage within the Phyllium or if this clade warrants treatment as a separate genus. But, at the present we do not have molecular evidence to suggest the proper placement of this clade, and therefore we place it under the taxonomic umbrella of Phyllium.
Females and eggs are only known for Phyllium monteithi and Phyllium zomproi, therefore only a key to males is included here. See
1 | Profemoral exterior lobe less than two times the greatest width of the profemoral shaft; tegmina with a radial sector vein (RS) and only one additional radial vein (R1); Papua New Guinea | P. lelantos sp. nov. |
– | Profemoral exterior lobe wider than two times the greatest width of the profemoral shaft; tegmina with a radial sector vein (RS) and more than one additional radial vein (two to four additional radials) | 2 |
2 | Large body size (~79.0 mm); margin of abdominal segments VIII and IX not uniformly converging to the terminal abdominal segment, instead segment VIII is subparallel, and segment IX is strongly rounded, not straight; tegmina with a radial sector vein (RS) and two additional radial veins only (R1 and R2); Papua New Guinea | P. zomproi |
– | Medium body size (61.0–64.0 mm); margin of abdominal segments VIII and IX with straight margins uniformly converging to the terminal abdominal segment; tegmina with a radial sector vein (RS) and four additional radial veins (R1, R2, R3, and R4); Northeastern Australia | P. monteithi |
The authors thank René Limoges, entomological technician at the Montreal Insectarium, Canada for taking many photos for this work, as well as for many professional courtesies. Jack Hasenpusch (Australia) for photographs of live Phyllium monteithi and habitat for this work. Judith Marshall and Benjamin Price at the Natural History Museum United Kingdom (