Research Article |
Corresponding author: Luis Felipe S. P. Mayorga ( luisfelipe@ipram-es.org.br ) Academic editor: Nilton Cáceres
© 2020 Luis Felipe S. P. Mayorga, Ralph E. T. Vanstreels, Renata C. C. Bhering, Natália Mamede, Luiz M. B. Costa, Flavia C. F. Pinheiro, Luciano W. D. Reis, Alessandro Trazzi, Wilson Luiz Chevitarese Meirelles, Alan Marques Ribeiro, Salvatore Siciliano.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Mayorga LFSP, Vanstreels RET, Bhering RCC, Mamede N, Costa LMB, Pinheiro FCF, Reis LWD, Trazzi A, Meirelles WLC, Ribeiro AM, Siciliano S (2020) Strandings of cetaceans on the Espírito Santo coast, southeast Brazil, 1975–2015. ZooKeys 948: 129-152. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.948.50468
|
Espírito Santo state is located on the eastern margin of Brazil, in a transitional tropical-subtropical area (18°S–21°S) dominated by oligotrophic waters. With the exception of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae), the cetacean community of Espírito Santo has been understudied. In addition to the chronic impacts from fisheries, marine pollution, urban development, and coastal habitat degradation, in November 2015 the cetacean communities of Espírito Santo were challenged by the greatest environmental disaster in Brazil’s history. The Mariana dam disaster caused 60 million cubic meters of mining waste to be washed into the Doce River, which ultimately flowed to the coastal waters of Espírito Santo, with a high concentration of heavy metals. This study reviews and updates information on cetacean strandings in the state of Espírito Santo (excluding humpback whales) prior to this disaster. From 1975 to September 2015, there were 461 recorded cetacean strandings, representing 20 species. An average 1.18 strandings per 100 km per month were recorded since a state-wide daily beach survey program was implemented in October 2010, contrasting with the 0.14 strandings per 100 km per month in previous years. Six species comprised the majority (94.7%) of stranding events: Guiana dolphin (Sotalia guianensis), Franciscana (Pontoporia blainvillei), rough-toothed dolphin (Steno bredanensis), bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus), sperm whale (Physeter macrocephalus), and melon-headed whale (Peponocephala electra). Oceanic cetaceans stranded most frequently on the southern portion of Espírito Santo, where the continental platform is narrower, whereas the strandings of coastal cetaceans such as Guiana dolphins and Franciscanas were concentrated near estuaries, especially the Doce River. This is particularly concerning in face of the Mariana dam disaster, which drastically altered the estuarine and coastal environment associated with the Doce River.
Atlantic Ocean, coast, estuary, Doce River, Odontoceti, Mysticeti, South America
Records of cetacean strandings provide reliable data on the occurrence of species and are good indicators of species richness, relative abundance and spatial distribution (
Espírito Santo state is located on the eastern margin of Brazil (Figure
Physical, biological, and human characteristics of the coast of Espírito Santo state, southeast Brazil. Legend: A, B Location of Espírito Santo and Trindade and Martim Vaz Islands C human population density, major ports, isobaths, sea surface chlorophyll-a concentration, estuaries, and bays in the study area. Data sources: (Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical et al. 2005,
In November 2015, the marine environment of Espírito Santo suffered drastic impacts from the greatest environmental disaster in Brazil’s history, the Mariana dam disaster. After the rupture of an iron ore tailings dam, approximately 60 million cubic meters of mining waste were washed into the Doce River at the Mariana municipality, Minas Gerais state. The toxic brown mud released by this disaster flowed through the Doce River until reaching the sea at Linhares, Espírito Santo. The toxic effects of the heavy metal-contaminated mudflow became a major concern for the marine fauna along the Espírito Santo coast (
The coastline of Espírito Santo state extends approximately 392 km from Riacho Doce stream (18.3475S, 39.6692W) to Itabapoana River (21.3067S, 40.9583W) (Figure
Data on strandings was derived from the published literature (including detailed data from articles previously published by the authors), publicly available reports, museum specimens and newspaper articles. Records of by-caught individuals that were brought ashore for necropsy were also included. Records of cetacean strandings were compiled from 01 January 1975 to 30 September 2015. The region is breeding grounds to M. novaeangliae, and this species has been the subject of long-term research efforts (
It should be noted that beach monitoring effort was considerably irregular during the study period. Until 2010, with the exception of a brief period of systematic beach surveys in 1989 (
For each stranding, the following data was compiled: species, date, sex (male, female, unknown sex), age group (calf, juvenile, adult, unknown age), and location. Geographic coordinates (decimal latitude and longitude, Datum WGS1984) were obtained for each stranding and were classified as: (a) “precise” when they were reported by the original source and indicated a location on the coastline of Espírito Santo, (b) “adjusted” when the coordinates provided by the original source were not sufficiently precise to indicate a location on the coastline, and had to be adjusted to represent the nearest location on the coastline, or (c) “approximate” when no coordinate was provided by the original source and an approximate location on the coastline was derived from a text description (e.g., name of the beach or city).
Geographic coordinates were plotted and used to create kernel density heat maps using ArcGIS 10 (ESRI, Redlands, CA, USA). Although the Trindade and Martim Vaz islands are part of Vitória municipality, they were considered separately. The species discovery curve was obtained by plotting the cumulative number of species recorded as the number of strandings increased chronologically. For each stranding, the lunar cycle day (LCD) was calculated, in days, by subtracting the date of the preceding New Moon (obtained from
A total of 461 strandings was recorded, representing 20 cetacean species (Table
Recorded cetacean strandings (excluding Megaptera novaeangliae) along the coast of Espírito Santo state, southeast Brazil, from January 1975 to September 2015. The number of stranded individuals is represented as “Male : Female : Unknown sex”.
Family | Species | Common name | Calf | Juvenile | Adult | Unknown age | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Balaenidae | Eubalaena australis | Southern right whale | – | – | – | 0:0:1 | 0:0:1 |
Balaenopteridae | Balaenoptera acutorostrata | Common Minke whale | 1:0:0 | 0:1:0 | – | 1:0:0 | 2:1:0 |
Balaenoptera borealis | Sei whale | – | – | – | 0:0:1 | 0:0:1 | |
Delphinidae | Globicephala macrorhynchus | Short-finned pilot whale | – | 1:0:0 | – | – | 1:0:0 |
Grampus griseus | Risso’s dolphin | 1:0:0 | – | 1:0:0 | – | 2:0:0 | |
Orcinus orca | Orca | – | 0:1:0 | – | – | 0:1:0 | |
Peponocephala electra | Melon-headed whale | 0:1:0 | 0:0:1 | 2:1:0 | 0:0:1 | 2:2:2 | |
Pseudorca crassidens | False killer whale | – | – | – | 0:1:0 | 0:1:0 | |
Sotalia guianensis | Guiana dolphin | 5:3:7 | 33:19:37 | 54:24:66 | 10:1:85 | 102:47:195 | |
Stenella attenuata | Pantropical spotted dolphin | 1:0:0 | 1:0:0 | – | 0:0:1 | 2:0:1 | |
Stenella frontalis | Atlantic spotted dolphin | – | – | 0:1:0 | – | 0:1:0 | |
Stenella longirostris | Spinner dolphin | – | 0:1:0 | 0:1:0 | 0:0:1 | 0:2:1 | |
Steno bredanensis | Rough-toothed dolphin | 0:0:2 | 2:0:0 | 3:4:1 | 1:0:2 | 6:4:5 | |
Tursiops truncatus | Bottlenose dolphin | – | 1:0:0 | 7:1:1 | 0:0:4 | 8:1:5 | |
Kogiidae | Kogia breviceps | Pygmy sperm whale | – | – | – | 0:0:1 | 0:0:1 |
Kogia sima | Dwarf sperm whale | – | – | – | 0:0:1 | 0:0:1 | |
Phocoenidae | Phocoena spinipinnis | Burmeister’s porpoise | – | – | 1:0:0 | – | 1:0:0 |
Physeteridae | Physeter macrocephalus | Sperm whale | 1:0:0 | 0:1:0 | 1:0:0 | 1:0:7 | 3:1:7 |
Pontoporiidae | Pontoporia blainvillei | Franciscana | 2:2:4 | 1:0:2 | 0:2:13 | 0:1:20 | 3:5:39 |
Ziphiidae | Ziphius cavirostris | Cuvier’s beaked whale | – | – | 0:3:1 | – | 0:3:1 |
Total | 11:6:13 | 39:23:40 | 69:37:82 | 13:3:125 | 132:69:260 |
The sex ratio was biased towards males in S. guianensis (Z = 4.516, p < 0.001; 95% CI of the proportion of males = 60.4–75.9%) and T. truncatus (Z = 2.334, p = 0.02; 95% CI = 51.8–99.7%). For the remaining species, sex ratio was not significantly different from an even distribution (all p > 0.30). The age distribution was different between S. guianensis and P. blainvillei (c2 = 21.288, df = 2, p < 0.001), with adults being the most frequent category in both species (respectively, 58% and 67%) but calves being more frequent in S. guianensis (31%) than in P. blainvillei (17%).
The monthly distribution of strandings of S. guianensis and P. blainvillei was significantly different (c2 = 26.596, df = 11, p = 0.005) with S. guianensis strandings occurring year-round with peaks in March, August and November, whereas those of P. blainvillei were predominantly concentrated from January to March (Figure
Twenty species were recorded in this study (21 spp. if humpback whales are included), representing nearly half of Brazil’s known diversity of cetaceans (45 spp.) (
The average number of recorded strandings increased by 750% after the start of a daily beach survey program (PMP-BC/ES), illustrating how the occurrence of strandings can be greatly underestimated in the absence of such survey efforts. During the period when daily beach surveys were conducted (October 2010 to September 2015), there was a relatively low rate of 1.2 recorded strandings per 100 km per month. This is not an unexpected result, considering the oligotrophic tropical waters of the region (
Six species were most frequent and represented nearly 95% of all strandings: S. guianensis (74.6%), P. blainvillei (10.2%), S. bredanensis (3.3%), T. truncatus (3.0%), P. macrocephalus (2.4%) and P. electra (1.3%). The fact that the two most frequently recorded species (S. guianensis and P. blainvillei) are coastal-dwelling suggests that the stranding probability might be influenced by the natural distribution of these species, and therefore stranding data might systematically underrepresent the abundance of pelagic species in the continental waters of Espírito Santo.
Interestingly, strandings were unevenly distributed with regards to the lunar phase. Previous studies have obtained contradictory results in this respect, showing that strandings may be more frequent during full or new moon in New Zealand and Canada (
Guiana dolphins were frequently recorded throughout the Espírito Santo coast, with hotspots of occurrence in estuaries. The Doce River estuary was a particularly significant hotspot for strandings of this species, in agreement with previous studies that suggested this is an important habitat for the Guiana dolphin (
Previous studies found that most Guiana dolphins stranded in Brazil are immature males (
The Guiana dolphin is a regionally abundant species that is highly sensitive to environmental impacts such as fisheries bycatch (
The population of Franciscanas is split into four Franciscana Management Areas (FMA) based on its ecogeography, morphology and genetics (
Most strandings occurred near the mouth of large rivers, especially of the Doce and São Mateus rivers, which is consistent with the species’ reliance on turbid waters to feed (
The Franciscana is currently classified as Vulnerable (
With the exception of one record at São Mateus, the strandings of rough-toothed dolphins were limited to the southern portion of Espírito Santo, where the continental platform is narrower. This may be related to the dietary habits of this species, which feeds predominantly on mesopelagic fish (depth 200–1,000 m) (
With the exception of two records (Conceição da Barra and Linhares municipalities), the strandings of common bottlenose dolphins were limited to the southern portion of Espírito Santo. However, unlike the rough-toothed dolphin, common bottlenose dolphins have a flexible diet that includes prey from coastal waters (
Sperm whale strandings were diffusely distributed along the Espírito Santo coast, without well-defined hotspots. At-sea observations suggest that sperm whales tend to concentrate along the central coast of Bahia, especially at the Camamu-Almada Basin, and occur at much lower densities in Espírito Santo (
Melon-headed whales are relatively common on the coast of northeast Brazil, including Bahia, where a mass stranding event involving 240 individuals was recorded on 1987 (
The remaining 14 species comprised 24 individuals, predominantly corresponding to small species with tropical oceanic distribution. Most of these records were at the southern portion of Espírito Santo, which suggests that the narrower continental platform may have increased the probability of stranding.
The only baleen whales recorded in this study were common Minke whale (Balaenoptera acutorostrata), Sei whale (Balaenoptera borealis) and southern right whale (Eubalaena australis). These species are known to occasionally occur in the region during their winter migration in the Southwest Atlantic (
With the exception of the Burmeister’s porpoise (Phocoena spinipinnis), the remaining records of odontocetes are within the known distribution of each species (
Based on their distribution range, the following odontocetes would also have been expected to occur in the study area but were not recorded in this study: long-beaked common dolphin (Delphinus capensis), short-beaked common dolphin (Delphinus delphis), pygmy killer whale (Feresa attenuata), Fraser’s dolphin (Lagenodelphis hosei), Blainville’s beaked whale (Mesoplodon densirostris), Clymene dolphin (Stenella clymene), and striped dolphin (Stenella coeruleoalba) (
Our results suggest that the Doce River estuary may be a particularly significant area for cetaceans in Espírito Santo, especially Guiana dolphins and Franciscanas. For this reason, the impacts that the Mariana dam disaster may have had on these species, both of which were already threatened with extinction, are acutely concerning. The mudflow resulting from this incident had a high concentration of heavy metals (
Four threatened species were recorded in this study: Guiana dolphin (Vulnerable), Franciscana (Vulnerable), sperm whale (Vulnerable), and Sei whale (Endangered) (
Although the seamounts along the Vitória-Trindade ridge likely provide attractive habitat for marine fauna (
Lastly, it is worth highlighting that strandings of sperm whales and melon-headed whales occurred with an unexpectedly high frequency in comparison to other similar surveys conducted in portions of the Brazilian coastline (
We are grateful to the numerous researchers, staff members, volunteers that have contributed to the beach survey and opportunistic stranding response over the years. We are thankful to the direct or indirect contributions of Instituto de Pesquisa e Reabilitação de Animais Marinhos (IPRAM), Instituto Estadual de Meio Ambiente e Recursos Hídricos (IEMA), Instituto Brasileiro do Meio Ambiente e dos Recursos Naturais Renováveis (IBAMA), Instituto Baleia Jubarte (IBJ), Organização Consciência Ambiental (ORCA), CTA Meio Ambiente, Scitech Environmental Science and Technology Ltda., Petrobras, Museu de Zoologia da Universidade de São Paulo (MZ-USP), Museu Nacional da Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro (MN-UFRJ), and Posto Oceanográfico Ilha da Trindade (POIT) da Marinha do Brasil. Projeto de Monitoramento de Praias das Bacia de Campos e Espírito Santo - PMP-BC/ES is one of the monitoring programs required by Brazil’s federal environmental agency, IBAMA, for the environmental licensing process of oil production and transport by Petrobras. We thank the reviewer Luís M.D. Barcellos for the helpful comments.
Historical records of cetacean strandings along the coast of Espírito Santo state, southeast Brazil, 1975–2015
Data type: occurrences
Explanation note: List of the historical records of cetacean strandings along the coast of Espírito Santo state, southeast Brazil, including information on the date, location, coordinates, species, age group, sex, musem accession code, field observations and reference/source.