Research Article |
Corresponding author: Miguel Alonso-Zarazaga ( zarazaga@mncn.csic.es ) Academic editor: Patrice Bouchard
© 2014 Miguel Alonso-Zarazaga.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Alonso-Zarazaga M (2014) On the identity of some weevil species described by Johann Christian Fabricius (1745–1808) in the Museum of Zoology of Copenhagen (Coleoptera, Cucujoidea, Curculionoidea, Tenebrionoidea). ZooKeys 451: 61-91. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.451.8462
|
The types of thirty-two nominal weevil species described by Johann Christian Fabricius are reviewed and lecto- and paralectotypes are designated for twenty-two of them. A neotype is designated for Curculio sticticus Fabricius, 1777. Protapion varipes (Germar, 1817) is declared a nomen protectum over Curculio flavipes Fabricius, 1775. Based on a study of syntypes, Rhinomacer curculioides Fabricius, 1781 is confirmed as a member of Mycterus (Mycteridae), Bruchus undatus Fabricius, 1787 is tentatively transferred to Erotylidae, Curculio fulvirostris Fabricius, 1787 and Anthribus roboris Fabricius, 1798 are confirmed as members of Salpingus (Salpingidae), and Brachycerus cristatus Fabricius, 1798 is transferred to Tenebrionidae. Based on lectotype designation, Curculio caninus Fabricius, 1792 is confirmed as a synonym of Sitona lineatus (Linnaeus, 1758) and Curculio innocuus Fabricius, 1802 as a synonym of Cneorhinus barcelonicus (Herbst, 1797). Bruchus rufipes Fabricius, 1792 is not considered an available species name, but a later use of Bruchus rufipes Olivier, 1790. Cossonus incisus Pascoe, 1885 is reinstated as valid from synonymy under Cossonus illigeri Champion, 1909 and Cossonus vulneratus Illiger, 1805 from synonymy under Cossonus canaliculatus (Fabricius, 1792) (a primary homonym of Curculio canaliculatus Olivier, 1791). Cossonus canaliculatus Fabricius, 1802 is a secondary homonym of the former and is replaced with Cossonus incisus. Salpingus fulvirostris (Fabricius, 1787) is reinstated as valid from synonymy under Salpingus planirostris (Fabricius, 1787), a primary homonym of Curculio planirostris Piller & Mitterpacher, 1783. The following new combinations are proposed: Brachysomus erinaceus (Fabricius, 1802) (from Curculio), Bronchus ferus (Gyllenhal, 1840) (from Hipporhinus), Bronchus glandifer (Fabricius, 1792) (from Curculio), Bronchus nivosus (Sparrman, 1785) (from Curculio), Bronchus sparrmani (Gyllenhal, 1833) (from Hipporhinus), Coelocephalapion atrirostre (Fabricius, 1802) (from Attelabus), Nerthops sticticus (Fabricius, 1777) (from Curculio), Piezotrachelus crotalariae (Fabricius, 1802) (from Attelabus), and Poropterus granulatus (Fabricius, 1802) (from Curculio). The junior homonym Brachycerus uva Fabricius, 1792 (non Sparrman, 1785) is replaced by Brachycerus fabricii nom. n. The following new synonymies are established: Brachycerus obesus (Fabricius, 1775) = Curculio scalaris Fabricius, 1777, syn. n., Brachyderes lusitanicus (Fabricius, 1781) = Curculio moratus Fabricius, 1798, syn. n., Brachypera (Brachypera) crinita (Boheman, 1834) = Curculio striatus Fabricius, 1787, syn. n., Brachysomus erinaceus (Fabricius, 1802) = Brachysomus villosulus (Germar, 1824), syn. n., Bronchus abruptecostatus (Gyllenhal, 1833) = Curculio spectrum Fabricius, 1802, syn. n., Bronchus nivosus (Sparrman, 1785) = Curculio recurvus Fabricius, 1802, syn. n., Camptorhinus tibialis (Sparrman, 1785) = Rhynchaenus alienatus Fabricius, 1802, syn. n., Coelocephalapion atrirostre (Fabricius, 1802) = Coelocephalapion luteirostre (Gerstäcker, 1854), syn. n., Cyrtoderes cristatus (DeGeer, 1778) (Tenebrionidae) = Brachycerus cristatus Fabricius, 1798, syn. n., Desmidophorus hebes (Fabricius, 1781) = Curculio tuberculatus Fabricius, 1792, syn. n., Donus salviae (Schrank, 1789) = Curculio denticornis Fabricius, 1798, syn. n., Exomias holosericeus (Fabricius, 1802) = Exomias chevrolati (Boheman, 1842), syn. n., Nerthops sticticus (Fabricius, 1777) = Nerthops guttatus (Olivier, 1807), syn. n., Phyllobius oblongus (Linnaeus, 1758) = Curculio mali Fabricius, 1782, syn. n., and Rhinocyllus conicus (Froelich, 1792) = Bruchus punctatus Fabricius, 1798, syn. n. Bronchus synthesys sp. n. is described to represent the concept of Hipporhinus spectrum sensu Marshall, 1904, a misidentification.
Weevils, Attelabidae , Brentidae , Curculionidae , Erotylidae , Mycteridae , Salpingidae , Tenebrionidae , Bruchela , Chlorophanus , Holotrichapion , Temnocerus , Johann Christian Fabricius, new species, new combinations, new synonymies, morphology, systematics
Johann Christian Fabricius (1745–1808), also known as the “Prince of Entomology”, was the most prominent entomologist of his time. His authority was enormous and so highly influential that later authors used to cite him as the author of others’ species (e.g., Linnaeus’ species). This favoured the establishment of the so-called “principle of authority”, which endangered the universality required by the scientific naming of animals and which was fought by Hugh E. Strickland and others; eventually this reaction led to the creation of the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature in 1895 and the adoption of an International Code of Zoological Nomenclature since 1905 (as the Règles in the beginning) (
In recent times, it has become clear that some kind of catalogue of the living beings on Earth should be prepared, not only for primary scientific use but also as a powerful tool for conservation management, pest control, etc. (
The database was originally compiled from secondary sources and we are currently checking the original sources, a task not without its surprises as we found several cases of species absent from the currently cited original source, species available from the original source but never recorded later, and species that at a given moment in the story of entomology disappeared from the catalogues. The aim of the present paper is to clarify the identity of several of these “lost species” published by J.C. Fabricius by examination of their type specimens. These species are either not recorded in the Junk-Schenkling Coleopterorum Catalogus or are recorded with uncertainty about their identity (usually by the use of a question mark or a placement incertae sedis). This list is not complete, as several problems compound the location and identification of syntypes, and Fabrician type specimens in British collections have been studied only fragmentarily. In one case the discovery of a Fabrician type was communicated to an appropriate specialist and he proceeded to a proper identification (
The holding of Fabricius’ specimens in Copenhagen is, for historical reasons, divided into two different collections, although these are now placed one after the other in the same drawer, following the page order of the Systema Eleutheratorum. The “Kiel collection” is on permanent loan, and the “Copenhagen collection” is basically the Sehestedt & Tønder Lund collection.
In this paper, 32 species are studied, based primarily on specimens located at the Museum of Zoology of the University of Copenhagen and the results published to be incorporated to WTaxa. Lectotypifications are made when considered necessary to fix the concept of a nominal species. I have extensively used the information given by
The treatment of every species includes the original reference, the original statement of locality or other data related to type specimens, comments and a summary of the present status of the species. Label lines are separated by a slash (/). Dates provided are those recorded in WTaxa, which may differ from dates given in other works.
Specimens were photographed with an Olympus C7070WZ camera mounted on a photographic frame Kaiser RA1. Extended focus images were generated using the software CombineZP. The programs Adobe Illustrator CS5.0 and Adobe Photoshop CS5.0 were used for image postproduction and mounting.
Curculio flavipes Fabricius, 1775: 133.
Location. Habitat frequens primo vere locis apricis calidioribus.
Comments. This nominal species has been currently placed in synonymy of Apion varipes Germar, 1817 or another member of genus Protapion Schilsky, 1908.
Present status. A nomen oblitum and a synonym of Protapion varipes (Germar, 1817), nomen protectum. The reversal of precedence is here made in accordance with Art. 23.9.2 by stating that, to my knowledge, Curculio flavipes Fabricius, 1775 (and its combinations) meet the requirements of Art. 23.9.1.1 and Apion varipes Germar, 1817 (and its combinations) meet those of Art. 23.9.1.2, quoting the following references:
Curculio sticticus Fabricius, 1777: 227
Location. Habitat ad Cap. B. Spei.
Comments. This nominal species has been treated subsequently by
Present status. This species is here accordingly transferred to the genus Nerthops Schoenherr, 1826, as Nerthops sticticus (Fabricius, 1777), comb. n. Nerthops guttatus (Olivier, 1807) is a new synonym of the former. The latter name has been used in the last 50 years only in a few catalogues, and does not qualify as a nomen protectum under Art. 23.9.2.
Curculio scalaris Fabricius, 1777: 228
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. Spei. Dr. Schulz.
Comments. This nominal species was subsequently mentioned by
I have found two syntypes in the “Kiel collection”, thus corroborating
Present status. This species is a new synonym of Brachycerus obesus (Fabricius, 1775). Olivier’s treatment is neither a different taxon nor a misidentification, just a transfer of the Fabrician species to the genus Brachycerus Olivier, 1789.
Rhinomacer curculioides Fabricius, 1781: 199
Location. Habitat in Italia. Dr. Allioni.
Comments. This nominal species was later treated by
Present status. This is the species currently known as Mycterus curculioides (Fabricius, 1781) (Mycteridae).
Curculio mali Fabricius, 1782: 499
Location. Habitat Lipsiae. Dom. Prof. Leske.
Comments. This nominal species was subsequently treated by
Present status. Curculio mali is a new synonym of Phyllobius oblongus (Linnaeus, 1758).
Bruchus undatus Fabricius, 1787a: 41
Location. Habitat in Africae floribus Dom. Vahl.
Comments. The description reads: “B. niger elytris fuscis: strigis undatis albis. Corpus medium, nigrum, immaculatum. Elytra laevia, fusca strigis tribus aut quatuor undatis fuscis.”
Present status. Apparently a member of Cucujoidea, probably in Erotylidae, that should be studied by a specialist. The species is not included in the recent volumes of the Catalogue of Palaearctic Coleoptera.
Curculio flavescens Fabricius, 1787a: 112
Location. Habitat in America meridionali Dom. Schreber [error,
Comments. This nominal species was later discussed by
Present status. A senior synonym of Chlorophanus graminicola Schoenherr, 1832. The nominal species Chlorophanus graminicola Gyllenhal, 1834 is a homonym and synonym of the former (synonymy by
Curculio fulvirostris Fabricius, 1787b: 381
Location. Habitat in Scania Dom. de Paykull.
Comments. This nominal species was later treated by
Present status. A species belonging to Salpingidae. Salpingus planirostris, being an invalid primary homonym, has been incorrectly used as valid by
Bruchus rufipes Fabricius, 1792: 373
Location. Habitat Parisiis. Mus. Dom. Bosc.
Comments. The original description reads “Bruchus rufipes Oliv. Ins. tab. fig.”, so there is at least some doubt whether this is to be considered a different nominal species from Bruchus rufipes Olivier, 1790. This corroborates my suspicion that the figs of Olivier’s Entomologie (at least those for the weevils) were available with names before 1792 and used by Fabricius. The Fabrician “species” was synonymized by
Present status. A later use of Bruchus rufipes Olivier, 1790 (now in Bruchela Dejean, 1821), not a different nominal species.
Brachycerus uva Fabricius, 1792: 383
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. Spei Dom. de Paykull.
Comments. This nominal species was later treated by
Present status. Being apparently a valid species, the name Brachycerus uva Fabricius, 1792 is a new homonym of that of Sparrman’s species, and is here replaced with Brachycerus fabricii Alonso-Zarazaga, nom. n.
Curculio caninus Fabricius, 1792: 467
Location. Habitat in Germania Dom. Smidt.
Comments. This nominal species was subsequently treated by
According to
Present status. The lectotype designation is made to avoid nomenclatural changes. Thus, this nominal species is confirmed as a synonym of Sitona lineatus (Linnaeus, 1758), as it has been recently treated by
Figs
Curculio glandifer Fabricius, 1792: 483
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. spei Mus. Dom. Lund.
Comments. This nominal species was subsequently treated by
Present status. I consider that this is a valid species, Bronchus glandifer (Fabricius, 1792), comb. n., for the time being, until a modern revision may reveal its true affinities or identity.
Bruchus punctatus Fabricius, 1798: 158
Location. Habitat.
Comments. This species was subsequently treated only by
Present status. This is a new synonym of Rhinocyllus conicus (Froelich, 1792), and is removed from synonymy under Nerthops guttatus (Olivier, 1807) [erroneously as guttula in
Anthribus roboris Fabricius, 1798: 161
Location. Habitat in Kiliae Robore.
Comments. In the original description,
Present status. This nominal species is a synonym of Salpingus ruficollis (Linnaeus, 1761) in Salpingidae. The current synonymy (cf.
Brachycerus cristatus Fabricius, 1798: 161
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. spei Mus. Dom. Lund.
Comments. This species was subsequently mentioned by
Present status. A new synonym and secondary homonym of Cyrtoderes cristatus (DeGeer, 1778) (Tenebrionidae).
Attelabus coeruleus Fabricius, 1798: 163
Location. Habitat in Germania Dom. Daldorff.
Comments. This nominal species was later treated by
Present status. Considered by
Curculio moratus Fabricius, 1798: 171
Location. Habitat in Isle de France D. Billardiere
Comments. Later mentioned only by
Present status. Curculio moratus is a new synonym of Brachyderes lusitanicus (Fabricius, 1781).
Curculio denticornis Fabricius, 1798: 173
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. spei Dom. Daldorff.
Comments. This nominal species has been later treated by
Present status. A junior synonym of Donus salviae (Schrank, 1789), syn. n.
Attelabus atrirostris Fabricius, 1802: 424
Location. Habitat in America meridionali D. Smidt. Mus. D. de Sehestedt.
Comments. This nominal species was transferred by
Present status. This is a valid species, Coelocephalapion atrirostre (Fabricius, 1802), comb. n., and C. luteirostre (Gerstäcker, 1854) is a new synonym of it (syn. n.). The latter name cannot be declared a nomen protectum for want of enough citations in the literature.
Attelabus crotalariae Fabricius, 1802: 424
Location. Habitat in Crotalariae leguminibus Americae. Mus. D. Lund.
Comments. Schoenherr (1833: 251), based on specimens apparently from the type series in his collection, transferred this species to the genus Apion Herbst, 1797.
Present status. A valid species, Piezotrachelus crotalariae (Fabricius, 1802), comb. n., whose origin is doubtful, as this genus is not known to occur in America, while it is very common in Africa, and I suspect that a mislabelling has happened.
Attelabus pisi Fabricius, 1802: 425
Location. Habitat in Austria. Dom. de Meyerle.
Comments. This is a well-known species, transferred to the genus Apius by
According to
Present status. A valid species, Holotrichapion pisi (Fabricius, 1802), very common and rather variable. For the moment, there is no need to designate a neotype.
Figs
Rhynchaenus granulatus Fabricius, 1802: 443
Location. Habitat in Amboina. D. Billardiere.
Comment. This species has not been mentioned in the taxonomic literature since description.
Present status. All these characters compel me to place this species in the genus Poropterus Schoenherr, 1844, as Poropterus granulatus (Fabricius, 1802), comb. n. This genus and its allies are in great need of revision. There is no other species of this genus recorded from Ambon or its adjacent islands, and the original locality could be incorrect, as the expedition commanded by Antoine Reymond Joseph Bruny d’Entrecasteaux (in which Jacques-Julien Houtou de La Billardière was enrolled as a naturalist) touched Australian lands at several places (
Rhynchaenus alienatus Fabricius, 1802: 471
Location. Habitat in Sumatra. D. Daldorff.
Comments. This species has not been treated since the original description.
Present status. A synonym of Camptorhinus tibialis (Sparrmann, 1785), syn. n.
Cossonus canaliculatus Fabricius, 1802: 496
Location. Habitat in Sumatra. D. Daldorff.
Comments. This species was mentioned later by
Cossonus canaliculatus (Fabricius, 1792) is an American species described as Curculio canaliculatus Fabricius, 1792 (l.c.: 471), which is a primary homonym of Curculio canaliculatus Olivier, 1791. It was correctly placed by
Cossonus incisus Pascoe, 1885, stat. res.
= Cossonus canaliculatus Fabricius, 1802 (secondary homonym)
= Cossonus illigeri Champion, 1909 (replacement name)
Cossonus vulneratus Illiger, 1805, stat. res.
= Curculio canaliculatus Fabricius, 1792 (non Olivier, 1791)
Present status. A synonym of Cossonus incisus Pascoe, as shown above.
Curculio innocuus Fabricius, 1802: 512
Location. Habitat in Mogador. D. Schousboe. Mus. D. de Sehestedt.
Comments. This species was transferred by
Present status. A synonym of Cneorhinus barcelonicus (Herbst, 1797) as currently understood. The identity of this species nevertheless needs confirmation.
Curculio holosericeus Fabricius, 1802: 526
Location. Habitat in Austria. D. Scheidler.
Comments. This nominal species was considered identical by
Present status. This is a valid species, Exomias holosericeus (Fabricius, 1802), with Exomias chevrolati (Boheman, 1842) as its new synonym. This species, originally described from Austria, has nothing to do with Exomias indigens, which is a South-Western European species.
Curculio erinaceus Fabricius, 1802: 527
Location. Habitat in Austria. Dom. de Meyerle.
Comments.
Present status. A valid species, Brachysomus erinaceus (Fabricius, 1802), comb. n., and a senior synonym of B. villosulus (Germar, 1824), syn. n. I have been unable to fulfil the requirements of Art. 23.9.1.2 to declare the latter name a nomen protectum.
Figs
Curculio recurvus Fabricius, 1802: 535.
Location. Habitat ad Cap. Bon. Spei. Mus. D. Lund.
Comments. This nominal species was transferred to the genus Hipporhinus Schoenherr, 1823 by
Present status. A new synonym of Bronchus nivosus (Sparrman, 1785) in Marshall’s sense. The present problems with the identifications of the types of Bronchus make a modern revision of the genus necessary. Some of the characters used by Marshall in his keys, e.g., the “transverse basal furrow on the underside of rostrum” are highly variable among individuals of the same species, difficult to see and subject to different interpretations of the degree of depth, while other characters, e.g., the kind and disposition of vestiture on legs, are underused. The genitalia of both sexes have not been described.
Curculio striatus Fabricius, 1787a: 117.
Location. Habitat in Africa Dom. Vahl [restricted by
Comments. This nominal species has been treated subsequently by
According to
Present status. A new synonym of Brachypera (Brachypera) crinita (Boheman, 1834).
Curculio planirostris Fabricius, 1787a: 119.
Location. Habitat Kiliae Dom. Daldorff.
Comments. This species was later treated by
Present status. A junior homonym, and consequently invalid, in use as Salpingus planirostris (Fabricius, 1787). Authors in Salpingidae seem to be unaware of this irregularity (e.g.,
Curculio tuberculatus Fabricius, 1792: 480.
Location. Habitat in India orientali Dom. Prof. Abildgard.
Comments. This nominal species is a primary homonym of Curculio tuberculatus O.F. Müller, 1776 (a hitherto unidentified species) and of C. tuberculatus DeGeer, 1778 (a synonym of Brachycerus obesus Olivier, 1790). This species has been subsequently treated by
Present status. A new synonym of Desmidophorus hebes (Fabricius, 1781).
Figs
Curculio spectrum Fabricius, 1802: 537.
Location. Habitat ad Cap.Bon.Spei. Mus. D. Lund.
Comments. This nominal species is a primary homonym of Curculio spectrum Fabricius, 1781 (now in Gyllenhalia Aurivillius, 1886). It was transferred to Hipporhinus by
Present status. A new synonym of Bronchus abruptecostatus (Gyllenhal, 1833).
HOLOTYPE: 1 male, pinned, dissected, two legs absent, with the following labels: Marshall MS: Uitenhage / Cape Col. / Rev. J. ONeil; printed: G.A.K. Marshall / Coll. / B.M. 1950 – 255; Marshall MS: H. spectrum F. (Natural History Museum, London). This is one of the specimens coming from Marshall’s collection and mentioned in his 1904 revision. Despite its condition, it is considered to be the best specimen to meet the requirements for a holotype. A white label with red margins and black writing: HOLOTYPUS / Bronchus synthesys sp. n. / Alonso-Zarazaga des. / 2014 has been added to this specimen.
See that of Hipporhinus spectrum in
The specific epithet of this new species makes reference to the EC-funded project SYNTHESYS (http://www.synthesys.info) and is to be taken as a name in apposition. It pays homage to all the people who have made its operation possible.
This is the species misidentified by
Reviews of the type specimens in old collections usually have taxonomic implications. This article was not going to be an exception. It is linked to an international initiative (the World Information Network on Weevils), which aims at making available all kinds of information about Curculionoidea for use by researchers, applied entomologists (in Agronomy, Forestry and Food Storage) and decision-makers. One of its results is WTaxa. During the building and checking of this database, many ‘orphan species names’ were found, and there is a need to know the true identity of these nominal species.
The original list of species for this article was much longer. The problems faced during the research and the writing suggested that a reduction was necessary. Even so, six years of careful examination of all the available data resulted in thirty-two nominal species being treated here, twenty-two having lecto- and sometimes paralectotypes designated, one having a neotype designated to remove uncertainty about its identity and four illustrated for the first time. The nomenclatural changes proposed do not severely affect the taxonomy of species, since most of them have seldom been treated. Nine new combinations, a new replacement name and fifteen new synonymies are proposed, and one new species is described. Many other such ‘orphan species names’ await study, and some of the species will merit a full redescription and placement in new, still undescribed genera. On the other hand, it is not unusual to find that some species that have been treated by later authors, and even monographed, cf. Bronchus (as Hipporrhinus) by
It is surprising that some of these species described long ago have apparently been only rarely collected since. Some (such as the Bronchus or Brachycerus species) have their habitats and ranges severely affected by human action and urban settlement, whereas others, bearing incorrect label data, may have been described from the real range of the species under a different name (e.g., Piezotrachelus crotalariae, Poropterus granulatus). In the end, this kind of study and its implications become archaeo-entomology, since we are studying a world that was but will never be again (cf. also
I visited the collection of the Zoological Museum of the University of Copenhagen in October 2008 as part of SYNTHESYS (European Community Research Infrastructure Action; FP6 ‘Structuring the European Research Area’ Programme), under DK-TAF-5211, whose support is gratefully acknowledged. Drs A. Solodovnikov and O. Martin are cordially thanked for their help during this visit. I also thank Drs Maxwell V.L. Barclay and Richard T. Thompson (NHM, London) for their help in locating a suitable specimen to be the holotype of the new species. Mr Manuel Sánchez-Ruiz is warmly thanked for his skills in photographing the specimens and preparing the pictures for publication. I also thank Dr Christopher H.C. Lyal (NHM, London) for revising the language of the manuscript. I lastly thank Drs Lyal and Rolf G. Oberprieler for improving the manuscript through their detailed and helpful reviews.