Citation: Hwang C-C (2014) Annotated type catalogue of land snails collected from Taiwan (Formosa) in the Natural History Museum, London. ZooKeys 428: 1–28. doi: 10.3897/zookeys.428.8061
The present catalogue lists the type specimens of land snail species, collected from Taiwan and deposited in the Natural History Museum, London. Thirty-seven nominal species described by Pfeiffer, Adams, Nevill, Moellendorff, Godwin-Austen and Gude were traced. I present here information on type status, collection data obtained from the registers and labels of each collection, and annotations on the current taxonomic affiliation. Lectotypes of 28 nominal (sub)species were newly designated. One holotype was fixed originally and two holotypes newly fixed by monotypy. Syntypes of two species and paralectotypes of three species were also discovered in the Museum. No specimen of the species Pupina adamsi Sowerby, 1878, which was supposed to be deposited in the NHM, was found. Pictures of the name-bearing types are provided for further research on biodiversity of the island.
Type specimen, taxonomy, Taiwan, Gastropoda, land snail
Taxonomic research on historic collections is essential for the modern study of taxonomy and biodiversity. Current taxonomic studies using morphological or molecular methods, e.g., Barcode of Life (
The Natural History Museum of London contains many specimens collected in Taiwan (Formosa). A major portion of these are housed in the type series which were previously in the collection of H. Cuming and H. Adams (
In preparing this catalogue, type specimens were recognized and verified by comparing information on the specimen labels, the original descriptions, NHM registers and curatorial records of the Mollusca Section, Natural History Museum, London.
The type specimens are listed using modern classifications (
I was able to find type specimens of 37 species in the NHM, including all 13 species identified by
Specimens from the collections of shell dealers B. Schmacker (Shanghai, China) and Y. Hirase (Kyoto, Japan) were also found. These species were described by
I noted the following features in the collection. (1) All specimens are cased in boxes having an originally handwritten label glued onto the bottom. The register information, if any, was also written on the bottoms of the cases. A concise locality, usually “Formosa” only, with or without a collector, was provided. (2) Some specimen lots are labelled “TYPE” using ink and handwriting different from the original labels. Such conditions are supposed to be determined as types and written by a curator or later researchers rather than by the original authors. (3) Ten species described by
Taiwan, Formosa [Taiwan Fu = Tainan City and northern Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1871.1.20.9/1), new designation, 10.1 × 16.5 mm, whorls 4.5.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1871.1.20.9/2–8, 7 shells). Taiwan, Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.22, 3 shells).
The lot NHMUK 1871.1.20.9 was registered and labelled as “Cyclotus formosensis”, but was later published as Cyclotus taivanus. Nine specimens were registered, but only eight were found. The specimen corresponding well in size with the measurement of
A Cyclotus taivanus H. Adams, 1870, lectotype NHMUK 1871.1.20.9/1 B Platyrhaphe minutus (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.6/1 C Platyrhaphe swinhoei (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.7/10 D Ptychopoma wilsoni (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040584/1 E Chamalycaeus hungerfordianus (Nevill, 1881), possible syntype NHMUK 1891.3.17.790 F Dioryx swinhoei (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.8/1 G Pupinella swinhoei (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.15/1 H Pupinella swinhoei syn. Pupinopsis morrisonia H. Adams, 1872, lectotype NHMUK 1871.1.20.16/1 I Euphaedusa sheridani (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040589/1 J Hemiphaedusa exilis (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.4/1 K Hemiphaedusa similaris (H. Adams, 1867), lectotype NHMUK 1878.1.28.10/1. Scale bars = 5 mm, unless otherwise specified above the bar.
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.6/1), new designation, 4.4 × 6.9 mm, whorls 4.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.6/2–3, 2 shells). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.73, 3 shells).
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.7/1, new designation, 6.8 × 11.6 mm, whorls 4.5.
Paralectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.7/2, 1 shell). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.231, 1 shells)
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040584/1). new designation, 9.4 × 22.5 mm, whorls 5.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040584/2-3, 2 shells).
No specimen corresponds in size with the measurements of
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Hungerford).
Possible syntypes: Tamsui, Formosa, from collection of Hungerford (NHMUK 1891.3.17.790–791, 2 shells), 2.2–2.5 × 3.6–3.8 mm, whorls 3.75. Also in SMF (
It is possible that further syntypes may be housed in the Indian Museum, Kolkata (Calcutta), India, where Nevill worked. Due to the lack of definitive evidence that the two specimens in the NHM were actually examined by Nevill, no lectotype designation has been made in the present article.
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.8/1), new designation, 6.0 × 5.5 mm, whorls 4.
Paralectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.8/2, 1 shell).
Kulung, Formosa [should be Keelung, Northern Taiwan] (Hungerford).
Possible syntypes: Formosa, coll. Hungerford (NHMUK 1891.3.17.724–726, 3 shells), 2.76–3.29 × 1.66–1.76 mm, whorls 5.5–6.5. Also in SMF (
A photograph of a syntype was provided by
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype of Pupinella swinhoei. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.15/1), new designation, 13 × 5.5 mm, whorls 7. (Figure 1G).
Paralectotypes of Pupinella swinhoei. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.15/2-3, 2 shells). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.58, 3 shells)
Mount Morrison, Formosa [Mt. Yushan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype of Pupinopsis morrisonia. South Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1871.1.20.16/1), new designation, 12.5 × 5.3 mm, whorls 6.5. (Figure 1H).
Paralectotypes of Pupinopsis morrisonia. South Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK1871.1.20.16/2, 1 shell). Mt. Morrison, South Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.50, 3 shells).
No specimen corresponds in size with the measurements and illustration of
Isl. Formosa [Taiwan] (ex. Mus. Brit.)
The type specimen of Pupina adamsi, which was collected from Formosa and has been stated as being deposited in the NHM (
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming NHMUK 20040589/1), new designation, 16.0 × 3.5 mm, whorls 10.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040589/2–4, 3 shells; NHMUK 20040589/5, 1 shell, non sheridani).
The largest specimen corresponds well in size with the measurements of
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.4/1), new designation, 27.0 × 7.1 mm, whorls 10.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.4/2–3, 2 shells). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.207, 2 shells).
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.10/1), new designation, 17.3 × 4.8 mm, whorls 10.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.10/2, 1 shell). Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.3, 3 shells).
None of these type series exactly match with the illustration and measurements in
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.5/1), new designation, 26.1 × 7.0 mm, whorls 10.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.5/2–3, 2 shells). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.245, 1 shell).
The specimen corresponding well in size with the measurements of
A Oospira formosensis (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.5/1 B Oospira swinhoei (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040583/1 C Elma swinhoei (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.14/1 D Videnoida shermani (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040584/1 E Petalochlamys formosanus (Schmacker & Boettger, 1891) syn. Petalochlamys hypograpta Godwin-Austen, 1907, holotype NHMUK 1903.7.1.1713 F Petalochlamys vesta (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040580 G Ovachlamys fulgens (Gude, 1900) syn. Lamprocystis fulgida Godwin-Austen, 1907, holotype NHMUK 1903.7.1.1714 H Aegista fulvicans (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.10/1 I Aegista granti (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040579. Scale bars = 5 mm.
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040583/1), new designation, 35.0 × 8.1 mm, whorls 10.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040583/2–3, 2 shells).
The original description gives a range of shell dimensions. The largest specimen is designated as the lectotype.
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.14/1), new designation, 15.7 × 6.1 mm, whorls 9.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.14/2–3, 2 shells). Tamsui, Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.28.30, 3 shells).
The largest specimen corresponds well in size with the measurements of
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040584/1), new designation, 8.7 × 19.3 mm, whorls 7.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040584/2–3, 2 shells).
The largest specimen mostly similar to the illustration in
South Formosa [southern Taiwan] (Hirase)
Holotype. Southern Formosa, from collection of Hirase (NHMUK 1903.7.1.1713), designated by monotypy, 11.0 × 6.3 mm, whorls 5.5. (Figure 2E).
This name was first recommended by Pilsbry for specimens from Hirase’s collection (Hirase 1908). However,
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040580), new designation, 8.5 × 16 mm, whorls 5.5.
Although only one specimen is found in the NHM, it should be designated as lectotype under
South Formosa [southern Taiwan] (Hirase)
Holotype of Lamprocystis fulgida. South Formosa, from collection of Hirase (NHMUK 1903.7.1.1714), designated by monotypy, 4 × 7.3 mm, whorls 4.5.
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.10/1), new designation, 9.9 × 14 mm, whorls 7.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.10/2–3, 2 shells). Formosa, from collection of H. Adams (NHMUK 1878.1.23.204, 2 shells).
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040579), new designation, 8.9 × 14.4 mm, whorls 6.5.
Although only one specimen is found in the NHM, it should be designated as lectotype under
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040582/1), new designation, ca. 10 × 4.5 mm, whorls 9.5 (peristome damaged).
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040582/2–4, 3 shells).
The largest specimen corresponds well in size with the measurements of
A Pseudobuliminus incertus (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040582/1 B Acusta assimilis (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.11/1 C Nesiohelix swinhoei (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040585/1 D Dolicheulota formosensis (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.1/1 E Dolicheulota swinhoei (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040586/1 F Satsuma bacca (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040577/1 G Satsuma bacca (Pfeiffer, 1866) syn. Eulota warburgi Gude, 1907, holotype NHMUK 1922.8.29.66 H Satsuma bairdi (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040587/1. Scale bars = 5 mm.
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.11/1), new designation, 13.7 × 19.4 mm, whorls 5.75.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.11/2–3, 2 shells).
Toyenmongai, Formosa [Dong-yuan-men-jie, Tainan = central area of modern-day Tainan City] (Rolle?)
Lectotype. Toyenmongai, Formosa (SMF 7405), designated by
Paralectotypes. Formosa (NHMUK 1912.8.16.131–133, 3 shells, “original specimen”), 11.3–12.3 × 13.3–14.2 mm, whorls 5.25–5.5. Also in SMF.
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040585/1, large form), new designation, 42.7 × 75.3 mm, whorls 5.5.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040585/2, 1 shell, large form, 50.9 × 68.1 mm, whorls 5.25; NHMUK 20040585/3–4, 2 shells, small form, 32.4–32.5 × 50.8–54.5 mm, whorls 4.75–5.0).
The shell sizes of these four specimens do not agree with Pfeiffer’s original measurements of 27–28 × 52–58 mm for the typical form and 25 × 46 mm for the minor form. I consider Pfeiffer’s measurements to be incorrect. The largest specimen is designated as the lectotype for the stabilization of the name (
Tamsui Mountains, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.1/1), new designation, 55.4 × 24 mm, whorls 8.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.1/2–3, 2 shells).
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040586/1), new designation, 37.1 × 21.4 mm, whorls 7.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040586/2–3, 2 shells, one bleached and the other immature).
The specimen in the best condition is designated as the lectotype for the stabilization of the name (
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype of Helix bacca. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040577/1), new designation, 16.6 × 24.5 mm, whorls 5.5. (Figure 3F)
Paralectotype of Helix bacca. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040577/2, 1 shell, immature).
This species was usually considered as a member of Pancala Kuroda & Habe, 1949.
Dunes at Long-Krau, South Formosa [coastal area of Northwest Hengchung Peninsula] (Warburg)
Holotype of Eulota (Euhadra) warburgi. Dunes at Long-Krau, Southern Formosa, coll. Warburg, Feb. 1888, from collection of Naturhistorisches Museum, Hamburg (NHMUK 1922.8.29.66), original designation, 19.2 × 30.5 mm, whorls 5.75. (Figure 3G)
Tamsui, Formosa [Danshui, New Taipei City] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040587/1), new designation, 22.7 × 40.0 mm, whorls 6.25.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040587/2–3, 2 shells).
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040578), new designation, 17 × 26 mm, whorls 6.
A Satsuma formosensis (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040578 B Satsuma mellea (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040576/1 C Satsuma succincta (H. Adams, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 1866.5.9.9/1 D Satsuma sphaeroconus (Pfeiffer, 1866), lectotype NHMUK 20040575/1. Scale bars = 5 mm.
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040576/1), new designation, 11 × 23.2 mm, whorls 5.
Paralectotypes. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040576/2–3, 2 shells).
The largest specimen mostly similar to the illustration in
Formosa [Taiwan] (Swinhoe)
Lectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040575/1), new designation, 23.1 × 18.5 mm, whorls 6.
Paralectotype. Formosa, coll. Swinhoe, from collection of H. Cuming (NHMUK 20040575/2, 1 shell, immature).
The only mature shell with a red spot is designated as the lectotype.
Takow, Formosa [northern Qi-Jin, Kaohsiung City] (Swinhoe).
Lectotype. Takow Mountain, Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.9/1), new designation, 22.8 × 31.2 mm, whorls 6.5.
Paralectotypes. Takow Mountain, Formosa, coll. Swinhoe (NHMUK 1866.5.9.9/2–6, 5 shells; NHMUK 1866.5.9.9/7, 1 shell, non succincta, immature shell of Aegista lautsi branchylasis (Schmacker & Boettger, 1891)).
One of the specimens is labelled "Takow mountains" on base of shell. It is here selected as the lectotype for the stabilization of the name (
insulae Hongkong [Hongkong Islands] (Moellendorff)
Lectotype. Hong Kong (SMF 45429), designated by
Paralectotypes. Hong Kong and Guangdung, China (SMF, 11 shells) (
Possible paralectotypes. Keelung, Formosa, coll. Hungerford (NHMUK 1891.3.17.5–6, 2 shells), 9.6 × 18.1 mm, whorls 5.5; 9.7 × 16.5, whorls 5.5.
This species was named by Nevill, in a letter to Hungerford, on the basis of the samples that Hungerford collected from Formosa; however, the species was not published until 1884 by Moellendorff. Having examined Moellendorff’s collection from Hong Kong and Guangdung (
Toyenmongai auf Formosa [Dong-yuan-men-jie, Tainan = central area of modern-day Tainan City] (Rolle?)
Lectotype of Stegodera helleri. Toyenmongai, Formosa, coll. Rolle, 1910 (SMF 7404), designated as holotype by
Paralectotypes of Stegodera helleri. (SMF, 4 shells) (
Possible paralectotypes of Stegodera helleri. Toyenmongai, Formosa, coll. Rolle, “1/2/11”, from collection of V.W. MacAndrew, no. 1563 (NHMUK 20040594, 4 shells), 6.4–6.9 × 15.9–17.4mm, whorls 4.75.
No holotype was originally fixed by
I gratefully acknowledge the assistance of all staff members in the Mollusca Research Group, Department of Zoology (NHM), and the librarians of the Museum. Special appreciation is directed to Fred Naggs, Jonathan Ablett and Manuel Malaquias. I also thank Paul Callomon (ANSP) for his help with locating types in the ANSP. I am grateful to R. Janssen, E. Neubert and H. Nordsieck (SMF) for their kindly having permitted and helped my study of type material. Lastly, I am indebted to The Biodiversity Heritage Library for providing access to rare literatures consulted for this work (www.biodiversitylibrary.org). The author wishes to express appreciation to Cheryl Rutledge for her editorial assistance. This study is partly granted by NSC-98-2621-B-390-001.