Research Article |
Corresponding author: Hsi-Te Shih ( htshih@dragon.nchu.edu.tw ) Academic editor: Sammy De Grave
© 2019 Hsi-Te Shih, Jhih-Wei Hsu, Kingsley J. H. Wong, Ngan Kee Ng.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Shih H-T, Hsu J-W, Wong KJH, Ng NK (2019) Review of the mudflat varunid crab genus Metaplax (Crustacea, Brachyura, Varunidae) from East Asia and northern Vietnam. ZooKeys 877: 1-29. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.877.38300
|
Intertidal mudflat crabs of the genus Metaplax H. Milne Edwards, 1852 (Crustacea: Brachyura: Varunidae) from China, Taiwan, and northern Vietnam are taxonomically revised by morphological and molecular evidence. These crabs show sexual dimorphism and morphological variation of a considerable range in the infraorbital ridge, one of the primary features previously used for species identification. In this study, four species were identified from the region: M. elegans De Man, 1888; M. longipes Stimpson, 1858; M. sheni Gordon, 1930; and M. tredecim Tweedie, 1950. Based on the results of the morphological examination, and as confirmed by molecular evidence from mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI), taxonomic confusion surrounding M. longipes was resolved, and M. takahasii Sakai, 1939, is considered a junior synonym of M. longipes. The geographical distribution of Metaplax longipes extends along the shores of China, north to Jiangsu, whereas the Southeast Asian M. tredecim was newly recorded from northern Vietnam and Hong Kong.
COI, Metaplax elegans, M. longipes, M. sheni, M. takahasii, M. tredecim, mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit I, morphology
Indo-West Pacific varunid crabs of the genus Metaplax H. Milne Edwards, 1852 commonly inhabit sheltered shores with silty muddy substrate often near or under shades of mangroves in tropical and subtropical regions. While some studies have reported on various biological aspects of selected species (e.g.,
Species of the genus Metaplax all share a broad, subquadrate, somewhat depressed carapace, which is shallowly marked, broad fronted (approximately 1/3 carapace width), and has lateral margins bearing at most five distinct teeth; slender and elongated ambulatory legs are also shared. One of the frequently used morphological features for species identification remains the number of lobes and tubercles along the infraorbital ridge (
In East Asia, the northern limit of this genus appears to be around Zhejiang, China (
In the present study, specimens of species of Metaplax were collected from various sites in East Asia (Fig.
Specimens were collected from China, Taiwan, and Vietnam (Table
Collection sites (solid symbols) for species of the genus Metaplax used in this study: green rhombus for M. elegans; red circles for M. longipes; blue triangles for M. sheni; and purple squares for M. tredecim. Empty symbols mean the additional records from references (see synonym lists for each species).
To understand whether the number of infraorbital tubercles and lobes of each species is related to the sex and body size, the numbers on both sides for each specimen were calculated, averaged, and plotted against CWs. Specimens used were 21 males (CW 7.7–15.9 mm) and 19 females (CW 6.3–13.2 mm) for M. elegans, 69 males (CW 6.8–26.6 mm) and 29 females (CW 7.9– 23.6 mm) for M. longipes, 7 males (CW 8.6–12.8 mm) for M. sheni (no female specimen), and 23 males (CW 12.8–22.7 mm) and 13 females (CW 10.3–23.4 mm) for M. tredecim.
Genomic DNA was isolated from the muscle tissue using extraction kits following
The haplotypes and accession numbers (DNA Data Bank of Japan) of the COI gene of Metaplax specimens and outgroups from East Asia and northern Vietnam. For abbreviations of museums and universities, see Materials and methods.
Species | Locality | Sample size | Catalogue no. of |
Haplotype of COI | Access. no. of COI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
M. elegans | Taiwan: Jhuwei, New Taipei City | 1 | 15480 | MXe1 | LC498179 |
Taiwan: Kinmen | 1 | 15489 | MXe2 | LC498180 | |
Vietnam: Ho Chi Minh City | 1 | 15499 | MXe3 | LC498181 | |
Singapore: Sungei Buloh | 1 |
|
MXe4 | LC498182 | |
Thailand: Ranong | 1 | 15494 | MXe4 | LC498182 | |
M. longipes | Taiwan: Danshuei, New Taipei City | 1 | NTOU | MXL2 | LC498183 |
Taiwan: Danshuei, New Taipei City | 1 |
|
MXL2 | LC498183 | |
Taiwan: Kinmen | 1 | 15460 | MXL2 | LC498183 | |
Taiwan: Kinmen | 1 | 15462 | MXL2 | LC498183 | |
China: Zhoushan, Zhejiang | 2 | 15466; 15465 | MXL2 | LC498183 | |
China: Xiamen, Fujian | 1 | 15475 | MXL2 | LC498183 | |
China: Qinzhou, Guangxi | 1 | 15449 | MXL3 | LC498185 | |
Hong Kong: Tung Chung | 1 | 15450 | MXL1 | LC498184 | |
M. sheni | Taiwan: Kinmen | 1 | 15467 | MXs1 | LC498186 |
China: Xiamen, Fujian | 2 | 15465 | MXs1, MXs2 | LC498186, LC498187 | |
Vietnam: Dong Rui, Quang Ninh | 1 | 15466 | MXs1 | LC498186 | |
M. tredecim | Hong Kong: Nai Chung | 1 | 15472 | MXt1 | LC498188 |
Vietnam: Dong Rui, Quang Ninh | 1 | 15477 | MXt2 | LC498189 | |
Vietnam: Nha Trang | 1 | 15498 | MXt3 | LC498190 | |
Malaysia: Labuan | 1 | 15475 | MXt4 | LC498191 | |
Total | 22 | ||||
Outgroups | |||||
Gaetice depressus | Taiwan: Keelung | 15544 | LC498192 | ||
Helice formosensis | Taiwan: Shengang, Changhua | 13083 | AB334543 | ||
Hemigrapsus sanguineus | Taiwan: Yongsing, New Taipei City | 15545 | LC498193 | ||
Varuna litterata | Taiwan: Kenting, Pingtung | 14816 | LC498194 |
Metaplax elegans De Man, 1888 (A–C
The best-fitting model of sequence evolution was determined by PartitionFinder (ver. 2.1.1;
Family Varunidae H. Milne Edwards, 1853
Genus Metaplax H. Milne Edwards, 1852
Metaplax elegans
De Man, 1888: 164, pl. 11(4–6) (type locality: Mergui, Myanmar);
Taiwan: 8 ♂♂ (6.1–14.0 mm), 4 ♀♀ (8.0–13.2 mm) (
Carapace (Figs
Metaplax elegans De Man, 1888. A Dorsal view B ventral view C left infraorbital ridge D right cheliped A–D male (CW 12.7 mm;
The Bay of Bengal, Southeast and East Asia: China (Zhejiang; Fujian; Guangdong; Hainan), western Taiwan (including Kinmen), Vietnam, Malaysia (Selangor; Sarawak; Labuan), Singapore, Brunei, Thailand, Myanmar (Mergui), and eastern India (Tamil Nadu, Godavari Delta) (Fig.
At Wazihwei Wetland, estuaries of Danshuei River, northwestern Taiwan, this species is found along shores with substantial freshwater influence, on banks with substrates plastic-muddy, somewhat distant from mangrove stands.
According to previous descriptions (De
Comparison of characters among four species of Metaplax from East Asia and northern Vietnam.
Characters | M. elegans | M. longipes | M. sheni | M. tredecim |
---|---|---|---|---|
lateral margin | five teeth | five teeth | five teeth | five teeth |
infraorbital ridge | 46–61 tubercles in males (lateral 20 vertically elongated); 33–42 isomorphic tubercles in females | 7–13 tubercles in males (mesial ones broad, and gradually decreasing in size); 14–22 isomorphic tubercles in females | 16–20 tubercles in males (mesial ones broad, decreasing in size laterally; mesial-most one more than twice the breadth of the next) | 13–20 tubercles in males (mesial ones broad and decreasing in size, lateral 4–5 roughly same size); 20–27 isomorphic tubercles in females |
cheliped | palm 2.2 times as long as broad, total length of palm nearly 1.8 times than length of dactyl, cutting edge of dactylus with distinct large teeth | palm 2.3 times as long as broad, length of palm nearly 1.3 times than length of dactyl, cutting edge of dactylus with low triangular molar, pollex unarmed | markedly elongated, palm 2.8 times as long as broad, length of palm nearly 2.0 times than length of dactylus, cutting edge of dactylus with triangular molar | palm 2.3 times as long as broad, length of palm nearly 1.6 times than length of dactyl, cutting edge of both fingers unarmed |
ambulatory legs | short, broad | long, slender | long, slender | long, slender |
Metaplax longipes
Stimpson, 1858: 97 (type locality: Hong Kong);
Metaplax takahasii
Sakai, 1939: 698, text-fig. 127 (type locality: Tansui (= Danshuei), Taiwan);
Metaplax takahashii:
? Metaplax longipes:
Not Metaplax longipes:
Not Metaplax longipes:
China: 2 ♂♂ (20.7–22.7 mm) (
Carapace (Figs
Metaplax longipes Stimpson, 1858. A, E Dorsal view B ventral view C left infraorbital ridge D right cheliped. A–D Male (CW 15.4 mm;
Western Taiwan (including Matsu and Kinmen), China (Jiangsu; Zhejiang; Fujian; Guangdong; Guangxi), and northern Vietnam (Haiphong) (Fig.
At Tung Chung Wetland, Hong Kong, where numerous specimens were collected, the habitat of this species is composed of muddy substrates and substantial freshwater influences. Considerable numbers flourish under fringes of mangrove stands, as well as the adjacent more open mudflats.
The identity of Metaplax longipes had long remained unclear since the publication of M. takahasii Sakai, 1939. The confusion between the two nominal species was mainly caused by two crucial morphological features used for species identification: the number of tubercles and lobes along the male infraorbital ridge, and the number of teeth on the lateral margin of the carapace.
Originally described from Hong Kong by
Interpretations of M. longipes by
Without accessing any material of M. longipes from South China,
Nevertheless, M. takahasii was described with an infraorbital ridge composed of 8 tubercles and the lateral margin of the carapace cut into five teeth. Considering the original descriptions of M. longipes and M. takahasii (
In the present study, we compared specimens from Hong Kong (identified as M. longipes) and various lots from Taiwan main island (originally labeled as M. takahasii: see Materials examined above) with morphological and molecular approaches. As noted by
Metaplax sheni
Gordon, 1930: 525 (type locality: Amoy (= Xiamen), Fujian, China);
Metaplax indica:
China: 5 ♂♂ (8.6–12.8 mm) (
Carapace (Figs
Metaplax sheni Gordon, 1930. A, B dorsal view C ventral view D left infraorbital ridge E right cheliped F right side of carapace showing the five teeth of lateral margin. A, C Male (CW 12.8 mm;
China (Zhejiang, Fujian), Taiwan (Kinmen), Vietnam (Khanh Hoa; Haiphong; Quang Ninh), and Malay Peninsula (including Singapore) (Fig.
One curious record of M. indica was reported by
Specimens collected from Kinmen, opposite Xiamen (Fujian, China), are confirmed as M. sheni based on molecular analyses (see below), being a new record to Taiwan.
Metaplax tredecim
Tweedie, 1950: 354, fig. 6 (type locality: Labuan, Malaysia);
Metaplax longipes:
Paratypes: 2 ♂♂ (15.6–16.2 mm), 1 ♀ (15.7 mm) (
Carapace (Figs
Southeast and East Asia: northern Borneo (Labuan, Malaysia; Brunei), Vietnam (Quang Ninh; Khanh Hoa), and South China (Hong Kong) (Fig.
In Hong Kong, in comparison to M. longipes, M. tredecim tends to occur in habitats of coarser, grittier substrates, with less freshwater input, and frequently on open sandflats rather unsheltered by mangroves.
Identification of the Metaplax tredecim had been confusing, particularly based on the number of teeth along the lateral margin of the carapace.
As mentioned above, two forms, differing in the number of tubercles or lobes on the infraorbital ridge, were recognized in specimens identified with M. longipes by
Metaplax tredecim Tweedie, 1950. A, F Dorsal view B ventral view C left infraorbital ridge D right cheliped E right side of carapace showing the five teeth of lateral margin. A–E paratype male (CW 16.2 mm;
Metaplax elegans De Man, 1888 (A–D
As one of the major morphological features for the identification of species of Metaplax species, the number of lobes and granules along both infraorbital ridges, which are in all cases sexually dimorphic, differs substantially among species. The following range indicate the number of these lobes and tubercles of both sexes (with the exception of M. sheni for which only males were collected), with differences between left and right ridges placed in brackets: in M. elegans 46–61 (0–5) for males and 33–42 (0–3) for females, M. longipes 7–13 (0–2) for males and 14–22 (0–2) for females, M. sheni 16–20 (0–2) for males, and M. tredecim 13–20 (0–3) for males and 20–27 (0–3) for females (Table
The molecular analysis of the COI marker included 22 specimens of Metaplax, with 13 haplotypes (Table
A Bayesian inference (BI) tree for Metaplax elegans De Man, 1888, M. longipes Stimpson, 1858, M. sheni Gordon, 1930, and M. tredecim Tweedie, 1950, and the outgroups, based on the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene. Probability values at the nodes represent support values for BI and maximum likelihood (ML). For haplotype names, see Table
The mean pairwise nucleotide divergence with K2P distances and bp differences of haplotypes of the four species are shown in Table
Matrix of percentage pairwise nucleotide divergence with K2P distance (lower left) and mean number of differences (upper right) based on COI within and between species of Metaplax from East Asia and northern Vietnam (see Table
Intraspecific | Interspecific | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
nucleotide divergence | Mean nucleotide difference | M. elegans | M. longipes | M. sheni | M. tredecim | |
M. elegans | 1.21 (0–1.86) | 7.8 (0–12) | 106.47 (104–108) | 102 (98–108) | 110.35 (107–112) | |
M. longipes | 0.1 (0–0.46) | 0.67 (0–3) | 18.36 (17.86–18.67) | 102 (101–103) | 97.75 (93–101) | |
M. sheni | 0.46 (0–0.92) | 3 (0–6) | 17.5 (16.7–18.7) | 17.5 (17.3–17.71) | 104.44 (102–106) | |
M. tredecim | 0.48 (0.15–0.92) | 3.17 (1–6) | 19.12 18.45–19.45) | 16.8 (15.87–17.45) | 17.99 (17.51–18.3) |
In this study, based on morphological and molecular evidences, we resolve the taxonomic confusions and updated the distribution of Metaplax species from East Asia and northern Vietnam. The presence of four species, viz., M. elegans, M. longipes, M. sheni, and M. tredecim are confirmed, and it is verified that M. takahasii is conspecific with M. longipes, and thus synonymized.
With regard to the number of infraorbital tubercles and lobes, despite elaborate sexual dimorphism among varunid species, serve as a reliable morphological feature in identifying Metaplax species (cf. Table
Phylogenetic relationships in the genus Metaplax or among genera of the Varunidae are far from settled. Monophyly of Metaplax has not yet been confirmed. Moreover, despite various recent research effort employing even complete mitochondrial sequences, the sister group of Metaplax remains unclear (
In our study, the four species of Metaplax can be separated by the COI marker with a minimum interspecific distance of 17.5 %, which is higher than that of most other crab species (see
Species of Metaplax are mainly distributed in the tropical and subtropical continental regions, in muddy and muddy sand habitats, always accompanied by mangroves (
The results of this study clarify the biogeographic distribution of three species (Fig.
This study was supported by a grant from the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST 105-2621-B-005-002-MY3), Executive Yuan, Taiwan, to HTS. We wish to thank Pei-Yi Hsu, Hong-Mei Zhu, Thanh Son Nguyen, Jian Chen, Fan-Qin Liu, Jin-Yan Zhai, and Wei-Jen Lin for helping specimen collection in the field; Takehiro Sato for helping check and take photographs of specimens in Kanagawa Prefectural Museum of Natural History; and P.-Y. Hsu for some of the molecular work. We acknowledge the subject editor Sammy De Grave, Shane Ahyong, and Tomoyuki Komai, who greatly improved the manuscript.