Print
Opiliones of Canada
expand article infoJeffrey W. Shultz
‡ University of Maryland, College Park, United States of America
Open Access

Abstract

The taxonomic diversity of the Opiliones fauna of Canada is reviewed and summarised. At present, 36 native and seven non-native species have been documented in Canada using traditional morphological taxonomy, although more than 20 species may remain undiscovered based on species diversity in the adjacent United States and evidence from DNA barcoding. Consequently, the native fauna is yet to be fully explored and the number, distribution and ecological effects of non-native species remain unclear. Until the 1960s, work on the Canadian Opiliones fauna was largely conducted by researchers based outside the country. From that time on, several Canadian workers became active. However, these taxonomists have now retired and no one has assumed their role. Thus, there is a need to invigorate taxonomic research on the harvestmen of Canada and for the production of easy-to-use identification tools for use by non-taxonomists.

Keywords

Arachnida, biodiversity assessment, Biota of Canada, harvestmen, Opiliones

The Opiliones, or harvestmen, encompass over 6600 described species and about 50 families worldwide (Kury 2013), with 42 species representing eight families currently known from Canada (Table 1). Harvestmen are among the most common and visible groups of poorly-studied arthropod, although interest in their biology was recently invigorated by the book Harvestmen: The Biology of Opiliones (Pinto-da-Rocha et al. 2007). Harvestman systematics has made significant progress in the last 20 years, after more than a century of neglect. As with many invertebrate groups, the rate of taxonomic progress suffers from a shortage of active taxonomists. This is particularly true in Canada, where the last major Canadian harvestman worker, Robert Holmberg, has retired.

Census in Opiliones in Canada.

Taxon1 No. species reported in Dondale (1979)2 No. species currently known from Canada3 No. BINs4 available for Canadian species Est. no. undescribed or unrecorded species in Canada General distribution by ecozone5 Information sources
Suborder Cyphophthalmi
Sironidae 0 0 2 Pacific Maritime, Montane Cordillera Bragg and Holmberg 2009, Giribet and Shear 2010
Suborder Laniatores
Paranonychidae 2 1 2 Pacific Maritime, Montane Cordillera Briggs 1971, Shear and Derkarabetian 2008, Bragg and Holmberg 2009, Derkarabetian and Hedin 2014
Travuniidae 0 0 1 Mixedwood Plains Bishop 1949
Suborder Dyspnoi
Ischyropsalididae 0 0 1 Pacific Maritime Bragg and Holmberg 2009, Richart and Hedin 2013
Sabaconidae 3 6 3 Pacific Maritime, Boreal Plain, Boreal Shield?, Mixedwood Plains; Atlantic Maritime Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Holmberg 1999, Holmberg and Buckle 2004
Taracidae 5 2 1 Pacific Maritime, Montane Cordillera, Mixedwood Plains Bragg and Leech 1972, Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Brousseau 2011, Shear and Warfel 2016
Nemastomatidae 3 (1) 4 1 Pacific Maritime, Mixedwood Plains, Atlantic Maritime Bragg and Holmberg 2009, Shear 2016
Acropsopilionidae 1 0 0 Mixedwood Plains, Boreal Shield, Atlantic Maritime? Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Shultz 2013
Suborder Eupnoi
Caddidae 1 2 1 Mixedwood Plains, Boreal Shield, Atlantic Maritime Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Shultz 2013
Phalangiidae 12 (6) 16 4 all ecozones Bragg and Holmberg 1974, 2009, Cokendolpher 1981b, 1985 Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Shear 2016, Cokendolpher and Holmberg in press
Protolophidae 1 2 1 Pacific Maritime Bragg and Holmberg 2009
Sclerosomatidae 15 31 5 Pacific Maritime, Montane Cordillera, Boreal Plains, Prairies, Boreal Shield, Mixedwood Plains, Atlantic Maritime Davis 1934, Katayama and Post 1974, Cokendolpher 1981a, Cokendolpher and Lee 1993, Ingianni et al. 2011, Hogue 2015
Total 47 43 (7) 64 22

In Danks’ seminal survey of Canadian terrestrial arthropods (Danks 1979), Dondale (1979) summarised the status of harvestman systematics in Canada in fewer than 60 words and without literature citations. He suggested that there were approximately 50 species in the country, which may be close to the true total (Table 1). At the time, he judged that taxonomic instability within the order was too great to assign species reliably to families or to other higher taxa. Since then, harvestman taxonomy has improved greatly, although insights from molecular phylogenetic studies continue to inspire reorganisations at the subfamilial, familial, and even subordinal levels (e.g., Hedin et al. 2012, Schönhofer 2013, Groh and Giribet 2015).

The rate of discovering and cataloguing Canadian harvestmen has been a slow and largely international process that has tended to lag behind that of other western countries. The year in which each native species was first recorded, data mined primarily from Cokendolpher and Lee (1993), illustrates several trends. For each of 24 species native to both Canada and the USA, the first record from the USA preceded the first record from Canada by about 60 years; that is, 53.6 ± 37.4 (SD) years (range: 9-149 y). Only two species were discovered first in Canada, with a difference of 34.5 ± 2.1 years. For over a century (1860 to 1966), all first national records in Canada were established by non-Canadian workers, most from the USA (Banks 1902, 1916, Crosby 1907, Davis 1934, Crosby and Zorsch 1935, Bishop 1949), with the remainder based in Europe (Britain: Walker 1860; Germany: Roewer 1910, 1957; Switzerland: Schenkel 1951; Finland: Hackman 1956). Canadian workers mobilised in earnest in the 1960s and 1970s, with notable contributions from Judd (1966–1978) in Ontario and Bragg and Leech (1972) in British Columbia. Harvestman systematics in western Canada continued to benefit from the work of Phillip Bragg, Robert Holmberg and collaborators (Bragg and Holmberg 1974, 2009, Holmberg 1999, Holmberg et al. 1981, Holmberg and Buckle 2004, Holmberg and Cokendolpher 1997). In contrast, the harvestman fauna of the central and eastern provinces has been comparatively neglected. In fact, significant first national records in the east have been made by citizen scientists contributing photos to such web sites as BugGuide (https://bugguide.net), including first national records for Crosbycus dasycnemus (Crosby) by Brousseau (2011) and Leiobunum nigropalpi (Wood) by Hogue (2015).

The Opiliones are divided into four suborders with the following relationships: Cyphophthalmi, (Laniatores, (Dyspnoi and Eupnoi)). Thus, the current taxonomic hierarchy does not strictly reflect the generally accepted phylogeny. Laniatores, Dyspnoi, and Eupnoi form the clade Phalangida, which is the sister group to Cyphophthalmi, and the Dyspnoi and Eupnoi are united in the Palpatores, which is the sister group to Laniatores (Kury 2018).

The Cyphophthalmi, or mite harvestmen, are not known from Canada, although Bragg and Holmberg (2009) suggested that Siro kamiakensis (Newell) and S. acaroides (Ewing), with northern Washington populations of the latter now known as S. boyerae Giribet & Shear, 2010, might range into southern British Columbia. Global biogeographic patterns indicate that Sironidae is the only family likely to occur in Canada (Boyer et al. 2007).

The taxonomic diversity of the Laniatores, or armored harvestmen, is very high in the New World tropics and subtropics but diminishes significantly with increasing latitude (Kury 2003). The recently circumscribed Paranonychidae encompass the former triaenonychid subfamilies Paranonychinae and Sclerobuninae and is the only family likely to occur in western Canada. With the synonymisation of Sclerobunus parvus Roewer with Paranonychus brunneus (Banks) (Shear and Derkarabetian 2008), just two species are known from British Columbia. Two others known from the northern USA might extend into that province as well (Bragg and Holmberg 2009). Bishop (1949) recorded Erebomaster flavescens (Cope) (Cladonychiinae: Travuniidae) in southeastern New York, an observation that is often overlooked (e.g., Kury 2003). Given the great distance from its known congeners in the mid-Atlantic and mid-western USA, Erebomaster may be more widespread than is currently supposed, and might even range into southeastern Canada.

The morphologically diverse Holarctic suborder Dyspnoi contains three main lineages, Ischyropsalidoidea, Troguloidea, and Acropsopilionidae, with the latter recently transferred from Caddoidea (Eupnoi) (Groh and Giribet 2015). The family-level classification of Ischyropsalidoidea has undergone significant reorganisation (Schönhofer 2013). Sabaconidae now includes only Sabacon (not Taracus), with Sabacon species being widespread in Canada and with barcoding data suggesting the existence of greater species diversity than current taxonomy would suggest (Table 1). The Ceratolasmatidae, erected by Shear (1986), was disbanded and its components transferred to the new family Taracidae (Crosbycus, Hesperonemastoma, Oskoron, Taracus) and to the subfamily Ceratolasmatinae (Acuclavella, Ceratolasma) within the family Ischyropsalididae, which otherwise contains only the European Ischyropsalis. Among the four families in Troguloidea, only the Nemastomatidae occur in Canada, specifically the native ortholasmatines, Dendrolasma and Ortholasma, in British Columbia (Bragg and Holmberg 2009), and the non-native European nemastomatine, Nemastoma bimaculatum (Fabricius), in the East (Shear 2016). Only one acropsopilionid species, Acropsopilio boopis (Crosby), is known from Canada and no additional species are expected to occur there.

The suborder Eupnoi consists of two superfamilies, the species-poor Caddoidea, and the species-rich Phalangioidea. Caddoidea s. str. (Groh and Giribet 2015) contains one genus, Caddo, with two species. Caddo agilis Banks is known from southeastern Canada and C. pepperella Shear may eventually be found there, given its occurrence in New England and its recent discovery in northern Wisconsin (Shultz 2013). The family-level taxonomy within Phalangioidea is in flux, with three major lineages being relevant to the Canadian fauna: Phalangiidae (25% of known Canadian species), Sclerosomatidae (36% of known Canadian species), and at least one species of Protolophidae (Bragg and Hoffman 2009, Ratnasingham and Hebert 2013: Barcode Index Numbers (BINs) BOLD:ACJ0890, BOLD:ACJ0891). Six phalangiid species are native to Canada: Mitopus morio (Fabricius), Odiellus pictus (Wood), Leptobunus borealis Banks, Leptobunus parvulus (Banks), Liopilio yukon Cokendolpher, and Liopilio glaber Schenkel, and at least six appear to have been introduced from Europe: Oligolophus tridens (CL Koch), Paroligolophus agrestis (Meade), Opilio parietinus (DeGeer), Phalangium opilio Linneaus, Lophopilio palpinalis (Herbst), and Rilaena triangularis (Herbst) (Shear 2016, Cokendopher and Holmberg 2018). The leiobunine Sclerosomatidae are represented by five native genera: Hadrobunus (2 spp.), Leiobunum (9 spp.), Leuronychus (1 sp.), Nelima (2 spp.), and Togwoteeus (1 sp.).

Increases in the number of species known from Canada are most likely to come from four sources: range extensions into Canada, introductions, taxonomic revisions, and discovery of cryptic species. The discovery of native species already known from the adjacent USA is the most likely source of new Canadian records. Bragg and Holmberg (2009) listed six species currently known in the USA that might extend into British Columbia, although the taxonomy of several species has since changed and a targeted search for northern populations of one was unsuccessful, i.e., Acuclavella in Richart and Hedin (2013). An unusually thorough study of harvestman distributions in North Dakota (Katayama and Post 1974) showed Eumesosoma roeweri (Goodnight and Goodnight) and Trachyrhinus [T. favosus (Wood) and/or T. marmoratus Banks] (see Cokendolpher 1981) to be present in counties along the USA-Canadian border. This would add two genera and one subfamily (Gagrellinae) to the Canadian fauna. Canada also seems prone to the introduction and establishment of European harvestmen, especially phalangiids (Cokendolpher and Holmberg 2018). The presence of the European Trogulus tricarinatus (Linneaus) in New York and Massachusetts (Shear 2016) indicates that a similar introduction could occur in Canada. Taxonomic revisions can also increase or decrease species diversity. Shear and Warfel (2016) recorded two new Canadian Taracus species and a new genus, Oskoron, that might extend into Canada. Also, an ongoing revision of Hadrobunus (Sclerosomatidae) has revealed two species in Ontario (J Shultz unpubl. data), where only one was assumed to exist. On the other hand, in Leiobunum (Sclerosomatidae), L. formosum (Wood) and L. nigripes Weed were found to be junior synonyms of L. verrucosum (Wood) (Shultz 2008), which eliminated two nominal species from the Canadian fauna. Finally, genetic diversity revealed by analysis of molecular genetic data, including barcodes (e.g. Ratnasingham and Hebert 2013), may indicate the existence of cryptic species (Table 1).

Progress in the discovery and understanding of harvestman diversity in Canada will require the effort of one or more professional taxonomists to engage in active, modern research on the order. A particularly urgent goal is the production and distribution of accessible and easy-to-use tools for the identification of the harvestmen species known or likely to occur in Canada. The virtual absence of such resources has already had significant negative consequences. For example, of the 64 BINs of Canadian harvestmen in the Barcodes of Life Data systems (BOLD) (Ratnasingham and Hebert 2013), about 25% were considered either “unidentified”, although they could be readily identified from photos of voucher specimens (ten BINs), or were identified incorrectly (six BINs). Indeed, the entry for Leiobunum vittatum (BOLD:AAM8191) contains no specimens of that species but encompasses at least three morphologically and geographically distinct species of Hadrobunus. Lastly, specimens in many BINs are identified to genus or species when, in fact, the photos show either juveniles or otherwise unidentifiable specimens. In some cases, the ambiguous specimens are determined as European adventives that are otherwise unrecorded from Canada, a situation that, if correct, could suggest an early stage in the expansion of a potential invasive species. In fact, results from barcoding based on accurate identifications (BOLD:AAM8194) revealed a previously unknown introduction and expansion of the European Oligolophus tridens in Alberta, Saskatchewan and extreme southeastern British Columbia. Clearly, surveys of the harvestman fauna should be undertaken throughout the country to establish the species composition of the native fauna as well as the distribution and environmental impacts of the comparatively numerous species that have been introduced into Canada.

References

  • Boyer SL, Clouse RM, Benavides LR, Sharma P, Schwendinger PJ, Karunarathna I, Giribet G (2007) Biogeography of the world: a case study from cyphophthalmid Opiliones, a globally distributed group of arachnids. Journal of Biogeography 34: 2070–2085. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2699.2007.01755.x
  • Bragg PD, Leech RE (1972) Additional records of spiders (Araneida) and harvestmen (Phalangida) for British Columbia. Journal of the Entomological Society of British Columbia. 69: 67–71. https://biodiversitylibrary.org/page/47081817
  • Bragg PD, Holmberg RG (1974) Platybunus triangularis and Paroligolophus agrestis: two phalangids introduced to North America (Arachnida, Opiliones). Journal of Arachnology 2: 127. https://biodiversitylibrary.org/page/53038358
  • Cokendolpher JC (1985) Revision of the harvestman genus Leptobunus and dismantlement of the Leptobunidae (Arachnida: Opiliones: Palpatores). Journal of the New York Entomological Society 92: 371–402. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25009444
  • Cokendolpher JC, Lee VF (1993) Catalogue of the Cyphopalpatores and bibliography of the harvestmen (Arachnida, Opiliones) of Greenland, Canada, U.S.A., and Mexico. Published by the authors, Lubbock, Texas, 83 pp.
  • Crosby CR (1907) Phalangid notes. Entomological News 18: 161.
  • Davis NW (1934) A revision of the genus Leiobunum (Opiliones) of the United States. American Midland Naturalist 15: 662–705. https://doi.org/10.2307/2419891
  • Derkarabetian S, Hedin M (2014) Integrative taxonomy and species delimitation in harvestmen: a revision of the western North American genus Sclerobunus (Opiliones: Laniatores: Travunioidea). PLoS ONE 9: e104982. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0104982
  • Dondale CD (1979) Opiliones, Pseudoscorpionida, Scorpionida, Solifugae. In: Danks HV (Ed.) Canada and is insect fauna. Memoirs of the Entomological Society of Canada No. 108, 250–251. https://doi.org/10.4039/entm111108250-1
  • Giribet G, Shear WA (2010) The genus Siro Latreille, 1796 (Opiliones, Cyphophthalmi, Sironidae), in North America with a phylogenetic analysis based on molecular data and the description of four new species. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology 160: 1–33. https://doi.org/10.3099/0027-4100-160.1.1
  • Groh S, Giribet G (2015) Polyphyly of Caddoidea, reinstatement of the family Acropsopilionidae in Dyspnoi, and a revised classification system of Palpatores (Arachnida, Opiliones). Cladistics 31: 277–290. https://doi.org/10.1111/cla.12087
  • Hackman W (1956) Phalangida (Opiliones) of Newfoundland. Societas Scientiarum Fennica. Commentationes Biologicae 15(17): 1–9.
  • Hedin M, Tsurusaki N, Macías-Ordóñez R, Shultz JW (2012) Molecular systematics of sclerosomatid harvestmen (Opiliones, Phalangioidea, Sclerosomatidae): geography is better than taxonomy in predicting phylogeny. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62: 224–236. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2011.09.017
  • Holmberg RG (1999) Harvestmen (Arachnida, Opiliones) of Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba [Abstract]. Proceedings of the 46th Annual Meeting of the Entomological Society of Alberta 46: 11.
  • Holmberg RG, Bragg PD, Belicek J (1981) Opiliones of western Canada: a progress report. Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Alberta 28: 19.
  • Holmberg RG, Buckle DJ (2004) Two new species of Sabacon harvestmen, with descriptions of the females of Sabacon astoriensis Shear and Sabacon sheari Cokendolpher, from western North America (Arachnida, Opiliones, Sabaconidae). American Arachnology 68: 6.
  • Holmberg RG, Cokendolpher JC (1997) Re-description of Togwoteeus biceps (Arachnida, Opiliones, Sclerosomatidae) with notes on its morphology, karyology and phenology. Journal of Arachnology 25: 229–244.
  • Ingianni EA, McGhee CR, Shultz JW (2011) Taxonomy of the Leiobunum calcar species-group (Opiliones: Sclerosomatidae: Leiobuninae). Journal of Arachnology 39: 454–481. https://doi.org/10.1636/Ha11-42.1
  • Judd WW (1961a) Insects and other invertebrates associated with flowering skunk cabbage, Symplocarpus foetidus (L.) Nutt., at Fanshawe Lake, Ontario. Canadian Entomologist 93: 241–249. https://doi.org/10.4039/Ent93241-4
  • Judd WW (1961b) Spiders and harvestmen trapped on the surface of Spettigue’s Pond at London, Ontario. Canadian Field-Naturalist 75: 238–241.
  • Judd WW (1962) Insects and other invertebrates from nests of the cardinal, Richmondena cardinalis (L.), at London, Ontario. Canadian Entomologist 94: 92–95. https://doi.org/10.4039/Ent9492-1
  • Judd WW (1965) Studies of the Byron Bog in southwestern Ontario. XVIII. Distribution of harvestmen and spiders in the bog. National Museum of Canada, Natural History Papers 28: 1–12.
  • Judd WW (1985) Harvestmen and spiders and their prey on milkweed, Asclepias syriaca L., at London, Ontario. Canadian Journal of Zoology 47: 159–161. https://doi.org/10.1139/z69-036
  • Judd WW (1977) Harvestmen (Phalangida) of Dunn Township, Canada. Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Ontario 108: 139–143.
  • Katayama RW, Post RL (1974) Phalangida of North Dakota. North Dakota Insects – Publication 9: 1–40.
  • Kury AB (2003) Annotated catalogue of the Laniatores of the New World (Arachnida, Opiliones). Revista Iberica de Aracnologia, Volumen especial monographico no. 1: 1–337.
  • Langor DW (2019) The diversity of terrestrial arthropods in Canada. In: Langor DW, Sheffield CS (Eds) The Biota of Canada – A Biodiversity Assessment. Part 1: The Terrestrial Arthropods. ZooKeys 819: 9–40. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.819.31947
  • Pinto-da-Rocha R, Machado G, Giribet G (2007) Harvestmen: The Biology of Opiliones. Harvard University Press: Cambridge MA, 597 pp.
  • Richart CH, Hedin M (2013) Three new species in the harvestmen genus Acuclavella (Opiliones, Dyspnoi, Ischyropsalidoidea), including description of male Acuclavella quattuor Shear, 1986. ZooKeys 311: 19–68. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.311.2920
  • Roewer C-F (1910) Revision der Opiliones Plagiostethi (=Opiliones Palpatores). I. Teil: Familie der Phalangiidae (Subfamilien: Gagrellini, Liobunini, Leptobunini). Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der Naturwissenschaften 19(4): 1–294. [pls 1–6]
  • Roewer C-F (1957) Über Oligolophinae, Caddoinae, Sclerosomatinae, Leiobuninae, Neopilioninae und Leptobuninae (Phalangiidae, Opiliones Palpatores). (Weitere Weberknechte XX). Senckenbergiana Biologica 38: 323–358.
  • Shear WA (1986) A cladistic analysis of the opilionid superfamily Ischyropsalidoidea, with descriptions of the new family Ceratolasmatidae, the new genus Acuclavella, and four new species. American Museum Novitates 2844: 1–29. http://hdl.handle.net/2246/3579
  • Shear WA (2016) New Canadian records of Nemastoma bimaculatum (Fabricius), and a brief summary of introduced Eurasian harvestmen in North America (Arachnida, Opiliones). Zootaxa 4088: 139–140. https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4088.1.7
  • Shear WA, Derkarabetian S (2008) Nomenclatural changes in Triaenonychidae: Sclerobunus parvus Roewer is a junior synonym of Paranonychus brunneus (Banks), Mutusnonychus Suzuki is a junior synonym of Paranonychus Briggs, and Kaolinonychinae Suzuki is a junior synonym of Paranonychinae Briggs (Opiliones: Triaenonychidae). Zootaxa 1809: 67–68. http://mapress.com/zootaxa/2008/f/zt01945p068.pdf
  • Shultz JW (2008) Leiobunum nigripes is a junior synonym of Leiobunum verrucosum (Opiliones, Sclerosomatidae). Journal of Arachnology 36: 184–186. https://doi.org/10.1636/H07-48SC.1
  • Shultz JW (2013) Significant range extensions for two caddid harvestmen in eastern North America, Caddo pepperella and Acropsopilio boopis (Opiliones: Eupnoi: Caddidae). Zootaxa 3637: 94–96. https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.3637.1.12