Research Article |
Corresponding author: Benny K.K. Chan ( chankk@gate.sinica.edu.tw ) Academic editor: Sammy De Grave
© 2018 Hsi-Te Shih, Benny K.K. Chan, Peter K.L. Ng.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Shih H-T, Chan BKK, Ng PKL (2018) Tubuca alcocki, a new pseudocryptic species of fiddler crab from the Indian Ocean, sister to the southeastern African T. urvillei (H. Milne Edwards, 1852) (Crustacea, Decapoda, Brachyura, Ocypodidae). ZooKeys 747: 41-62. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.747.23468
|
A new pseudocryptic species of fiddler crab, Tubuca alcocki sp. n., is described from the northern Indian Ocean. The new species was previously identified with T. urvillei (H. Milne Edwards, 1852), but can be distinguished by the structures of the anterolateral angle of the carapace and male first gonopod. The molecular data of the mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit I gene shows that both are sister taxa and the divergence time is estimated at 2.2 million years ago, around the beginning of the Pleistocene. While the new species is widely distributed in the northern part of Indian Ocean, occurring from the Red Sea to India and the Andaman Sea; T. urvillei sensu stricto has a more restricted range, and is known only from southeastern Africa.
mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit I, molecular clock, morphology, new species, Tubuca alcocki , Tubuca urvillei
In recent years, various genetic and morphological studies on fiddler crabs (Ocypodidae) from the Indian Ocean have shown that there are a number of species endemic to the region: Austruca albimana (Kossmann, 1877), A. bengali (Crane, 1975), A. iranica (Pretzmann, 1971), A. occidentalis (Naderloo, Schubart & Shih, 2016), A. sindensis (Alcock, 1900), Cranuca inversa (Hoffmann, 1874), Paraleptuca chlorophthalmus (H. Milne Edwards, 1837), Gelasimus hesperiae (Crane, 1975), and Tubuca urvillei (H. Milne Edwards, 1852) (
Of these taxa, Tubuca urvillei is a large-sized species, which has been widely reported from throughout the Indian Ocean and is the only Tubuca Bott, 1973 species known in the western Indian Ocean (
In this study, specimens from the range of Tubuca urvillei, including the type specimens, were examined. There are two clades, with small but consistent morphological differences supported by DNA evidence from cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI). The material from the northern and eastern parts of the Indian Ocean is herein described as a new pseudocryptic species, T. alcocki.
Specimens of Tubuca urvillei sensu lato collected from southeastern Africa, India and western Thailand examined (including the types) are deposited in the Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris, France (
Sequences of COI were obtained following the method described by
The haplotypes of COI gene of Tubuca alcocki sp. n. and T. urvillei from the Indian Ocean. Abbreviations of museums or universities see Material and methods.
Species | Locality | Catalogue no. | Sample size | Access. no. of COI |
---|---|---|---|---|
Tubuca alcocki sp. n. | India: Mumbai | NCHUZOOL 14899, 14925, 14901, 14902 | 4 | LC150445 |
NCHUZOOL 14903 | 2 | LC150445 | ||
Thailand: Ranong |
|
2 | LC369625 | |
NCHUZOOL 14896 (paratype) | 1 | LC369625 | ||
|
1 | LC369625 | ||
Thailand: Phuket |
|
1 | LC369625 | |
|
1 | LC369626 | ||
Tubuca urvillei | Mayotte: Poroani |
|
1 | LC053375 |
Kenya: Shimo la Tewa |
|
1 | LC053375 | |
Kenya: Mida Creek, Malindi | NCHUZOOL 14895 | 1 | LC053375 |
The phylogenetic tree was reconstructed by the maximum likelihood (ML) analysis by using RAxML (vers. 7.2.6,
Gelasimus
arcuatus
–
Gelasimus
urvillei
H. Milne Edwards, 1852: 148, pl. 3(10) [type locality: “Vanikoro”];
Gelasimus
dussumieri
– A.
Uca
arcuata
–
Uca
arcuatus
–
Uca
dussumieri
–
Uca
urvillei
–
Tubuca
urvillei
–
Uca (Uca) urvillei
–
Uca (Uca) dussumieri
–
Uca (Deltuca)
[coarctata] urvillei –
Uca (Deltuca) urvillei
–
Uca (Tubuca) urvillei
–
Lectotype ♂ (CW 18.5 mm, CL 11.0 mm, PL 17.0 mm) (
1 ♂ (CW 28.5 mm), 1 ♀ (CW 22.9 mm) (
Male. Carapace (Figs
Tubuca urvillei (H. Milne Edwards, 1852) A male (CW 29.7 mm,
Southeastern Africa from Giumbo (= Jumboo), southern Somalia, to Cape Province, South Africa (mouth of Umtata R.); Madagascar (
In his revision of the genera and subgenera of the fiddler crabs of the world,
A note on Gelasimus dussumieri H. Milne Edwards, 1852 (at present Tubuca dussumieri) is necessary. The type material of Tubuca dussumieri include specimens from Samarang (Java, Indonesia) and Malabar (Mumbai, India) (H. Milne Edwards, 1852), and as no holotype was originally selected,
With regard to the records of T. urvillei and T. acuta in
Gelasimus
Dussumieri
H. Milne Edwards, 1852: 148, pl. 4(12) [part; Malabar, India];
Gelasimus
acutus
–
Gelasimus
Urvillei
–
Uca
angustifrons
–
Uca (Deltuca)
[coarctata] urvillei –
Uca
urvillei
–
Uca (Deltuca) urvillei
–
Uca (Deltuca) dussumieri
–
Uca (Tubuca) urvillei
–
Uca (Tubuca) acuta
–
Tubuca
urvillei
–
Holotype: ♂ (CW 30.1 mm, CL 17.9 mm; PL 58.2 mm) (
Thailand: 2 ♂♂ (CW 17.8–26.1 mm) (
Male. Carapace (Figs
Right G1. Tubuca alcocki sp. n. A–D holotype (CW 30.1 mm,
Female. Anterolateral angle more broadly triangular; anterolateral margin moderately long, joining dorsolateral margin as convex structure (Fig.
Tubuca alcocki sp. n. A–G variation of the live colouration. A, B holotype (CW 30.1 mm,
Carapace morphology. A, C, E, G Tubuca alcocki sp. n., B, D, F, H T. urvillei (H. Milne Edwards, 1852). A holotype male (CW 30.1 mm,
Adults with carapace and legs brown or dark brown, posterior part gray, especially in females (Fig.
In western Thailand, this species inhabits muddy banks of mangroves (Fig.
This species is named after Alfred William Alcock, who first recorded this species from India and Pakistan as “Uca urvillei” (cf.
Western Thailand, India, Pakistan, and the Red Sea (see Remarks).
Although the number of tubercles on the floor of orbit and thumb morphology of G1 are sometimes useful for distinguishing species of fiddler crabs, they are too variable in Tubuca alcocki sp. n. and T. urvillei (
The specimen from Malabar, western India, and one of the paralectotypes of Gelasimus dussumieri (see discussion earlier), have the G1 distal tube relatively more slender, almost straight, with the distal and proximal parts subequal in width (
There are also colour differences between T. urvillei and T. alcocki. While the colouration of females, young males, and juveniles are variable in Tubuca species, the colouration of the adult male carapace is generally more useful (
The molecular analyses include 12 specimens of Tubuca alcocki sp. n. from western Thailand and western India; and three specimens of T. urvillei from southeastern Africa (Table
The genetic distance between these two sister species is 3.78 % (K2P distance) or 3.65 % (p-distance), and the total bp difference is 24 bp. The value is higher than some species within the Ocypodoidea, e.g., the minimum genetic distance of K2P between two species is 2.79 % between Paraleptuca crassipes (White, 1847) and P. splendida (Stimpson, 1858); 3.62 % between Gelasimus hesperiae (Crane, 1975) and “Clade U”; and 3.62 % between Mictyris brevidactylus Stimpson, 1858 and M. guinotae Davie, Shih & Chan, 2010, but still smaller than 6.25 % between Ocypode stimpsoni Ortmann, 1897 and O. mortoni George, 1982; and 4.43 % between Scopimera globosa (De Haan, 1835) and S. ryukyuensis Wong, Chan & Shih, 2010 (see
Tubuca alcocki and T. urvillei are quite similar in general morphology, but can be still distinguished by characters of the carapace and G1 (see Remarks under T. alcocki), which is supported by molecular evidence (Fig.
According to
Based on the pairwise divergence rates of 1.66 % per million years for COI of marine coastal crabs (
This study was supported by a grant from the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST 105-2621-B-005-002-MY3), Executive Yuan, Taiwan, to HTS. We wish to thank Kingsley Wong, Hsi-Nien Chen, Ng Ngan Kee, Lee Bee Yan, Tan Siong Kiat, for helping specimen collection in the field; for providing specimen used in this study; Laure Corbari, late Michael Türkay, Stefano Cannicci and Sara Fratini for providing specimens used in this study; S. Cannicci and Joseph Poupin for providing photographs; Anand. Jeya Kumar for specimen information from the Red Sea; and Pei-Yi Hsu for measuring specimens and part of molecular work. Special thanks are due to Somsak Panha (Chulalongkorn University) and Somchai Bussarawit (previously from the Phuket Marine Biological Centre) for help with work in western Thailand over the years. We acknowledge Tomoyuki Komai and one anonymous referee, who greatly improved this manuscript.