Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Zhe-Yu Chen ( chenzheyu1998@163.com ) Corresponding author: Neil D. Young ( nyoung@unimelb.edu.au ) Academic editor: Thierry Backeljau
© 2025 Zhe-Yu Chen, Tanapan Sukee, Anson V. Koehler, Bonnie L. Webster, Robin B. Gasser, Winston F. Ponder, Neil D. Young.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Chen Z-Y, Sukee T, Koehler AV, Webster BL, Gasser RB, Ponder WF, Young ND (2025) Mitogenome and nuclear rRNA gene cluster of Austropeplea subaquatilis (Tate, 1880) from South Australia, with molecular and morphological comparison of A. cf. brazieri (Smith, 1882) from Victoria (Gastropoda, Hygrophila, Lymnaeidae). ZooKeys 1255: 41-62. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1255.164109
|
Species of Austropeplea are lymnaeid snails endemic to Australia and New Zealand, and most are intermediate hosts of parasitic trematodes. Their taxonomy has long been uncertain due to the high phenotypic plasticity of most species. In this study, we used Oxford Nanopore sequencing technology to characterise the mitogenome and nuclear ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene cluster of Austropeplea subaquatilis from South Australia to support comparative taxonomic investigations of this species. Then, A. subaquatilis was compared with A. cf. brazieri at both morphological and molecular levels. Morphologically, A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri can be distinguished by shell morphometric indices, mantle edge morphology, pigmentation, and reproductive and neural anatomy. The two taxa differed by 1.9% in both the mitogenome and nuclear rRNA gene cluster. Sequence divergence was pronounced in the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions of the latter gene cluster, with nucleotide differences of 13.8% in ITS1 and 8.2% in ITS2. Phylogenetic analyses of sequence data for the mitochondrial 16S gene and ITS2 placed the two taxa in distinct groups. Taken together, the integrative evidence presented herein supported species-level divergence between A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri.
Australia, freshwater snails, integrative taxonomy, mitochondrial genome, molecular phylogeny, nuclear rRNA gene cluster
Lymnaeidae Rafinesque, 1815 (commonly known as pond snails) are a globally distributed group of freshwater hygrophilid snails, which have attracted widespread attention as intermediate hosts of various species of parasitic trematodes (e.g.,
The aim of this study was to characterise A. subaquatilis from South Australia morphologically and molecularly, and then compare this species with A. cf. brazieri from Victoria, Australia to establish their taxonomic and phylogenetic relationship.
Austropeplea subaquatilis were collected from “Drain M” near Princes Highway in Thornlea, South Australia, Australia (latitude −37.36891397, longitude 140.2052126). Austropeplea cf. brazieri were previously collected from a roadside irrigation channel in Werribee South, Victoria, Australia (latitude −37.944706, longitude 144.698857) (see
Both species of Austropeplea were then cultured in aquaria within a designated laboratory at The University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. Snails from different sources were maintained in strict isolation in separate tanks containing clean artificial pond water with aeration. Water was changed regularly and the snails were fed a commercial fish diet. A small section (~5 mm) of the foot muscle was excised from adult specimens and preserved in RNAlater at 4 °C for 24 h, -20 °C for one month and then stored at -80 °C until further processing. The remainder of each adult specimen was then placed in 70% ethanol for subsequent dissection and collection of morphological features.
Animal external features in the living state were observed in the field and in individuals maintained in culture. Ten and 13 individuals of A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri were dissected for internal morphological observation respectively, all individuals had attained a body size sufficient for oviposition. Terminology for the characters followed
The radular sac was removed from three adult snails of each species and the soft tissue removed using a 10% potassium hydroxide (KOH) solution. After complete dissolution of soft tissues, each radula was washed extensively in MilliQ water. While still soft, each radula ribbon was transferred onto a round coverslip (Ø 13 mm), air-dried and fixed in place. The coverslip was then mounted onto an aluminium stub using conductive carbon tape (ProSciTech Pty Ltd). A 4-μm thick gold coating was deposited on the radula surface using SafeMatic® CCU-010 coater. Radulae were then scanned using a Hitachi® SU7000 scanning electron microscope under a low vacuum mode (5 kV). Images generated from the middle detector were used in this study.
Foot tissue of a specimen of A. subaquatilis (voucher number: AB291) was removed from the RNAlater and washed extensively in nuclease-free water (Qiagen). DNA was then isolated from each section of tissue using the E.Z.N.A. Mollusc DNA Kit according to manufacturer’s instructions (Omega Bio-tek Inc.). The quantity of DNA isolated from each tissue was determined using the Qubit 1X dsDNA HS Assay and a Qubit 2.0 Fluorometer 2 (Invitrogen, ThermoFisher).
Amplification of the A. subaquatilis mitochondrial DNA was performed using the REPLI-g mitochondrial DNA kit (Qiagen) following the manufacturer’s protocol using a custom primer mix that was designed to match conserved regions of the lymnaeid 12S and 16S mitochondrial ribosomal subunits and the cox1 gene. Primers were 11–14 nt in length and incorporated phosphorothioate links between the last three bases at the 3’ end of the primers (Table
Modified primers used to amplify lymnaeid mitochondrial DNA using the REPLI-g mitochondrial DNA amplification kit (Qiagen). Asterisks represent the incorporated phosphorothioate links.
| Primer name | Primer sequence | Targeted region | Direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| RepGS_Aust16F | TACCTGTTTATC*A*A | 16S | Forward |
| RepGS_16SBRis | AACTCAGATCAT*G*T | 16S | Reverse |
| RepGS_12sF | CAACGGCAATAT*A*T | 12S | Forward |
| RepGS_12sR | CTAGGATTAGAT*A*C | 12S | Reverse |
| RepGT_JB3 | ATCCT GAGGTTT*A*T | cox1 | Forward |
| RepGT_JB4.5 | ACATAATGAAAA*T*G | cox1 | Reverse |
| RepGT_16sF | CCTTTTGCATCA*T*G | 16S | Forward |
| RepGT_16sR | CGGTCTTAACTC*A*A | 16S | Reverse |
For A. subaquatilis, a barcode was assigned to amplified DNA template using the RAPID 24 (SQK-RBK114) barcoding library kit (Oxford Nanopore Technologies) and loaded onto a R10.4.1 flow cell and sequenced for 4 h on the PromethION 2 Solo (Oxford Nanopore Technologies) sequencing platform. Post-sequencing base-calling of POD5 data was performed using the program Dorado v. 0.7.2 (Oxford Nanopore Technologies) in super-accurate mode and reads were stored in FASTQ format. Nanopore long read sequence data for A. cf. brazieri was available from a previous study (
Long reads with homology to reference mitochondrial genomes or ribosomal RNA subunit of freshwater molluscs were identified using pblat v. 2.5.1 (
Nucleotide pairwise distances (p-distance) of complete mitochondrial genome, the nuclear rRNA gene cluster and each gene were calculated in Geneious Prime v. 2024.0.7 after alignment with Clustal Omega v. 1.2.3. Sliding window analyses of nucleotide diversity (300-bp windows with 10-bp steps for mitochondrial genome and 50-bp windows with 10-bp steps for nuclear rRNA gene cluster) were performed on the aligned mitogenomes and nuclear rRNA gene cluster of A. cf. brazieri and A. subaquatilis using the PopGenome package (
To compare A. cf. brazieri and A. subaquatilis samples with available molecular data for Austropeplea spp. (see
The mitochondrial genomes (mitogenome) of A. subaquatilis (GenBank accession number PV749633) and A. cf. brazieri (GenBank accession number PP100270) are 13,768 and 13,757 bp, respectively (Fig.
Sliding window analysis of the pairwise differences in the nucleotide identity of Austropeplea subaquatilis and Austropeplea cf. brazieri mitochondrial genomes (A) and nuclear rRNA gene cluster (B). Gene boundaries are indicated by vertical dotted lines. The horizontal dotted line indicates the average nucleotide diversity between the two sequences.
Location, lengths, and directions of annotated genes within the mitochondrial and nuclear rRNA gene clusters of Austropeplea subaquatilis, with comparisons to Austropeplea cf. brazieri (values after slash). Nucleotide pairwise identity of each gene between the two species is shown.
| Gene designations | Location start | Location end | Length (bp) | Direction | Pairwise Identity | p-distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mitochondrial genes | ||||||
| 16S | 1/1 | 986/986 | 986/986 | forward | 99.4% | 0.6% |
| tRNA-L1(tag) | 988/988 | 1051/1051 | 64/64 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-P(tgg) | 1047/1047 | 1106/1106 | 60/60 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-A(tgc) | 1107/1107 | 1170/1170 | 64/64 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| nad6 | 1171/1171 | 1629/1629 | 459/459 | forward | 97.6% | 2.4% |
| nad5 | 1631/1631 | 3277/3277 | 1647/1647 | forward | 96.9% | 3.1% |
| nad1 | 3279/3279 | 4154/4154 | 876/876 | forward | 98.3% | 1.7% |
| nad4L | 4155/4155 | 4452/4452 | 298/298 | forward | 98.3% | 1.7% |
| cytb | 4453/4453 | 5533/5533 | 1081/1081 | forward | 98.3% | 1.7% |
| tRNA-D(gtc) | 5536/5536 | 5588/5587 | 53/52 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-F(gaa) | 5589/5588 | 5651/5650 | 63/63 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| cox2 | 5652/5651 | 6294/6293 | 643/643 | forward | 98.3% | 1.7% |
| tRNA-Y(gta) | 6297/6296 | 6346/6345 | 50/50 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-W(tca) | 6347/6346 | 6405/6405 | 59/60 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-C(gca) | 6410/6410 | 6468/6468 | 59/59 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-G(tcc) | 6471/6470 | 6524/6522 | 54/53 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-H(gtg) | 6527/6525 | 6583/6582 | 57/58 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-Q(ttg) | 6592/6591 | 6650/6649 | 59/59 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-L2(taa) | 6651/6650 | 6703/6701 | 53/52 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| atp8 | 6705/6703 | 6855/6853 | 151/151 | reverse | 98.2% | 1.8% |
| tRNA-N(gtt) | 6857/6854 | 6920/6917 | 64/64 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| atp6 | 6921/6918 | 7560/7557 | 640/640 | reverse | 98.6% | 1.4% |
| tRNA-R(tcg) | 7561/7558 | 7623/7620 | 63/63 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-E(gaa) | 7624/7621 | 7675/7672 | 52/52 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| 12S | 7676/7673 | 8393/8388 | 718/716 | reverse | 98.2% | 1.8% |
| tRNA-M(cat) | 8394/8389 | 8466/8457 | 73/69 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| nad3 | 8467/8458 | 8806/8797 | 340/340 | reverse | 99.1% | 0.9% |
| tRNA-S2(tga) | 8817/8808 | 8871/8862 | 55/55 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| tRNA-S1(gct) | 8872/8863 | 8926/8917 | 55/55 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| nad4 | 8927/8918 | 10252/10243 | 1326/1326 | forward | 98% | 2% |
| tRNA-T(tgt) | 10253/10244 | 10319/10311 | 67/68 | reverse | N/A | N/A |
| cox3 | 10321/10313 | 11100/11092 | 780/780 | reverse | 98.8% | 1.2% |
| tRNA-I(gat) | 11141/11133 | 11205/11197 | 65/65 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| nad2 | 11206/11198 | 12109/12101 | 904/904 | forward | 97.8% | 2.2% |
| tRNA-K(ttt) | 12110/12102 | 12191/12180 | 82/79 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| cox1 | 12203/12192 | 13694/13683 | 1492/1492 | forward | 97.7% | 2.3% |
| tRNA-V(tac) | 13695/13684 | 13755/13744 | 61/61 | forward | N/A | N/A |
| Nuclear rRNA gene cluster | ||||||
| 18S | 1/1 | 1865/1865 | 1865/1865 | forward | 100% | 0% |
| ITS1 | 1866/1866 | 2374/2369 | 509/504 | forward | 86.2% | 13.8% |
| 5.8S | 2375/2370 | 2532/2527 | 158/158 | forward | 100% | 0% |
| ITS2 | 2533/2528 | 2900/2915 | 368/388 | forward | 91.8% | 8.2% |
| 28S | 2901/2916 | 6731/6747 | 3831/3832 | forward | 99.3% | 0.7% |
The completed nuclear rRNA gene cluster of A. subaquatilis (GenBank accession no. PV593739) and A. cf. brazieri (GenBank accession no. PV593740) span 6,712 bp and 6,747 bp respectively (Fig.
Phylogenetic trees were constructed from a dataset consisting of 29 16S + ITS2 sequences of Austropeplea, 27 of them were obtained from previous study (
Bayesian phylogenetic tree of Austropeplea based on combined 16S and ITS2 sequences. Red tip labels represent the sequences generated in this study. Coloured shading and the corresponding inset map summarise the geographic distributions of the principal lineages. Maximum likelihood (ML) bootstrap (BS) and Bayesian posterior probability (BPP) support values for shown for each node. Scale bar represents substitutions per site.
Specimens from “Drain M” near Princes Highway in Thornlea, South Australia, Australia, and their artificially bred offspring.
Shell
(Fig.
Shells (A, B), mantle pigmentations (C, D) and living individuals (E, F) of Austropeplea spp. A, C, E. Austropeplea subaquatilis; B, D, F. Austropeplea cf. brazieri. G. Schematic representation of mantle extension ranges (green areas), A. subaquatilis shown above, A. cf. brazieri below. The red arrows (in C) indicate the mantle pigmentation on the visceral coil. Scale bar: 5 mm (except G not to scale).
Head-foot
(Fig.
Central nervous system
typical of family (Fig.
Dorsal side of central nervous system (A, B) and pallial complex (C, D) of Austropeplea spp. A, C. Austropeplea subaquatilis; B, D. Austropeplea cf. brazieri. Abbreviations: an – anus, au – auricle, cc – cerebral commissure, cg – cerebral ganglia, cl – commissural lobule, k – kidney, pn – cut wall of pneumostome, pv – pulmonary vein, re – rectum, ve – ventricle. The red-dotted line shows the additional lobe from the cerebral ganglion with a clear boundary. Scale bars: 1 mm.
Pulmonary roof
(pallial complex) (Fig.
Prostate
pear-shaped, with single internal fold. Sperm duct long and thick, equal to or slightly longer than oothecal gland in length. Praeputium (Fig.
Male (A, B) and female (C, D) copulatory apparatus of Austropeplea spp. A, C. Austropeplea subaquatilis; B, D. Austropeplea cf. brazieri. Abbreviations: bt – bulbous termination of praeputium, prep – praeputium, prer – praeputium retractor muscles, ps – penis sheath, sp – spermatheca, srd – spermatheca duct, vag – vagina, vd – vas deferens. Scale bars: 1 mm.
Radula
of the haplolateral multidentate type (Fig.
The name A. subaquatilis (Tate, 1880: 103, pl. 4, Fig.
South-eastern South Australia and western Victoria (
Artificially bred specimens in the lab, which were originally from Werribee South, Victoria, Australia.
Shell
(Fig.
Head-foot
(Fig.
Central nervous system
(Fig.
Pulmonary roof
(Fig.
Prostate
fusiform, with single internal fold. Sperm duct short, almost invisible in natural position. Praeputium (Fig.
Radula
of the haplolateral multidentate type (Fig.
We use the species-group name A. cf. brazieri for our Victorian specimens because both molecular and morphological data indicate clear differences from typical Austropeplea brazieri (E. A. Smith, 1882: 274, pl. 5, fig. 15, from Glebe Point, Sydney, New South Wales). The currently recognised distribution of A. brazieri is broad (
There are three additional names available for this taxon, all from New South Wales (Glacilimnaea gelida Iredale, 1943: 214, Blue Lake, Mt Kosciusko, NSW; Simlimnea morbida Iredale, 1944: 119, figs 5-4, Walcha, NSW; and Simlimnea aegrifer Iredale, 1944: 119, fig. 5-5, Bombala, NSW), but based on the molecular data of species from representative location of above (Fig.
Victoria, Australia.
Due to its short apex and very large aperture, A. subaquatilis can be distinguished from A. cf. brazieri by shell morphometrics such as the Index Spire height/Shell height and Index Aperture height/Shell height (Table
Morphometric characteristics of studied specimens of Austropeplea subaquatilis and Austropeplea cf. brazieri. ICA: Index of the copulatory apparatus, ratio of praeputium length and penis sheath length. Parenthetical values represent the mean of the group, * indicates p < 0.001.
| Characters and Indexes | Species | p | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. subaquatilis (n = 10) | A. cf. brazieri (n = 13) | ||
| Number of whorls | 3.75–4.5 | 4–4.25 | |
| Shell height (SH), mm | 9.02 – (10.37) – 12.5 | 9.71 – (11.30) – 14 | |
| Shell width (SW), mm | 6.04 – (6.87) – 8.41 | 5.92 – (7.14) – 8.98 | |
| Spire height (SpH), mm | 1.45 – (2.07) – 2.63 | 2.86 – (3.79) – 4.66 | * |
| Body whorl height (BWH), mm | 8.58 – (9.54) – 11.45 | 8.63 – (9.95) – 12.19 | |
| Aperture height (AH), mm | 7.27 – (8.20) – 9.75 | 6.36 – (7.46) – 9.5 | |
| Aperture width (AW), mm | 4.29 – (5.05) – 6.48 | 3.84 – (4.72) – 6.12 | |
| Index SW/SH | 0.63 – (0.66) – 0.70 | 0.55 – (0.63) – 0.69 | |
| Index SpH/SH | 0.16 – (0.20) – 0.21 | 0.28 – (0.34) – 0.41 | * |
| Index BWH/SH | 0.87 – (0.92) – 0.95 | 0.86 – (0.88) – 0.92 | |
| Index AH/SH | 0.75– (0.79) – 0.85 | 0.59 – (0.66) – 0.71 | * |
| Index AW/AH | 0.44 – (0.49) – 0.52 | 0.34– (0.42) – 0.45 | * |
| ICA | 1.34 – (1.69) – 2.02 | 1.12 – (1.51) – 2.21 | |
The mantle pigment on the visceral coil of mature individuals of A. subaquatilis does not occur in A. cf. brazieri. The internal pigmentation of A. subaquatilis is generally lighter than that of A. cf. brazieri. The difference in the relative size of the bulbous termination of the praeputium is a consistent distinction in the male reproductive system of the two species, as are the shape of the spermatheca and the width of the spermathecal duct in the female system. Apart from the larger commissural lobule in A. cf. brazieri, mature A. subaquatilis formed a distinctly demarcated and ellipsoid lobe from each cerebral ganglion situated opposite the commissural lobule (namely adjacent to the buccal mass).
This study used an integrative approach, combining morphological data, mitogenome and nuclear rRNA gene cluster comparisons and phylogenetic analyses to assess the relationship between A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri. Based on morphological features, these two snail taxa could be readily distinguished. The complete mitochondrial and nuclear rRNA gene clusters sequenced and compared herein are some of the first such data sets for the family Lymnaeidae and are among the very few available for the order Hygrophila (
The patterns of nucleotide divergence in mitochondrial genes and the nuclear rRNA clusters of A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri are distinct. Most mitochondrial genes exhibit low pairwise nucleotide divergence between the two species. For instance, the nucleotide p-distance for the cox1 gene is 2.3%, a value that was at the threshold between intra- and interspecific variation in other lymnaeid taxonomic studies (
Despite the limitations of using 16S gene and ITS2 markers alone for this group, we proceeded to use only these regions to make a phylogenetic comparison with data available for Austropeplea. The topology of the 16S + ITS2 phylogenetic trees in this study and that of
The newly sequenced A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri were placed in two geographically structured lineages within Austropeplea (southern versus eastern Australia), consistent with regional structuring rather than constituting definitive evidence of species level divergence. Nevertheless, the limitations of the current markers were evident, as the main Australian Austropeplea lineage and several within group relationships showed polytomies, indicating unresolved relationships. These unresolved nodes may have reflected limited phylogenetic signal, rapid radiation, or incomplete lineage sorting, and thus warrant further investigation using additional genetic markers. Future studies employing complete mitochondrial genome sequences and nuclear rRNA gene clusters are warranted to address the unresolved relationships within the genus.
The morphological features of A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri generally corresponded to the type B and type A morphs, respectively, as described by
The external features of the head-foot and mantle of A. subaquatilis included a broad foot with the shell enveloped by the mantle. In its natural habitat, A. subaquatilis was observed living in extremely dense water milfoil (Myriophyllum spp.) environments, which presumably necessitated moving between tightly packed branches. The reduction of shell-related hindrance may have enhanced the animal’s ability to survive in such environments. The abnormally high mucus production in A. subaquatilis when stimulated may have served as an alternative defence mechanism against predators, perhaps compensating for the fragile shell. This trait was commonly observed in land slugs and semi-slugs (
Taken together, the integrative evidence presented herein supported species-level divergence between A. subaquatilis and A. cf. brazieri. While mitochondrial divergence alone approached the threshold of interspecific separation, the pronounced differences in ITS regions, along with the morphological traits, provided a coherent framework for species delimitation. Nevertheless, the phylogeny of this group remains poorly resolved. Continued efforts involving additional phylogenetically informative genetic datasets and comparative anatomical studies will be essential for resolving outstanding taxonomic uncertainties and understanding the evolutionary dynamics of this group.
We are grateful to Ms Christine Andersen, Prof. Ian Beveridge, and Mr Kasem Driver for their invaluable support during the fieldwork.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
No use of AI was reported.
This study was supported by the Australian Research Council Discovery Project no. DP230100270.
All authors have contributed equally.
Zhe-Yu Chen https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4150-8906
Tanapan Sukee https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3181-5045
Anson V. Koehler https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8330-6416
Bonnie L. Webster https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0930-9314
Robin B. Gasser https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4423-1690
Winston F. Ponder https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8600-3952
Neil D. Young https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8756-229X
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
Location, code, and NCBI GenBank accession numbers of the lymnaeid snail nucleotide sequences used in this study
Data type: pdf