Research Article |
Corresponding author: Deborah Matthews ( dlott@flmnh.ufl.edu ) Academic editor: Bernard Landry
© 2017 Deborah Matthews.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Matthews DL (2017) A new species of Oxyptilus Zeller from the southwestern United States (Lepidoptera, Pterophoridae). ZooKeys 698: 75-93. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.698.14999
|
Oxyptilus eleanerae sp. n., is described from New Mexico, Arizona, and Southwest Texas, and compared with the only other Oxyptilus occurring in the Nearctic Region, O. delawaricus Zeller. A redescription is provided for O. delawaricus. Adults and male and female genitalia are illustrated for both species. Key morphological characters, distributions, and relationships within the genus are discussed.
Davis Mountains, Crombrugghia , Hieracium , Madrean Archipelago, Nearctic Region, new species, Paliza Canyon, sky islands
The genus Oxyptilus Zeller (type species Pterophorus pilosellae Zeller) formerly included 28 species worldwide (
Of the remaining 28 species listed by
The Nearctic fauna includes eight genera of Oxyptilini. Of these, Dejongia Gielis, Trichoptilus Walsingham, Megalorhipida Amsel, and Buckleria Tutt can be easily separated from the others by the narrow, apically pointed lobes of the forewing which lack a distinct termen. Following key characters described and illustrated in
Several years ago, while identifying and curating Pterophoridae at the McGuire Center, I found three very worn specimens from the Davis Mountains of Texas that I recognized as something different and confirmed by dissection that they were not O. delawaricus as previously determined. Although recognizing the species as new, I did not proceed with further investigation until James Adams presented me with a fresh female for identification from samples he and his mom collected on a memorable trip to the Davis Mountains in
Specimens examined for this study, including comparative material of O. delawaricus, are from the following institutions and private collections: Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia (ANSP); Deborah Matthews Collection, Gainesville, Florida (DMC); Canadian National Collection, Ottawa (CNC); Great Lakes Forestry Centre, Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario (GLFC); Laurence L. Crabtree Collection, Adin, California (LLCC); Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard University (MCZ); McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity, Florida Museum of Natural History, University of Florida (MGCL); Florida State Collection of Arthropods, Lepidoptera housed at McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity, Gainesville, Florida (FSCA); Mississippi Entomological Museum, Mississippi State, Starkville, Mississippi (MEM); Essig Museum of Entomology, University of California, Berkeley, California (UCB); National Museum of Natural History, Washington, D.C. (USNM); Department of Entomology, Washington State University, Pullman, Washington (WSU). Collections or institutions are indicated within material examined by the database number prefix or the collection coden given in parentheses if the specimen has not yet been assigned a unique identifier.
Genitalia were prepared following standard dissection techniques of tissue maceration in heated 10% KOH and light staining with Chlorazol Black E and Eosin Y followed by slide mounting in Euparal. Adult images were taken with a Canon 70D camera and Canon 100mm IS macro lens against a standard gray background in a white reflective light funnel illuminated with OttLite bulbs. Genitalia slides were photographed at manually selected multiple focal planes using a Canon Rebel T3i camera mounted on a Zeiss Axiophoto transmitted light microscope in conjunction with Canon EOS Utility software. Ventral adult images and genitalia images were stacked as needed with Zerene Stacker, version 1.04 using the DMap algorithm and images were assembled on the plates with Adobe Photoshop CS5.1. Images of heads and palpi were taken with an Auto-montage Pro 5.01 system (Synoptics Ltd.) using a JVC digital camera (model KY-F65U) and Leica Z16APO lens.
Forewing measurements in descriptions are from the wing base to apex and include apical fringe scales. Cleft origin proportions exclude fringe scales. Wing venation follows
HOLOTYPE. ♀ – with the following labels: ΄U.S.A. NM: Sandoval Co. │ 1.1 mi NE jct. 10 & 266 │ on 266, 7319 ft. │ 35.70860° N 106.61876° W │27 July 2013 MA Solis΄ [white printed]; ΄HOLOTYPE ♀ │ Oxyptilus │ eleanerae │ D. Matthews΄[red printed]; ΄USNMENT │ 01338013΄ [white thermal printed with data matrix code]. PARATYPES. 13 ♂, 20 ♀ as follows: 4 ♂ – USA: ARIZONA: Apache Co.: White Mts., 7200 ft, 1 – 15 Aug 1925, O.C. Poling, USNMENT01338024, 01338029 [slide DM 1822], 01338031, 01338033; 2 ♀ – same data, USNMENT01338022, 01338032 [slide DM 1835]; 2 ♂ – same data except, 1–15 Sep 1925, USNMENT01338015 [slide DM 1817], USNMENT01338026; 1 ♀ – same data, USNMENT01338027; 1 ♂ – White Mts., near McNary P.O., 15 – 30 Aug 1925, O.C. Poling, USNMENT01338028; 1 ♀ – same data, USNMENT01338030; 1 ♀ – White Mts., near Rice, 7000 ft, 15 – 30 Jul 1925, O.C. Poling, USNMENT01338025 [slide DM 1831]; 1 ♀ – Coconino Co.: Chiricahua Mts., Herb Martyr forest camp, 5840 ft, 7 Aug 1966, Robert G. Beard, at UV light, Barcode of Life DNA voucher specimen, SmplID CCDB-20275-B04, BOLD Proc. ID LNAUS2296-13, USNMENT00869147; 1 ♂ – Clover Springs, 25 Aug 1978 R. Wielgus, CUVBL, Barcode of Life DNA voucher specimen, SmplID CCDB-20275-B05, BOLD Proc. ID LNAUS2297-13, USNMENT00869148; 1 ♂ – Fort Valley, 7 ½ mi. NW Flagstaff, 7350 ft, 16 Aug 1961, Ronald W. Hodges, USNMENT01338020; 1 ♀ – Hochderffer Hill, 12 ½ mi. NNW Flagstaff, 8500 ft, 4 Aug 1961, Ronald W. Hodges, USNMENT01338017; 1 ♀ – Kehl Spring Forest Camp, 7450 ft, 30 Jul 2014, R.S. Wielgus, 15 watt UV light trap, USNM [no number]; 1 ♂ – West Fork, 16 mi. SW Flagstaff, 6500 ft, 13 Jul 1961, Ronald W. Hodges, USNMENT01338016 [slide USNM PYR. 93 / RWH USNM 63,602]; 1 ♀ – same data except 13 Aug 1961, USNMENT01338023; 2 ♀ – same data except 20 Aug 1961, USNMENT01338019, 01338021; 1 ♀ – County unspecified [locality near Santa Cruz/Pima border]: Madera Canyon, Santa Rita Mtns., 4880 ft, 29 Jul 1959, Ronald W. Hodges, USNMENT01338018; 1 ♂ – NEW MEXICO: Sandoval Co.: Valles Caldera National Preserve, 0.5 mi. past jct. VC033 & VC06 on VC06, 9610 ft, 35.8994°N, 106.5670°W, 24 Aug 2010, M. Pogue & M. Metz, collected in MV light trap 3, USNMENT01338014 [slide DM 1829]; 1 ♂ – TEXAS: Jeff Davis Co.: Davis Mtns. Resort, 5800 ft, 29 Sep 1994 D.G. Marqua, Acc. No. 2009-30, MGCL 100049 [slide DM 1823]; 1 ♀ – same data except 21 Jul 2004, MGCL 168736 [slide DM 1812]; 1 ♀ – Davis Mts. Pres., Madera Canyon 5800’ 12,13 Sep 2001 B/K [Bordelon/Knudson] (MGCL); 1 ♂ – Davis Mts. State Park 27 Jun – 1 Jul 1987 J.B. Heppner, MGCL 168735 (FSCA) [slide DM 1613]; 3 ♀ – same location, 22,23 Aug 1995, E. Knudson (MGCL); 1 ♀ – same location 3 Oct 1999 ECK [Knudson] (MGCL); 1 ♀ – Ft. Davis, 19 Aug 1984 E. Knudson (MGCL); 1 ♀ – 18.5 road mi. NW of Fort Davis, along St. Hwy. 118, 10–11 Aug 2005 James & Eleaner Adams, light trap, MGCL 168734.
The holotype and 23 paratypes are property of the National Museum of Natural History, Washington, DC. (USNM). In addition, ten paratypes are deposited at the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity (MGCL), one of which [MGCL 168735] is the property of the Florida State Collection of Arthropods (FSCA) housed within the McGuire Center.
1 ♂ – USA: Arizona: Pima Co. Santa Rita Mts., Madera Canyon 17 Aug 1949 C.W. Kirkwood, CPK collection, slide DM 634 (MCZ). This specimen is identified as O. eleanerae based on images of the genitalia slide. The specimen was previously examined by the author and returned to MCZ identified as O. delawaricus. This specimen is excluded from the type series as it was not on hand at the time of preparation of the present description.
This species is distinguished from the only other nearctic Oxyptilus, O. delawaricus, by the drab or grayish ground color as opposed to ochraceous-tawny in O. delawaricus. It is further distinguished by having white as opposed to ochraceous-tawny or clay colored apices on both ventral forewing lobes. The anterior dorsal forewing lobe has two transverse white bands, with the more basal band distinctly wider as opposed to similar widths in O. delawaricus. The hindwing second lobe has a distinct patch of white linear fringe scales two-thirds from the wing base along the anal margin which only appears as a trace in some O. delawaricus. In O. eleanerae, the ventral surface of the abdomen has a strong mesal band, about twice the width of that in O. delawaricus. Key differences in the male genitalia include distinctly shorter tegumen lobes in males of O. eleanerae and the bilobed process of sternite VIII with triangular as opposed to finger-shaped lobes. Females of O. eleanerae have proportionally larger and robust signa and simple cup-shaped antrum without a dorsal bilobed marginal lip.
(male, female). Based on the holotype (female) and 33 paratypes (13 males, 20 females). HEAD (Figs
Male genitalia (Figs
Female genitalia (Figs
This species is named in honor and memory of Eleaner Ruth Adams who together with her son James, collected one of the paratypes in the Davis Mountains of Texas. Eleaner is fondly remembered for her sense of adventure and passion for natural history which she passed on to her sons and grandchildren. The epithet is a noun in the genitive case reflecting the meaning of the common name Eleaner’s Oxyptilus.
Unknown. Other species in the genus feed on Hieracium. Seven native species of Hieracium are known to occur within parts of the range of O. eleanerae. Of particular interest as a potential host is Hieracium carneum Green (Huachuca hawkweed) which has a similar range to O. eleanerae, restricted to Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas (
The holotype was collected in Sandoval County New Mexico, within the Santa Fe National Forest southeast of Jemez Springs and just east of Paliza Canyon. The area is dominated by ponderosa pine with some Douglas fir, oak brush, and nearby pinyon-juniper woodland. The habitat where the holotype was collected (based on an image provided by M.A. Solis) was a canopy gap adjacent to Highway 266. This opening was surrounded by Pinus ponderosa, a few Populus tremuloides, and shrub oaks. Ground cover included Ericameria (rabbit brush) in bloom and sparse grasses. Low groundcover also included some rosette leaf clusters which could be Hieracium as well as Antennaria but these cannot be identified with certainty from the photo. The altitude of the type locality is 2231 meters (7319 feet).
The known distribution (Fig.
Oxyptilus adults and corresponding labels: 1 dorsal view of O. eleanerae, holotype, female, New Mexico, Sandoval County 2 ventral view of holotype 3 holotype specimen labels 4 dorsal view of female paratype, Texas, Jeff Davis County 5 ventral view of female paratype 6 female paratype labels 7 dorsal view of male paratype, Arizona, Coconino County 8 ventral view of female paratype 9 male paratype labels 10 dorsal view of male O. delawaricus, Montana, Mineral County 11 ventral view, same individual 12 specimen labels.
Oxyptilus male genitalia: 17 O. delawaricus phallus, slide DM 1837, California, El Dorado County, S. Lake Tahoe, Cold Creek, 10 Aug 1991, D.L. Bauer, MGCL Acc. # 2010-29 18 same individual and slide, genitalia in situ at sternite VIII, with sternite VIII bilobed structure folded open toward anterior, and phallus removed 19 O. eleanerae male paratype, phallus, slide 1829, New Mexico: Sandoval County (see Type material section) 20 same individual, genitalia in situ at sternite VIII, with sternite VIII bilobed structure folded open toward anterior, and phallus removed.
Oxyptilus delawaricus Zeller, Verhandlungen der Kaiserlich-Königlichen Zoologisch-Botanischen Gesellschaft in Wien Vol. 23, p. 320, 1873.
Oxyptilus bernardinus f. finitimus Grinnell, Canadian Entomologist, Vol. 19, p. 315, 1908.
More than 284 specimens were examined from various institutions and label data captured. In the interest of brevity, locality data is given in captions for figured specimens and summarized for all other O. delawaricus specimens examined in the distribution map (Fig.
As in O. eleanerae, the second segment of the labial palpus bears a scale tuft that extends partway alongside the distal segment distinguishing it from related genera. The species is recognized externally by the ochraceous-tawny ground color; the metascutum with three ochraceous-tawny or clay color stripes, as opposed to buff in O. eleanerae (mid-dorsal stripe may be obscure), and flanked by narrow white stripes with the pattern continued on the first abdominal segment; and patterns of the forewing first lobe. Dorsally, the first lobe is traversed by equally narrow white stripes, as opposed to a wider proximal band as in O. eleanerae. The trajectory of the distal white stripe is also at a smaller angle than in O. eleanerae. Ventrally, the forewing apex is ochraceous-tawny or clay colored as opposed to white in O. eleanerae. The midventral white band of the abdomen is narrow in O. delawaricus, about half the width of that in O. eleanerae. Genitalia characters also distinguish the two species including the longer tegumen lobes and constricted base of the valvular lobe in O. delawaricus males, and the bilobed ostial margin and smaller signa in females.
(male, female). HEAD (Figs
Male genitalia (Figs
Female genitalia (Figs
Larvae web together leaves and feed within these masses on the developing inflorescences of Hieracium (hawkweeds) (Asteraceae). Three species have been recorded as hostplants: H. abiflorium Hook., H. cynoglossoides Arv.–Touv. (= H. albertinum Farr), and H. scouleri Hook. (
Oxyptilus delawaricus occurs in both the western and eastern United States and Canada with a large gap in the distribution representing the Great Plains (Fig.
Distribution records of O. delawaricus do not overlap with those of O. eleanerae which is restricted to sky islands within the southern part of the Intermountain Basin and Plateau Region. No records of O. delawaricus have been found as yet for Colorado, likewise showing a separation of the two species by the Wyoming Basin and Southern Rocky Mountains. Adults have been collected from the middle of May through the first week of September. The earliest confirmed spring records (mid May) are from Northern Mississippi, and are also the southernmost records with dates included on the labels. Late season records (August, September) are from more northern latitudes but no clear flight patterns are evident.
Oxyptilus female genitalia: 21 O. delawaricus, slide DM 1836, Washington, Chelan County, Wenatchee NF, Swakane Canyon Rd. (FR 7415), 4.2 mi. W of jct w/Hwy 99, 8 Jul 2010, James Adams (DMC) 22 O. eleanerae paratype, slide DM 1831, Arizona: Apache County (see material examined) 23–26 enlargements of ostium/antrum - 23 O. eleanerae paratype, slide DM 1835, Arizona: Apache County 24 O. eleanerae paratype, slide DM 1831, Arizona: Apache County 25 O. delawaricus, slide DM 1811, California, El Dorado County, S. Lake Tahoe, Cold Creek, 1 Aug 1977, D.L. Bauer, MGCL Acc. # 2010-29 26 O. delawaricus, slide DM 1836, data cited above for same slide.
Oxyptilus abdominal segments I and II: 27 O. delawaricus male, slide DM 1837, California, El Dorado County, S. Lake Tahoe, Cold Creek, 10 Aug 1991, D.L. Bauer, MGCL Acc. # 2010-29 28 O. delawaricus female, slide DM 1836, Washington, Chelan County, Wenatchee NF, Swakane Canyon Rd. (FR 7415), 4.2 mi. W of jct w/Hwy 99, 8 Jul 2010, James Adams; 29 O. eleanerae male, slide DM 1829, New Mexico: Sandoval County 30 O. eleanerae female, slide DM 1831, Arizona: Apache County.
Distribution of Oxyptilus delawaricus and O. eleanerae. Assembled with simplemappr.net, accessed March 2017.
As a key character, the position of the lateral concavity of tergite II in males, along with other characters of the upper abdominal segments, was of interest in confirming the generic placement of the new species. In males of both O. eleanerae and O. delawaricus this concavity (Figs
Two of the O. eleanerae paratypes (previously sorted in USNM protem material as Capperia sp.) bear Barcode of life voucher numbers (see Type material section). The corresponding CO1 sequences were retrieved via the BOLD systems public portal (
The close relationship of Crombrugghia and Oxyptilus found by
In addition to the extent of the northern range of O. delawaricus, that of the southern range of O. eleanerae is unknown. Examination and identification of material from northwestern Mexico, specifically the southern extent of the Madrean Archipelego (
I would first like to thank James and Eleaner Adams for providing the first suitable specimen for description of the new species. Jacqueline Y. Miller supported visits to USNM resulting in discovery of additional specimens. Thanks to M. Alma Solis (USNM) for the loan of these specimens and for providing a habitat photograph and details on the type locality. Jim Vargo supplied excellently prepared comparative material of O. delawaricus. Ed Knudson and Charles Bordelon are acknowledged for the significant donation of the Texas Lepidoptera Survey to the McGuire Center. Thanks are also due to Terry A. Lott for access and assistance in photographing genitalia slides and for reviewing the text. Cees Gielis, Helen Alipanah, and Bernard Landry are gratefully acknowledged for their helpful comments on the manuscript. James E. Hayden [FSCA] graciously provided access and assistance with Automontage imaging. Financial support was provided by the Florida Biodiversity Foundation.