Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Chi-Feng Lee ( chifeng@tari.gov.tw ) Academic editor: Caroline Chaboo
© 2025 Chi-Feng Lee.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Lee C-F (2025) What drives the reduction of hindwings in Galerucinae sensu stricto (Insecta, Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae)? A case study based on the Taiwanese fauna. In: Chaboo CS, Matsumura Y, Schmitt M (Eds) Research on Chrysomelidae 10. ZooKeys 1252: 111-137. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1252.142772
|
Most Taiwanese species of Galerucinae s. str. have been revised taxonomically in recent years. In Taiwan, reduction of hindwings occurs in 37 species in eight genera. A citizen science-led fieldwork project (Taiwan Chrysomelid Research Team, TCRT) targeting the biology of galerucine species has produced many specimens for morphological and taxonomic study and allowed the development of evolutionary scenarios to explain hind-wing reduction in the following genera: Paraplotes Laboissière, Lochmaea Weise, Shairella Chûjô, Furusawaia Chûjô, Sikkimia Duviver, Taiwanoshaira Lee & Beenen, Apterogaleruca Chûjô, and Hirtigaleruca Chûjô. The results reveal that the drivers of the reduction of hindwings vary across different galerucine genera in Taiwan based on character complexes involved in the transformations.
Apterogaleruca, Citizen science, Furusawaia, Hirtigaleruca, leaf beetles, Lochmaea, Paraplotes, Shairella, Sikkimia, Taiwanoshaira
Wing size, venation, and form can vary inter- and intraspecifically in many chrysomelids. In addition to the full-winged (macropterous) flying morph, there are several stages of flightless (wing-reduced) morphs. Quantifying stages of wing reductions is challenging.
Insect juvenile hormone (JH) regulates flight-wing development. Increased levels of JH lead to juvenile characters, i.e., brachyptery, and lower levels to adult characteristics, such as macroptery. In cases of alary polyphenism, abiotic environmental factors may influence the concentration of JH or other morph-determining hormones prior to adult eclosion. The most commonly reported stimulus affecting morph determination is photoperiod. Biotic factors such as high population densities also induce alary polyphenism. In addition, abiotic and biotic factors may interact to determine flight apparatus development (
This study focuses on both brachyelytrous species of Galerucinae s. str. (
The Taiwan Chrysomelid Research Team was organized by myself and Hsing-Tzung Cheng (鄭興宗) during 2005. Mr Cheng made detailed inventories and photographs of insects and developed a website, “Insect Observation at Sishou Hills” (
Historical photographs of the TCRT A first annual meeting of TCRT in 2008 (from left): Hsuei-Hon Han, Su-Fang Yu, Chih-Kai Yang, Chi-Feng Lee, Hsueh Lee, Hsing-Tzung Cheng, Mei-Hua Tsou, Hou-Jay Chen B annual meeting of TCRT in 2010 (from left): Mei-Hua Tsou, Su-Fang Yu, Hou-Jay Chen, Jung-Chang Chen, Chi-Feng Lee, Hsing-Tzung Cheng, Hsueh Lee, Min-Der Chen C Hsing-Tzung Cheng introduced the third volume of the book “The Chrysomelidae of Taiwan” during a forum for celebrating the tenth anniversary of TCRT D Su-Fang Yu autographed the book at the forum E Su-Fang Yu worked as actress on the TV program “Discovery” on the DaAiVideo (大愛電視) F exhibit during the 39th Annual Meeting of Taiwan Entomological Society in 2018 (from left): Chi-Feng Lee, Wen-Chuang Liao, Mei-Hua Tsou, Su-Fang Yu G Su-Fang Yu and Mei-Hua Tsou stood besides the poser during the meeting in 2018 H annual meeting in 2025 (from left): Yen-Cheng Hsu, Jung-Chang Chen, Yi-Ting Chung, Hseuh Lee, Shiang-Lien Yang, Yi-Chia Chiu, Chi-Feng Lee, Hsing-Tzung Cheng, Min-Der Chen, Chen-Han Ma, Mei-Hua Tsou, Su-Fang Yu.
We cooperated with students and faculty at universities for some species living in alpine habitats. For example, Chrysolina laeviguttata Chûjô, 1958 is the only member of the genus living in such environments (in Alishan 阿里山). The study on its biology was completed in collaboration with students and faculty at the National University of Tainan with access to thermostatically controlled incubators (
Recently, five new members joined TCRT, including Yen-Cheng Hsu (徐彥承), Yi-Ting Chung (鍾奕霆), Shiang-Lien Yang (楊庠廉), Yi-Chia Chiu (邱奕家), and Chen-Han Ma (馬承漢) (Fig.
Although this article integrates my previous studies, all Taiwanese species of wingless galerucines were studied using the following procedures. Researchers investigated or collected wingless species at various localities during night hours to determine which species are present. When specimens were located, researchers observed them to determine host plants. When host plants were found, searches were conducted at different localities at night to document patterns of distribution and activity. Observations were made at the same place once or twice each month to investigate patterns of occurrence of adults and larvae. Live females were collected for laboratory rearing to document complete life cycles under controlled conditions.
We found that different evolutionary scenarios for the reduction of hindwings occur in different genera. We present each different morphological aspect of wing reduction under the genus accounts below.
Lochmaea is a good candidate for comparative analysis because it comprises in Taiwan two winged and three wingless species (
Adults are nocturnal and active on host plants at night. However, they don’t crawl down and shelter on the ground during the daytime. Thus, adults can be collected effectively by beating host plants during the day or night, and they can be trapped using Malaise traps. A number of adults of L. lesagei were collected in one Malaise trap set at Yuanfeng (鳶峰, 2756 m) from 2001 to 2006. Records indicated that adults were active from April to November and overwintered from December to March.
The genus Lochmaea Weise A L. tsoui, a winged species B distribution of winged species of Lochmaea in Taiwan C L. chen, a wingless species D distribution of wingless species of Lochmaea in Taiwan. Solid line: 1000 m, broken line: 2000 m, black areas: 3000 m; different colors represent different species. (after
Among those orders of insects in which both winged and flightless species occur, both sexes are most frequently flightless in six orders, females in nine orders, and in two orders the male is the predominant flightless sex (
Species of Paraplotes are multivoltine. Adults are nocturnal and closely associated with their Urticaceae host plants (Pilea spp. (Fig.
Ten species of Paraplotes are recognized in Taiwan. Five of these are widespread and inhabit lowlands (Fig.
This genus was considered brachelytrous and monotypic when
The genus Shairella Chûjô A Clinopodium laxiflorum var. taiwanianum (Lee & Beenen, 2017) B Hemiboea bicornuta (Lee, 2022) C Larva of S. guoi feeding on leaves of Strobilanthes flexicaulis D pupa of S. guoi E Adult of S. aeneipennis species group (Lee & Beenen, 2017) associated with C. laxiflorum var. taiwanianum F adult of S. cheni species group (Lee and Beenen 1027) associated with H. bicornuta G adult of S. quadricostata (
Distribution of brachelytrous Shairella species and Clinopodium laxiflorum var. taiwanianum A solid line: 1000 m, broken line: 2000 m; different colors represent different species, circles represent species associated with C. laxiflorum var. taiwanianum, squares represent species associated with H. bicornuta B C. laxiflorum var. taiwanianum (after
Shairella quadricostata (Kimoto, 1996) (Fig.
Adults of S. quadricostata (Fig.
Moss (Bryophyta) cushions constitute a special environment characterized by several important features: food source and habitat for overwintering when many tracheophytes are absent; buffered temperature and moisture; and the small size of spaces among the stems and leaves within cushions (
The genus Taiwanoshaira is the first genus of moss-feeding Galerucinae s. str. described that is endemic to Taiwan (
The genus Taiwanoshaira Lee & Beenen A microhabitat for T. taipingshanensis and T. tsoui Lee & Beenen at Yuanyang Lake (鴛鴦湖) B active adults of T. chujoi inside moss cushions at Pilu (畢祿) C adult of T. taipingshanensis feeding on leaves of Plagiomnium vesicatum at Yuanyang Lake (鴛鴦湖) D adults of T. taipingshanensis mating at Yuanyang Lake (鴛鴦湖) (after
Mosses are common all over Taiwan due to high humidity and precipitation. They are most dominant in cloud forests, which cover most montane areas above 1000 m altitude. However, species of Taiwanoshaira are restricted to limited areas, based on the TCRT’s collecting experience (Fig.
Although Sikkimia is widespread in continental Asia and Taiwan, only Taiwanese species are wingless and nocturnal (
Adults of Taiwanese species are characterized by a reduction of the hindwings and elytral humeral calli (Fig.
All Sikkimia species are allopatric, restricted to different mountain ranges, and not separated by elevation. Populations of S. tsoui have a wide distribution and occupy northern and central Taiwan (Fig.
Furusawaia Chûjô is a small wingless galerucine genus distributed in China (two species) and Taiwan (five species). Most members of wingless genera are exclusively nocturnal. However, adults of Furusawaia exhibit bizarre behavior with diurnal or nocturnal habits in different individuals of the same species. Adults can often be observed walking on forest trails during the day, while others are active at night. Such behavior may be associated with bicolored elytra (Fig.
The genus Furusawaia Chûjô A microhabitat of F. lui in Hsinpaiyang (新白楊) B adult of F. jungchani in the daytime, Huakang (華崗) C adult of F. lui at night, Hsinpaiyang (新白楊) D adult of F. tahsiangi in the daytime, Hsuehshan (雪山) E two adults of F. tsoui Lee & Bezdèk at night, Jianqing trail (見晴步道) F adult of F. yosonis at night, Alishan (阿里山) (
In Taiwan, adults were observed walking or resting on forest trails at low altitudes (1000–2000 m) in northern Taiwan or middle and high altitudes (above 2000 m) in central and southern Taiwan. Most Furusawaia species have broad distributions except for F. jungchani Lee & Bezděk. Two species are sympatric in Taipingshan (太平山). Most adults were collected at lower altitudes (below 2500 m), where they are easily accessible to collectors. Very few individuals were found above 3000 m (Fig.
Apterogaleruca comprises two species, A. hirtihumeralis Chûjô and A. uenoi Kimoto. The former represents a species group that is widespread from lowlands to 2000 m (Fig.
Adults of Apterogaleruca and Hirtigaleruca A A. hirtihumeralis, male, collected from Tengchih (藤枝) B different individual collected at same locality C same species, feeds on Cirsium japonicum var. australe, collected from Yangmingshan (陽明山) D same species, female, collected from Neiwan (內灣) E A. uenoi, male, collected from Pilu (畢祿) F Hirtigaleruca aptera, male, collected from Ima (依麻).
Immature stages of Apterogaleruca and Hirtigaleruca A eggs of A. hirtihumeralis B eggs of Hirtigaleruca aptera C second-instar larva of A. hirtihumeralis feeding on Cirsium japonicum var. australe, collected from Nanya (南雅) D third-instar larva of A. hirtihumeralis feeding on Elatostema lineolatum var. majus, collected from Huisun (惠蓀).
Unlike most wingless members of Galerucini in Taiwan, individuals of Apterogaleruca inhabit not only mountainous regions but also alpine regions and lowlands. Members of this genus are most widespread and utilize most ecological niches in Taiwan since they are multivoltine and polyphagous in lowlands, and modifications of their external morphology (smooth surface and short antennae) are adapted to alpine regions.
Evolutionary scenarios for reduction of hindwings in each galerucine genus in Taiwan are different and characteristic.
I am grateful to all members of the Taiwan Chrysomelid Research Team (TCRT) and citizen scientists, including Hou-Jay Chen (陳厚潔), Jung-Chan Chen (陳榮章), Hsing-Tzung Cheng (鄭興宗), Yi-Ting Chung (鍾奕霆), Hsueh Lee (李雪), Sin-Sue Li (李欣學), Wen-Chuan Liao (廖文泉), Wei-Ting Liu (劉威廷), Ui-Ka Ong (王惟加), Mei-Hua Tsou (曹美華), and Su-Fang Yu (余素芳) for assistance in collecting material, taking photos of specimens, field photography. I thank Chang-Chin Chen (陳常卿) for assisting our study in various ways. I thank Chris Carlton for reading the draft and editing for American English style.
The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This study was supported by the National Science and Technology Council NSTC 112-2313-B-055-001-MY3. Finally, I thank Ron Beenen, Yongying Ruan, and one anonymous reviewer for reviewing the manuscript, and Caroline Chaboo for editorial assistance.
The author solely contributed to this work.
Chi-Feng Lee https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1996-0557
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.