Monograph |
Corresponding author: Francisco Javier Peris-Felipo ( peris.felipo@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Jose Fernandez-Triana
© 2025 Francisco Javier Peris-Felipo, Fernando Santa, Cornelis van Achterberg, Sergey A. Belokobylskij.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Peris-Felipo FJ, Santa F, van Achterberg C, Belokobylskij SA (2025) Review of the genera and subgenera of the subtribe Aspilotina (Hymenoptera, Braconidae, Alysiinae), with a new illustrated key. ZooKeys 1229: 133-200. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1229.142489
|
The genera and subgenera of the subtribe Aspilotina are reviewed. A new illustrated key to all accepted supraspecies taxa is provided. Grandilota Fischer, 2002, stat. nov. is proposed as subgenus of Aspilota Foerster, 1863. Carinthilota Fischer, 1975, syn. nov. is synonymised with Alitha Cameron, 1906, stat. nov. and the latter is treated as subgenus of Dinotrema Foerster, 1863; Eudinostigma Tobias, 1986, syn. nov. is considered a synonym of Dinotrema Foerster, 1863. Moreover, the new subgenus Pseudoprosapha subgen. nov. (type species: Dinostigma stenosoma van Achterberg, 1988) is described. Additionally, Synaldotrema Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002, stat. nov. is treated as a separate genus. The following new combinations are proposed: Aspilota (Aspilota) ruficollis Stelfox & Graham, 1950, comb. nov., Dinotrema (Alitha) lada (Belokobylskij, 1998), comb. nov., D. (A.) longipennis (Cameron, 1906), comb. nov., D. (A.) mavka (Belokobylskij, 1998), comb. nov., D. (A.) parapsidalis (Fischer, 1975), comb. nov., D. (A.) vechti (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov., Dinotrema (Dinotrema) alox (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov., D. (D.) entabeniense (Fischer, 2009), comb. nov., D. (D.) latum (Chen & Wu, 1994), comb. nov., D. (D.) planiceps (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov., D. (D.) subpulvinatum (Fischer, 2009), comb. nov., D. (Pseudoprosapha) stenosoma (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov., D. (Synaldis) bienesae (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov., D. (S.) fischeri (Tobias, 1986), comb. nov., D. (S.) latistigma (Fischer, 1962), comb. nov., D. (S.) planiceps (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov., D. (Synaldis) cespitator (Belokobylskij, 2004), comb. nov., D. (S.) perfidum (Fischer, 1970), comb. nov., D. (S.) trematosum (Fischer, 1967), comb. nov. and Panerema fulvicornis (Haliday, 1838), comb. nov.
Alysiini, Aspilota group, illustrated key, parasitoid of Diptera, Phoridae, redescriptions
The parasitoid wasps of the subtribe Aspilotina Belokobyskij & Tobias, 2002 are the largest aggregation within the braconid tribe Alysiini (Hymenoptera: Braconidae: Alysiinae) with approximately 850 valid species worldwide (
Despite host-parasitoid relationships in the Alysiini are yet insufficiently known, already 29 families of cyclorrhaphous Diptera have been listed in the literature as their hosts. Most of them belong to the families Agromyzidae, Anthomyiidae, Calliphoridae, Drosophilidae, Muscidae, Phoridae, Sarcophagidae, and Tephritidae (
Over the years, the genera included in this subtribe have changed statuses. For example,
The revisions of the type species of the Aspilota group genera (= subtribe Aspilotina) carried out during many years and checking a large number of Aspilota, Dinotrema, and Orthostigma species allows us to recognise the main diagnosis characters to classify the almost 850 valid species worldwide. These characters are: paraclypeal fovea remained removed from or reaching the border of the eye; mandible without or sometimes with transverse carina; furrow between antennal socket and eye absent or present; notauli mainly absent in dorsal view or sometimes well developed; scutellum without or with transverse crenulated depression; position of the origin of the vein r; pterostigma almost not differentiated, very narrow, or sometimes well isolated and wide; vein 2-SR of fore wing present or absent; subbasal cell of hind wing distally closed or open; first subdiscal cell of fore wing distally close or open; main cells of the hind wing closed or open; fore femur narrow and simple or wide and with tooth; first metasomal tergite with or without dorsope; second metasomal tergite entirely smooth or rarely sculptured basally; hypopygium not retracted under distal metasomal segments or sometimes strongly retracted.
For the terminology of morphological features, sculpture, and measurements (including for mandibles) see
The specimens examined are preserved in the entomological collections at the institutions listed below:
BMNH The Natural History Museum (London, U.K.)
ENV Entomological Collection of the University of Valencia (Valencia, Spain)
NHMB Museum für Naturkunde (Berlin, Germany)
NHMD Natural History Museum of Denmark (Copenhagen, Denmark)
NMA Naturhistorisk Museum Aarhus (Aarhus, Denmark)
PFEC F.J. Peris-Felipo Private Entomological Collection (Basel, Switzerland)
To establish the position and relationship between genera and subgenera, a multivariate statistical approach was used to build the cladogram (Table
Character | Plesiomorphic (0) | Apomorphic (1) |
---|---|---|
Furrow between antennal socket and eye | absent | present |
Paraclypeal fovea | small to medium-sized | large and reaching eye border |
Mandible | without transverse carina | with distinct submedial transverse carina |
First flagellar segment | longer than second segment | equal to or shorter than second segment |
Notauli | complete | posterior half absent |
Scutellum | without depression posteriorly | with transverse depression posteriorly |
Pterostigma | very slender | secondary widened |
Vein r of fore wing originated | from the basal quarter of pterostigma | far from the base of pterostigma, arising near its middle |
Subbasal cell of hind wing distally | closed | open |
First subdiscal cell of fore wing distally | closed | open |
Vein 2-SR of fore wing | present | absent |
Hind wing cells | closed | open |
Fore femur | simple without tooth | with wide ventral tooth |
First tergite of metasoma | without dorsope | with dorsope |
Hypopygium of metasoma | not retracted anteriorly under posterior tergites | distinctly retracted anteriorly under posterior tergites |
Second tergite | smooth | sculptured |
Clypeus | not protruding | protruding |
Class Hexapoda Blainville, 1816
Order Hymenoptera Linnaeus, 1758
Family Braconidae Nees, 1811
Subfamily Alysiinae Leach, 1815
Tribe Alysiini Leach, 1815
Subtribe Aspilotina Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002
The relation between the diagnostic characters has allowed the construction of a cladogram of the relationships in the Aspilotina (Fig.
Orthostigma group contains three genera: Cubitalostigma Fischer, 1998, Neorthostigma Belokobylskij, 1998, and Orthostigma Ratzeburg, 1844. The latter is made up of four subgenera: Africostigma Fischer, 1995, Orthostigma Ratzeburg, 1844, sensu stricto, Patrisaspilota Fischer, 1995, and Whartonstigma Peris-Felipo, 2020. The distances between genera/subgenera generated from the multivariate statistical approach of the diagnostic characters are provided in Appendix
Aspilota group
Genus Apronopa van Achterberg, 1980
Genus Aspilota Foerster, 1863
subgenus Aspilota Foerster, 1863, sensu stricto
subgenus Eusynaldis Zaykov & Fischer, 1982 (= Regetus Papp, 1999; Adelphenaldis Fischer, 2003)
subgenus Grandilota Fischer, 2002, stat. nov.
Genus Dinostigma Fischer, 1966
Genus Dinotrema Foerster, 1863 (Syn.: Pterusa Fischer, 1958; Eudinostigma Tobias, 1986, syn. nov.)
subgenus Alitha Cameron, 1906, stat. nov. (= Carinthilota Fischer, 1975, syn. nov.)
subgenus Dinotrema Foerster, 1863, sensu stricto
subgenus Prosapha Foerster, 1863
subgenus Pseudoprosapha subgen. nov.
subgenus Synaldis Foerster, 1863
Genus Leptotrema van Achterberg, 1988
Genus Lysodinotrema Fischer, 1995
Genus Panerema Foerster, 1863
Genus Synaldotrema Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002, stat. nov.
Orthostigma group
Genus Cubitalostigma Fischer, 1998
Genus Neorthostigma Belokobylskij, 1998
Genus Orthostigma Ratzeburg, 1844
subgenus Africostigma Fischer, 1995
subgenus Orthostigma Ratzeburg, 1844, sensu stricto
subgenus Patrisaspilota Fischer, 1995
subgenus Whartonstigma Peris-Felipo, 2020
Aspilotina Belokobyskij and Tobias 2002: 2.
Morphological diagnosis. See
Apronopa
van Achterberg, 1980: 75;
Apronopa haeselbarthi van Achterberg, 1980, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Apronopa haeselbarthi) Germany: • ♀, Dransfeld, B/L 2.vi.1966 (Haeselbarth leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, robust, tridentate. Paraclypeal fovea short, remaining far from inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum without medio-posterior pit; notauli absent in posterior half of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus always present; propodeum smooth or with different types of sculpture and sometimes with longitudinal or transverse carinae. Marginal cell of fore wing never shortened; vein r originating approximately from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR always present and distinctly sclerotized; veins m-cu and cu-a distinctly postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by CU1a vein. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed laterally. First metasomal tergite without dorsope; second tergite often longitudinally striate medially. Ovipositor sheath not longer than metasoma.
This is a small genus with only three described species exclusively from the Palaearctic region (two of these species have an East Palaearctic distribution). Unfortunately, there is no data about its biology. Apronopa is characterised by three distinct diagnostic characters (
Aspilota
Foerster, 1863: 268;
Dipiesta
Foerster, 1863: 268 (synonymised with Aspilota Foerster by
Eusynaldis
Zaykov & Fischer, 1982: 70;
Regetus
Papp, 1999: 391;
Grandilota
Fischer, 2002: 103;
Adelphenaldis
Fischer, 2003: 41;
Alysia ruficornis Nees von Esenbeck, 1834, by monotypy.
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, often with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea large, reaching inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum with or without medio-posterior pit; notauli present only in anterior part of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus almost always present; propodeum smooth or more common with different types of sculpture and sometimes with longitudinal and/or transverse carinae, rarely forming areas. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR often present and usually distinctly sclerotised but absent in subgenus Eusynaldis; veins m-cu and cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by vein CU1a. In hind wing, subbasal cell usually closed. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed laterally; second tergite always smooth. Ovipositor sheath usually not longer than metasoma.
Members of the genus Aspilota are frequently encountered as they are one of the most common genera among Alysiini wasps. It is mainly distributed in forested and humid areas of the Holarctic region and only a few species have been already recorded from other zoogeographic regions. This genus is undersampled in the tropics where their main hosts (Phoridae) have the greatest diversity.
Aspilota species are koinobiont endoparasitoids of larvae, mainly of the family Phoridae (Diptera). Previous reports established Aspilota as parasitoid of the families Anthomyiidae, Lonchaeidae, Muscidae, Platypezidae, Sarcophagidae, Syrphidae, and Tephritidae. However, these hosts need to be especially reconfirmed. The records of lepidopterous and hymenopterous larvae as hosts (families Erebidae, Bucculatricidae, Lasiocampidae, and Tortricidae, and family Tenthredinidae, respectively) are extremely doubtful because the known biology and perhaps were concerned to the Phoridae living in dead larvae of the species from these families.
The genus Aspilota contains three subgenera, Aspilota sensu stricto, Eusynaldis Zaykov & Fischer, 1982, and Grandilota Fischer, 2002.
Aspilota
Foerster, 1863: 268;
Dipiesta Foerster, 1863: 265.
Alysia ruficornis Nees von Esenbeck, 1834, by monotypy.
Numerous species from the Palaearctic, Nearctic, and Neotropical regions were reviewed (e.g., Peris-Felipo and Belokobylskj 2014;
This largest and easily recognised subgenus includes most of Aspilota species. Pterusa ruficollis (Stelfox & Graham, 1950) is returned to Aspilota as A. ruficollis Stelfox & Graham, 1950, comb. nov. after the revision of type because the paraclypeal fovea are wide and reaching the inner margin of the eyes. Its new generic position is also supported by Fischer’s re-description of the species (
Eusynaldis
Zaykov & Fischer, 1982: 70;
Regetus
Papp, 1999: 391;
Adelphenaldis
Fischer, 2003: 41;
Eusynaldis varinervis Zaykov & Fischer, 1972, by monotypy (Figs
Holotype
Regetus balcanicus [= Aspilota (Eusynaldis) globipes] Former Yugoslavia: • ♀, Kosovo, Mts. Sar, Brezovica, 900–1200 m, 20–23.v.1971 (Papp & Hortatovich leg.) (
Subgenus Eusynaldis shares all diagnostic characters of Aspilota sensu stricto, except the absent vein 2-SR of the fore wing.
Regetus Papp, 1999 and Adelphenaldis Fischer, 2003 are junior synonyms of Eusynaldis Zaykov & Fischer, 1982 because both taxa are characterised by the same diagnostic features (
Grandilota
Fischer, 2002: 103;
Grandilota kenyaensis Fischer, 2002, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Grandilota kenyaensis). Kenya: • ♀, Mt. Elgon Natural Park, bamboo (Arundinaria alpine) thicket, 2740 m; swept. No. 496, 22.i.1992 (G. Varkonyl leg.) [Hym. Typ. No. Mus. Budapest 11673] (
Mandible well developed, tridentate, with upper (first) tooth diminished to respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea long, reaching inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum without mesoscutal pit; notauli present only in anterior half of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus present; propodeum with pentagonal areola, delineated by carinae. In fore wing, marginal cell reaching apex of wing; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR present and sclerotised; veins m-cu and cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell closed postero-apically by CU1a vein. In hind wing, subbasal cell open. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed laterally. Ovipositor sheath not longer than metasoma.
This subgenus has only one known species, Aspilota (Grandilota) kenyaensis Fischer, 2002, from Kenya and shares the main characters with Aspilota sensu stricto, however, the subbasal cell of the hind wing open distally (absent vein cu-a) and the wing membrane is pigmented, which distinguishes it at the subgeneric level.
Dinostigma
Fischer, 1966: 182;
Dinostigma muesebecki Fischer, 1966, by monotypy (Figs
Holotype
(Dinostigma muesebecki). United States Of America: • ♀, North East, Pa. [= Pennsylvania], No 9019, 6.vii.1912 (F. Johnson leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate. Paraclypeal fovea short, far from reaching inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum without mesoscutal pit; notauli present only in anterior part of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus absent; propodeum always smooth; spiracles of propodeum large. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR absent; vein cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell open distally (without vein 2-1A). Hind wing with all cells open. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed laterally. Ovipositor sheath shorter than metasoma.
After careful revision of former Dinostigma and Eudinostigma (as subgenus of Dinostigma) species, only the type species of this genus, Dinostigma muesebecki Fischer, 1966, is retained in Dinostigma. The species D. stenosoma (van Achterberg, 1988) is transferred to the genus Dinotrema as a type species of the new subgenus, Pseudoprosapha subgen. nov. (see below), because this species has the first subdiscal cell of fore wing closed, the pterostigma broad and wider than vein r length, and all cells of the hind wing closed (Dinotrema (P.) stenosoma (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov.).
This genus is very close to the Oriental-Afrotropical Lysodinotrema Fischer, 1995, because both of them share, among others, such main diagnostic characters as simple tridentate mandible, short paraclypeal fovea, and mesoscutum without medio-posterior pit. However, the lack of closed cells in the hind wing in Dinostigma (present in Lysodinotrema), absence of vein 2-SR (present in Lysodinotrema), and absence of the precoxal sulcus (present in Lysodinotrema) are sufficient to separate both as different genera.
Dinotrema
Foerster, 1863: 268;
Coloboma Foerster, 1863: 268.
Spanomeris Foerster, 1863: 268.
Synaldis
Foerster, 1863: 273;
Scotioneurus Provancher, 1886: 156.
Alitha
Cameron, 1906: 28;
Pterusa
Fischer, 1958: 14;
Aspilota
auct. p.p.
Carinthilota
Fischer, 1975: 311;
Eudinostigma
Tobias, 1986: 244;
Dinotrema erythropa Foerster, 1863, by monotypy.
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, often with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea short, not reaching more than half distance between clypeus and inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum with or without mesoscutal pit; notauli usually present only in anterior part of mesoscutum, although in some species of the subgenus Alitha it is rather well developed and reaching or almost reaching mesoscutal pit; precoxal sulcus usually present, propodeum with different types of sculpture and sometimes with longitudinal and/or transverse carinae, rarely entirely smooth. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR usually present and distinctly sclerotised or sometimes (subgenus Synaldis) absent or weakly developed and vein r not angled with vein 3-SR (
Dinotrema is the most complicated and largest genus within the tribe Alysiini with more than 440 known species, predominantly occurring in the temperate climatic regions (Peris-Felipo and Belokobyslkij 2018a). However, after studying a large amount of type material from different regions it should be possible to present a new generic classification, including the following subgenera: Alitha Cameron, 1906, stat. nov. (with Carinthilota Fischer as a new synonym), Dinotrema sensu stricto, Prosapha Foerster, 1863, Pseudoprosapha Peris-Felipo subgen. nov. and Synaldis Foerster, 1863 (with Eudinostigma Tobias as a new synonym).
A revision of Eudinostigma Tobias species was carried out for this reclassification. After careful study of the type species of Eudinostigma we consider it a synonym of Dinotrema. However, depending on the presence or absence of vein 2-SR of the fore wing, its species are divided between the subgenera Dinotrema and Synaldis. The main diagnostic characters of Eudinostigma are as follows: distinctly depressed head (resulting in antennal sockets situated at the upper level of eye and maximum width of head in dorsal view 1.6–2.4× width of mesoscutum), compressed mesosoma, and vein 2-SR of fore wing often absent (
The following species previously belonging to Eudinostigma are transfered to the subgenus Dinotrema sensu stricto: D. (D.) alox (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov.; D. (D.) entabeniense (Fischer, 2009), comb. nov.; D. (D.) latum (Chen & Wu, 1994), comb. nov.; D. (D.) planiceps (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov. and D. (D.) subpulvinatum (Fischer, 2009), comb. nov.. Moreover, four other Eudinostigma species are transferred to the subgenus Synaldis: D. (S.) bienesae (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov., D. (S.) fischeri (Tobias, 1986), comb. nov. (type species of Eudinostigma), D. (S.) latistigma (Fischer, 1962), comb. nov., and D. (S.) planiceps (Fischer, Tormos & Pardo, 2006), comb. nov.
Furthermore, after studying the types of Dinostigma and Eudinostigma species, we consider the features of Eudinostigma stenosoma van Achterberg, 1988 (see below) enough different to transfer it to a new subgenus Pseudoprosapha subgen. nov.: Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) stenosoma (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov.
In summary, five subgenera of the genus Dinotrema are recognised, Alitha Cameron, 1906, stat. nov., Dinotrema sensu stricto, Prosapha Foerster, 1863, Pseudoprosapha Peris-Felipo subgen. nov. and Synaldis Foerster, 1863.
Alitha
Cameron, 1906: 28;
Carinthilota Fischer, 1975, syn. nov.
Alitha longipennis Cameron, 1906, by monotypy (lost).
Holotype
(Carinthilota parapsidalis) (Figs
This subgenus has all main characters of Dinotrema sensu stricto but differs from it by having the notauli more or less complete posteriorly, reaching or almost reaching the mesoscutal pit.
Despite the loss of the type material of Alitha Cameron, 1906 described from South Africa (
The development of the notauli in Alitha species is highly variable: usually they are developed as rows of closely circular grooves more or less reaching the medio-posterior mesoscutal pit [Dinotrema (A.) longipennis (Cameron, 1906), comb. nov., D. (A.) parapsidalis (Fischer, 1975), comb. nov. and D. (A.) vechti (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov.] while the distal part of the notauli is more or less reduced in the two Eastern Palaearctic species [D. (A.) lada (Belokobylskij, 1998), comb. nov. and D. (A.) mavka (Belokobylskij, 1998), comb. nov.]. The variable development of the notauli supports our opinion that the presence of nearly complete notauli in several genera of Aspilota group (Dinotrema and Orthostigma) is an unsuitable generic character; at most it may be used provisionally at subgeneric level.
Dinotrema
Foerster, 1863: 268;
Pterusa
Fischer, 1958: 14;
Dinotrema erythropum Foerster, 1863, by original designation (Figs
(Dinotrema (Dinotrema) erythropum): England: • 1 female (paratype of Aspilota praecipua) and 1 male (paratype id.), Coll. Marshall Cornwall, Botusfleming (
The main diagnostic characters of this subgenus are the short paraclypeal fovea which remain far from the eye margins, the pterostigma very narrow (linear) and vein 2-SR of fore wing present and more or less completely sclerotised.
This is the largest subgenus including the main part of Dinotrema species with approx. 440 species described worldwide (Peris-Felipo and Belokobyslkij 2018a). As shown by
Prosapha
Foerster, 1863: 263;
Dinotrema (Prosapha)
Alysia speculum Haliday, 1838, by original designation (Figs
(Dinotrema (Prosapha) speculum): Austria: • ♂, Spitzzicken, Burgenland, 24.viii.1959 (Fischer leg.) (
This subgenus shares the main characters of Dinotrema sensu stricto but differs by having, in the fore wing, the maximum width of pterostigma wider than vein r (especially in males) and vein 2-SR of fore wing always present.
This subgenus includes five Palaearctic species: D. (P.) comptum Tobias, 2003, D. (P.) pachysemoides Tobias, 2003, D. (P.) speculum (Haliday, 1838), D. (P.) tobiasi (Fischer, 1994) and D. (P.) ussuricum Tobias, 2007. The status of Prosapha has been variable for a long time.
Eudinostigma stenosoma van Achterberg, 1988 (Figs
Holotype
(Eudinostigma stenosoma) Hungary: • ♂, Budapest, Biró, 21.ix.1927, “226” (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea short, length not more than half distance between clypeus and inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum without medio-posterior pit; notauli present only in anterior part of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus present; propodeum completely smooth. Marginal cell of fore wing never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of wide pterostigma; vein 2-SR absent; vein cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by vein CU1a. Hind wing with all cells closed. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed posteriorly. Ovipositor sheath not longer than metasoma.
This new subgenus includes only a single species, Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) stenosoma (van Achterberg, 1988), comb. nov.. This subgenus shares with Prosapha the comparatively broad pterostigma (viz., wider than the length of vein r) and in female vein r + 3-SR forming a (nearly) straight line but differs by the loss of vein 2-SR (present in Prosapha), the depressed head (antennal sockets situated near the upper level of the eyes), the strongly compressed mesosoma and the very narrow clypeus. These differences make it worth to name a different subgenus for it.
Synaldis
Foerster, 1863: 273;
Eudinostigma Tobias, 1986: 244, syn. nov.
Bassus concolor Nees, 1812, by original designation (lost) (Figs
Dinotrema (Synaldis) concolor: Austria: • ♀, Mischerdorf, Burgenland, 5.ix.1956 (Fischer leg.) (
The main characters of this subgenus are shared with Dinotrema sensu stricto, but it has vein 2-SR of fore wing absent.
The status of Synaldis has been uncertain for a long time.
Leptotrema
van Achterberg, 1988: 42;
Aspilota dentifemur Stelfox, 1943, by original designation (Figs
(Leptotrema dentifemur) Denmark: • ♀, Stegelykke VG, 8–15.vii.1991 (Munk leg.) (PFEC). The Netherlands: • ♀, Putten (Gld.), Malaise trap, 26.ix–2.x.1973 (J.v.d. Vecht leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, often with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea short, not reaching more than half distance between clypeus and inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum with or without mesoscutal pit; notauli usually present only in anterior part of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus usually present, propodeum with different types of sculpture and sometimes with longitudinal and/or transverse carinae, rarely entirely smooth. Fore femur has a distinct apomorphic character, viz., the presence of a large obtuse tooth (flange) or two or three small teeth. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR usually present and distinctly sclerotised; veins m-cu and cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by vein CU1a. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed laterally. Ovipositor sheath usually not longer than metasoma.
Only three rare Leptotrema species are known from the Palaearctic, Oriental and Australasian regions, L. bovefemora (Bhat, 1979), L. dentifemur (Stelfox, 1943) and L. wilhelmense Braet & van Achterberg, 2014.
Lysodinotrema
Fischer, 1995: 717;
Lysodinotrema madli Fischer, 1995, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Lysodinotrema madli) Madagascar: • ♀, Ste. Marie Flues Manandriana, 14–25.xi.1994 (Fischer leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate. Paraclypeal fovea short, remaining far from the inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum without mesoscutal pit; notauli present only in anterior half of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus present; propodeum mainly sculptured, without areola. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR present and sclerotised; veins m-cu and cu-a always postfurcal; first subdiscal cell completely open posteriorly and without vein 2-1A. Hind wing without closed cells. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed. Ovipositor sheath shorter than metasoma.
This rare genus, with only three described species from the tropical areas (L. madli Fischer, 1995, L. minimum Fischer, 2004, L. sarawakense Fischer, 1995), is considered to be related with Dinostigma Fischer, 1966, because of sharing the open first subdiscal cell in the fore wing. However, the combination of closed cells in the hind wing (absent in Dinostigma), presence of vein 2-SR of fore wing (absent in Dinostigma) and of the precoxal sulcus (absent in Dinostigma) makes it possible to maintain Lysodinotrema as a valid genus.
Panerema
Foerster, 1863: 263;
Panerema inops Foerster, 1863, by original designation (lost) (Figs
(Panerema inops): Germany: • ♀, Zaarensee, Seggenwiese, 29.vi.1998 (v. Broen leg.) (PFEC). The Netherlands: • ♀, Cadier, 5.v.1975 (B. v. Aartsen leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, often with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth. Paraclypeal fovea short, not reaching more than half distance between clypeus and inner margin of eyes. Third antennal segment distinctly elongated. Mesoscutum with or without mesoscutal pit; notauli usually present only in anterior part of mesoscutum. Scutellum with a transverse crenulate depression subposteriorly. Females are brachypterous with strongly reduced wings (commonly in this group of genera males are brachypterous but females macropterous). The preserved distal anterior veins in such wing are distinctly thickened, with veins r and 2-SR of the fore wing absent but hind wing with closed cells (
During many years, Panerema was considered as a valid genus (
Synaldotrema
Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002: 3 (as subgenus of Dinotrema Foerster);
Dinotrema (Synaldotrema) speciosum Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Dinotrema (Synaldotrema) speciosum) Russia: • ♀, Primorskiy kray, 10 km SSW of Partizansk, border of forest, 12–13.vii.1996 (S. Belokobylskij) (
Synaldotrema Belokobylskij & Tobias shares the main characters of Dinotrema sensu stricto but differs by having the hypopygium of the female strongly retracted under the posterior tergites of metasoma and the fourth tergite strongly elongated, ~ 2.5× longer than fifth tergite (vs approximately of equal length in Dinotrema s. str.).
The type species of Synaldotrema (D. speciosum Belokobylskij & Tobias, 2002) has a variable vein 2-SR of the fore wing. This vein is usually present, but sometimes, mostly discoloured and its posterior half or sometimes entire vein 2-SR is absent (
Cubitalostigma
Fischer, 1998: 482;
Cubitalostigma reichli Fischer, 1998, by monotypy (Figs
Holotype
(Cubitalostigma reichli) Indonesia: • ♀, Sumatra, Aceh, Gunung Leuser Nat. Pk., Ketambe Res. Sta., 1° rainforest, Mature forest, Terrace 4 closed canopy, 400 m, 3°41'N, 97°29'E, Malaise trap W/pans, 1–30.xi.1989 (D.C. Darling leg.) (
Mandible small, simple, tridentate, with upper (first) tooth diminished with respect to lower (third) tooth, with complete submedial transverse curved carina. Paraclypeal fovea short, remaining far removed from edge of eyes. Mesoscutum without mesoscutal pit; notauli present only in anterior part of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus always absent; propodeum smooth. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from almost middle of pterostigma; first submarginal cell very reduced; second submarginal cell widened; vein 2-SR present and well sclerotised; first subdiscal cell closed postero-apically by CU1a vein. Subbasal cell of hind wing minute but closed. Metasoma of ♀ distinctly compressed laterally. Ovipositor sheath shorter than metasoma.
This is a peculiar monotypic genus with only the type species known from Indonesia. Cubitalostigma is characterised by the very aberrant venation of the fore wing, with vein r arising almost from the middle of the very narrow pterostigma, very far from its basal part. This is a unique character within the subtribe Aspilotina.
Neorthostigma
Belokobylskij, 1998b: 9;
Neorthostigma eoum Belokobylskij, 1998 (= Aspilota macrops Stelfox & Graham, 1951), by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Aspilota macrops) Ireland: • ♀, Sligo, S. shore of Lough Gill near Doonee Rock, 15.x.1937 (AWS leg.) [USNM #76022; USNMENT01569377] (
Norway: • 1 ♀, Oslo [AK], Maridalen, Dausjøen, Spruce forest, 5.vi–16.x.2010, 60.01234 N 10.787665 E, 160 m, Malaise trap, river outlet (Lars Ove Hansen leg.) (NHMO). Russia. Leningradskaya Province: • 1 ♀, Tolmachevo, mixed forest, 22.viii.1960 (V. Tobias leg), “Aspilota macrops Stelf., Tobias det. 1961” (
Mandible small, tridentate, with very small and screwed upper tooth, with complete transverse and curved submedian carina. Paraclypeal fovea long, reaching or almost reaching inner margin of eyes. Mesoscutum always without mesoscutal pit; notauli present only in anterior half of mesoscutum; precoxal sulcus always developed; propodeum with wide and rather distinctly delineated by carina areola and with different types of sculpture but sometimes almost smooth. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR always developed; veins m-cu and cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by vein CU1a. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly compressed. Ovipositor sheath shorter than metasoma.
Five described species are known: one from the Palaearctic region (widely distributed from Ireland to Japan), two from Papua New Guinea (
Orthostigma
Ratzeburg, 1844: 53;
Africostigma
Fischer, 1995: 677 (as subgenus of Orthostigma);
Patrisaspilota
Fischer, 1995: 721;
Whartonstigma
Peris-Felipo in
Aphidius flavipes Ratzeburg, 1844: 71, by monotypy.
Delocarpa Foerster, 1863; Ischnocarpa Foerster, 1863; Patrisaspilota Fischer, 1995; Africostigma Fischer, 1995; Whartonstigma Peris-Felipo, 2020.
Mandible small, tridentate and with a wide ventral lobe as third tooth, with complete submedial transverse curved carina. Paraclypeal fovea short, far distant from inner margin of eyes. First flagellar segment usually longer or sometimes as long as second flagellar segment (slightly shorter in subgenus Africostigma). Mesoscutum usually with mesoscutal pit; notauli often present only in anterior part of mesoscutum, but in subgenus Patrisaspilota notauli almost reaching mesoscutal pit; precoxal sulcus always present; propodeum usually with different types of sculpture and sometimes with longitudinal or transverse carinae, rarely almost smooth. In fore wing, marginal cell never shortened; vein r originating from basal quarter of pterostigma; vein 2-SR usually distinctly sclerotised (but absent in subgenus Whartonstigma); veins m-cu and cu-a postfurcal; first subdiscal cell always closed postero-apically by vein CU1a. Metasoma of ♀ more or less distinctly laterally compressed. Ovipositor sheath usually not longer than metasoma.
This genus includes more than 60 described species and is easily separated from other genera in the Aspilota group by the presence of the peculiar structure of mandible with complete transverse and curved submedial carina and usually wide lobe-shaped third tooth.
Currently four subgenera are recognised within this genus, Africostigma Fischer, 1995, Orthostigma sensu stricto, Patrisaspilota Fischer, 1995, and Whartonstigma Peris-Felipo, 2020 (
Africostigma
Fischer, 1995: 677 (as subgenus of Orthostigma);
Orthostigma (Africostigma) karkloofense Fischer, 1995, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Orthostigma (Africostigma) karkloofense) South Africa: • ♀, Howick, Natal, Karkloof Forest, 19.ix.1963 (Haeselbarth leg.) (
This Afrotropical subgenus includes two species from South Africa and shares the main diagnostic characters with Orthostigma but differs from all other subgenera by having the first flagellar segment of antenna shorter than the second one.
Orthostigma
Ratzeburg, 1844: 53;
Aphidius flavipes Ratzebrug, 1844, by monotypy.
Several species from Palaearctic region were studied. For example:
– Orthostigma beyarslani Fischer, 1995: Spain: • ♀, Alicante, Torrevieja, Natural Park of Lagunas de la Mata-Torrevieja, 25.v.2004 (ENV).
– Orthostigma laticeps (Thompson, 1895): Spain: • ♀, Alicante, Alcoi, Natural Park of Carrascal de La Font Roja, 20.v.2004 (ENV).
– Orthostigma maculipes (Haliday, 1838): Spain: • ♀, Castellon, Pobla de Benifassà, Natural Park of Tinença de Benifassà, 26.ix.2005 (ENV).
– Orthostigma mandibulare Tobias, 1962: Russia: Holotype: • ♀, Leningradskaya oblast’. Tolmachevo, border of forest near floodplain of Ostrovenka River, 19.viii.1960, Tobias [leg] (
– Orthostigma pumilum (Nees, 1834): Spain: • ♀, Castellon, Pobla de Benifassà, Natural Park of Tinença de Benifassà, 17.vi.2004 (ENV).
– Orthostigma sculpturatum (Tobias, 1962): Spain: • ♀, Castellon, Pobla de Benifassà, Natural Park of Tinença de Benifassà, 28.viii.2006 (ENV).
Main characters for the subgenus Orthostigma are the long first flagellar segment (longer than second segment), the notauli only anteriorly present on the mesoscutum and fore wing with vein 2-SR present and more or less distinctly sclerotised.
This is the largest subgenus with about 60 known species from the Holarctic, Oriental, and Australasian regions.
Patrisaspilota
Fischer, 1995: 721; Fischer, 2002: 102; 2004: 78; 2010: 636;
Patrisaspilota memoranda Fischer, 1995 (= Orthostigma multicarinatum Tobias, 1990) by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) multicarinatum) Vietnam: • ♀, Bathuok, 125 km W of Thanh Hoa, prov. Thanh Hoa, 26.i.1989 (B. Korotyaev leg.) (
This subgenus shares the main characters of Orthostigma but has the notauli almost reaching the mesoscutal pit.
The four Oriental species of this subgenus share the almost completely developed notauli as in Dinotrema (Alitha). The notauli consist of a row of closely located large points more or less reaching the mesoscutal pit. The presence of such type of notauli in different genera of the subtribe Aspilotina (Orthostigma and Dinotrema) is obviously a parallelism and perhaps indicates the limited value of the character, viz., at least as subgeneric character.
Whartonstigma Peris-Felipo in Peris-Felipo & Belokobylskij, 2020: 412 (as subgenus of Orthostigma).
Orthostigma gallowagi Wharton, 2002, by original designation (Figs
Holotype
(Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) gallowagi): Australia: • ♀, Queensland, Wongabel S. F., 6 km S of Atherton, 12.xi–1.xii.1983, Storey and Brown. M.T. (
Very similar to the subgenus Orthostigma sensu stricto but differs from it by the absence of vein 2-SR of the fore wing.
This recently described subgenus includes four species from Australia and Papua New Guinea (
1 | First metasomal tergite without dorsope. Second metasomal tergite sculptured medio-basally (except in A. levis) (Fig. |
Apronopa |
– | First metasomal tergite always with dorsope. Second metasomal tergite always completely smooth (Fig. |
2 |
2(1) | Mandible with distinct and curved transverse carina. Third tooth usually widest and often lobe-shaped (Fig. |
[Orthostigma group] 3 |
– | Mandible without curved transverse carina. Third tooth usually narrow and not lobe-shaped (Fig. |
[Aspilota group] 8 |
3(2) | Vein r of fore wing originating far from base of pterostigma (Fig. |
Cubitalostigma |
– | Vein r of fore wing originating near base of pterostigma (Fig. |
3 |
4(3) | Paraclypeal fovea large and reaching or almost reaching inner border of eye (Fig. |
Neorthostigma |
– | Paraclypeal fovea smaller, reaching at most halfway distance between clypeus and eye (Fig. |
[Orthostigma] 5 |
5(4) | First flagellar segment shorter than second flagellar segment (Fig. |
Orthostigma (Africostigma) |
– | First flagellar segment either as long as or longer than second flagellar segment (Fig. |
6 |
6(5) | Notauli present posteriorly and reaching mesoscutal pit (Fig. |
Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) |
– | Notauli absent in posterior half of mesoscutum (Fig. |
7 |
7(6) | Vein 2-SR present (Fig. |
Orthostigma (Orthostigma) |
– | Vein 2-SR absent (Fig. |
Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) |
8(2) | Paraclypeal fovea enlarged and reaching inner border of eye (Fig. |
[Aspilota] 9 |
– | Paraclypeal fovea short, at most halfway distance between clypeus and inner border of eye (Fig. |
11 |
9(8) | Notauli complete and well developed in posterior half of mesoscutum, reaching to mesoscutal pit (Fig. |
Aspilota (Alitha) |
– | Notauli absent in posterior half of mesoscutum (Fig. |
10 |
10(9) | Vein 2-SR of fore wing present (Fig. |
Aspilota (Aspilota) |
– | Vein 2-SR of fore wing absent (Fig. |
Aspilota (Eusynaldis) |
11(8) | Subdiscal cell of fore wing open posteriorly (Fig. |
12 |
– | Subdiscal cell of fore wing completely closed posteriorly (Fig. |
13 |
12(11) | Vein 2-SR of fore wing present (Fig. |
Lysodinotrema |
– | Vein 2-SR of fore wing absent (Fig. |
Dinostigma |
13(11) | Fore femur with wide and obtuse ventral tooth (Fig. |
Leptotrema |
– | Fore femur usual, without ventral teeth (Fig. |
14 |
14(13) | Metasoma with strongly retracted apical sternites under dorsal distally elongated tergites (Fig. |
Synaldotrema |
– | Metasoma without strongly retracted apical sternites under distal tergites (Fig. |
15 |
15(14) | Scutellum with transverse crenulate depression subposteriorly (Fig. |
Panerema |
– | Scutellum without transverse crenulate depression subposteriorly (Fig. |
[Dinotrema]. 16 |
16(15) | Pterostigma of fore wing narrow, its maximum width less than length of vein r (Fig. |
17 |
– | Pterostigma of fore wing broad (especially in male), its maximum width larger than length of vein r (Fig. |
18 |
17(16) | Vein 2-SR of fore wing present (Fig. |
Dinotrema (Dinotrema) |
– | Vein 2-SR of fore wing absent (Fig. |
Dinotrema (Synaldis) |
18(16) | Vein 2-SR of fore wing present (Fig. |
Dinotrema (Prosapha) |
– | Vein 2-SR of fore wing absent (Fig. |
Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) |
Fore wing and mesosoma A vein 2-SR of fore wing present and hind wing with closed cells [Lysodinotrema madli Fischer, 1995] B vein 2-SR of fore wing absent and hind wing without closed cells [Dinostigma muesebecki Fischer, 1966] C precoxal sulcus present [Lysodinotrema madli Fischer, 1995] D precoxal sulcus absent [Dinostigma muesebecki Fischer, 1966].
The alysiine belonging to the subtribe Aspilotina are a relatively homogeneous group of taxa with only a few available diagnostic characters for the determination of its genera and subgenera. This taxonomic group is characterised by several homoplesian features, which are developed parallel in different genera. The most important for identification of the generic diagnostic characters is the state of mandible (with or without a curved transverse carina): it is the most important character to separate Orthostigma and Neorthostigma from the other alysiine genera. The complete reduction of the vein 2-SR is an appreciable evolutionary event which is connected with the disappearance of the break (angle) between the veins r and 3-SR, and the connection between both veins is only gently curved or almost straight. In most cases it is distinct character state and useful for separation at least of subgenera (
In the hind wing, sclerotised veins usually close the basal and subbasal cells. However, as an exception, there are species with no closed cells in the monotypic Nearctic genus Dinostigma (in the modern sense), Lysodinotrema and some very derived small species of the genus Dinotrema. Besides the wing venation characters, some other valuable features are found on the mesosoma. For example, the notauli are predominantly developed in the anterior subvertical third of the mesoscutum and absent in its posterior horizontal part, except in the subgenera Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) and Dinotrema (Alitha), where they are complete or nearly so and rather well developed dorso-posteriorly. In addition to these characters, the variation of the propodeal sculpture from entirely smooth or smooth with delineated basolateral areas and often a large areola to entirely finely or coarsely rugose-reticulate and sometimes also with more or less visible delineated areola, shows a considerable intraspecific variation.
Hopefully, the revised classification for the subtribe Aspilotina presented in the current work will facilitate the identification of the genera and subgenera and will allow a better understanding of the character variability in this very complicate and speciose group of genera. Further revisions of this subtribe with use of molecular data will allow for a better insight in each of the genera and subgenera.
We are very thankful to Dominique Zimmermann and Manuela Vizek from Naturhistorisches Museum (Vienna, Austria), Gavin Broad from the Natural History Museum (London, UK), Frederique Bakker from Naturalis Biodiversity Center (Leiden, Netherlands), Zoltán Vas from the Hungarian Natural History Museum (Budapest, Hungary), Claire Villemant from Museum National d’Histoire Naturelle (Paris, France), Robert Kula from Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History (Washington, USA), late Stefan Schmidt from Zoologische Staatssammlung München (München, Germany) and Viola Richter from Museum für Naturkunde (Berlin, Germany) for providing us with type material for this study. Also, we want to thank Seraina Klopfstein, Mirjam Luzzi Conti and Matthias Borer, Naturhistorisches Museum Basel, Switzerland, for their kindness and help during our work with the photosystem.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This work was in part funded by grants given by the Russian State Research Project No. 125012901042-9 for SAB.
All authors have contributed equally.
Francisco Javier Peris-Felipo https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9929-3277
Fernando Santa https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6309-2908
Cornelis van Achterberg https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6495-4853
Sergey A. Belokobylskij https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3646-3459
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.
The distances between genera/subgenera generated from the multivariate statistical approach of the diagnostic characters.
Group | Genus/subgenus | Apronopa | Aspilota (Aspilota) | Aspilota (Eusynaldis) | Aspilota (Grandilota) | Dinostigma |
Aspilota | Apronopa | 0 | 1.750 | 1.800 | 1.836 | 2.347 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Aspilota) | 1.750 | 0 | 0.347 | 0.416 | 1.764 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Eusynaldis) | 1.800 | 0.347 | 0 | 0.565 | 1.680 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Grandilota) | 1.836 | 0.416 | 0.565 | 0 | 1.638 |
Aspilota | Dinostigma | 2.347 | 1.764 | 1.68 | 1.638 | 0 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Alitha) | 1.470 | 0.759 | 0.873 | 0.917 | 1.768 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Dinotrema) | 1.642 | 0.459 | 0.54 | 0.667 | 1.626 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Prosapha) | 1.742 | 0.729 | 0.679 | 0.942 | 1.425 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) | 1.844 | 0.917 | 0.729 | 1.106 | 1.389 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Synaldis) | 1.706 | 0.608 | 0.459 | 0.794 | 1.547 |
Aspilota | Leptotrema | 1.982 | 1.211 | 1.294 | 1.333 | 1.987 |
Aspilota | Lysodinotrema | 1.895 | 0.994 | 1.087 | 0.758 | 1.194 |
Aspilota | Panerema | 2.035 | 1.295 | 1.122 | 1.419 | 1.907 |
Aspilota | Synaldotrema | 1.982 | 1.211 | 1.294 | 1.333 | 1.987 |
Orthostigma | Cubitalostigma | 2.239 | 1.599 | 1.472 | 1.462 | 1.958 |
Orthostigma | Neorthostigma | 2.244 | 1.352 | 1.398 | 1.459 | 2.234 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Africostigma) | 2.172 | 1.500 | 1.557 | 1.595 | 2.179 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Orthostigma) | 1.879 | 1.033 | 1.074 | 1.167 | 1.856 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) | 1.762 | 1.242 | 1.317 | 1.367 | 2.009 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) | 1.933 | 1.105 | 1.033 | 1.242 | 1.785 |
Group | Genus/subgenus | Dinotrema (Alitha) | Dinotrema (Dinotrema) | Dinotrema (Prosapha) | Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) | Dinotrema (Synaldis) |
Aspilota | Apronopa | 1.470 | 1.642 | 1.742 | 1.844 | 1.706 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Aspilota) | 0.759 | 0.459 | 0.729 | 0.917 | 0.608 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Eusynaldis) | 0.873 | 0.540 | 0.679 | 0.729 | 0.459 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Grandilota) | 0.917 | 0.667 | 0.942 | 1.106 | 0.794 |
Aspilota | Dinostigma | 1.768 | 1.626 | 1.425 | 1.389 | 1.547 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Alitha) | 0 | 0.483 | 0.747 | 0.967 | 0.678 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Dinotrema) | 0.483 | 0 | 0.502 | 0.723 | 0.347 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Prosapha) | 0.747 | 0.502 | 0 | 0.347 | 0.47 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) | 0.967 | 0.723 | 0.347 | 0 | 0.502 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Synaldis) | 0.678 | 0.347 | 0.470 | 0.502 | 0 |
Aspilota | Leptotrema | 1.218 | 1.021 | 1.173 | 1.331 | 1.135 |
Aspilota | Lysodinotrema | 0.998 | 0.878 | 1.082 | 1.247 | 1.002 |
Aspilota | Panerema | 1.313 | 1.140 | 1.331 | 1.243 | 0.96 |
Aspilota | Synaldotrema | 1.218 | 1.021 | 1.173 | 1.331 | 1.135 |
Orthostigma | Cubitalostigma | 1.63 | 1.484 | 1.617 | 1.553 | 1.36 |
Orthostigma | Neorthostigma | 1.646 | 1.501 | 1.63 | 1.724 | 1.555 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Africostigma) | 1.546 | 1.37 | 1.497 | 1.614 | 1.446 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Orthostigma) | 0.909 | 0.839 | 1.017 | 1.145 | 0.911 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) | 0.839 | 1.024 | 1.205 | 1.354 | 1.131 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) | 1.023 | 0.905 | 0.999 | 1.017 | 0.839 |
Group | Genus/subgenus | Leptotrema | Lysodinotrema | Panerema | Synaldotrema | Cubitalostigma |
Aspilota | Apronopa | 1.982 | 1.895 | 2.035 | 1.982 | 2.239 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Aspilota) | 1.211 | 0.994 | 1.295 | 1.211 | 1.599 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Eusynaldis) | 1.294 | 1.087 | 1.122 | 1.294 | 1.472 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Grandilota) | 1.333 | 0.758 | 1.419 | 1.333 | 1.462 |
Aspilota | Dinostigma | 1.987 | 1.194 | 1.907 | 1.987 | 1.958 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Alitha) | 1.218 | 0.998 | 1.313 | 1.218 | 1.630 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Dinotrema) | 1.021 | 0.878 | 1.140 | 1.021 | 1.484 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Prosapha) | 1.173 | 1.082 | 1.331 | 1.173 | 1.617 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) | 1.331 | 1.247 | 1.243 | 1.331 | 1.553 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Synaldis) | 1.135 | 1.002 | 0.960 | 1.135 | 1.360 |
Aspilota | Leptotrema | 0 | 1.378 | 1.592 | 1.529 | 1.848 |
Aspilota | Lysodinotrema | 1.378 | 0 | 1.465 | 1.378 | 1.528 |
Aspilota | Panerema | 1.592 | 1.465 | 0 | 1.592 | 1.790 |
Aspilota | Synaldotrema | 1.529 | 1.378 | 1.592 | 0 | 1.848 |
Orthostigma | Cubitalostigma | 1.848 | 1.528 | 1.790 | 1.848 | 0 |
Orthostigma | Neorthostigma | 1.85 | 1.773 | 1.926 | 1.850 | 1.885 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Africostigma) | 1.771 | 1.648 | 1.836 | 1.771 | 1.793 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Orthostigma) | 1.365 | 1.249 | 1.445 | 1.365 | 1.367 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) | 1.553 | 1.376 | 1.620 | 1.553 | 1.561 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) | 1.450 | 1.337 | 1.306 | 1.450 | 1.230 |
Group | Genus/subgenus | Neorthostigma | Orthostigma (Africostigma) | Orthostigma (Orthostigma) | Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) | Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) |
Aspilota | Apronopa | 2.244 | 2.172 | 1.879 | 1.762 | 1.933 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Aspilota) | 1.352 | 1.5 | 1.033 | 1.242 | 1.105 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Eusynaldis) | 1.398 | 1.557 | 1.074 | 1.317 | 1.033 |
Aspilota | Aspilota (Grandilota) | 1.459 | 1.595 | 1.167 | 1.367 | 1.242 |
Aspilota | Dinostigma | 2.234 | 2.179 | 1.856 | 2.009 | 1.785 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Alitha) | 1.646 | 1.546 | 0.909 | 0.839 | 1.023 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Dinotrema) | 1.501 | 1.37 | 0.839 | 1.024 | 0.905 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Prosapha) | 1.63 | 1.497 | 1.017 | 1.205 | 0.999 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Pseudoprosapha) | 1.724 | 1.614 | 1.145 | 1.354 | 1.017 |
Aspilota | Dinotrema (Synaldis) | 1.555 | 1.446 | 0.911 | 1.131 | 0.839 |
Aspilota | Leptotrema | 1.85 | 1.771 | 1.365 | 1.553 | 1.45 |
Aspilota | Lysodinotrema | 1.773 | 1.648 | 1.249 | 1.376 | 1.337 |
Aspilota | Panerema | 1.926 | 1.836 | 1.445 | 1.62 | 1.306 |
Aspilota | Synaldotrema | 1.85 | 1.771 | 1.365 | 1.553 | 1.45 |
Orthostigma | Cubitalostigma | 1.885 | 1.793 | 1.367 | 1.561 | 1.23 |
Orthostigma | Neorthostigma | 0 | 1.63 | 1.126 | 1.354 | 1.194 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Africostigma) | 1.63 | 0 | 0.972 | 1.252 | 1.074 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Orthostigma) | 1.126 | 0.972 | 0 | 0.483 | 0.347 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Patrisaspilota) | 1.354 | 1.252 | 0.483 | 0 | 0.678 |
Orthostigma | Orthostigma (Whartonstigma) | 1.194 | 1.074 | 0.347 | 0.678 | 0 |