Research Article |
Corresponding author: Ernesto Rázuri-Gonzales ( ernesto.razuri-gonzales@senckenberg.de ) Academic editor: Simon Vitecek
© 2024 Ernesto Rázuri-Gonzales, Wolfram Graf, Jacqueline Heckenhauer, Julio V. Schneider, Steffen U. Pauls.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Rázuri-Gonzales E, Graf W, Heckenhauer J, Schneider JV, Pauls SU (2024) A new species of Rhyacophila Pictet, 1834 (Trichoptera, Rhyacophilidae) from Corsica with the genomic characterization of the holotype. ZooKeys 1218: 295-314. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1218.132275
|
We describe a new species in the Rhyacophila tristis group, Rhyacophila lignumvallis Graf & Rázuri-Gonzales, sp. nov., from the island of Corsica (France) based on a single male specimen. In addition to the morphological differences between the new species and the most similar species in the group, we also provide a phylogenetic tree based on the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (mtCOI), including sequences from 16 out of the 28 currently recognized species in the group. These data, together with conspecific larval sequences, support the status of the new species and shed light on an additional potential new species near Rhyacophila pubescens. Using a low-cost next-generation sequencing approach, we generated the mito- and draft nuclear genome assembly of the holotype of R. lignumvallis sp. nov. as well as that of R. tsurakiana. This genetic data represents an important additional characterization to the description of morphological features and is valuable for future investigations, such as population or phylogenomic studies.
Caddisflies, holotype genomics, mitogenome, taxonomy
The genus Rhyacophila
One of the groups proposed by Schmid is the Rhyacophila tristis group in the R. invaria branch. It is mainly characterized by a large segment IX without an apical dorsal lobe, a simple and oblique segment X, with fairly large anal sclerites, which can be joined or partially fused to each other and fused to segment X, very large phallotheca with a simple or complex dorsal arm, a simple chitinous aedeagus, simple lobe-like parameres, and lacking a ventral lobe, among other characteristics (
Only two species in the R. tristis group were previously known on the island of Corsica (France): R. pubescens Pictet, 1834 and R. tristis Pictet, 1834. Both species were initially recorded by
In the present paper, we confirm the genetic and morphological distinctness of adult males of the Corsican lineage to represent a new species and describe it as Rhyacophila lignumvallis sp. nov. in the pubescens subgroup of the R. tristis group. Additionally, we present an annotated draft genome from the holotype and its complete mitogenome, adding valuable genetic information to the holotype description. Finally, we also include a draft genome and the mitogenome for a second species in the Rhyacophila tristis species group, R. tsurakiana Malicky, 1984 from Albania. We hope these genomic resources stimulate research on this group of insects, especially since their diversity is high in this area and they seem to be restricted to specific mountain ranges, as suggested by
The specimen was swept from the riparian vegetation using a hand net.
A pair of legs from the holotype of R. lignumvallis sp. nov. were removed, and the tissue was incubated overnight in 60 µl TNES lysis buffer (100 mM Tris-HCl, 25 mM NaCl, 10 mM EDTA, 1% SDS) and 8 µl Proteinase K (20 mg/ml). For DNA binding and cleanup, 75 µl custom speed-bead suspension was added (Sera-Mag SpeedBeads Carboxylate, hydrophobic, Cytiva; see
DNA sequences were generated for the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I barcoding region (mtCOI, 658 bp) using primers LCO1490-L and HCO2198-L (
Genomic DNA was taken from the above DNA isolates, quantified using a Qubit 4.0 fluorometer with a 1x dsDNA HS Assay Kit (ThermoFisher Scientific, Waltham, USA), and sheared to a target fragment size of 350 bp using a Bioruptor Pico (Diagenode, Seraing, Belgium). Genomic libraries were prepared from 27.4 ng sheared gDNA using the NEBNext Ultra II DNA Library Preparation Kit for Illumina (New England Biolabs, Ipswich, MA, USA), following the manufacturer’s manual. Adapters were diluted 1:10 as recommended for low input libraries, and size selection was omitted due to the low DNA amount. A dual indexing PCR was run for 7 cycles on a Mastercycler (Eppendorf, Germany) using NEBNext Multiplex Oligos for Illumina (Dual Index Primers Set 1; New England Biolabs, Ipswich, MA, USA). After cleanup, library integrity was verified on a 2200 TapeStation with a High Sensitivity D1000 Tape (Agilent, Santa Clara, CA, USA), and shipped for 150 bp paired-end sequencing (ordering 30 Gbp output) on a partial lane of an Illumina NovaSeq 6000 platform (San Diego, CA) at Novogene (Cambridge, UK).
Raw reads are deposited in the National Center for Biotechnology Information’s Sequence Read Archive (NCBI SRA) under the accession number SRR22799047 under Bioproject PRJNA899095.
The final mtCOI alignment included 71 sequences: 68 sequences from 16 species and 2 morphospecies in the Rhyacophila tristis group. Rhyacophila italica Moretti, 1981, Himalopsyche kuldschensis (Ulmer, 1927), and H. triloba (Hwang, 1958) were included as outgroups. All sequences were generated for this manuscript, except R. bosnica Schmid, 1970 (MK211322), H. kuldschensis (KX143534), and H. triloba (KX295339), which were retrieved from GenBank. The barcode region is 658 bp in length. However, some of our sequences were incomplete, and their lengths were between 576 and 658 bp. Therefore, the final alignment was completed with Ns on both ends, reaching 3.69% of missing data. Sequence specimen data and GenBank accession numbers are summarized in Table
Sequence specimen data, with GenBank accession numbers, of the studied Rhyacophila species and the outgroups Himalopsyche kuldschensis (Ulmer, 1927) and H. triloba (Hwang, 1958).
Species | Country* | Locality | Latitude, Longitude | Accession No. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Himalopsyche kuldschensis | KG | Kalay Makhmud valley between Or-Mazan-Suu and Ala Malden | 39.683, 70.8833 | KX143534 |
Himalopsyche triloba | CN | Sichuan, near Jiuzhaigou | 30.45, 102.50 | KX295339 |
R. akutila | BG | Prava Marica stream at Zavracica mountain hut | 42.16789, 23.64139 | PP515197 |
R. aquitanica | FR | Ruisseau de Chousse, upper tributary; between Arrette & La Pierre Saint-Martin | 43.00757, -0.73572 | PP515198 |
R. aquitanica | FR | Ruisseau de Chousse, upper tributary; between Arrette & La Pierre Saint-Martin | 43.00757, -0.73572 | PP515199 |
R. aquitanica | FR | Ruisseau de Chousse, upper tributary; between Arrette & La Pierre Saint-Martin | 43.00757, -0.73572 | PP515200 |
R. aquitanica | FR | Ruisseau de Chousse, upper tributary; between Arrette & La Pierre Saint-Martin | 43.00757, -0.73572 | PP515201 |
R. aquitanica | ES | tributaries to the Barranco de Urdiceto, above Embalse de Urdiceto | 42.67832, -0.2772 | PP515202 |
R. bosnica | BA | Vareš municipality, Rajčevački stream | – | MK211322 |
R. carpathica | RO | Galeş Lake | 45.38650, 22.90914 | PP515204 |
R. carpathica | RO | Galeş Lake | 45.38650, 22.90914 | PP515205 |
R. carpathica | RO | Galeş Lake | 45.38650, 22.90914 | PP515206 |
R. carpathica | RO | Galeş Lake | 45.38650, 22.90914 | PP515207 |
R. carpathica | RO | Caraş-Severin, Iauna Mare stream | 45.51636, 22.59017 | PP515208 |
R. carpathica | RO | Caraş-Severin, Poiana Mărului | 45.39583, 22.53422 | PP515209 |
R. cibinensis | RO | unnamed stream near Păltiniş | 45.63878, 23.92540 | PP515210 |
R. cibinensis | RO | unnamed stream near Păltiniş | 45.63878, 23.92540 | PP515211 |
R. cibinensis | RO | unnamed stream near Păltiniş | 45.63878, 23.92540 | PP515212 |
R. cibinensis | RO | Lotru river | 45.38, 23.62 | PP515213 |
R. italica | IT | Purello | 43.32, 12.77 | PP515214 |
R. lignumvallis sp. nov. | FR | Corsica, Tributary to the Tavignano | 42.25639, 9.20583 | PP515216 |
R. lignumvallis sp. nov. | FR | Corsica, Tributary to the Tavignano | 42.25639, 9.20583 | PP515217 |
R. lignumvallis sp. nov. | FR | Corsica, Tributary to the Tavignano | 42.25639, 9.20583 | PP515218 |
R. lignumvallis sp. nov. | FR | Corsica, bridge over the river Vecchio near the confluence with the river Tavignano | 42.2275, 9.24306 | PP515215 |
R. margaritae | BG | Lower left tributary to Zavodna, above Ribaritsa village and below Vezhen peak | 42.76, 24.37 | PP515219 |
R. margaritae | BG | Lower left tributary to Zavodna, above Ribaritsa village and below Vezhen peak | 42.76, 24.37 | PP515220 |
R. margaritae | BG | Lower left tributary to Zavodna, above Ribaritsa village and below Vezhen peak | 42.76, 24.37 | PP515221 |
R. obtusa | BG | Zavodna river, upstream of the confluence with the Beli Vit at the Ribaritsa village | 42.812, 24.371 | PP515222 |
R. obtusa | BG | Zavodna river, upstream of the confluence with the Beli Vit at the Ribaritsa village | 42.791, 24.377 | PP515223 |
R. orghidani | RO | right-side inflow of Leşu artificial lake | 46.80981, 22.58948 | PP515224 |
R. orghidani | RO | right-side inflow of Leşu artificial lake | 46.80981, 22.58948 | PP515225 |
R. orghidani | RO | Băişoara | 46.53287, 23.28078 | PP515226 |
R. orghidani | RO | Băişoara | 46.53287, 23.28078 | PP515227 |
R. pirinica | BG | 24.5 km NNW from Gotse Delchev | 41.63156, 23.44628 | PP515228 |
R. pirinica | BG | 24.5 km NNW from Gotse Delchev | 41.63156, 23.44628 | PP515229 |
R. pirinica | BG | 24.5 km NNW from Gotse Delchev | 41.63156, 23.44628 | PP515230 |
R. producta | AT | Nockberge | 46.85, 13.76 | PP515231 |
R. producta | AT | Nockberge | 46.85, 13.76 | PP515232 |
R. pubescens | CH | La Motte above Ocourt | 47.35, 7.06 | PP515233 |
R. pubescens | CH | La Motte above Ocourt | 47.35, 7.06 | PP515234 |
R. pubescens | FR | Ravin de Chambiéres | 43.93278, 6.63694 | PP515235 |
R. pubescens | FR | Ravin de Chambiéres | 43.93278, 6.63694 | PP515236 |
R. pubescens | FR | La Condamine-Châtelard | 44.451, 6.741 | PP515237 |
R. pubescens | FR | La Condamine-Châtelard | 44.451, 6.741 | PP515238 |
R. pubescens | FR | La Condamine-Châtelard | 44.451, 6.741 | PP515239 |
R. pubescens | IT | Tributary of Fiume Tescio | 43.09722, 12.67556 | PP515240 |
R. pubescens | IT | Tributary of Fiume Tescio | 43.09722, 12.67556 | PP515241 |
R. pubescens | IT | Tributary of Fiume Tescio | 43.09722, 12.67556 | PP515242 |
R. pubescens | IT | Nameless brook near Rezzo | 44.02583, 7.86667 | PP515243 |
R. pubescens | IT | Valle di Pietra | 44.07722, 7.80639 | PP515244 |
R. pubescens | IT | Valle di Pietra | 44.07722, 7.80639 | PP515245 |
R. sarplana | AL | Tropojë, open stream on Mt. Callumit, above town | 42.49862, 20.12443 | PP515203 |
Rhyacophila sp., tristis grp. | AT | Carinthia, Gail river at Kötschach-Mauthen town | 46.67, 12.98 | PP515255 |
Rhyacophila sp., tristis grp. | IT | Lombardia, Valle del Ferro | 45.77277, 9.98996 | PP515256 |
Rhyacophila sp., tristis grp. | IT | Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol, Camposilvano | 45.75988, 11.14189 | PP515257 |
Rhyacophila sp., tristis grp. | FR | Ruisseau de Chousse, upper tributary; between Arrette & La Pierre Saint-Martin | 43.00757, -0.73572 | PP515258 |
R. trescavicensis | ME | Ali-pašini springs | 42.54706, 19.83240 | PP515246 |
R. trescavicensis | ME | Ali-pašini springs | 42.54706, 19.83240 | PP515247 |
R. trescavicensis | ME | Ali-pašini springs | 42.54706, 19.83240 | PP515248 |
R. trescavicensis | ME | Ali-pašini springs | 42.54706, 19.83240 | PP515249 |
R. tristis | RO | Hunedoara, Câmpu lui Neag | 45.30227, 22.97388 | PP515250 |
R. tristis | RO | Hunedoara, Câmpu lui Neag | 45.30227, 22.97388 | PP515251 |
R. tristis | RO | Covasna, Comandău | 45.81488, 26.32934 | PP515252 |
R. tristis | RO | Harghita, Voşlăbeni | 46.6815, 25.6738 | PP515253 |
R. tristis | RO | Vâlcea, Voineasa, Lotru river | 45.463, 23.62 | PP515254 |
R. tsurakiana | AL | river Shushica at the village of Brataj | 40.26622, 19.67198 | PP515259 |
R. vranitzensis | BA | Sljeme | 43.9403, 18.5122 | PP515260 |
R. vranitzensis | BA | Sljeme | 43.9403, 18.5122 | PP515261 |
R. vranitzensis | BA | Sljeme | 43.9403, 18.5122 | PP515262 |
R. vranitzensis | BA | Skakavac waterfall | 43.94238, 18.44196 | PP515263 |
R. vranitzensis | BA | Skakavac waterfall | 43.94238, 18.44196 | PP515265 |
The maximum likelihood tree was produced using IQ-TREE v.2.1.3 (
The consensus tree was visualized and edited in TreeViewer v.2.2.0 (
After quality control with FastQC v.0.11.9 (
Genome size was estimated using a method based on k-mer distribution. For this, k-mers were counted with JELLYFISH v.2.3.0 (
The mitochondrial genomes were first assembled with the raw reads using NOVOplasty v.4.2 (
Nuclear genome assembly was conducted in Spades v.3.14.1 (
Genomic methods were identical for R. tsurakiana (see Suppl. material
The holotype specimen was prepared and examined following standard methods for ethanol-preserved material (
The abdomen was removed from the specimen, soaked in 85% lactic acid, and heated to 99 °C for 60 min to dissolve internal soft tissues. The macerated tissues were then flushed out of the abdomen with a syringe. The holotype was examined on an Olympus SZX10 stereomicroscope, and pencil sketches of the genitalia were prepared using a Leitz Dialux 20 compound microscope outfitted with a drawing tube. Pencil sketches were scanned and placed in an Adobe Illustrator CS6 document as a template for vector illustrations. Morphological terminology follows
After collapsing clades with less than 70% bootstrap support, the species in the Rhyacophila tristis group were placed in a polytomy, and sister to R. italica (Fig.
Phylogenetic relationships in the Rhyacophila tristis group based on the mtCOI barcode region and estimated by maximum likelihood, as implemented in IQ-TREE v.2.1.3 (
The second clade in the polytomy includes several species from the tristis subgroup (R. orghidani Botosaneanu, 1952, R. cibinensis Botosaneanu & Marinkovic-Gospodnetic, 1967, R. margaritae Kumanski, 1998, R. bosnica, and R. obtusa Klapalek, 1894), and two species from the pubescens subgroup (R. pirinica Kumanski, 1980 and R. producta McLachlan, 1879). These specimens were collected in Albania, Austria, Bulgaria, and Romania. The third clade in the polytomy exclusively includes species from the tristis subgroup (R. aquitanica McLachlan, 1879, R. carpathica Botosaneanu, 1995, R. trescavicensis Botosaneanu, 1960, R. tristis Pictet, 1834, R. vranitzensis Botosaneanu & Marinkovic-Gospodnetic, 1967, and Rhyacophila sp.). These specimens were collected in Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, France, Italy, Montenegro, Romania, and Spain.
Illumina sequencing resulted in 212,866,450 raw reads with a data amount of 31.9 Gbp for R. lignumvallis sp. nov. After trimming and contamination filtering, 173,132,236 reads (22.2 Gbp) were kept. The Genomescope2 analysis revealed a genome size of 699,853,381 bp and heterozygosity of 20% (see Suppl. material
The NOVOplasty mitogenome assembly resulted in three contigs (18,087 bp, 1,404 bp, 238 bp) that could not be circularized. Therefore, the 15,623 bp long contig obtained by MitoZ was chosen for annotation. The annotation of the mitogenome revealed all expected 13 protein-coding genes and both rRNAs and 23 tRNAs.
The nuclear genome assembly of R. lignumvallis sp. nov. contains 206,802 scaffolds with a total length of 644 Mb, an N50 of 5.6 kb, and a GC of 30%. The BUSCO search with 2,124 Endopterygota orthologs resulted in 82.5% BUSCOs; of these, 47.9% were complete (47.4% single, 0.5% duplicated), and 34.6% were fragmented. 96.3% of the reads were mapped back to the original assembly. Blobtools detected no contamination in the assembly for R. lignumvallis sp. nov. (see Suppl. material
The genomic characterization of R. tsurakiana is included in Suppl. material
France • ♂; Corsica, bridge over the river Vecchio near the confluence with the river Tavignano; 42.2275°N, 9.24306°E; 195 m a.s.l.; 25 Jul. 2019; col. W. Graf leg.; in ethanol; SMF (SMFTRI00018634).
Rhyacophila lignumvallis sp. nov. (Figs
The dorsal surface of segment X is convex in all these species but narrower and higher in the new species, R. tsurakiana, and R. harmasa. In dorsal view, however, the new species has a slightly membranous, mesally notched, and inflated segment X, while segment X in R. tsurakiana appears flatter. Additionally, the dorsal branch of tergum X is rounded and broader in the new species, while it is narrower in R. tsurakiana and R. harmasa.
The dorsal appendix of the phallic apparatus in the new species is longer than the aedeagus and the parameres (Fig.
The aedeagus and parameres in R. lignumvallis sp. nov. are most similar to R. pubescens. However, in lateral view, the tip of the aedeagus in the new species is slenderer and slightly more curved apically than in R. pubescens. In lateral view, the parameres in the new species are broader than in R. pubescens. In ventral view, the parameres in the new species are club-shaped and curved mesad, while in R. pubescens, the parameres are digitate and directed posterad.
The second segment of the inferior appendages in the new species is triangular, with a straight dorsal margin, while all the other species have a concave dorsal margin (Fig.
Adult male. Specimen in ethanol, mostly denuded; dorsally brown, ventrally light brown. Legs light brown with slightly darker tibial spurs. Head with frontal setal wart triangular; antennal setal wart subtriangular and smaller than frontal setal wart; posterior setal warts oval and connected to ocellar setal warts via a raised cuticular “bridge” (see Schmid, 1970; pl. I, fig. 1). Forewing length (8.8 mm, N = 1) mostly denuded, with sparse, very short light brown setae and golden brown microtrichia. Hind wings also mostly denuded, with slightly longer light brown setae. Forewing (Fig.
Rhyacophila lignumvallis sp. nov., wing venation. C, costal vein; Sc, subcostal vein; R1–R5, first to fifth branches of the radial vein; M1–M4, first to fourth branches of the medial vein; M3+4, medial vein 3+4 (hindwing); Cu1a, anterior branch of first cubital vein; Cu1b, posterior branch of first cubital vein; Cu2, second cubital vein; 1A–3A, first to third anal veins; r, radial crossvein; r-m, radiomedial crossvein; m-cu, mediocubital crossvein; I–V, first to fifth wing forks; TC, thyridial cell. Scale bar: 1 mm. Illustrations were produced by Ernesto Rázuri-Gonzales.
Male genitalia. Segment IX longitudinally short in lateral view (Fig.
We dedicate this species to Dr Ralph W. Holzenthal to honor his contributions to caddisfly taxonomy and systematics. Lignumvallis, wood valley, is derived from the Latin translation of Ralph’s last name.
The river Vecchio is a crystal-clear, slow-flowing stream with a heterogeneous bottom substrate that varies from sandy patches to gravel to boulders. Stabile substrates were densely covered by Agapetus cyrnensis pupae. As many spring trickles enter the river on its left margin and the specimen was collected by sweeping the vegetation, the habitat of R. lignumvallis sp. nov. remains unknown.
Despite being one of the most well-known faunas in the world, on average more than 770 new animal species are described from Europe each year (
In the case of caddisflies, southern Europe (e.g., Spain, Italy, and the Balkan Peninsula), mountainous regions (e.g., the Alps and the Pyrenees), and the Caucasus have been shown to be particularly species-rich and centers of endemism (
The Rhyacophila tristis group now includes 29 species distributed throughout central-southern Europe and Western Asia, with many of them occurring in biodiversity centers in these regions (e.g., southern Europe and the Balkans, Suppl. material
Aquatic insects have traditionally been neglected in genomic research (
The percentage of BUSCOs recovered in the draft genome assembly was 82.5%. Of these, 47.9% were complete and 34.6% were fragmented. Meanwhile, the previously generated Rhyacophila genomes had a complete BUSCO score of 95.4% for R. brunnea (only 2.5% fragmented) and 74.1/75.1% for two R. evoluta specimens (17.9/18.7% fragmented) (
Genome assembly quality can be assessed using various metrics, such as contiguity and BUSCO completeness (
We would like to acknowledge the financial support from the LOEWE Centre for Translational Biodiversity Genomics, Frankfurt am Main, Germany (LOEWE-TBG) to sequence the genome of the holotype of Rhyacophila lignumvallis sp. nov. and Miklós Bálint (Senckenberg Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre, Frankfurt am Main, Germany) for sharing unpublished sequence data on the R. tristis group.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
Financial support from the LOEWE Centre for Translational Biodiversity Genomics, Frankfurt am Main, Germany (LOEWE-TBG).
ER: investigation, data curation, formal analysis, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing, visualization. WG: investigation, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing, visualization. JH: data curation, formal analysis, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. JS: investigation, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. SUP: study design, data curation, investigation, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing.
Ernesto Rázuri-Gonzales https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7554-0816
Wolfram Graf https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6559-0644
Jacqueline Heckenhauer https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8771-9154
Julio V. Schneider https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9823-6569
Steffen U. Pauls https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6451-3425
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
Blobtools graphs for the Rhyacophila lignumvallis sp. nov. assembly
Data type: docx
Genomic methods and characterization for the Rhyacophila tsurakiana genome assembly
Data type: docx
Geographic distribution of species in the Rhyacophila tristis species group
Data type: docx
Explanation note: This list includes the geographic distribution of the 25 currently known species in the Rhyacophila tristis species group based on literature records. We only include papers with geographic data.