Research Article |
Corresponding author: Joel H. Kits ( joel.kits@agr.gc.ca ) Academic editor: J. Adilson Pinedo-Escatel
© 2024 Joel H. Kits.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC0 Public Domain Dedication.
Citation:
Kits JH (2024) Boreolimnus, a new leafhopper genus from northern North America, with a review of Cribrus Oman (Hemiptera, Cicadellidae, Deltocephalinae). ZooKeys 1217: 273-290. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1217.126602
|
The poorly known leafhopper species described as Deltocephalus (Laevicephalus) concinnus var. incisurus DeLong, 1926 previously had no accepted generic placement. It is here redescribed and placed in Boreolimnus gen. nov. in the tribe Paralimnini, as Boreolimnus incisurus (DeLong) comb. nov. Cribrus micmac Hamilton, 1987 is a junior syn. nov. of B. incisurus. Due to historic confusion, the species currently placed in Cribrus Oman, 1949 were also reviewed. Cribrus concinnus (Sanders & DeLong, 1917) is redescribed, and a lectotype is designated to clarify the application of the name. Deltocephalus plagus Ball & DeLong, 1926 and Laevicephalus shingwauki Beamer & Tuthill, 1934 are recognized as junior syn. nov. of C. concinnus, now the only recognized species in the genus.
COI barcodes, morphology, new genus, Paralimnini, phylogeny
The leafhopper taxon described by
Deltocephalus incisurus belongs to the tribe Paralimnini as delimited by
Although D. incisurus is clearly distinct from the Nearctic paralimnine genus Cribrus Oman based on male and female genitalia and wing venation, they share similar colour patterns and there has been previous confusion between the two. The holotype of D. incisurus is one of the two syntypes of Cribrus concinnus (Sanders & DeLong), and examination of the holotype and only known specimen of Cribrus micmac Hamilton showed that it is conspecific with D. incisurus. Thus, the other species currently placed in Cribrus were also reviewed to determine whether they are correctly placed and clarify their taxonomy.
While morphological evidence suggests that both genera examined here are distinct from other Paralimnini, molecular evidence was also examined as a further test of their status. The most comprehensive phylogeny of the Paralimnini is that of
SEMC Snow Entomological Museum Collection, University of Kansas (Lawrence, Kansas, USA)
Images were taken using a Leica M205C stereomicroscope with 1.6× objective (Leica Microsystems GmbH, Wetzlar, Germany), with infinity-corrected 5× or 10× objectives (Mitutoyo Corp., Kawasaki, Japan) mounted on a Canon R10 camera (Canon Inc., Tokyo, Japan) via a Thorlabs ITL200 tube lens (Thorlabs Inc., Newton, NJ, USA), or Nikon Eclipse E800 compound microscope with 10× or 20× objectives (Nikon Corp., Tokyo, Japan). Images were stacked using Zerene Stacker (Zerene Systems, Richland, WA, USA), edited using Adobe Photoshop CS6, and assembled into plates using Adobe Illustrator CS6 (Adobe Inc., San Jose, CA, USA). Morphological terminology follows
Additional occurrence data for mapping Cribrus distribution were obtained from
COI sequences from
Sequences were obtained from 44 genera and 160 species of Paralimnini (Suppl. material
Relationships between genera were generally only moderately or poorly resolved. Boreolimnus incisurus was resolved as sister to Rosenus Oman with fairly high support (95% bootstrap, 61 SH-aLRT). Cribrus concinnus was resolved in a clade with Lebradea Remane and part of Sorhoanus with high support (90% bootstrap, 83 SH-aLRT), with a sister relationship to the latter weakly supported (19% bootstrap, 72 SH-aLRT).
Deltocephalus (Laevicephalus) concinnus var. incisurus DeLong, 1926 (here designated)
The name is derived from the Greek βορέας (north) and λίμνη (marsh), describing the habitat of the type species. The gender is masculine.
Separated from other genera of Paralimnini by the following combination of characters: male subgenital plates with uniseriate macrosetae, plates as long as pygofer and tapering to a narrow rounded apex; pygofer with a process on postero-ventral margin, process nearly straight; segment X about as long as wide, broadly scerotized laterally and narrowly sclerotized dorsally; connective linear and elongate with arms fused in a stem which is about as broad as long (connective loop-shaped sensu
Small leafhoppers with typical Paralimnini structure. Colour generally stramineous, head and pronotum with longitudinal stripes, wing with brown infuscation around cell borders (Figs
Boreolimnus incisurus 2 dorsal habitus 3 lateral habitus 4 abdomen ventral, female 5 face 6 male pygofer, dorsal 7 male pygofer, lateral 8 male subgenital plate, styles, connective, dorsal 9 aedeagus, caudal 10 aedeagus, lateral 11 female genital capsule, ventral 12 female sternite VII, ventral 13 first valvifer, lateral, with enlargement 14 second valvifers, lateral, with enlargement.
Head with crown bluntly angled, medial length about 1.5× width between eyes (Fig.
Pronotum slightly narrower than width of head across eyes, slightly longer than medial length of head. Fore femur with AM1 near ventral margin, row IC with a few fine setae, row AV consisting of a few, widely spaced, very short setae. Fore tibia with 1 AD and 4 PD macrosetae. Hind femur with 2+2+1 macrosetae. First hind tarsomere with two rows of plantar setae, four apical platellae between a pair of normal setae. Fore wing usually with three closed anteapical cells; outer anteapical cell short and closed by distal fusion of R2+3 and R4+5 or occasionally absent.
Male abdomen with apodemes on sternite II about twice as long as wide, apical half transparent, strongly curved dorsally. Pygofer about as long as wide, with a triangular distal lobe and a sclerotized process from posteroventral corner; with a patch of long macrosetae posterodorsally and shorter fine macrosetae scattered ventrally (Figs
Female pygofer with moderate length macrosetae (Fig.
Boreolimnus runs to Latalus in the keys of both
Deltocephalus (Laevicephalus) concinnus var. incisurus DeLong, 1926: 77
Laevicephalus concinnus var. incisurus
(DeLong). Comb.
Laevicephalus incisurus
(DeLong, 1926). Rev. stat.
= Latalus hultus Beirne, 1954: 123. Syn.
= Cribrus micmac Hamilton in
Males 3.1–3.4 mm. Females 3.2–3.6 mm.
Colour mostly pale straw to light yellow, with two longitudinal stripes on crown and four longitudinal stripes on pronotum in a deeper yellow colour usually apparent. Palest specimens with dark colour restricted to basal tergites and spots at bases of leg macrosetae. Darker specimens may have light to dark brown markings medially on frontoclypeus (interrupted laterally by pale horizontal lines), in antennal pits, on anepisternum, medially on abdominal tergites, on base of sternite II and laterally on all sternites, and on pygofer. Fore wing milky white with brown infuscation around border of some cells.
Male pygofer process short, originating on postero-ventral margin and extending slightly dorsally. Process typically with two small teeth on ventral margin. Subgenital plates bearing a single row of approximately eight macrosetae laterally. Style with lateral lobe of apophysis quadrately rounded, medial lobe of apophysis sickle-shaped, with four or five widely spaced, rounded teeth ventrally. Aedeagus in lateral view dorsoventrally flattened, strongly curved anterodorsally, extending slightly dorsally of atrium. Atrium in posterior view with deep and broad dorsal excavation; shaft in posterior view broad, narrowing preapically, with a single pair of lateral processes just before apex, terminating in a round plate above gonopore.
Female sternite VII rectangular, posterior margin with slight, rounded projections medially and laterally and gently convex in between, medial projection with a small emargination surrounded by a dark area (Fig.
Holotype
of Deltocephalus incisurus DeLong. USA • ♀; Wisconsin, Ladysmith; 9 Aug. 1916; D.M. DeLong leg.;
Holotype
of Latalus hultus Beirne. Canada • ♂; Manitoba, Birch River; 13 Aug. 1930; R.H. Handford leg.;
Holotype
of Cribrus micmac Hamilton. Canada • ♀; Nova Scotia, Cape Breton Highlands National Park, Paquet’s Lake; 27 Aug. 1983; M. Sharkey leg.;
Canada – Alberta • 1 ♂; Beaverlodge; 1 Aug. 1961; A.R. Brooks leg.;
The holotype of Deltocephalus incisurus (Figs
Boreolimnus incisurus and synonyms, primary types 15–18 Deltocephalus concinnus var. incisurus DeLong, holotype 15 dorsal habitus 16 lateral habitus 17 abdomen, ventral 18 labels 19–21 Latalus hultus Beirne, holotype 19 lateral habitus 20 labels 21 dorsal habitus 22–24 Cribrus micmac Hamilton, holotype 22 lateral habitus 23 labels 24 dorsal habitus.
The holotype of Latalus hultus (Figs
The holotype of Cribrus micmac (Figs
Females of this species can be separated from Cribrus and other Nearctic Paralimnini with longitudinal stripes on the head and pronotum based on the distinctly infuscated cell borders of the fore wing, reduction of the outer anteapical cell, sternite VII with slightly projecting posterior corners and a small darkened emargination medially, and dark gonoplacs.
Recorded from Alberta to Nova Scotia, south to Wisconsin (Fig.
Associated with graminoids in northern wetlands, although the specific host is unclear. The type specimen was collected from “grasses on the margin of a tamarack bog” (
Laevicephalus shingwauki Beamer & Tuthill, 1934, by original designation (
Separated from other genera of Paralimnini by the following combination of characters: male subgenital plates with uniseriate macrosetae, plates truncate and shorter than pygofer; pygofer without processes; pygofer with a prominent pair of dorsal spots; connective linear with posterior stem about as long as wide (connective loop-shaped sensu
Small leafhoppers with typical Paralimnini structure. Colour generally stramineous, head and pronotum with longitudinal stripes, wing with indistinct brown infuscation around cell borders (Figs
Head with crown bluntly angled, medial length about equal to width between eyes (Figs
Cribrus concinnus 26 dorsal habitus, male 27 dorsal habitus, female 28 abdomen ventral, female 29 lateral habitus, male 30 face 31 lateral habitus, female 32 male pygofer, dorsal 33 male pygofer, lateral 34 male subgenital plate, styles, connective, dorsal 35 aedeagus, caudal 36 aedeagus, lateral 37 female genital capsule, ventral 38 first valvifer, lateral, with enlargement 39 second valvifers, lateral, with enlargement 40 female sternite VII, ventral.
Pronotum slightly narrower than width of head across eyes, about as long as medial length of head. Fore femur with AM1 near ventral margin, row IC with a few fine setae, row AV consisting of a few, widely spaced, very short setae. Fore tibia with 1 AD and 4 PD macrosetae. Hind femur with 2+2+1 macrosetae. First hind tarsomere with two rows of plantar setae, four apical platellae between a pair of longer normal setae. Fore wing with three closed anteapical cells, although venation may be distorted due to brachyptery.
Male abdomen with apodemes on sternite II poorly developed, shorter than width. Pygofer about twice as long as wide, with a patch of long macrosetae posterodorsally and a few small macrosetae scattered ventrally (Figs
Female pygofer with moderate length macrosetae (Fig.
Deltocephalus concinnus Sanders & DeLong 1917: 86.
Laevicephalus concinnus
(Sanders & DeLong): Comb.
Cribrus concinnus
(Sanders & DeLong): Comb.
= Deltocephalus plagus Ball & DeLong, 1926: 241. New synonym.
= Laevicephalus shingwauki Beamer & Tuthill, 1934: 19. New synonym.
Males 2.5–2.8 mm. Females 3.3–3.6 mm.
Colour mostly light yellow, with two light brown longitudinal stripes on crown and four longitudinal stripes on pronotum. Legs with dark spots at bases of macrosetae. Abdominal tergites with four brown to black longitudinal stripes usually apparent. Abdominal sternites may have lateral brown markings. Fore wing pale brown with indistinct darker brown infuscation around border of cells. Wing length variable in females, from fully macropterous to brachypterous with fore wing reaching apex of tergite VI and hind wing reaching apex of tergite II. Males brachypterous with fore wing reaching base to midpoint of pygofer and hind wing reaching apex of tergite II to III.
Subgenital plates bearing a single row of approximately seven macrosetae laterally. Style with medial lobe of apophysis finger-shaped. Aedeagus with long apical processes curving toward base, sculptured with complex ridges.
Female sternite VII rectangular, posterior corners rounded, posterior margin straight to moderately convex, may have slight projections medially and laterally (Fig.
Lectotype
of Deltocephalus concinnus Sanders & DeLong (here designated). USA • ♀; Wisconsin, Ladysmith; 9 Aug. 1916; D.M. DeLong leg.;
Holotype
of Deltocephalus plagus Ball & DeLong. USA • ♀ (specimen missing from point, not examined); Wisconsin, Madison; 21 Sep. 1917; E.D. Ball leg.;
Holotype of Laevicephalus shingwauki Beamer & Tuthill. USA • ♂ (apparently lost, not examined); Minnesota, Aitkin; 25 Aug. 1933; P.B. Lawson leg.; SEMC.
USA – Illinois • 1 ♂, 3 ♀; 3 mi W Kankakee; 25 Aug. 1980; K.G.A. Hamilton leg.;
All males examined are brachypterous and clearly belong to a single species with distinctive genitalia. Females differing in wing length were previously treated as distinct species (e.g.
The holotype of D. plagus is missing from the point, with only a leg remaining (S. McKamey pers. comm. 2022). The original description and illustrations are both good matches to brachypterous females of this species.
The holotype and a male paratype of Laevicephalus shingwauki are stated in the original description to be deposited in the SEMC, but they can not be located there now (R. Osborn pers. comm. 2024).
Females of this species can be separated from Boreolimnus and other Nearctic Paralimnini with longitudinal stripes on the head and pronotum based on the longitudinal dorsal stripes on the abdomen, outer anteapical cell well developed and closed by crossvein s, sternite VII entirely pale with rounded posterior corners and without medial emargination, and pale gonoplacs.
Found in the midwestern United States (Minnesota to Indiana), around the eastern margin of the tallgrass prairie region (Fig.
Associated with Calamagrostis, usually in mesic to wet prairie or wetlands (
Although the Nearctic fauna of Paralimnini is fairly well known as a whole, many taxa have not yet been included in modern revisionary studies. In addition to various undescribed or unrecognized species, some currently recognized species are inadequately characterized and require more research to resolve their status. The new genus and new synonymies here resolve the status of a few of these obscure nominal species. Continued taxonomic research on other little-known taxa of Nearctic Paralimnini is needed to further advance the taxonomy of this diverse group of leafhoppers.
The phylogenetic analysis also points to potential issues in generic classification of the Paralimnini, with a few well-sampled genera recovered as non-monophyletic. However, the single gene used is insufficient for robust recovery of deeper, mostly intrageneric relationships, with low support values for most nodes near the base of the tree. Revisions to the generic classification should not be based on these results alone, but further analysis with multiple genes and dense taxon sampling should be prioritized.
I thank Tommy McElrath (
The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
This project was funded by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (project J-002279).
Conceptualization: JHK. Investigation: JHK. Writing - original draft: JHK. Writing - review and editing: JHK.
Joel H. Kits https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2685-0567
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
Maximum likelihood tree of Paralimnini, based on 658 base pairs of cytochrome oxidase I
Data type: tif
Explanation note: Support values at nodes are bootstrap/SH-aLRT.
Georeferenced localities for Boreolimnus incisurus and Cribrus concinnus
Data type: csv
Data for COI sequences used in phylogenetic analysis
Data type: csv