Research Article |
Corresponding author: Hsuan-Ching Ho ( ogcoho@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Mao-Ying Lee
© 2024 Hsuan-Ching Ho, Toshio Kawai.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Ho H-C, Kawai T (2024) Verification of two barracudina species Lestrolepis japonica (Tanaka, 1908) and L. philippina (Fowler, 1934) (Aulopiformes, Paralepididae). In: Ho H-C, Russell B, Hibino Y, Lee M-Y (Eds) Biodiversity and taxonomy of fishes in Taiwan and adjacent waters. ZooKeys 1220: 79-92. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1220.125860
|
Examination of the type series of Lestidium japonica Tanaka reveals that the generally accepted concept of this species does not accord with the type series. A historical review of the literature showed that the characterization of L. japonica changed over time, and what has been recognized as “L. japonica” for more than 70 years actually represents a distinct and different species. Among the junior synonyms of “L. japonica”, Paralepis philippinus Fowler, 1934 is resurrected as a valid species herein in a new combination, Lestrolepis philippina. Lestrolepis nigroventralis Ho, Tsai & Li is recognized as a junior synonym of L. japonica herein. Revised diagnostic characteristics for both L. japonica and L. philippina are provided, along with comments on related names to verify their nomenclatural status.
Biodiversity, ichthyology, ICZN, nomenclature, taxonomy
Naked barracudinas, often classified as the Lestidiini, Lestidiinae, or sometimes Lestidiidae, are a group of small, slender fishes found worldwide from the surface to the deep sea. This group comprises seven genera with approximately 60 species, although some remain problematic (
The taxonomic history of Lestrolepis is complex and somewhat confusing, even more so as the author, Robert Rees Harry (
Recently, the second author (TK) examined specimens deposited in the fish collection of Hokkaido University and identified inconsistencies between the original description and the specimens currently recognized as L. japonica. Examination of the holotype (Fig.
Verification of some name records of Lestrolepis and their current status.
Publication | Name used | Correct names |
---|---|---|
|
Paralepis intermedius | Valid as Lestrolepis intermedia |
|
Lestidium japonicum | Valid as Lestrolepis japonica |
|
Paralepis luetkeni | Valid as Lestidiops luetkeni |
|
Paralepis bellottii | Synonym of Lestidiops luetkeni |
|
Paralepis philippinus | Valid as L. philippina |
Fowler 1944 | Sudis vanderbilti | Synonym of L. intermedia |
|
Lestidium japonicum | L. philippina |
|
Lestidium intermedium (in part) | L. japonica |
Kamohara 1955 | Lestidium japonicum | L. japonica |
|
Lestrolepis japonica | L. philippina |
|
Lestrolepis japonica | L. philippina |
|
Lestrolepis intermedia | L. japonica |
|
Lestrolepis japonica | L. philippina |
|
Lestrolepis japonica | L. philippina |
|
Lestrolepis nigroventralis | Synonym of L. japonica |
|
Lestrolepis japonica | L. philippina |
To clarify the identification of these species, we conducted a study on the type series of Lestrolepis japonica and L. philippinna and provide here revised diagnoses or comments for the species related to these names. In the present study we confirm the validity of L. japonica, synonymize L. nigroventralis with L. japonica, resurrect L. philippina, and clarify the taxonomic history of these species.
Methods for taking morphometrics and meristics followed
SL, standard length; HL, head length; TL, total length; VFO, DFO, AFL, the origins of pelvic fin, dorsal fin and anal fin, respectively; V–D, space between VFO and DFO; V–A, space between VFO and AFO. Other abbreviations followed
On the taxonomic issues
Lestidium japonicum was described based on two types collected from Sagami Bay (ZMUT 2013 and 2014). In the synonymy of this species,
The original description of Paralepis bellottii was based on a single specimen (60 mm SL, 64 mm TL). This species was synonymized with Lestidium nudum Gilbert, 1905 and Paraelpis luetkeni Ege, 1933 by
The original description of Paralepis philippinus was based on eight type specimens collected from the Philippines. Examination of the type series revealed that it is different from that of L. japonica and is what has been commonly recognized as “L. japonica” in the western Pacific Ocean.
Consequently, neither philippinus nor leutkeni or bellottii, can be regarded as synonyms of japonica, but can be considered here to represent what has been called “L. japonica” in the western Pacific (Table
As mentioned above,
The earliest records of Lestrolepis intermedia in the Western Pacific Ocean are found in
Lestidium japonicum
Tanaka, 1908:27 (type locality: Sagami Sea, Japan);
Lestrolepis intermedia
(non Poey, 1868): Fujii in Masuda et al. 1984:77 (Japan; short description);
Lestrolepis nigroventralis Ho, Tsai & Li, 2019:123 (type locality: off Dong-gang, Pingtung, southwestern Taiwan).
Lestrolepis nigroventralis was described to accommodate the Pacific population of L. intermedia. However, because of its nearly identical morphology (Table
Selected morphological and meristic data of L. japonica and L. philippina. * Data of “L. nigroventralis” and ** of “L. japonica” taken from
L. japonica | L. philippina | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Types | Types of L. nigroventralis | Types | Non-types** | ||||
HT | PT | HT | Types* | HT | PT | ||
SL (mm) | 159.5 | ca 180 | 230 | 180–249 (n = 11) | 118.2 | 109.6–128.0 (n = 4) | 88.0–222 (n = 29) |
Proportion (%) | Mean (Range) | Mean (Range) | |||||
HL/SL | 20.9 | 21.1 | 20.0 | 19.6 (18.9–20.7) | 20.8 | 21.3–22.0 | 20.5 (18.0–21.8) |
BD/SL | 5.7 | 5.2 | 5.3 | 5.2 (4.9–5.6) | 8.5 | 7.1–7.9 | 6.9 (5.9–8.6) |
PreD/SL | 63.7 | – | 62.8 | 62.7 (61.7–63.3) | 58.8 | 59.4–60.9 | 61.8 (60.2–63.5) |
PreV/SL | 52.7 | – | 52.1 | 51.6 (50.6–52.6) | 51.2 | 51.6–53.4 | 53.0 (52.3–55.2) |
PreA/SL | 73.3 | – | 73.5 | 73.3 (71.9–74.8) | 72.8 | 73.0–75.2 | 74.9 (75.8–76.6) |
ED/HL | 20.1 | 17.9 | 15.5 | 16.1 (14.8–17.3) | 19.1 | 18.1–19.1 | 18.4 (15.9–22.6) |
SN/HL | 54.7 | 53.8 | 52.4 | 54.4 (52.4–57.0) | 52.8 | 49.8–52.8 | 50.8 (47.7–53.4) |
HD/HL | 27.1 | 24.8 | 26.3 | 26.4 (25.4–27.4) | 30.9 | 27.8–30.8 | 28.5 (28.6–28.5) |
UJ/HL | 51.4 | 49.6 | 49.1 | 49.0 (47.2–50.4) | 47.6 | 47.7–49.5 | 46.8 (44.0–50.0) |
V–D/V–A | 53.1 | 51.0 | 50.0 | 51.0 (47.6–55.0) | 35.3 | 34.0–36.1 | 39.1 (32.5–43.1) |
Meristics | |||||||
Anal-fin rays | 42 | ca 40 | 42 | 41–43 | ca 38 | 37–38 | 36–40 |
Vertebrae | |||||||
PHV | 34 | 33 | 33 | 32–35 | 29 | 30–31 | 29–32 |
PVV | 33 | 34 | 34 | 33–35 | 30 | 30–32 | 30–33 |
PDV | 43 | 44 | 44 | 43–46 | 38 | 38–39 | 36–40 |
PAV | 53 | 55 | 55 | 53–57 | 48 | 49–51 | 48–51 |
CV | 60 | 61 | 62 | 60–66 | 55 | 56–59 | 52–58 |
TV | 94 | 95 | 95 | 94–98 | 85 | 86–89 | 84–88 |
V–D | 9 | 10 | 10 | 9–11 | 8 | 7–8 | 5–9 |
Lateral-line scales | |||||||
PVLL | 34 | – | 34 | 33–36 | 30 | 30–32 | 31–32 |
PDLL | 44 | – | 44 | 43–46 | 38 | 39–40 | 38–40 |
PALL | 54 | – | 54 | 53–57 | 49 | 49–51 | 49–50 |
TLL | ca 81 | – | 78 | 75–81 | 71 | 68–70 | 65–72 |
A species of Lestrolepis with DFO situated at about midline of V–A, V–D 46.8–55.0% of V–A; anal-fin rays 41–43 (mainly 41–42); lateral-line scales: PVLL 33–36 (34–35), PDLL 43–46 (44–46), PALL 53–57 (55–56), TLL 75–81 (77–80); vertebral counts: PHV 32–35 (mainly 32–34), PVV 33–35 (34–35), PDV 43–46 (44–45), PAV 53–57 (54–55), CV 60–66 (61–64), TV 94–98 (94–97); vertebrae between DFO and VFO 9–11. Body slender, body depth at pectoral-fin base 15–19 times in SL; band of melanophores along abdominal margin. Attains 249 mm SL.
Known from the northwestern Pacific Ocean off Japan, Taiwan, and Korea. Records from other localities require verification.
The taxonomic concept of what has long been called Lestrolepis japonica is now revised based on the type series and additional specimens. A review of the literature with documentation of L. japonica is listed in the synonymy above, although there might be more records that are not included therein. Detailed comparisons with congeners are provided in
There are some minor differences found in the types compared to the non-types (Table
Paralepis philippinus Fowler, 1934: 281, fig. 42 (type locality: Varadero Harbor, Philippines).
Lestidium japonicum
(not of Tanaka):
Lestrolepis japonica
(not of Tanaka): Fujii in Masuda et al. 1984:77 (Japan; short description);
A species of Lestrolepis with DFO situated well before midline of V–A, V–D 32.5–43.1% of V–A; anal-fin rays 36–40 (mainly 37–39); lateral-line scales: PVLL 30–32 (31), PDLL 38–40 (38–39), PALL 49–51, TLL 65–72 (65–68); vertebral counts: PHV 29–32, PVV 30–33 (30–32), PDV 36–40 (37–40), PAV 48–51, CV 52–58 (54–57), TV 82–88 (84–88); vertebrae between DFO and VFO 5–9 (7–8). Body moderately slender, body depth at pectoral-fin base 13–16 times in SL; narrow band of melanophores along abdominal margin. Attains 222 mm SL.
Widespread in the western Pacific Ocean, with confirmed records from Japan, Taiwan, the Philippines, northwestern Australia, and the South China Sea.
Some minor differences are observed between the holotype and non-types (Table
Several ambiguities in earlier studies have led to subsequent problems, including the inadvertent naming of a new species.
Regarding other paralepidid species, some taxonomic problems have been reviewed, such as the resurrection of Lestrolepis pofi and the placement of L. leutkeni in Lestidiops (
This work provides an opportunity to underscore the importance of not relying solely on previously published works but also examining type material in museum collections, even for well-known species.
Lestrolepis japonica
: Holotype. ZMUT 2013 (159.5), Sagami Bay, Japan. Paratype. ZMUT 2014 (ca. 180), same as holotype. Non-types. HUMZ 71212 (1, 183), Fukushima, Japan, trawl net, 200–300 m, 8 Nov. 1977. HUMZ 71248 (1, 243), Hayakawa Port, Odawara, Kanagawa, Japan, 7 Nov. 1977. HUMZ 71844 (1, 193), HUMZ 71845 (1, 296), HUMZ 71846 (1, 184), HUMZ 71847 (1, 213), HUMZ 71848 (1, 186), Hayakawa Port, Odawara, Kanagawa, Japan, 5 Nov. 1977. HUMZ 134997 (1), 38°35'30.0"N 141°59'48.0"E, off Minamisanriku, Miyagi, Japan, bottom trawl, 331 m, 17 Oct. 1994. HUMZ 163755 (1, 120), 38°24'32.4"N, 142°04'13.2"E Miyagi, 461 m, 12 Oct. 1999. HUMZ 163832 (1, 123), HUMZ 163833 (1, 125), Miyagi, 38°23'09.6"N, 142°07'27.0"E, 552 m, 26 Oct. 1999. HUMZ 206777 (1, 162), 38°24'57"N, 142°02'50.4"E, Miyagi, Japan, 425–430 m, 30 Oct. 2009. HUMZ 206833 (1, 140), 38°22'13.2"N, 142°03'13.8"E, Miyagi, bottom trawl, 412 m, 9 Oct. 2009. HUMZ 209243 (1, 92), 39°35'24.6"N, 142°31'E, 890-897 m, 7 Oct. 2010. HUMZ 214579 (1, 134), 39°05'15.6"N, 142°09'34.8"E, off Tohoku, 398–412 m, 19 Oct. 2011. HUMZ 222513 (1, 183), Miyagi, 38°52'01.2"N, 142°04'24.6"E, 357 m, bottom trawl, 23 Oct. 2013. HUMZ 226859 (1, 155), 39°01'59.4"N, 142°12'55.8"E, off Kesennuma, Miyagi, Japan, bottom trawl, 575 m, 23 Oct. 2015. HUMZ 226876 (1, 146), HUMZ 226877 (3), 37°36'56.4"N, 141°50'31.8"E, off Souma, Fukushima, Japan, 380 m, 5 Nov. 2015. HUMZ 226942 (2), 37°43'N, 141°53'51"E, off Souma, Fukushima, Japan, bottom trawl, 411 m, 29 Oct. 2015. NSMT-P13816 (2, 147–154), Suruga Bay, Shizuoka, Japan, 17 Nov. 1968. NSMT-P48916 (1, 168), south of Sagami Bay, Japan, 4 Nov. 1995. NSMT-P48931 (1, 154), off Tohoku, northern Japan, trawl, 5 Nov. 1995. NSMT-P58786 (3, 75–130), 39°00'36"N, 143°32'06"E, off Pacific coast between Miyagi Pref. and Iwate, 550–578 m, Japan, mesopelagic trawl, 29 Jul. 1996. NSMT-P 58787 (1, 100), 39°00'36"N, 143°32'06"E, between Miyagi Pref. and Iwate, 650–677 m, mesopelagic trawl, 29 Nov. 1996. NSMT-P58788 (1, 115), NSMT-P58789 (1, 93), 39°02'24"N, 143°30'07.2"E, between Miyagi Pref. and Iwate, northern Japan, 650–677 m, mesopelagic trawl, 30 Jul. 1996. NSMT-P65464 (1, 176), 37°45'54"N, 142°09'32"E, off Fukushima, northern Japan, 647–676 m, otter trawl, 19 Oct. 2002. NSMT-P65466 (1, 136), 36°53'45.6"N, 141°33'43.2"E, off Ibaraki, Japan, 495–530 m, otter trawl, 20 Oct. 2002. NSMT-P67563 (1, 158), 31°20'39.1"N, 128°10'53"E, southern Japan, 392 m, otter Trawl, 8 Nov. 2003. NSMT-P67589 (1, 237), 28°59'47"N, 127°09'21.2"E, Ryukyus, 350 m, otter Trawl, 5 Nov. 2003. NSMT-P91547 (1, 170), 38°21'32.4"N, 141°56'24.0"E, off Miyagi, Japan, 280 m, trawl, 3 Oct. 2007. NSMT-P102802 (1, 169), 36°58'26.4"N, 141°25'43.3"E, off Fukushima, Japan, 251-252 m, otter trawl, 26 Oct. 2006. Also listed as Lestrolepis nigroventralis in
Lestrolepis philippina
: Holotype. USNM 92323 (118.2), Varadero Bay, southern Luzon, Mindoro, Philippine, 22 Jul. 1908. Paratypes. USNM 93414 (2, 109.6–125), Noble Point, Tulayan Island, Sulu, Philippine, 283 m, 15 Sep. 1909. CAS-SU 14970 (1), USNM 135257 (2, 121–128), Anchorage, Dupon Bay, Leyte, Philippine, 17 Mar. 1909. Non-types. HUMZ 146645 (1, 228), 25°37'16.8"N, 126°05'21"E, Miyoko, Okinawa, 388–394 m, 2 Aug. 1994. HUMZ 222365 (1, 153), HUMZ 222366 (1, 165), HUMZ 222367 (1, 180), HUMZ 222368 (1, 185), HUMZ 222462 (1, 144), Dong-gang, Taiwan, 7 Nov. 2013. NSMT-P59709 (2, 87–96), 35°50'38.4"N, 152°59'49.2"E, 0–20 m, trawl, 24 May 1995. NSMT-P67590 (2, 185-232), 28°59'47"N, 127°09'21.2"E, East China Sea, 350 m, otter Trawl, 5 Nov. 2003. NSMT-P94628 (8, 123–160), Sagami Bay, southern Japan, set net, Tokyo Sea Life Park, 15 Nov. 1988. NSMT-P115090 (1, 138.2), NSMT-P115091 (1, 154.5), Dong-gang fishing port, Taiwan, 17 Oct. 2013, G. Shinohara et al. NSMT-P115637 (1, 142), Dong-gang fishing port, Taiwan, 19 Oct. 2013. NSMT-P128174 (1, 268.8), off Amami-Oshima Is., Ryukyus, Japan, Yamakawa, 26 Jun. 1972. NSMT-P128175 (1, 226.1), off Amami-Oshima Is., Ryukyus, Japan, 26 Jun. 1972. Also listed as L. japonica in
We thank H. Wada (The University Museum, The University of Tokyo), S.L. Ng (Department of Environmental Biology and Fisheries Science, National Taiwan Ocean University), K. Bemis, A. Reft (NOAA National Systematics Lab), and D. Pitassy (Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History) for providing various assistance, S. Nihei for taking photos of ZUMT specimens, and B. Russell for giving the critical review. This study is supported by the National Kaohsiung University of Science and Technology, Kaohsiung, Taiwan, and JSPS KAKENHI grant number JP23K05364 to TK.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Only museum collection specimens were used in present study.
This study was supported by the National Science and Technology Council, Taiwan, to HCH, and JSPS KAKENHI Grant (no. JP23K05364) to TK.
H.-C. Ho and T. Kawai took data, photos, and composed and reviewed the manuscript. All authors approved the manuscript.
Hsuan-Ching Ho https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1154-601X
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.