Research Article |
Corresponding author: Debora Barbato ( debora.barbato@unisi.it ) Academic editor: Eike Neubert
© 2024 Giuseppe Manganelli, Andrea Benocci, Debora Barbato, Folco Giusti.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Manganelli G, Benocci A, Barbato D, Giusti F (2024) Five alien achatinid land snails (Gastropoda, Eupulmonata) first reported in greenhouses of Italian botanical gardens. ZooKeys 1208: 99-132. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1208.119147
|
Plant trade and exchange for horticulture, recreation or research play a significant role in the dispersal of molluscs. Alien slugs and snails accidentally introduced into Europe have established rich communities in several countries, but although these introductions could have ecological and economic implications, mollusc xenodiversity in Italian botanical gardens, plant nurseries, and greenhouses has never been investigated. Facilities throughout the country were therefore visited between 2017 and 2023. Here the list of the achatinoidean species so far recorded from Italian greenhouses is provided, giving a short description of their diagnostic characters. The greenhouses of Trento and Padua host interesting assemblages of achatinoideans: the results of this study include the first reports of four achatinids, namely Allopeas clavulinum, Opeas hannense, Paropeas achatinaceum and Subulina octona from Italy and the first record of Geostilbia aperta from Europe. Reproductive anatomy of all species except Geostilbia aperta is illustrated in detail, integrating anatomical knowledge of this group of tiny molluscs, some of which are known mainly from their shell characters. The systematics of all the species is discussed, highlighting topics for future research (e.g., status of Allopeas mauritianum, real identity of Helix hannense, anatomy of Opeas hannense, species-level taxonomy of Subulina, systematic relationships and species-level taxonomy of Geostilbia).
Geographical distribution, non-indigenous molluscs, shell and genital morphology, taxonomy, translocated species
An increasing number of organisms of limited mobility are rapidly spreading outside their native range and habitat (
Alien slugs and snails have already established rich communities in European plant nurseries, greenhouses, and botanical gardens (e.g.,
Achatinoideans include several travelling snails (e.g., species that have the ecological flexibility to survive long journeys and spread and prosper in their new habitats;
As pointed out by
Anatomical dissection of small achatinoideans is not easy: the proximal part of the penial complex is difficult to interpret since its components are so reduced and closely packed as to appear a single structure. Nor are anatomical differences between extant genera very evident. Nevertheless, although anatomical study may only provide partial solutions, it is absolutely necessary because generic taxa were defined on anatomical characters so that identification is only possible by this examination. The aim of the paper is to list the species of achatinoideans so far recorded from Italy, giving a short description of their diagnostic shell and anatomical characters in order to facilitate identification, and understanding of their taxonomic and nomenclatural framework.
Between 2017 and 2023, the tropical greenhouses of seven facilities in central and northern Italy (Science Museum of Trento (
Snails and slugs were detected by visual search and by collecting leaf litter and surface soil. The visual search enabled detection of larger specimens, while collection of litter and soil revealed smaller species. The litter and soil were dried and sieved through decreasing mesh sizes. The coarser fraction was sorted visually, the others under a stereomicroscope. Although this method involves a huge investment in terms of sampling effort and time, it ensures more efficient collection of small mollusc species than a visual search.
Identifications were based on morphological features (i.e., shell and anatomical characters). Live specimens were drowned in water, then fixed and preserved in 75% ethanol buffered with sodium carbonate. The bodies were dissected under a light microscope using fine-pointed watchmaker’s forceps. Anatomical organs were drawn using a camera lucida. Anatomical nomenclature usually followed the standard references for Eupulmonata (e.g.,
The descriptive terms (e.g., short vs long, slender vs wide) refer to comparisons of the same section of the genitalia in different taxa of achatinids. The directional terms proximal, basal, and initial denote the part closer to the gonad, whereas distal, apical, final, and terminal denote the part closer to the gonopore in the case of ducts of the main axis of the genitalia (e.g., free oviduct, vagina, vas deferens, penis). The same terms denote the part closer to (proximal, basal, or initial) or further from (distal, apical, final, or terminal) the main axis of the genitalia in the case of blind structures radiating from the main axis of the genitalia (bursa copulatrix, penial/vaginal/atrial appendix, etc.).
The material is stored in the G. Manganelli collection (GMC; Dipartimento di Scienze Fisiche, della Terra e dell’Ambiente, Università di Siena, Italy).
Acronyms of the shell variables:
AH aperture height,
AW aperture width,
SD shell diameter,
SH shell height.
Acronyms of the anatomical organs:
AG albumen gland,
BC bursa copulatrix (gametolytic gland),
BW body wall,
DBC duct of bursa copulatrix,
DP distal penis,
DV distal vagina,
Eg egg/eggs in the uterine spermoviduct,
Ep epiphallus,
FHD first hermaphrodite duct,
FO free oviduct,
GA genital atrium,
LB vaginal lateral bulge,
P penis,
PC penial caecum,
PP proximal penis,
PR penial retractor,
PS penial sheath,
PSO prostatic spermoviduct,
SOD spermoviduct (ovispermiduct; second hermaphrodite duct),
USO uterine spermoviduct,
V vagina,
VD vas deferens.
Non-native molluscs were observed in all the facilities investigated, but achatinids were only found in Padua (3 species: Allopeas clavulinum, Paropeas achatinaceum, Subulina octona) and Trento (4 species: Allopeas clavulinum, Opeas hannense, Subulina octona, Geostilbia aperta). In these two greenhouses, high densities of small achatinids and other exotic slugs, snails, and soil invertebrates were found. The systematics, morphology, ecology, and distribution of the five species of achatinids are described below. A small undescribed slug of the little-known systellommatophoran family Rathouisiidae found in the tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
The superfamily Achatinoidea Swainson, 1840 has a complex and still unresolved systematic framework.
In their “Revised classification, nomenclator and typification of gastropod and monoplacophoran families”,
Bulimus clavulinus
Potiez & Michaud, 1838, 1: 136, pl. 14, figs 9, 10. Type locality: “L’île Bourbon”, namely Réunion Island, Mascarene Archipelago. Type material: lost (
Italy • 6 shells and 6 spirit specimens; Trento, Tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Shell
(Figs
Shells of alien achatinids in Italian greenhouses: 1–6 shells of Allopeas clavulinum from the tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Female distal genitalia
(Figs
Male distal genitalia
(Figs
Genital anatomy of alien achatinids in Italian greenhouses: 12, 13 genitalia (hermaphrodite gonad excluded) and diagram of the proximal penial complex of Allopeas clavulinum from the tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Genital atrium
(Figs
Although Allopeas clavulinum is a well-known greenhouse snail (
Today, Allopeas clavulinum occurs in humid tropical and subtropical lowlands across the world. It is reported from the West Indies, South America, West Indian Ocean islands, South and South-east Asia, New Guinea, Australia, and Pacific islands. Outside the tropics and subtropics it only occurs in heated greenhouses or very disturbed habitats, mainly in the northern hemisphere. Indeed it has been reported from North America, Europe, the Middle East, and New Zealand (see Table
Geographical distribution of Allopeas clavulinum. Asterisks indicate countries / islands where the species has been recorded only in greenhouses or very disturbed anthropogenic habitats.
Regions | Countries / Islands | References |
---|---|---|
North America | United States* |
|
West Indies | Hispaniola |
|
South America | Brazil and Suriname |
|
Europe | Austria*, Czech Republic*, Finland*, Germany*, Great Britain*, Ireland*, Italy*, Netherlands* and Sweden* |
|
Indian Ocean | Madagascar, Mascarene, and Seychelles |
|
West Asia | Israel* |
|
South Asia | Nepal |
|
South-East Asia | Indonesia, Peninsular Malaysia, Philippines, Sabah in Malaysian Borneo and Singapore |
|
Oceania | Australia, New Guinea, New Zealand* and Pacific islands (American Samoa, Chilean Islands: Rapa Nui, Cook Islands, Fiji, French Polynesia, Hawaii, Norfolk Island, Pitcairn Islands and Tonga) | Anonymous undated, |
The genital anatomy of Allopeas species is poorly understood. Earlier studies have been performed on specimens of Allopeas gracile (Hutton, 1834) from Puerto Rico (
Allopeas clavulinum has been found in the tropical greenhouse of
Helix hannensis Rang, 1831: 41–42, pl. 3, fig. 8. Type locality: Senegal, Cape Verde Peninsula, Hann village (“village de Hann sur la presqu’île du Cap-Verd”). Type material: unknown.
Italy • 47 shells and 1 spirit specimen; Trento, Tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Shell
(Figs
Shells of Opeas hannense from the tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Female distal genitalia
(Fig.
Male distal genitalia
(Fig.
Genital atrium
(Fig.
The species was first named Helix clavulus by Férussac (1821: 52) based on specimens from Guadeloupe and then Helix goodalli by
Opeas hannense is regarded as native to tropical America (
Geographical distribution of Opeas hannense. Asterisks indicate countries / islands where the species has been recorded only in greenhouses or very disturbed anthropogenic habitats.
Regions | Countries / Islands | References |
---|---|---|
North America | United States* |
|
Central America | Guatemala, Mexico, Nicaragua, and Panama |
|
West Indies | Bahamas, Cuba, Hispaniola, Jamaica, Lesser Antilles (Barbados, Curaçao, Guadeloupe, Martinique, and Saint Martin) |
|
South America | Argentina, Brazil, Ecuador, Suriname, and Uruguay |
|
Atlantic Ocean | Bermuda, Capo Verde, Saint Helena, and São Tomé |
|
Europe | Austria*, Czech Republic*, Denmark*, France*, Germany*, Great Britain*, Ireland*, Italy*, Netherlands* and Sweden* |
|
Africa | Mozambique |
|
Indian Ocean | Madagascar and Seychelles |
|
South-East Asia | Singapore |
|
Oceania | Pacific Islands (American Samoa, Belau/Palau, Cook Islands, Federated States of Micronesia, Fiji, French Polynesia, Galapagos Islands, Guam, Hawaii, Pitcairn Islands, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, and Vanuatu) |
|
The genital anatomy of Opeas species was investigated by
Thus, little continues to be known about the genital anatomy of this genus. We need to ascertain whether the proximal complex of the penis is really undivided, to understand the relationships between the vas deferens and the penial sheath and whether the different structure of the female distal genitalia is due to individual variation or to phylogenetic divergence.
Opeas hannense has only been found in the tropical greenhouse of
Bulimus achatinaceus
Pfeiffer, 1846: 82. Type locality: “Java”. Type material: lectotype no. ZMB Moll. 65746, Zoological Museum, Berlin (
Italy • 173 shells and 21 spirit specimens; Padua, Biodiversity Garden (Botanical Garden of Padua); 45°23'52.59"N, 11°52'50.37"E; 06 Mar. 2019; D. Barbato leg.; GMC 57373.
Shell
(Figs
Female distal genitalia
(Figs
Male distal genitalia
(Figs
Genital atrium
(Figs
Paropeas achatinaceum is one of the best known subulinids thanks to the excellent anatomical study and the careful taxonomic revision by
This species is regarded as native to tropical Asia, where it occurs from Nepal and Sri Lanka to South East Asia. Outside this area it is found in Australia and Pacific islands, West Indian Ocean islands, Europe, and the West Asia (see Table
Geographical distribution of Paropeas achatinaceum. Asterisks indicate countries / islands where the species has been recorded only in greenhouses or very disturbed anthropogenic habitats; hash symbol denotes one record based on a specimen of unknown origin recovered from sandy detritus collected on a beach.
Regions | Countries / Islands | References |
---|---|---|
Europe | Austria*, Italy*, and Malta# |
|
West Indian Ocean | Mascarene and Seychelles |
|
West Asia | Iraq |
|
South Asia | Nepal and Sri Lanka |
|
South-East Asia | Borneo, Indonesia, and Singapore |
|
East Asia | Dongsha Island and Hong Kong |
|
Oceania | Australia and Pacific islands (American Samoa, Cook Islands, Fiji, French Polynesia, Guam, Hawaii, Northern Mariana Islands, Samoa, and Tonga) |
|
The species was found in the Biodiversity Garden (Botanical Garden of Padua), where it forms a well-established population, as in Vienna Zoo, Austria (
Bulimus octonus
Bruguière, 1789: 325. Type locality: “… dans les îles Antilles. M. de Badier l’a trouvé abondamment à l’île de la Guadeloupe, & j’en ai vu chez M. d’Antic qui lui ont été envoyés de l’île de Saint-Domingue”. Type material: presumed lost (
Italy • 112 shells and 2 spirit specimens; Trento, Tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Shell
(Figs
Female distal genitalia
(Fig.
Male distal genitalia
(Figs
Genital atrium
(Fig.
Subulina octona is a well-known travelling snail that occurs worldwide (
Subulina octona is now distributed widely in humid tropical and subtropical lowlands across the world. It occurs in Central America, the West Indies, South America, sub-Saharan Africa, West Indian Ocean islands, South, South-East, and East Asia, New Guinea, Australia, and Pacific islands. In the mid temperate latitudes of the northern hemisphere, it only occurs in greenhouses and hothouses (see Table
Geographical distribution of Subulina octona. Asterisks indicate countries / islands where the species has been recorded only in greenhouses or very disturbed anthropogenic habitats.
Regions | Countries / Islands | References |
---|---|---|
North America | United States* |
|
Central America | Belize, Costa Rica, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, and Salvador |
|
West Indies | Bahamas, Cuba, Hispaniola, Jamaica, and Lesser Antilles (Barbados, Curaçao, Guadeloupe, Martinique, Saint Barthélemy, Saint Martin, and Trinidad) |
|
South America | Brazil, Columbia, Ecuador, Peru, Suriname, and Venezuela |
|
Atlantic Ocean | Bermuda |
|
Europe | Austria*, Czech Republic*, Denmark*, Great Britain*, Ireland*, Italy*, Netherlands*, and Sweden* |
|
Africa | South Africa, Tanzania, and Zimbabwe |
|
Indian Ocean | Aldabra, Madagascar, Maldives, Mascarene, Pemba, and Seychelles |
|
South Asia | India and Sri Lanka |
|
South-East Asia | Indonesia, Peninsular Malaysia, Sabah in Malaysian Borneo, Singapore, and Vietnam |
|
East Asia | Dongsha Islands and Japan* |
|
Oceania | Australia, New Guinea, and Pacific islands (American Samoa, Belau/Palau, Cook Islands, Federated States of Micronesia, Fiji, French Polynesia, Galapagos Islands, Guam, Hawaii, Marshall Islands, New Caledonia, Northern Mariana Islands, Pitcairn Islands, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, and Vanuatu) |
|
The distal genitalia of
The small size and the very fine structure of the sections of the proximal portion of the penial complex make dissection difficult and differentiation of its components elusive. Our results substantially agree with Baker’s description. The differences are: the vas deferens enters the penial complex near the base and not at the tip of the epiphallus; the penial retractor consists of two branches, one joined to the epiphallus, the other to the penial caecum; the small size of the proximal penis makes the penial papilla impossible to detect by stereomicroscope; a classical penial sheath (such as that of Allopeas and Paropeas) is absent, although a muscular branch from the right lower tentacle retractor joins the distal penis directly on the penial wall. Unfortunately, the scarcity of material prevented a more careful anatomical examination. Some uncertainties about its real organisation and the meaning of such differences among the various anatomical reports therefore remain.
Multi-gene phylogenetic analysis of the achatinoid snails by
Subulina octona is common in the tropical greenhouse of
Macrospira aperta
Swainson, 1840: 335, fig. 97e, f. Type locality: no locality given; according to
Achatina gundlachi Pfeiffer, 1850: 80. Type locality: Cuba. Type material: unknown.
Geostilbia caledonica
Crosse, 1867: 186–187, Pl. 7, fig. 4. Type locality: Nouméa, New Caledonia. Type material: 1 syntype in Crosse collection (MNHN-IM-2000-4720) (
Italy • 2 shells; Trento, Tropical greenhouse of the Science Museum of Trento (
Shell
(Figs
Body and anatomy. Unknown.
The early taxonomy of this land snail revolves around three named species: Macrospira aperta Swainson, 1840, Achatina gundlachi Pfeiffer, 1850 and Geostilbia caledonica Crosse, 1867.
Commenting on the land mollusc species introduced to Saint Helena, Edgar Smith maintained that Achatina gundlachi was a junior synonym of Macrospira aperta based on examination of Guilding’s material from St. Vincent, West Indies, deposited in the British Museum (
No subsequent authors made any significant contribution for a better taxonomic framework of the species. They repeated what
A species, sometimes named Geostilbia aperta (or Cecilioides aperta), Geostilbia caledonica (or Cecilioides caledonica) or Geostilbia gundlachi (or Cecilioides gundlachi), is currently reported from North, Central and South America, the Caribbean and the Indo-Pacific Region from South-East Asia to Hawaii and Cook Islands (see Table
Geographical distribution of Geostilbia aperta. Asterisks indicate countries / islands where the species has been recorded only in greenhouses or very disturbed anthropogenic habitats.
Regions | Countries / Islands | References |
---|---|---|
North America | United States* |
|
Central America | Nicaragua |
|
West Indies | Cuba, Hispaniola, Jamaica, Lesser Antilles (Guadeloupe, Martinique, Saint Martin, and Saint Vincent) |
|
South America | Brazil |
|
South-East Asia | Indonesia, Peninsular Malaysia, and Philippines |
|
Oceania | Australia, New Guinea, and Pacific Islands (Cook Islands, Guam, Hawaii, and New Caledonia) |
|
It is difficult to say anything new about this group of species, since there is no anatomical data. We can rely on shell characters, the most interesting of which are the spiral sculpture particularly evident in the last whorl, the non-truncated or slightly truncated columella and the basally flared aperture. Based on a close resemblance to Cecilioides, the species of Geostilbia have been placed in the family Ferussaciidae but this similarity could also be due to convergence: true Cecilioides have no microsculpture on the teleoconch, have a truncated columella and have no basally flared aperture. In their phylogenetic analysis of the achatinoideans
MolluscaBase lists eight Geostilbia species (
We assign two shells found in the litter of the tropical greenhouse of
We thank the staff of
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
D. Barbato and G. Manganelli were funded under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4 Component 2 Investment 1.4 - Call for tender No. 3138 of 16 December 2021, rectified by Decree n.3175 of 18 December 2021 of Italian Ministry of University and Research funded by the European Union – NextGenerationEU; Award Number: Project code CN_00000033, Concession Decree No. 1034 of 17 June 2022 adopted by the Italian Ministry of University and Research, CUP B63C22000650007 Project title “National Biodiversity Future Center - NBFC”.
Conceptualisation: DB and GM; Methodology, Formal analysis, Investigation, Data Curation: AB, DB, FG, and GM; Writing - Original draft & Writing - Review and Editing: AB, DB, FG, and GM; Supervision: GM; Funding Acquisition: GM.
Giuseppe Manganelli https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8453-280X
Andrea Benocci https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3145-215X
Debora Barbato https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1105-1711
Folco Giusti https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8722-4653
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.