Research Article |
Corresponding author: Peter Huemer ( p.huemer@tiroler-landesmuseen.at ) Academic editor: Gunnar Brehm
© 2023 Axel Hausmann, Gyula M. László, Toni Mayr, Peter Huemer.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Hausmann A, László GM, Mayr T, Huemer P (2023) Surprising discovery of an enigmatic geometrid in Croatia: Mirlatia arcuata, gen. nov., sp. nov. (Lepidoptera, Geometridae). ZooKeys 1183: 99-110. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1183.110163
|
A new monotypic genus of Geometridae, Mirlatia gen. nov., and a new species, M. arcuata sp. nov., are described from Croatia. Based on external and genitalia characters, the new genus is tentatively placed in the subfamily Larentiinae. However, the new genus takes a highly isolated position by having unique characters of the tympanum and showing an unusually long pectination of female antennae. Genetic analysis of a fragmented DNA barcode (mtDNA; cytochrome c oxidase 1) did not result in a clear assignation to any geometrid subfamily or tribe. Adults, male and female genitalia, and habitat photos of the type locality of the new species are illustrated.
Cold-adapted, DNA barcoding, geometer moths, Mediterranean, tympanum
In January 2014, the third author of this paper acquired the Lepidoptera collection of Robert Hentscholek, an amateur entomologist from Linz (Austria). In the course of inspecting the collection, a male specimen of a peculiar geometrid moth collected in 1983 in Podgora, Croatia (then Yugoslavia) was detected. The moth clearly differed from every known European geometrid species and could not even be assigned to a known genus. The collector was contacted for further information about the unusual moth, and it became evident that a male and a female specimen of the same species had been donated to the late Kurt Huber (1941–2002) who had allegedly passed the two specimens on to a geometrid specialist at the Insect Fair in Weiden, the identity of whom could not be clarified. Later in the same year, two Geometridae specialists, Peder Skou and the first author of this paper, were contacted by TM for help in identifying the unknown species; however, both failed to find out more about the identity and potential relationships of the Croatian moth.
In 2015, the second author independently and unexpectedly had located a female specimen of the same species collected in 1982 in Podgora by R. Hentscholek in the Rudolf Pinker (1905–1987) collection during a survey in the Natural History Museum, Vienna. This specimen is likely the female mentioned by the collector to have been obtained by Huber and seemingly had ended up in the Pinker collection. As the second author also failed to identify the species, he contacted the first author hoping to get the species identified and, thus, the two parallel discoveries of the same problematic geometrid had been linked together. However, as no Geometridae specialist who had been contacted for advice could even attribute the species to a genus, the moth remained unidentified and the whereabouts of one of the three specimens remained unknown. In 2022, with the aim to revive the identification efforts and attempt to trace the missing second male, the third author contacted the fourth author for an opinion about the taxon. As a result, a team was formed to work on identifying the enigmatic geometrid moth. Although the authors could not trace the second male specimen, both sexes of the taxon were available for detailed examination.
After ruling out the possibility of an accidental introduction of the species (see Discussion) we regarded it as a resident species new to science. Venation and shape of hindwing suggest the placement of the species in the subfamily Larentiinae. However, many unique characters (e.g. the peculiar morphology of the ansa of the tympanum) make this attribution rather tentative. A set of largely distinctive morphological characters and the highly isolated position of the taxon based on a DNA barcode analysis suggest that the species belongs to a new monotypic genus, which is together with its type species described in this present paper: Mirlatia arcuata gen. et sp. nov.
The genitalia were dissected, stained with Chlorazol black (holotype) or Eosin red (paratype) and embedded in Euparal on microscope slides applying standard methods of preparation (
Wing venation was examined under a Wild M3Z stereomicroscope equipped with a Wild drawing tube type 308700.
DNA barcodes were obtained by removing one mid-leg from the dry holotype specimen. DNA extraction, amplification and sequencing of the “barcode” region of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I (COI-5P) gene region (658 base pairs) were carried out for the outgroup specimens at the Canadian Centre for DNA Barcoding, Ontario, Canada (CCDB), using standard high through-put protocols (
Analysis of DNA barcodes: sequence divergences within and between species were calculated using the Kimura 2-parameter model (
Information provided in quotation marks is transcribed verbatim. A new line on the label is denoted with “/”, and a different label with “//”; any additional information is provided in square brackets.
BOLD Barcode of Life Data System;
CBG Centre for Biodiversity Genomics, Guelph, Canada;
CCDB Canadian Centre of DNA Barcoding, Guelph, Canada;
coll. collection;
gen.prp. genitalia preparation;
NHMV The Natural History Museum, Vienna, Austria;
Mirlatia arcuata sp. nov. (by monotypy).
(Figs
Abdomen. Tympanal organ (Fig.
Genitalia. Descriptions of the male and female genitalia are provided under the description of the type species of the new genus.
Presence of paired tympanal caves with ansa at the base of the abdomen clearly proves the assignation of the new genus to the family Geometridae. Mirlatia is distinguished from the vast majority of members of the subfamily Ennominae by the tubular M2 vein of the hindwing and the long fusion of hindwing veins Sc+R1 and Rs. It differs from the genera of the subfamilies Ennominae, Geometrinae, Larentiinae, and Sterrhinae by the very broad base and in the lacking apical dilatation of the tympanal ansa. So far, no other geometrid is known to display a similarly shaped ansa, although a broad ansa basis is found in Archiearinae, Desmobathrinae, and Alsophilini, but these groups have an ansa with a pointed tip. The new genus differs from the vast majority of geometrid genera also by the long pectination of the female antenna.
The genetic data are summarised under the species description. The COI barcode suggests a largely isolated position within Geometridae. The new genus is tentatively placed in the subfamily Larentiinae, supported by the double forewing areole and the hindwing venation with presence of the M2 vein and long fusion of Sc+R1 and Rs. Further aspects of the phylogeny are discussed later in this paper.
The new generic name Mirlatia is introduced as a feminine noun. It is an aggregate of the stems of two latin words, i.e. mir- (stem of the noun mirum, mira meaning surprise(s)) and lat- (latum, the perfect participle form of the verb ferre meaning to bring, referring to the rather surprising discovery of this curious new geometrid moth.
Holotype
: male, “Podgora – Drvenik / YU [southern Croatia, 25 km SE Makarska] [leg. Robert] Hentscholek / [handwritten] 18.3.1983” // DNA barcode sample ID BC_ZSM_Lep_115293 // gen. prp. Hausm. G 22091 // coll.
Paratype : 1 female, “Podgora – Drvenik / YU [southern Croatia, 25 km SE Makarska] [leg. Robert] Hentscholek / [hand written] 27.3.1982” // [gen. prp. nr. László] 3352 ♀ // coll. NHMV.
For structural external morphology of adults, see the genus description.
Male (Fig.
Male genitalia
(Fig.
Female (Fig.
Female genitalia
(Fig.
The male holotype has been successfully sequenced to a 658-bp fragment containing an internal 200-bp gap. Nearest neighbor: Idaea muricata at a distance of 7.8% in the BOLD barcode-gap analysis, with several next-nearest species at distances of 7.8–8.0% from various families such as Gelechiidae, Blastobasidae, Erebidae, and Euteliidae. Chimera status excluded by examination of both subfragments: Subfragment 1 (3’) with nearest neighbor from genus Adoxophyes (Tortricidae: 6.37%) and several geometrids (all subfamilies) at distances of 6.8–7.0%. Subfragment 2 (5’) with nearest neighbor from genus Ergavia (Sterrhinae: 5.95%) and several Lepidoptera from other families (e.g. Erebidae) at distances of ~6.2%. Hence, there is no evidence for contamination in both fragments and, therefore, no evidence for a chimera sequence. Nevertheless, from a genetic point of view, our fragmented COI sequence does not allow for a clear assignation of the new genus to any geometrid subfamily, tribe, or genus.
The distinctive features of the new species are discussed under the differential diagnosis of the genus.
The species name refers to the arcuate hindwing termen.
The type series was collected in southern Croatia at Drvenik (25 km SE of Makarska) from mid- to late March, close to the Mediterranean shoreline, in a habitat dominated by steep limestone rocks and scree (Fig.
The phylogenetic position of this new taxon is still unclear and requires further study. Its assignation to Larentiinae is tentative and is mainly based on venation; no larentiine moth is known with a similarly shaped tympanal ansa. The double forewing areole and the long fusion of Sc+R1 and Rs in the hindwing are characteristic for Larentiinae (the latter also present in Alsophilini) (Fig.
The COI barcode data suggests a highly distinct position of Mirlatia arcuata within Geometridae, with the closest species at a large p-distance in Sterrhinae (Idaea muricata; in the BOLD barcode-gap analysis). No phylogenetic conclusions can be drawn from p-distances of this amplitude; thus, the available data likely point to an isolated phylogenetic position of M. arcuata, which is in full agreement with its unique morphological characters. Multi-gene molecular analyses would probably shed more light on the potential relationships of this peculiar taxon and allow to its attribution to one of the described subfamilies and tribes (cf.
Male and female genitalia of M. arcuata sp. nov. do not exhibit any unique characters that would help establish any closer relationships with other geometrid lineages.
As the discovery of a new geometrid in Europe is rather unusual in the third decade of the 21st century, the possibilities of introduction of the species from other continents had to be scrutinised. A possible introduction of this species from other parts of the world can be ruled out from the following reasons:
It may seem peculiar that such a remarkable species has remained undiscovered for so long. However, Dalmatia has not been a highly popular research area for lepidopterists, especially early in the year, in March. It is worth noting that recently there have been other surprising discoveries from the Balkan Peninsula, for example, Kresnaia beshkovi (Ganev, 1987) which belongs to a separate, hitherto unknown genus, and Idaea millesima Hausmann & Prochazka, 2020 (in
We are most grateful to Stanislav Gomboc for trying to confirm the present occurrence of this species at the type locality and allowing us to use his photograph of the habitat. We are also indebted to Martin Lödl and Sabine Gaal-Haszler (NHMV) for providing access to the Geometridae collection under their care and the opportunity to use the microphotography system of the collection, and to Robert Hentscholek for collecting efforts and information on the type locality. Images of the tympanal organ of the female specimen deposited in NHMV have been provided through the kind help of László Ronkay.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
No funding was reported.
All authors have contributed equally.
Axel Hausmann https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0358-9928
Peter Huemer https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0630-545X
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text.