Research Article |
Corresponding author: Matteo Montagna ( matteo.montagna@unina.it ) Academic editor: Michael Schmitt
© 2019 Matteo Brunetti, Giulia Magoga, Mattia Iannella, Maurizio Biondi, Matteo Montagna.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Brunetti M, Magoga G, Iannella M, Biondi M, Montagna M (2019) Phylogeography and species distribution modelling of Cryptocephalus barii (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae): is this alpine endemic species close to extinction? In: Schmitt M, Chaboo CS, Biondi M (Eds) Research on Chrysomelidae 8. ZooKeys 856: 3-25. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.856.32462
|
The alternation of glacial and interglacial cycles of the Quaternary period contributed in shaping the current species distribution. Cold-adapted organisms experienced range expansion and contraction in response to the temperature decrease and increase, respectively. In this study, a fragment of the mitochondrial marker COI was used to investigate the phylogeography of Cryptocephalus barii, a cold-adapted alpine leaf beetle species endemic of Orobie Alps, northern Italy. The relationships among populations, their divergence time, and the most probable migration model were estimated and are discussed in light of the Pleistocene climate oscillations. Through a species distribution modelling analysis, the current habitat suitability was assessed and the distribution in a future global warming scenario predicted. The main divergence events that led to the actual population structure took place from ~750,000 to ~150,000 years ago, almost following the pattern of the climate oscillations that led to the increase of the connections between the populations during cold periods and the isolation on massifs in warm periods. The most supported migration model suggests that the species survived to past adverse climatic conditions within refugia inside and at the limit of the actual range. The species distribution modelling analysis showed that C. barii is extremely sensitive to air temperature variations, thus the increase of temperature caused by global warming will reduce the suitable areas within the species range, leading to its possible extinction in the next 50 years. Cryptocephalus barii is a representative case of how cold adapted and limited distributed species have been and could be affected by climate change, that highlights the implementation of conservation actions.
cold-adapted species, endemism, global warming, Italy, Orobie Alps, phylogeography, species distribution models, species extinctions
The Quaternary Period, alternating at least seven glacial and interglacial cycles within the last 650,000 years, affected population migration and survival of animals and plants and thus contributed in shaping the current species distribution (
Italy is an endemic species rich country both in term of flora and fauna (
In this study we investigate the phylogeography of the alpine endemic leaf beetle Cryptocephalus barii Burlini, 1948 (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) currently distributed on isolated areas of the southern part of the Alps (Orobie Alps), above 1,800 meters of altitude. The species was described by Burlini in 1948 basing on eight specimens collected in Alben Mount (
In this study, through an extensive sampling across the distributional range of the species, we have investigated the phylogeography of C. barii in order to define the relationships between the currently isolated populations, estimate their divergence time taking into account Pleistocene climate oscillations, assess the current habitat suitability and predict the distribution of this orophilous and endemic species in a future global warming scenario.
Between 2005 and 2012, different collecting campaigns were organised on mountainous reliefs of the Orobie Alps where the species was already known to be present, viz. Alben, northern Grigna, Presolana, and Arera (
Cryptocephalus barii Burlini, 1948 distribution. A) Geographic location of the Orobie Alps and Cryptocephalus barii distribution. Yellow dots indicate localities where the species was observed, red dots indicate localities investigated with extensive sampling campaigns in which the species was absent (the source map was downloaded from http://www.geoportale.regione.lombardia.it/ and elaborated with QGIS 3.4.1). B) Cryptocephalus barii picture acquired using a Canon 450D camera; the multilayered micrographs were processed with Zerene Stacker (Richland, WA, USA).
The obtained 53 COI sequences were aligned using MUSCLE (
Phylogeographic relationships within C. barii were investigated based on Bayesian inference using the software BEAST 2.5.1. (
The tree prior was set using the Constant coalescent Kingman model (
In order to confirm the rooting position of the tree, we carried out a preliminary phylogenetic reconstruction using an alignment consisting of the haplotype sequences of C. barii and orthologous sequences of five species mined from GenBank (i.e., Cryptocephalus cristula Dufour, 1843, Cryptocephalus asturiensis Heyden, 1870, Cryptocephalus flavipes Fabricius, 1781, Cryptocephalus azurescens Escalera, 1914 and Pachybrachis sp.; accession numbers: HE600320, HE600302, KJ765877, HE600310, HF947529) used as outgroups. In this phylogenetic reconstruction, performed on a dataset of 15 sequences, the tree prior was set using the Yule model (
We used the coalescent-based program MIGRATE-N 3.7 (
We used the sequence model of
Since the suitable habitat of the species is currently between 1,800 and 2,100 meters of altitude, we hypothesise that during glacials the amount of areas with a suitable habitat increase, thus allowing the formation of corridors connecting the massifs where the species is present. The correspondence between the phylogeography of the species and possible corridors of suitable habitat connecting the different mountainous reliefs was evaluated building maps of the Orobie Alps highlighting areas above a certain altitude by QGIS 3.4.1 software (
A dataset of 35 presence localities was generated from GPS-precision field-recorded points for the target species C. barii. Nineteen bioclimatic variables were downloaded from the web repository Worldclim.org (
For the modelling process, the ‘biomod2’ package (
Each species distribution model obtained from the different GCMs was processed through the MEDI algorithm (
In biomod2, Generalized Linear Models (GLMs, set with type = “quadratic”, interaction level = 3), Multiple Adaptive Regression Splines (MARS, set with type = “quadratic”, interaction level = 3), Generalized Boosting Model, also known as Boosted Regression Trees (BRT, set with number of trees = 5000, interaction depth = 3, cross-validation folds = 10) and Maxent (MaxEnt, set with maximum iterations = 5000) were selected as single modelling techniques (
The extensive sampling campaigns within the Orobie Alps and in neighbouring massifs suitable for the presence of C. barii (according with the proposed criteria, Materials and Methods), led to the collection of 60 individuals on eight massifs: the already known Mount Alben, Pizzo Arera, Presolana, and northern Grigna, with the addition of the newly discovered southern Grigna (hereafter reported as Grigna in association with the geographical neighbour northern Grigna), Corna Grande, Pegherolo, and Concarena (Figure
DNA was extracted and COI amplified from 53 C. barii individuals (Table
Collection localities and host plants of Cryptocephalus barii individuals from which the DNA was extracted, and COI amplified. Specimen IDs are reported for sequences obtained during this study, while for sequences already published in
Collection locality | Specimen id† | Collection date | Latitude | Longitude | E‡ | Host plants |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alben | Alb-1 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8721N, 9.7807E | 1855 | Helianthemum nummularium, Hieracium sp., Telekia speciosissima | |
Alb-2 | 08 Aug 2008 | 45.8714N, 9.7780E | 1855 | |||
Alb-3 | 08 Aug 2008 | 45.8714N, 9.7780E | 1855 | |||
Alb-4 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8723N, 9.7779E | 1855 | |||
Alb-5 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8720N, 9.7766E | 1855 | |||
Alb-6 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8727N, 9.7766E | 1855 | |||
Alb-7 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8727N, 9.7766E | 1855 | |||
HE600313 | 17 Aug 2010 | 45.8713N, 9.7787E | 1855 | |||
Arera | Are-1 | 23 Aug2010 | 45.9263N, 9.8013E | 1929 | Helianthemum nummularium, Hieracium sp. | |
Are-2 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9176N, 9.7952E | 1601 | |||
Are-3 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9309N, 9.8043E | 2011 | |||
Are-4 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9309N, 9.8043E | 2011 | |||
Are-5 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9336N, 9.8029E | 2066 | |||
Are-6 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9336N, 9.8029E | 2066 | |||
Are-7 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9176N, 9.7952E | 1601 | |||
Are-8 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9263N, 9.8044E | 1965 | |||
Are-9 | 23 Aug 2010 | 45.9401N, 9.8072E | 2072 | |||
Corna Grande | Bob-1 | 30 Jul 2011 | 45.9618N, 9.5206E | 1900 | Helianthemum nummularium | |
Bob-2 | 30 Jul 2011 | 45.9618N, 9.5206E | 1900 | |||
Grigna (southern and northern Grigna) | Gri-1 | 17 Jul 2006 | 45.9663N, 9.3849E | 1817 | Hieracium spp., Helianthemum nummularium, Telekia speciosissima | |
Gri-2 | 17 Jul 2006 | 45.9657N, 9.3870E | 1817 | |||
HE600311 | 17 Jul 2006 | 45.9657N, 9.3870E | 1817 | |||
Gri-3 | 17 Jul 2006 | 45.9657N, 9.3870E | 1817 | |||
Gri-4 | 24 Jul 2011 | 45.9219N, 9.3763E | 1700 | |||
Gri-5 | 1 Aug 2005 | 45.9649N, 9.3857E | 1817 | |||
Gri-6 | 1 Aug 2005 | 45.9649N, 9.3857E | 1817 | |||
Gri-7 | 1 Aug 2005 | 45.9649N, 9.3876E | 1817 | |||
Gri-8 | 1 Aug 2005 | 45.9642N, 9.3856E | 1817 | |||
Gri-9 | 13 Aug 2012 | 45.9218N, 9.3841E | 1898 | |||
Pegherolo | Peg-1 | 26 Aug 2010 | 46.0375N, 9.6929E | 2100 | Helianthemum nummularium | |
Peg-2 | 26 Aug 2010 | 46.0358N, 9.6938E | 2100 | |||
Peg-3 | 26 Aug 2010 | 46.0361N, 9.6953E | 2100 | |||
Peg-4 | 20 Jul 2012 | 46.0351N, 9.6940E | 2100 | |||
Peg-5 | 20 Jul 2012 | 46.0349N, 9.6940E | 2100 | |||
Peg-6 | 20 Jul 2012 | 46.0349N, 9.6935E | 2100 | |||
Peg-7 | 20 Jul 2012 | 46.0348N, 9.6943E | 2100 | |||
Presolana | Pre-1 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9696N, 10.0435E | 2066 | Helianthemum nummularium, Hieracium sp. | |
Pre-2 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9640N, 10.0577E | 1923 | |||
Pre-3 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9640N, 10.0577E | 1923 | |||
Pre-4 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9655N, 10.0519E | 2002 | |||
Pre-5 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9640N, 10.0577E | 1923 | |||
Pre-6 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9640N, 10.0577E | 1923 | |||
Pre-7 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9665N, 10.0494E | 2031 | |||
HE600312 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9665N, 10.0494E | 1938 | |||
Pre-8 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9665N, 10.0494E | 2031 | |||
Pre-9 | 11 Aug 2010 | 45.9662N, 10.0531E | 1995 | |||
Concarena | Con-1 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | Hieracium tenuiflorum | |
Con-2 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | |||
Con-3 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | |||
Con-4 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | |||
Con-5 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | |||
Con-6 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 | |||
Con-7 | 09 Sep 2012 | 46.0044N, 10.2735E | 1750 |
Nucleotide p-distance within and between Cryptocephalus barii populations.
Comparison | Nucleotide p-distance† |
Alben | 0 (0) |
Arera | 0.00066 (0.00045) |
Corna Grande | 0 (0) |
Grigna (southern Grigna, northern Grigna) | 0 (0) |
Pegherolo | 0.00042 (0.00041) |
Presolana | 0.0018 (0.0010) |
Concarena | 0.00042 (0.00040) |
Alben – Arera | 0.0074 (0.0032) |
Alben – Corna Grande | 0.0089 (0.0035) |
Alben – Grigna | 0.024 (0.0056) |
Alben – Pegherolo | 0.012 (0.0040) |
Alben – Presolana | 0.0080 (0.0033) |
Alben – Concarena | 0.0089 (0.0035) |
Arera – Corna Grande | 0.0045 (0.0026) |
Arera – Grigna | 0.022 (0.0055) |
Arera – Pegherolo | 0.0045 (0.0025) |
Arera – Presolana | 0.00049 (0.00048) |
Arera – Concarena | 0.0014 (0.0014) |
Corna Grande – Grigna | 0.024 (0.0058) |
Corna Grande – Pegherolo | 0.0059 (0.0029) |
Corna Grande – Presolana | 0.0050 (0.0026) |
Corna Grande – Concarena | 0.0059 (0.0029) |
Grigna – Pegherolo | 0.021 (0.0054) |
Grigna – Presolana | 0.023 (0.0055) |
Grigna – Concarena | 0.024 (0.0056) |
Pegherolo – Presolana | 0.0050 (0.0025) |
Pegherolo – Concarena | 0.0059 (0.0028) |
Presolana – Concarena | 0.0021 (0.0015) |
Maximum clade credibility tree and Minimum-spanning haplotype network. A Minimum-spanning haplotype network. Each colour represents a Cryptocephalus barii population. Circles represent the different haplotypes; their diameter is proportional to the haplotypes abundance. B Maximum clade credibility tree. Horizontal blue bars represent 95% HPD age confidence intervals for the nodes. Under the main lineage nodes is reported the divergence time in thousands of years before present. Above the nodes Bayesian posterior probabilities > 0.8 are reported, black asterisks indicate Bayesian posterior probabilities values < 0.80. Vertical coloured bars on the right of the tree indicate monophyletic clades, the colours identify the C. barii populations. Under the tree, in blue, the estimated surface temperature for the last 800,000 years (
Based on the performed coalescence analysis, almost all the individuals from the same mountainous massif clustered together in monophyletic groups and are supported by high values of Bayesian posterior probability (BPP > 0.85; Figure
Concerning the estimation of the divergence time among populations, the most ancient split, represented by the separation of Grigna lineage (tree rooted on outgroups) and all the remaining lineages occurred ~724,600 years before present (BP) (95% High posterior density (HPD) 1,140,700–389,900 years BP; BPP = 1) in correspondence with a period of warm climate, probably during the Pastonian or the Günz-Mindel interglacials (Figure
In order to understand how C. barii populations became isolated on different mountainous reliefs, six possible migration models were formalised and tested (Suppl. material
Most likely migration model and altitudinal habitat maps reporting suitable area for the presence of the species during cold periods. A Most likely migration model. Arrows indicate unidirectional flows (in black) and bidirectional flows (in gray) between populations. B–F Suitable altitudinal habitat maps. In light grey are reported the areas suitable for the presence of the species above a certain altitudinal threshold; the yellow ellipses are schematic drawing of Cryptocephalus barii populations; dendrograms showing the divergence events among populations, according to the tree in Fig.
The suitable altitudinal habitat maps, showing the increase of the areas appropriate for the C. barii survival and the available corridors connecting the present populations due to the decrease of the temperature, almost perfectly match with the topology achieved by the coalescent and the migration model analyses (Figure
Concerning the Species Distribution Modelling (SDM) analysis, multicollinearity among the nineteen bioclimatic predictors was prevented by discarding nine variables, keeping as predictors for the modelling process: the mean diurnal range (BIO2); the isothermality (BIO3); the maximum temperature of the warmest month (BIO5); the minimum temperature of the coldest month (BIO6); the mean temperature of the wettest quarter (BIO8); the mean temperature of the driest quarter (BIO9); the annual precipitation (BIO12); the precipitation of the wettest month (BIO13); the precipitation seasonality (BIO15); the precipitation of the driest quarter (BIO17). The corresponding correlation matrix is reported in Suppl. material
Predicted suitability for Cryptocephalus barii for current and future climatic conditions. Predicted suitability resulting from the Ensemble Modelling process performed over bioclimatic variables for Cryptocephalus barii, with the Minimum Convex Polygon built on the species’ presence sites for A current B 2070 – 4.5 scenario of radiative forcing, and C 2070 – 8.5 scenario of radiative forcing.
For future scenarios, the 2070_4.5 predictions resulted in a partial north-eastern shift of the habitat suitability, with an apparent increase of the compatible areas, which however show lower suitability with respect to the current situation (Figure
Changes in habitat suitability for Cryptocephalus barii. Histogram reporting classes of habitat suitability calculated within the Minimum Convex Polygon built on Cryptocephalus barii presence sites through Ensemble Modelling process. Areas calculated for current and future climatic conditions (2070, 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios) are reported, respectively, in green, orange and red.
With this study the presence of the species is discovered on four mountainous reliefs from which it was never sampled before, thus extending its previous distribution towards the north (Pegherolo), east (Concarena), and south (southern Grigna). Since during the collecting campaigns the species has been searched also on suitable areas outside the previously known species range and it was not detected, we can be confident in supporting the fact that the species is nowadays confined in a limited area between the Como (on west) and Iseo (on east) lakes, corresponding to the glacial paleochannels of Adda and Oglio glaciers. The actual range of C. barii is limited to mountainous and geographically isolated calcareous reliefs of Orobie Alps, thus presenting a patchy distribution similar to that of an insular species inhabiting an archipelago. Regarding populations size, we observed that the most vigorous populations are those of northern Grigna (Circo di Moncodeno), Alben, Presolana, and Arera; while, those of southern Grigna, Pegherolo, Corna Grande, and Concarena inhabit a surface restricted area and consist of a limited number of individuals.
Species distribution modelling analyses showed that the most contributing variables retained as predictors are the mean diurnal range, the isothermality and the precipitation of the driest quarter. As other insect species associated with high altitude (
A geographic structure characterising C. barii populations was first confirmed by the positive correlation between geographic and nucleotide distances resulting from the Mantel test, even if based on a single mitochondrial marker. Indeed, most of the populations are characterised by private COI haplotype and only Presolana and Arera partially share haplotypes (Figure
The long-term isolation and the high average nucleotide distance from other populations inferred for individuals collected from Grigna seem to counteract with the migration model that has been selected as the most probable (Figures
In this study, through an extensive sampling the comprehensive distribution of C. barii, species endemic of Orobie Alps, was defined. As expected, the population genetic structure of this cold adapted species was strongly affected by Pleistocene climate oscillations; in fact the observed phylogeographic patterns reflect population connections and isolation during cold and warm periods, respectively. Even if the obtained results are based on a single mitochondrial marker and not on the whole mitochondrial genome or part of the nuclear genome, the correspondence between presence of corridors among populations predicted at different temperatures and the observed genetic variability, let us to be confident about the accuracy of COI in phylogeographic pattern reconstruction, at least in the analysed case. This result further confirms the possibility to exploit the huge amount of COI sequences developed through DNA barcoding and DNA metabarcoding studies in the last 15 years, not only for DNA taxonomy purpose but also for phylogeography and genetic conservation ones.
The reduction of C. barii habitat suitability predicted within 50 years because of global warming, in association with the presence of biogeographic barriers that prevent the species dispersion, open the possibility that C. barii will be extinct during this time span. This prediction, in association with the observed low population size, the isolation of populations and the limited area of occupancy of the species prompt us to propose the inclusion of C. barii in the IUCN Red List as vulnerable or superior category, thus requiring urgent conservation actions pursued by Natural Parks and environmental agencies.
The case of C. barii can be representative of the cold adapted species, both animals and plants, currently present in the Alpine arc and inhabiting high altitude environments. Such species can be considered habitat specialists and the spatial extent of areas with suitable characteristics will be strongly reduced in the next years due to global warming. Beside the decrease in term of biodiversity, caused by the possible species extinctions, the impact on ecosystems, produced by the loss of these habitats, is currently unknown.
The authors sincerely acknowledge Davide Sassi for his help in the collection activity; in addition, we would like to thank the reviewers for their thoughtful comments and efforts towards improving our manuscript. The study was partially supported by funds assigned to MM by Parco delle Orobie Bergamasche contract ML 18 (22nd February 2011) and 438 (9th March 2011) and by MIUR Fondo per il finanziamento delle attività base di ricerca FFABR 2017.
Migration models tested in this study using Migrate-n E) Most likely migration model
Data type: statistical model
Explanation note: Arrows indicate unidirectional flows (in black) and bidirectional flows (in gray) between populations. Abbreviations: con = Concarena; pre = Presolana; are = Arera; alb = Alben; gri = Grigna; cg = Corna Grande; peg = Pegherolo.
Correlation matrix built among the 19 candidate predictors downloaded from the online repository Worldclim.org.
Data type: statistical data
Explanation note: Variables showing a Pearson’s | r | > 0.85 are highlighted in yellow and were discarded from the model building process.